now this happens from beethoven to brahms, bruckner, mahler, richard strauss, john williams. and i think that shaped our collective memory. today we have three of our academies here to get a masterclass. two violinists, one flute player. our academy is a training program for young musicians to become excellent orchestral musicians. being the academy for me is a great gift. i can rememberwatching, i think, every new year'sl concert to vienna philharmonic my whole life _ you get so many opportunities to play with the orchestra and to rehearse with them. to nurture young players, this is our future. the orchestra is now since 183 years. because of all our great composers who shaped our sounds. we had members who played in the first performance of beethoven's ninth symphony conducted by beethoven. so these people brought the knowledge how beethoven wanted his music to be played into our orchestras. now this happens from beethoven to brahms, bruckner, mahler, richard strauss, john williams. and i think that shaped our collective memory. today we have three of our academies here to

and we're joined now by over at bruckner, who is a professor of political science at stanford university in bill, and he joins us from the len, thanks very much for being with us here on al jazeera. first of all, what's your reaction to this proposal? i mean, does it make sense from the both syrians, but as, as well as gemini as a whole? well, the situation is a very complex one, because when we only look at the aggregated number is that there is something like a 1000000 people off the story. and do send in germany, and some of them have changed their nationality. some have this state or some have all those staters people who look at this from various angles depending on where they stand politically. so what we just heard from dominic is that there's a growing number of people who simply want to know what the burden of granting asylum and giving a helping hand to people. indeed which is true. but at the same time, there's still a vast majority of people who are strongly committed to that you might need terry and supports to people in need. and if the circumstances have changed, then one