we are in touch with volodymyr kupchak, head of the south caucasian branch of the center for the studythe army, conversion and disarmament. karabakh is somewhere near it, and there are many. who thinks that karabakh can that crimea can suffer the fate of karabakh, yes, it is not recognized by anyone, or rather, it is not recognized by anyone. good health, mr. volodymyr. thank you for finding time for us on sunday, and so the question about karabakh first, since it is still the south caucasian branch of the ukrainian center for the study of the army, conversion and disarmament, what is the situation in karabakh and can crimea turn into karabakh, but with an emphasis on karabakh, it was about crimea , we know something about karabakh, i am convinced that few people in ukraine have anything you know, well, when there is an acute phase of the war, give me something, someone from the people, i understand, but now, if only silence and silence, please, greetings and er greetings dear tv viewers, my topic is to be honest , i'm a little bored with it and explain what, explain why well right awa

wait no one is in sight. a dance group with such a northern name cloudberry will perform a hot south caucasiance hooray concert activity. season premiere let's sing in the kitchen all over the country today on farms vtb team will offer a solution.ru. go to vtb and that's it, you get apteka.ru. chat. a suspicious transaction was made on your card, a defender was kidnapped, plug it in. if anything goes wrong, my good girl. be closer with your loved ones , unlimited instant messengers are now available to all mts subscribers. even at zero, and with the defender system, your communication will not be interrupted by spam calls activate the defender option for 30 days free of course you are not gifts, but every offer needs a gift. this is masha she used to feel cramped and uncomfortable due to stool retention and bowel problems, but now with her modelax n he solves delicate problems at the right time and at the right pace, releasing heaviness in the stomach, allowing you to stay light and live a full life modelax n in. the right time in the right place. chat. you say, as if we will work in the new y

volodymyr , volodymyr kopchak, military expert, head of the south caucasian branch of the center for evaluation of conversion and disarmament in tbilisi. let's all try to understand what vladimir putin wants now. what does he want? and by the way, i want to start our conversation with today's interview of the president . the french republic emmanuel macron gave three editions to the french edition a lemon to the american edition and joked to the lebanese leading edition and in this interview he says that ukraine should receive a security guarantee, but at the same time it cannot join nato with russia, which is now i often say that i have lost logic. because if russia threatens ukraine, ukraine can not be accepted into nato. why then is ukraine accepted into nato if there is a russia that does not threaten it ? here is the logic of the development of events. security guarantees for ukraine, alas, we understand macron's logic and, first of all, he wants to provoke moscow, don't look at the fact that moscow is waging an aggression against ukraine. thank god that he said that ukraine nee

volodymyr volodymyr kopchak, military expert leader of the south caucasian branch, the center of gravityf conversion and disarmament in tbilisi and now our next interlocutor is the former ambassador of the united states to ukraine, the head of the eurasia center in atlantic consol john gerbs, congratulations mr. john good evening well, let's all try to understand what vladimir putin wants now, what does he want, and by the way, i want to start the conversation with today's interview, which the president of the french republic, manuel macron, gave in three editions to the french e- he gave an american eye to a leading lebanese publication and in this interview he says that ukraine should receive a security guarantee, but at the same time it cannot join nato with russia i often say that i have lost logic , because if there is russia that threatens ukraine, ukraine can not be accepted into nato. why then will ukraine accept nato if there is a russia that will not threaten it, this is the logic of the development of security guarantees for ukraine, alas, we understand the logic of macron and

participants in this part of our broadcast were volodymyr kopchak, a military expert , the head of the south caucasian branch of the army research center for conversion and disarmament, and valery romanenko, an aviation expert. we talked about what is happening at the front, what the ukrainian army needs to win now let's move on to foreign policy problems, of which there are many, because now we have heard new statements from western leaders, different statements, and we know that there was a high-profile visit of the president of the french republic maneel macron to the russian to the american capital with a discussion of the russian topic, this discussion continued after macron returned to the elysee palace in miner on the basis of the interview he gave to the mass media of the french republic during his stay in washington, this is it from this we will start our conversation with the minister of foreign affairs of ukraine for 2014-2019 pavlo klimkin. congratulations, it's true. congratulations, mr. vitaly, it's nice to see you and everyone, let's go anyway let's try to understand what i mean by macr

near future, our guests in this part of the broadcast are a military expert, the head of the south caucasianter for the study of army conversions and armaments in belarus, volodymyr kopchuk congratulations, mr. volodymyr. congratulations, vitaliy. congratulations to you , the audience. as we are not visible, i can hear very well. aviation expert valery romanenko. congratulations to valery. good day, not even evening. unfortunately, this evening after 18:00, the discussion began. good afternoon, mr. valeryovich, discussion club. so, let's talk about how will supply anti-aircraft systems to ukraine, the general of the military command of the armed forces of ukraine spoke with the head of the joint staff of the chiefs of staff of the armed forces of the united states, general michael zero, and now the question arises to what extent can we now expect such help from the united states and other nato member countries to mr. volodymyr and mr. valery already supplied, one might say, within the framework of the planned rammstein in this system e-e air defense systems are supplied in the well-known par

volodymyr kopchak, military expert, head of the south caucasian branch , the conversion and armamentisi. and now our next interlocutor is the former ambassador of the united states to ukraine , the chairman

to compensate in such a full amount, uh, in the event of the loss of our market, now both the south caucasianl asian countries, yes, in logistical terms. they already mean they are looking for other logistics to bypass us, because it is blocked, but we have a huge market in some countries of the reserve from the moment we started. uh, it means fighting for everyone, which means the gross product has grown significantly. why? well, because supplies go through them then gray schemes and so on, and losses. this one. well, no compensation is not european, our frightened patriots brought certain. yes, that means, as they say, a separate issue. and uh, so the second thing is, of course, that we have e. for all that, there is a large number of labor diaspora on our territory. yes, so to speak, who also earn to send there. it can't be replenished at all. and by the way, with regard to diasport, we also really need to be careful here. we see what was done in paris in a couple of days. yes, what happened there? so, now i will say, it means that no one will create such the missile is no tomahawk, they p

short term we are talking about, we control the situation regarding the agreement between the two south caucasian, but this contract cannot be an end in itself. i am for peace throughout the world, including in the caucasus. this treaty should determine our strategic interests in this region. let's get it there. we have some special rights to this . the right to be invested huge amounts for 200 years. it means the means of human life there. i repeat again, i hear 200,000 russian officers , generals, uh, and the soldiers died, so these damn, we can't just say that's all peace in the whole world. and now what do you want? no it's not will go again, what we see what happens during this time, while we are there, uh, we condemn some such scale, so to speak, yes, mr. pashinyan, for example, mr. armenia is discussing the us state department, how the contact between baku and stepanaket will be carried out not bad, yes, at the same time, stepanakerchik karabakh is our relatives. and what do you nail me to build? and who else? yes, there is no one else on the armenian, turkish border, in november a technic

able to compensate in such a full amount, uh, in the event of the loss of our market now, the south caucasianthey already mean they are looking for other logistics to bypass us, because it is blocked, but we have a huge market in some countries of the reserve from the moment we started. uh, it means fighting for everyone, which means the gross product has grown significantly. why? well, because supplies go, then through them so on to the gray schemes and so on, yes, and the loss. this one, well, no compensation, not europeans, frightened patriots, they brought certain ones. yes, that means, as they say, a separate issue. and uh, so the second thing is, of course, that we have a large number of labor diaspora on our territory. by the way, who also earn to send there. it can't be replenished at all. and by the way, with regard to the diaspora, we also really need to be careful here. we see what they did in paris for a couple of days. yes, what happened there? it means that no rocket, no tomahawk, they put anything like that, in fact, the kurds on their knees the entire administration. uh, that

south korea in a fire trap on the highway. there were dozens of cars. there are victim details after the advertisement. give your caucasianece the thirty-first of december on the russia channel hunting for gifts to wait. what a pity that he celebrated the new year with us one day. only then did gifts come true for purchases from 600 rubles. at check pyaterochka rescues and rescues gifts. magnets will be lucky in the new year, buy. play win a car and a wagon of prizes bought, dolgit yes one in a yellow package. i asked to buy a few, so that the debts would last for a long time. now in a package of 150 g. long 150 g. new large package. i came to the top five of wishes, so that here a million gifts and gifts are given many years ago. we saw the prospects where we were born, grew up and opened here . since then, we have continued to embody the prospects of those who are looking for a life's work. and those who sees the beauty around, wherever they are. uralsib prospects are where you are and now our conversation is coming unload, sausage, bundle, dairy 129 90 magnet lucky in the new year you use to securely fix prostheses. on