james gaskell was hidden at the bottom of that bundle but even in plain sight, the reigning championsore tries following to inflict exeter‘s first defeat of the season on them, but not enough to knock them from top spot. at the other end, gloucester‘s hopes of climbing off the bottom looked promising for 77 minutes. in the 78th, sale'sjosh beaumont, back after 1a months out, put paid to that. from ten points down, it was quite the comeback and a frustrating finish for gloucester. billy twelvetrees took it out on the water carrier, achieving very little bar a yellow card and some running repairs to the advertising hoardings, merely leaving gloucester starting the new year rock bottom. ben croucher, bbc news. and in the pro 1a, ulster extended their unbeaten run with victory over provincial rivals munster. meanwhile, edinburgh capitalised on some poor handling from glasgow to secure their third league win this season, 10 points to 7 it finished at murrayfield. there's more on the bbc sport website including the latest from the world darts championship semi—finals at alexandra palace in