my name's bob walsh and i am with scoot. thank you chair melgar, vice peskin and supervisor preston for your time. so i'm actually going to -- we've got two other folks from scoot here. our operations manager and brian bucell our vice president of consumer products to jump into these questions pretty thoroughly. i was going to haveryia come in and how we track our violations separate from the 311s. how do we track sidewalk riding and then also brian will jump in and talk about the sidewalk technology that we demoed on wednesday and specifically supervisor peskin, to your question about alerts and how the vehicle will behave on the sidewalk and that sort of thing. so without further adieu and we'll bring in real posada. >> good afternoon, supervisors. so i'll run through first-time parking violations and to where they have occurred in the past and then i'll pass it to brian. so looking at how we track parking violations, we review our ride end photos. we require our riders of how did they park and then we review them. on that

this is bob walsh speaking on behalf of scoot, but also a life long native san franciscan and a 33-year resident of district five. we'd like to state our support for improving safety outcomes for all road users and peds with disabilities. shared micromobility operators are constantly innovating new ways. which is still under development. however, the first condition proposed in today's resolution prohibiting waiver and release provisions in our user agreements would likely make shared biking mobility operators in san francisco uninsurable and therefore unable to operate in the city. waiver and release provisions for standard clauses are found for every agreement in california. example for bike rentals, car rentals. safety data on shared micromobility does not support treating the industry different from all other industries. our data shows medical impotence on shared scooters occur in once in 50,000 rides which is comparable to standard bicycle. removing these provisions would remove the rider responsibility and not protect pedestrians to mobility. treat the industry differently from al

my name's bob walsh and i am with scoot. thank you chair melgar, vice peskin and supervisor preston for your time. so i'm actually going to -- we've got two other folks from scoot here. our operations manager and brian bucell our vice president of consumer products to jump into these questions pretty thoroughly. i was going to haveryia come in and how we track our violations separate from the 311s. how do we track sidewalk riding and then also brian will jump in and talk about the sidewalk technology that we demoed on wednesday and specifically supervisor peskin, to your question about alerts and how the vehicle will behave on the sidewalk and that sort of thing. so without further adieu and we'll bring in real posada. >> good afternoon, supervisors. so i'll run through first-time parking violations and to where they have occurred in the past and then i'll pass it to brian. so looking at how we track parking violations, we review our ride end photos. we require our riders of how did they park and then we review them. on that

and then there is the fellow that likes growing on the river, the young fellow that walsh is on the bob i recommend all of them by giving them opportunities. i don't trouble them with political arguments. i just studied human nature and act accordingly. so then, he is building up loyalty not simply through politics directly or discussing great political theories or what needs to be done to improve the city. it's by giving people something to do. by giving them a social life, encouraging the things that they like to do that they then come to associate with their political party. and a lot of it is interesting to just decide here -- a lot of these activities that were done through political parties or through fraternal organizations, often ethnic fraternal organizations, gradually get absorbed by the schools. the school becomes everything. and the spirit of the civil service. we have to get people playing baseball for tammany hall? no, no. seeing at the high school. you want to sing for tammany hall? no, seeing for your school. these activities, sports, arts, music. entertainment, if you