we have chief scott from the san francisco police department and executive director paul henderson from the department of police accountability. all right. line item one. weekly officer recognition certificate. presentation of an

with us tonight are chief scott from the san francisco police department and executive director paul hendersonrtment of police accountability. thank you. welcome, everyone, to our january. seventh meeting. we can't believe we're already halfway through january. um, all right, let's get this party

tonight, we have chief scott from the san francisco police department and executive director paul henderson from the department of police accountability. uh, sergeant, could you call the first item, please? line item one. general public comment at this time. the public is now welcome to address the commission for up to two minutes on items that do not appear on tonight's agenda, but are within the subject matter jurisdiction of the police commission under police commission, rules of order during public comment, neither police or epa personnel nor commissioners are required to respond to questions by the public, but may provide a brief response. alternatively you may submit public comment in either of the following ways. email the secretary of the police commission at sfpd. commission at sf dot org or written comments may be sent via us postal service to the public safety building, located at 1245 third street, san francisco, california. 94158. if you would like to make public comment, please approach the podium. uh, good evening, commissioners. my name is charlotte and i'm a lifelong reside

joining us now, carol lam, former federal prosecutor, and paul henderson a veteran federal prosecutore there legitimate arguments to be made to dismiss this case? >> well, a lot of the arguments that donald trump's legal team has indicated they're going to file today are arguments that are rehashed that we've already seen in jack smith's other litigation. for example, presidential immunity now pending before the supreme court. so some of these arguments have already been made, some are going to be decided in short order so we're going to have to see exactly what they filed but one of the things they're going to file is a challenge even to the appointment of jack smith. they're going to say that the special counsel can't be appointed by just the attorney general. there has to be some sort of congressional approval. some of these issues have not made their way up to the supreme court, so again, this is a delay tactic that they are hoping to accomplish to put this trial off until after the november election, if at all. >> i was going to ask you if they were following the delay, delay, de

magazine senior writer and former federal prosecutor and veteran prosecutor and trial attorney paul hendersonrrett, what can you tell us about this supreme court move and the time line for hearing trump's immunity claim arguments? >> reporter: the court's decision here would set oral arguments on april 22nd, and then you're looking at another month or longer until you get a decision from the court. all of it pushes the start date for a potential trial late into the summer or possibly early into the fall, and up against what is an informal but predict effective doj policy not to engage in actions that might affect the outcome of an election within 60 days of an election. all of this is to say this delay puts in jeopardy the idea that this trial could be held, certainly concluded anytime before the election in november. remember, we don't have election day anymore. we have election month with early votes and so forth going on. i can tell you the trump team is thrilled by this development. they want to see this argument play out. legally speaking his strategy has long been to delay, delay, delay

um, i'll defer to sarah hawkins because paul henderson seems to be out.h, chief scott and commission uh, deputy chief peter walsh, uh, of the administrator bureau. i'll be conducting the presentation, uh, with the assistance of officer duarte. um, for the sparks report. okay slide. thank you. um, i know that you know the history, but just for the public, uh, the sparks resolution 2706 requires quarterly reports from both sfpd and dpa. uh, and we provide the police commission with policy, uh, development awareness. currently, um, the status updates on 19 dgos are actively going through a developmental process, and approximately i should say, 71 department notices are set to expire within 120 days. and again, this is for the fourth quarter next slide. one of the um, more important dgos, uh, that we wanted to update is 7.01, which is, uh, juveniles. um, it's been posted for the 30 day public review process. it concluded in december 13th, 2023. um, we received 55 entries, uh, which wound up being about 40 comments and recommendations on the grid. seven of tho

we have chief scott from the san francisco police department and executive director paul henderson from the department of police accountability. all right. line item one. weekly officer recognition certificate. presentation of an officer who has gone above and beyond in the performance of their duties. sergeant kira delaney, star number 1320 from the homicide unit. good evening. president or vice president? cornerstone commissioners. chief scott, director henderson. my name is kelvin sanders. i'm the lieutenant at the homicide detail this evening. i'd like to recognize and congratulate. sergeant kira delaney of our homicide detail for sergeant khiara. delaney has been working in homicide detail for 12 years and has been involved in investigating over 500 cases. sergeant delaney's years of dedicated service to the citizens of san francisco and members of san francisco police department are truly appreciated. i would like to thank sergeant delaney for her continued commitment, accomplishments and accomplishments, and tremendous success in bringing closure to so many families of homicide v

with us tonight are chief scott from the san francisco police department and executive director paul henderson from the department of police accountability. thank you. welcome, everyone, to our january. seventh meeting. we can't believe we're already halfway through january. um, all right, let's get this party started. so go ahead. line line item one weekly officer recognition certificate presentation of an officer who has gone above and beyond in the performance of their duties. sergeant patrice heath, star number 40 209. forensic science division csi. oh, this is your people, right. here. thank you. hi thank you. commissioners executive director and chief for this opportunity to recognize sergeant heath. uh just to tell you a little bit about what the day to day at csi is, they, uh, like everyone else in the department, they're short staffed. so there's a lot of on call. they're expected to respond to scenes 24 over seven. um a lot of backfill. they've um, about nine people in the unit, two of which are in training, and they've done over 1000 scenes in 2023. so they're they're very busy. and

uh paul henderson and uh, chief scott. uh, tonight i am introducing lieutenant lisa springer from the internal affairs division, who will be doing the presentation, uh, on the fourth quarter, firearms discharge review board. um, there is a slide packet. and just for note, we won't go into the very end, which lists all the previous cases, but for your, uh, for you to review and then we can take any questions after that. good evening, president elias. vice president carter oberstein, director henderson, commissioners and chief scott, um, as dc walsh said, i am lisa springer and i am the officer in charge of the internal affairs division. and i'm just here to talk about the firearm discharge review board. um, summary for the fourth quarter of 2023. so there's two cases we're going to talk about tonight. the first one involves officer shooting 17 dash 007. this actually occurred in 2017. on december 1st when officers from bayview responded to a report of a carjacking. uh the vehicle that was carjacked was reported as a white l

tonight, we have chief scott from the san francisco police department and executive director paul hendersonment of police accountability. hello, everyone. welcome. happy valentine's day. i know it's so great to be her

commissioners executive director paul henderson and chief william scott, it's our honor to be here tonight to present the second quarter disciplinary review board. myself and chief of staff hawkins will be co-presenting today. we understand we are in the late hours, so we will get through this briefly. um, the second quarter display review board, convene. on august 28th for iads aggregate trends. there was a failure to report for duty at a mandatory overtime assignment, as well as failed to follow an email directives. these were specifically attached to the mandatory overtime wheel, which ended in november. uh and mid november. so that's resolved itself at and for dpa. the aggregate trends were failure to activate body worn camera and inappropriate language or comments. i'm just going to note that we're going to probably just speak because the slides are showing up, um, in a not user friendly format for reviewing on a screen. so we'll just we'll just talk. and then the third item that was touched on is the board really got into depth about what is the definition of aggregate trend. and you

we have chief scott from the san francisco police department and executive director paul henderson fromtment of police accountability. all right. line item one. weekly officer recognition certificate. presentation of an officer who has gone above and

> i am paul, sheriff of san francisco. [ music ] >> february 20, 2024 regular meeting of the municipal transportation board of directors and parking commission. >> item 2, roll call. >> henderson, present. hinze, present. tarlov, present. eaken, present. director so is not expected today but we are expecting --places on item 3, the ringing and use of cell phones and electronic devices are prohibited at the meeting. the chair may removal from the room.