mr. productman. one key thing they think note he sited and quoted the 2018 report from the turn are center uc berkeley. and i think it would be good to note that was background he sighted for his comments i think it is important to note it is supported by research. with that ma'am i move to adopt minutes. >> okay. is public comment? >> i don't see public comment. so, we have a motion from vice president lopez to adopt the minutes at provided resunriseed reference the 2018 report from the turn are center from uc berkeley on that motion commissioner trasvina. >> aye >> commissioner lemberg >> aye >> commissioner eppler. >> aye >> president swig. >> aye. >> the minutes are adopted. 5-0. now on to item 4. this is appeal 22-065600 alvarado street. subject property 600 alvarado appealing september 7 of 22 to 600 alvarado homeowner's association. denial of application to remove 2 cypress tree one on publicerate of way and one on private property. we'll will hear from the appellate first. >> mr. toll you hav