is so thank you very much. >> alice. >> commissioners and diane i didn't forgot forgot and i'm alice rogers and with the working group and really the privilege the waterfront plan is something that you were have to do. but there was nothing about this waterfront plan it and diane stated that but you dedicated thousands of dollars of time and to educate the community to examine and get all the issues to really three years worth. encourage public participation and testimony and ideas and that was um, we didn't get lost and i think thanks to rudy we didn't get lost and administer that was all on the substantive issues we were able to work with rudy and linda with diane and the entire team. i never would have thought i'll be in a group like that so a milestone i hope yourself approve that plan. >> thank you alice for being a great steward of our waterfront and appreciate all you have done and thank you for a committee chair and helping rudy and diane and bring the process to where it is today. thank you very much. >> okay. commissioners do i hear a motion to approve? the resolution 23-15 you so

thank you so much for your time. >> alice rogers thank you for your comments. all right, let's hear from our next caller, please. all right, billy that may be unattended. next caller, please. frankly we don't have a homelessness, we a urban homelessness problem. i'll tell you y let's play this out. imagine, we go ahead and spend a billion dollars to create mostly permanent housing, half a billion a year to manage and maintain it. what are we going to do when another 1,000 arrive in san francisco. how about the 4,000 after that. where does this end? do any of you, still believe that we can solve this by gifting 3 san francisco condos. martin boisei is a decision that we cannot stop urban camping until we have, sufficient heads. that's what we need to solve for. so we need a plan to create 2000 shelter beds. it does not need to be permanent housing. it does not need to be something that is embraced by the homeless communities. it needs to be 2000 beds. if hsh is incapable of presenting a plan that accomplishes that, you need to take it to bid to somebody who will