as was mentioned in amman, working closely with saudi arabia, monte u e and the un before, as a truce, is known as 15th week. we've welcome the leadership racket prime minister economy to bring countries from the navy, from the neighbor, from the region together or talks and bag thanks. 2 months of quiet, persistent diplomacy. we help finalize that agreement to remove the national peacekeepers from john island, the red sea, and transform an area that once sparked wars into a future have a peaceful tourism in economic development. and as we continue to work closely with many of you to count the threat posed by close of the region by iran were also pursuing diplomacy to return constraints on a raised nuclear program. but no matter what united states is committed to ensuring that iran never gets a nuclear weapon forth. united states will build political economic insecurity. connections between the united states, between the u. s. partners wherever possible, while respecting each country sovereignty independent choices, integration, interconnection. those are the underlying themes of our

u. s. and e, u companies dominating international trade in coffee and grains, you know, people like car deal and then you have others like monsanto and buy on fertilizers and so on. so they seemed rather the argument that we say it's money printing the scores, the inflation. no, it's also monopolization, as well as a ranch interests and people who are simply taking advantage of the crisis so that they can raise prices. and this is very indicative of the problem of rising inequality. i mean, it shows that the economic system pushed forward by the e u and the u. s. which is basically neoconservatism plus neoliberalism. chose that they really don't care about their own people. actually, they could not care less about the impact on their people. and we wait for our activists and progressive friends in the north to actually start having discussions . you know, inequality is cold for class, but why can't we say that there's a class war going on here? well, well, we'll talk more about that after a short

last month in a symbolic gesture of their progress towards joining the block. lawmakers raised the e u flag in ukraine's parliament chamber, but it will likely take years to clear all the hurdles for e u membership. did oh, he's nick connelly spoke to us earlier about the targeting of civilian infrastructure. i asked him if moscow was trying to break the morale of the people in ukraine. that's certainly the way it's being read here. and key of that is certainly what most people use me here, especially in government circles, would tell you. i think the intention added level is perhaps less important than the results we've seen. now in the past week, civilians lose their lives on a huge scale and come and choke in odessa today. but also in the mac ally of close to front lines. and it's abundantly clear that russia is not willing to stop hitting targets or going for targets that it claims a military targets. even if there is a significant risk of civilian loss of life at the rockets they're using now are increasingly old and less precise. some of the rockets use the past week are ones tha

u. s. s e team to this finding that the bullet likely emanated from an id of position and that the killing the tragic killing of sharina booklet was not in fact intentional. are you still committed to who they liver committed? it's all content and now we're chip. determine the what we said in the statement yesterday, the u. s. s u s. se found no reason to believe that that this was intentional, but rather the result of tragic circumstances. this ins right here, it's over. well, use you few aren't you you heard from us early in the statement yesterday that we will remain engaged with israel and the p h. i on next steps and to urge accountability. we do want to see accountability. we would expect accountability in any case involving a wrongful death and is clearly was the case of a wrongful death. our goal and what we believe is the collective goal of the parts is to see to it that something akin to this, the killing of a journalist in a conflict zone. can't happen again, but must not begin happe

u. s. and e, you were blocking poor countries from public stockpiling or food so that they can pay to for emergencies. and then when it comes into context of the ukrainian rule, they're all supportive of the african position. they block us from storing grain, you know, so that they can make profit from higher prices, yet they pretend to care for african countries. it's ridiculous. well, it's probably because they also want to keep it for themselves. there's green supplies, and i think this is one of the very unique features of the ukranian crisis. is that absolutely well, he can not only came home to roost, but it came home pretty soon and not only the poorest countries of the south that have to deal now when they arriving with fuel prices. but also the developing the world has to deal with certain insecurity. shortage is energy high. political as it in the united states had of the i could only trim election i one day if you think that the west may have miscalculated what it was getting itself in

think i'm the only one who shares this view. meanwhile, germany's economy minister insist that the e u is united in the face of gas supply shortages from russia. his latest statements came on tuesday when e. u government deliberated over a draft european law that would require member states to rush and gas to protect countries from supply cuts. the main proposal was to slash consumption by 15 percent with mandatory moves across the block if necessary. however, while germany, italy and some other member states rely heavily on russian imports, spain, portugal and greece are less defended. eventually, the eas, supposedly united stand spoiled down to fresh divisions at the latest talks in brussels. it shows that your distaste, united, that europe is able to find, you mean in unity um giving a strong sigma also in the day we're, the flows of decimals to run are reduced them to another 20 percent to protein. and to russia, you won't split off, of course, a lot of compromises in this text. well, this is the way how europe operates. doesn't make sense that teacher, the additionally i shaving m

and the e u, we commits itself to green energy. after all, the e u expensive gas demands to fall 30 percent back 2030. then what european companies will leave and nations on african constant will be left behind with dumped production facilities and reduced marcus. all this has pushed african needed to call out the sudden interest in the wind as a double standard. that perpetuates the width exploitation of this region. they sending out a simple message. we are not europe, gas station. they cannot just come and say we need your gas or buy your gas and we'll take it to europe. they need to give something back to us. so it's not just about abandoning those green energy models at the drop of the heck. it's about an equal partnership. at view of continues to not practise what is creatures and critic save adulthood old colonial this mindset. is it any surprise that african novel, china, not the waste, as the greatest to ally off to all the multi $1000000.00 projects have improved the lives of local from providing bridges to hospitals to in

u. s. and e. u companies dominating international trade in coffee and grains. you know, people like car deal and then you have others like monsanto and by on fertilizers and so on. so they seemed rather the argument that we say it's money printing that's caused the inflation. no, it's also monopolization, as well as a ranch interests and people who are simply taking advantage of the crisis so that they can raise prices. and this is very indicative of the problem of rising inequality. i mean, it shows that the economic system pushed forward by the e u and the u. s. which is basically neoconservatism plus neoliberalism shows that they really don't care about. they own people, actually, they could not care less about the impact on their people. and we wait for our activists and progressive friends in the north to actually start having discussions in our inequality is cold for class. but why can't we say that there's a class war going on? yeah, well, well, we'll talk more about that after a short break. but between b i, we have to take it, we will be back in just a

while e u. member states have agreed an emergency plan to reduce gas consumption. people across the continent, a bracing themselves for a tough wind ahead. as we mentioned earlier, e u energy ministers are meeting now in brussels, where the trying to reach an agreement on rationing natural gas this winter. now, even before russia's latest gas cut, the e u had been working on a draft law that would require member states to cut demand for natural gas by 15 percent between august and next march. other remain significant disagreements over the details with several european countries heavily dependent on natural gas supplies from russia. and tell us more about all of this, we are joined from brussels by dw correspondent christine manuel. hi christine. now and e ministers. they're meeting to a group today to agree on this emergency proposal to curb gas usage. what more can you tell us about today's meeting? that's right. onion, as you've highlighted on the initial planned by the commission or would have done more effectively, it would have given the commission the powers

do you think the e u brussels ever expected? the kind of blow back that those restrictions created was not in their thinking at all. probably now i don't think that they, these people think these things through because they're already been sold the energy problems in the e. u, even before february, the 24th. and basically, the europeans have been relying on renewables to replace the bill that they know getting off the ground. so they expect that the renewable to take the place of the fuel. so that was the problem. then they failed to sign the contract with russia, referring to gamble, everything on the market. that was a gamble. and so now they've, they're closing expansions. i think the europeans are just make one disastrous mistake after another. and now that goes into this mess. all was a pleasure to have you on the program, george global analyst and rider dr. george zamarelli. thank you. can let's move to south asia, the resignation letter of sure. like as president has been received by the countries, parliamentary speaker f

b, e u agrees to reduce gas consumption and prepare for a total of minutes to sign up to production targets to safe reserves for the winter rushes slashes, deliveries, germany's energy minister, calls it economic warfare. great. find his battle for a 6th day to down a massive wildfire is consuming, vast stretches of protected forest endangering wild life, and they habitat and sweet and take on england. in the semi final of 2022 euros. the hosts are hungry for their 3rd european championship final. they have a sold out crowd in sheffield behind them. ah, i'm been visible and welcome. the european union has agreed to cut back on natural gas at an emergency meeting in brussels. russia is slashing deliveries. moscow saying it needs to carry up maintenance work on a key pipeline and that a complete stoppage is not on the cards. e, you officials don't believe either statement. member states reaching a deal to voluntarily reduce gas consumption by 15 percent for next month. as europe's energy ministers met in brussels on tuesday, the urgency of the challenge they faced had become increasingly obvi

you see that in particular between the u. e and israel, where there's a great deal investment these days. huge number of tourists coming from is all to the u. a, just since the abraham courts were find and also in other regions as well. we've seen israel, the u. v and jordan with a very important deal on solar energy and water, desalination deals between israel and morocco, etc, etc. the last thing is a negative aspect, which is that in the past would help things back was always a palestinian issue. and now many of these are countries and in particular the u. e . saudi arabia as well as i just simply let that buy, let that be on the side while they try to move forward with what they see as their own interest. so it's really a push and pull the push of the fear of her on the opportunity that on the going to otherwise and the lack of the pull back that we've seen in the past on the pallets and energy. yeah, i understand your latest book is entitled does is real, have a plan referring to the palestinians, and if i'm reading you co

were e u states unified in their response? well, at the beginning of this meeting this morning though, there was no that sense of unity. we have seen countries like portugal and poland as well as countries from central europe as hungry that there in fact even threatened to go on its own and have its own separate agreements with russia. because the you handled through the commission, all the agreements in terms of the power supplies and the energy supplies in general. so that he was able to come this agreement after kind of conceding the, the part where it comes to mandatory cuts. it said that these are, these cuts will not be imposed her for the countries that has their own a special needs as cited in the statement. and at the same time, it also gave the option that if 5 countries or 5 members of the you ask for this cuts to be imposed, that will also happen. so it was that mid point that the, you, a, you know, has been able to reach are just there a few, a few minutes before the start of your, the press conference in which th

i mean, when the u. e in the end is, are come together. i think the stomach world usually would probably worry more than anyone else. cuz why bring india into gov security for example, and is iran that the focus on discussion? and if you're on is the focus of discretion. and we know what separates india near one, it's pakistan and afghanistan and thus again a major issue. so what is at stake here and, and, and what is a play? it's not good because they have not made it clear. or what we know about it is either it's banality, meaning nothing is gonna really come and come out of it. or possibly a dangerous thing that there's really being cooked up between india, jojo and israel, that we should worry about come the future of the gulf region in going, going back to that that, that the trip at hand are at one the priority of the trip. if you like, eh, we know that under donald trump, u. s. policy to eds tilted very much more closely to eds israel. so when joe biden came to par, presumably the hope in the palestinian camp was the things were goi

sites d, w dot com ah, today u e u countries decided to, to reduce their agreed to reduce their gas usage this winter by 15 percent as russia place fast and loose with gas supplies to europe, vibe and north stream one pipeline. and a g minister's hail the plan as evidence of european solidarity and played down the various optim agreed for countries who didn't want to play. i'm fil gail in berlin and this is the day ah, we got recently no longer be surprised that put in we'll turn off the gas cap with the wind is coming off and we don't know how cold it will be. we have experience with russians. numerous time ukraine was cut off supply of gas in the middle of winter issue. during the last 6 to 7 years. the european union has been saying that russia is using gases a weapon without giving any concrete examples. but what we know for sure that the in the will continue to play. he's not the games. this will also be heard in moscow . europe can not be divided also coming up. it's a symbol of cooperation in the stars, the international space station, with tensions over the war in ukraine high rus

it is, but the international energy agency has cautioned that the e u and u. s. shouldn't depend on those supplies and should instead boost their own manufacturing, particularly if the e wants to reach it's 0 emission go within the next 3 decades. it's also called on the u. s. could drupal it, solar panel production reportedly to avoid trade policy risks with beijing. china has been instrumental in bringing down costs worldwide for solar power, with multiple benefits for clean energy transitions. at the same time, the level of geographical concentration in global supply chains also poses potential challenges that governments need to address now as well, struggles with the severe energy crisis due to a disruption in supply chains. the thought of china controlling it, developing energy sources, apparently raising west and fears. but whereas the u. e. u. previously accused beijing of ignoring its screen agenda. the goal of reaching 0 missions by 2050 could now rely entirely on china. independent expert under lung says, china's role in the global moved to green ene

u. s. and e. u to export more oil as western countries seek, alternative suppliers of energy, former grief diplomats and basketball lea a night as chris and topless told us that negotiating with russia is the only way to resolve europe's energy crisis. the only way to go ahead is that to sit down in a neutral country like switzerland of western countries and to moscow and tried, tried to come out of the trying to find a practical solution. which of course would involve the lifting of the sanctions because it, it, it doesn't work for europe. and when i say europe, i include the russian. so because i think that russia is, is part of europe, these agreements that have been signed, for example, one that will connect electricity from saudi arabia and it's not going to help much also to reach this cannot happen overnight. it will take quite a long time. and i don't think that this is a solution to it, to resolve the energy crisis that europe itself has created her as, as created by putting the sanctions

since the start of the war, within the e u. it is a vocal support opp sanctions against russia. but the central european country, like many others on the continent, is heavily dependent on russian energy. and there are serious concerns here about how secure that supplies energy took, reduce important topic right now. and our dependence on russia is sort of huge for us. so it's a really enormous sir dependency on rational garrison oil and turn, we have to find a solution for all of us about 3rd to chic republic knows this would be, have been possible only a solidarity of all your countries. but e u countries are increasingly drifting apart on how to respond to russia's invasion of ukraine. people i've spoken to here in prague favor continued support for ukraine, and a hot line on russia. they say this country's history being occupied by the soviet union has a lot to do with it. but the sentiment isn't the same across the union. and so a big part of this presidency for the check republic will be to keep the e you united going forward. some say that the timing, the czech republic p

clear though things would be better if the british army left altogether can know the story to bring u e. u foreign policy chief usa barrel has announced that block will not recognize russian passports issued to don bounce residents. the new russian legislation now simplifying the procedure for all ukrainians to obtain russian citizenship is yet another flagrant violation of ukrainian sovereignty. the you will not recognize these passports. more than 600000 residents self, they done yet scandalous, ganske republic, savell ready receive the russian passports on. according to moscow, that number is going to grow. vladimir putin simplified the procedure of acquiring the travel document for residents often bus 3 years ago, citing the dyers humanitarian situation in the conflict zone at the time. i spoke to martin dole her a german human rights lawyer who believes the use approaches, misguided and inappropriate. since it violates the principles of the european human rights convention. to my mind is kind of strange and you make a little inviting people in different class citizens. and that is

y'all e gonna ve me baing out here gettg all--u. [cers and plause] out here get- thk you. who was affeionatelynown all o- ya helen!len. [cheers d applau] he knew erody, ev biblicay. [lghter] - s, he di - he left himark his secd home, whh is herat lafit's. - llelujah - yeah - yes,ir. - yeah. al good m. [lauter] heers anapplause - od morning! - od morning. - ay, evybody, put a hay though to yr balln of aunhelen. uh-huh. - and on cnt of ree, let's lethem go, toucthe sky, antouch th. one, t, three. - od morni, helen! [cheerand plause] - ere she es. - od mo- s. helen! - that pretty. that's. - at's perct. - th's prettgay. - th wor. - e got caht, red. [lauter] that's at helen [indistinct chatr] - and toave anotr drink. [lau] [indisnct chatr] my lover on here annow auntelen's he. but wee all goa die one of tse days. st don'tnow when - there's a world-famous puppet show created by robert "the mouth . - mm-h. - 's robers braincld. 's his characts. - ah. and it'sthese chacters d the puets, they'r- ey're hind you [carol jni's hit and n love - ♪ bute sped ay inhe mide of the night♪ ♪ h

oh, there are fresh concerns in e. u. after rush a hole sit at the flow of gas through the notes tree worn pipeline to germany for 10 days. that is due to scheduled maintenance. germany's vice chancellor says european countries need to agree to tighten a belt in an attempt to get through expected shortages. however, the pipelines maintenance was agreed by all sides in advance on will last until the 21st of july. no stream one flows directly from russia to germany through the baltic sea and his a key energy pipeline for berlin. last month, russia reduced the pipelines capacity by 40 percent of to saying that some he hardware needed for the gus roots is being held up by western sanctions. the pipeline accounts for around half of germany's gas import oxy contributes a ritual. marston has more mustered german economy minister, robert havoc express concerns de russia when his gas applies as a political weapon. amid the program maintenance shut down of the north stream, one pipeline which normally transports gas from russia to

maker says that he is disappointed with a lack of progress after the latest round of e mediated talks between the u. s. and iran to potentially restore the nuclear deal failed to pat. now, unfortunately, not yet the progress the e u team as coordinator had hoped for. we will keep working with even greater urgency to bring back on track. a key deal for non proliferation and regional stability. u. s. spokesperson has been quick to blame your on for the lack luster talks claiming that to ron has rejected and you back the draft deal, but iran says it's all washington's fault. as the western proposals included, nothing of economic benefit to the islamic republic. jo biden's administration has so far failed to woo iran back towards an international nuclear energy deal, which was scrapped by donald trump in 2018. we heard from independent journalist luc rivera, who says, european powers want to revive trade with iran, because they desperately need gas for the coming winter. the europeans are concerned because they would like to continue trading with iran. you know, since donald trump being posed harsher s

strikes are made on the territory of the luhansk e people's republic using tactical missile systems u ewinds of hurricanes bm-21 g hammers and say. uh 98% of all these missiles are knocked down more than the degree of air defense forces cope with their task, also on the eve of the sun hit the elderly quarter of the city of stakhanov, they hit from a multiple launch rocket system. american-made hummers fire killed two people. two more were damaged, 11 apartment buildings, a school and a kindergarten, were damaged. now there are repairs. syrian missiles or rso are trying to break through e against air defenses and inflict a painful blow on some settlement, that is, this is a terrorist activity, and which is aimed at inflicting maximum human damage and destruction of peaceful buildings and striking at peaceful targets on july 3, special forces units of the people's militia of the donetsk people's republic are advancing towards the cities. artyomovsky, from where shelling of the territory of the lpr often takes place, enemy units are taken in pincers and neutralized, while the people's mili

well see the extremely important and you all know that and we've been talking about how are the b n u e are the ones that have spec capacity left? but there is a lot of debate around just how much back capacity do these people have, how much more ability they have to produce more than what they already produce a. and there's a lot of debate around that. so it's what say that perhaps they do not have enough for a spare capacity to bring down prices significantly. and also there is a question that if they end up actually using tapping into all of the spare capacity that going to actually leave traders anxious and going to make the prices volatile. because we all know that the spec capacity is actually used as a cushion against any potential disruption or geopolitical risks. such a touch of the same time, the u. s. is in its own right, a major oil producer. why can't it just produce more domestically to solve its own problems? but that would be so easy, right? isn't it? they do. they do have a lot of capacity to do that, but they do what they don't have. is it all material, things like cem

, women, the elderly, and children, the destruction of civilian infrastructure, including bridges, e. u. sponsors should bear the same responsibility as to key if or she. maria's or harvard has also accused the e. u. of escalating the war by supplying even more weapons to ukraine with the west said to be ignoring the fact that many of its arms are being used by key to strike civilian targets. according to the latest official reports, both the e u and u. s. have sent over $10000000000.00 worth of military aids to ukraine. we spoke with some people in italy and spain, who believed that their government's actions are only exacerbating the crisis. diane novel, italy, as again in crisis from the political point of view. absolutely. we are not a country that can afford to support a war, neither in economic terms nor in social and civil terms, our constitution repudiate war. i repeat it. i believe that we must develop actions to end the war, not to make a continue. i believe that european countries and my country, italy should not give ukraine more weapons. those of you, what i find absolutely

on the whole block, it's, it already has 12 countries on the list. 12 countries are out of 27 of the e u that it has stopped. act, you know, are giving energy supplies to on our partial beaches or on a full basis. so if this happens, the g d, p of the e zone will fall by 1.5 percent at list and energy prices are rising as well. so that you find yourself in such a situation where it cannot really afford to, ah, wait for its members to come to an agreement. because also the agreement has made with other countries outside of the block, like other be jane or egypt and israel at these agreements neither or at least till the beginning of the next year to have these alternatives to have supplies that it can use in instead of the russian supplies, but it finds itself at this moment really in a very critical point. and a lot of the you countries are really afraid that them at the block could not be it may not be able to actually, ah, you know, take advantage of the time. and it would find herself in one of the probably more stir, harshest a winters. it could see it in the years ahead. and at this

for the e. u has been feeling the conflict for a long time. i know the history, i have heard about what has been happening in ukraine since 2014. i know that don bass lugens can all the territories where the russian speaking population lives, which has been suffering for 8 years, were constantly bomb. and i don't think that the e u sending weapons to the country leads to conflict mitigation courses. i believe that trying to stop the war with the instruments of war is not the best way because it seems to me that europe has already proved that it has other international instruments to stop the war. i mean, diplomatic and other methods, but i don't think guns against guns is the way out. and yes, i think that the war would have already ended if europe was looking for an alternative solution. most political commentators, john brick, mont, believe european leaders don't care about civilians being killed by the weapons they are providing. well, i think the thought was in the beginning was to have a change in victory, as i said, the collapse of the r

are planning for ukraine and the u. e. u pores, another 500 millions of euros in the army, despite struggling to fix its own budget. amid the economic backlash of extensions against russia, ukrainian troops have resumed intense shelling of the new gods republic than a desperate attempt to reclaim the territory.

that's actually not true though, because the e u does reserve the right to remove that status. if those conditions aren't fulfilled as corruption affected people's perception of the war and who they blame for starting it. this is a study that just come out in conjunction with wall street journal and found that as some at 85 percent of ukrainians, who responded to that study at said that they were highly concerned about levels of corruption. and how that could be exacerbated by the war. and they said that what they were concerned about is that that was corruption. 85 percent amongst ukrainian high officials were talking about potentially government members and also the wealthy in the country. what's also really interesting about this study was what the perceptions of ukrainians in regards to whose responsibility it is for the war that are going on at the moment as you'd expect, the high percentage at blaine russia some 85 percent. but more surprising is the number that felt the acquainted government itself was to blame some 70 percent of respondents. that's really quite striking

while e u member states have agreed an emergency plan to reduce gas consumption. people across the continent, bracing themselves for a tough winter ahead and for more no less we can bring in d w. 's political correspondent emanuel assures morning emma, so we've got germany and the rest of the eas saying they want to work together to save gas. but i mean, how easy is that gonna be? can you tell us a bit more about this plan? morning? i mean, yes, well, you have to keep in mind 12 e, u member states, a get russian got to know stream one. and for them it is crucial that they come to an agreement as to how to counter these dependency. oh, so for each member states, they have to agree to an emergency gas plan. this has been done to have, they've agreed on a draft is going to be discussed today. this includes the voluntary 15 percent reduction of natural gas consumption. this will occur between august this year to march next year. they also want to create together and make counties to tweak a block wide alert eve. there is a widespread gas shortage to out the continent.

the e u commission lowering its growth forecast today by almost a full percentage points of brussels. now protecting g d p growth of 1.5 percent next year. that's down from a spring estimate of 2.3 percent. a behind the change is higher than expected price growth. the you now says inflation driven by storing energy costs. as a consequence of the warren, ukraine will be considerably higher than expected this year, as was next year. right. enjoy now by dw brussels correspond marina strauss, and also by maria de meritus. she's the interim director of the brutal think tank and brussels. welcome to you both, maria. i want to start with you were talking about lower growth as well as ramp it . inflation. isn't that a dangerous mix for some you members? how concerned should we be? it is indeed a dangerous makes us very awkward position to dane, where policies that are honest make us have to take and decisions they have to make will actually pulling over the directions. but that's the reality. we are having inflation that is coming in finally from to begin with from energy prices. unless we lo

he didn't post or use and that's on the list you should give, but the u. e. wonderful. now for the middle when you're creating another my me, this is ashley and i'm not sure how to do it. we love, we're both durham. i wish him that you thought of you just because of wiki, kept away appraiser sleep domain, prop say use of what usa. ringback after events in odessa, the head of the new guns, people's republican unit message, nick was left with millions about key. i was intentions. yesterday we have been his issue to list these go below story. not just additional should he was in there. it is near most of ukraine was broken, but done thus has stood its ground. mm hm. but was the 1st place ever in history where the globalization and the western hedge money was sobered by collections by very, very different people than they are used to cope with. desperate to resolve issues peacefully done, best citizens have called for a referendum on may live the done, yet can no guns regions voted on their status. the dynamic and low ganske people's republics declare themselves sovereign s

that was proposed over a week ago that really caused half of that plan was rejected by a number of e u. member states. it would have seen the commission take control over the situation in a way, ab be in a position to, to mandate those cuts and dictates to, to you. members how to ration a gas supply at, in their own countries that was widely rejected by number of countries. and so this version and its current form has only been rejected out by hungry. but bear in mind to get you at these concession, these exemptions that i talked about and have been faked in there, which effectively give a lifeline to, to any you member state at any given time to be able to exercise some level of exemption. and so in terms of what the e u is, is showing today, it is of course, something that they can say will united over. but in truth, it was difficult getting to this point. and anybody can tell you, this is a significantly watered down version of what the commission intended cruising this and the war, of course, are going to isolate raj, a long term, but short term it's european solving most absolutel