let's speak to david robinson.orjoining us. good morning. first, _ thank you forjoining us. good morning. first, what - thank you forjoining us. good morning. first, what is - thank you forjoining us. good morning. first, what is this i thank you forjoining us. good - morning. first, what is this report actually telling — morning. first, what is this report actually telling us _ morning. first, what is this report actually telling us in _ morning. first, what is this report actually telling us in terms - morning. first, what is this report actually telling us in terms of - morning. first, what is this report actually telling us in terms of the | actually telling us in terms of the big difference here in the participation levels? this big difference here in the participation levels? as you mentioned _ participation levels? as you mentioned in _ participation levels? as you mentioned in your - participation levels? as you - mentioned in your introduction, we looked at two key aspects. we looked at which groups of stu

next we have david robinson applying for seat 2. >> good morning. thank you for having me. my name is david robinson and own a home [indiscernible] few doors up the hill from octavia boulevard. thank you for reviewing my application to serve on the committee representing the hayes valley neighborhood . i was proposed to the committee by long time robin leveta mioral appointment to the committee. i attended a few meetings as a concerned resident and citizen. also a member of the board of the hayes valley neighborhood association and as of last week annual meeting in fact, dean, you may not know this yet but elected to serve as president for the upcoming term. i'm very active in the community and neighborhood, not only with the association, but assisting friends of urban forest planting trees with the refuge and [indiscernible] cleaning the steets. one of the cocaptains on the saturday morning cleanups in hayes valley. and evenen pitching in to clean clogged storm drains. most recently as the last tuesday. i also assist with court watch initiative at the hall of justice and s

of singapore, doctor ngozi okonjo-iweala director-general of the world trade organization and david robinson cochairmen the carlyle group it's a thank offering joining us. let me start off 2023 we surprised expectations the upside is a global economy really not as easily as we think? >> we are to think about it not on a year-to-year basis because the largest challenges of resilience we face are what's creaking beneath. it's the slow-moving changes that threaten us far more fundamentally in the years to come. we know what they are. we know what's happening in the shift in the global ecological balance. we know what's happening in terms of the aging of societies which we are by and large not prepared for it we know what's happening in the gradual drift towards polarization. these are the real threats to resilience and human security. and a not even talking about the wars, including the stupid wars that we see. >> thank you so much. can you talk to us about what you saw in 2023 that gives you hope for economies in the future? >> well, good morning to everyone first, and thank you for having me

let's bring in "the new yorker"'s david remnick and staff writer at "the atlantic" anne applebaum. eugene robinsonroblem. we have trump. from 2017 to 2021, you had republicans at least in the senate of the house that would pass strong legislation, anti-putin legislation. no more. they have collapsed. now, they really have folded into trump's, sort of, admirations of vladimir putin. >> well, i think it is important to recognize what's been lost here. a real sense of a russian future for millions of russians. this is as if south african regime had killed mandela in jail. imagine the repercussions of that for the south african future. imagine if havel had been killed in jail. bad enough he was jailed in the first place, but imagine what it would have meant to the czech future. this is a catastrophe, first and foremost, for the navalny family, but for the world, but for the stability of things, for the possibility of any kind of future or liberty in russia. the consequences are enormous. unfortunately, what's not surprising is that donald trump is a moral vacuum in a suit. the fact that he couldn't be

raven robinson , whose official monster robinson, whose official monster raving loony , and david tullyr the situation in gaza . a new report situation in gaza. a new report today alleges growing disagrees between the american president , between the american president, joe biden, and the israeli prime minister, benjamin netanyahu . minister, benjamin netanyahu. >> well, this comes as israel continues with its planned offensive in rafah . that's offensive in rafah. that's despite strong international criticism. >> joining us now , gb news >> joining us now, gb news reporter charlie peters on this one. so, um, if biden and netanyahu aren't seeing eye to eye, where does that leave us? well last night, president joe biden, after a meeting with king abdullah of jordan in the white house, said that the situation in rafah was disastrous. >> he said that people in there were packed and exposed and said that any planned operation inside rafah, that small city on the border with egypt in the small coastal enclave, would require a credible plan for the civilian population there before the war, po