commissioner chen chen i chair dorsey i dorsey i. ommissioner and guardian and guardian i commissioner fielder. fielder i. commissioner mahmood mahmood ai vice chair amendment amendment i. commissioner melgar melgar i commissioner sardar sardar i. commissioner sherril sherril i. commissioner walton walton i there are ten eyes. the motion to approve the minutes has passed. >> thank you, madam clerk. the minutes are approved. >> would you please call the next item? item five election of chair and vice chair for 2025. this is an action item. >> thank you, madam clerk. nominations are now in order for the office of the chair. commissioner madam, i would like to nominate our extraordinary chair matt dorsey to continue to serve. >> thank you. commissioner randleman. >> is there a second shot? commissioner sherril are there any further nominations? if so i think nominations are now closed. madam clerk, can we please check for public comment on nominations for the office of chair? >> there are no public. there is no public comment in chambers

chair mahmood vice chair mahmood i member salter high member salter i chair dorsey i chair dorsey i have three eyes. >> thank you madam clerk the motion passes and congratulations to the applicant. madam clerk, can you please call the next item? >> yes. item number two is a hearing to consider that the person to person premise to premise transfer of a type 21 off sale general beer wine and distilled spirits liquor license to dapper hill llc to one businesses dapper located at 1198 pacific avenue will serve the public convenience or necessity of the city and county of san francisco. >> thank you madam clerk and i think now i'll welcome up officer froines from s.f. pd's abc liaison unit officer florence the floor is yours. >> thank you. good morning. you have before you a pc and report for dapper hill to operate as dapper they have applied for a type 21 license and if approved this would allow them to operate an off sale general package store at 1190 1198 pacific avenue. there are zero letters of support zero letters of protest . they're located in plot 136b which is considered a low crime

commissioner chen chen i chair dorsey i dorsey i. ommissioner and guardian and guardian i commissioner fielder. fielder i. commissioner mahmood mahmood ai vice chair amendment amendment i. commissioner melgar melgar i commissioner sardar sardar i. commissioner sherril sherril i. commissioner walton walton i there are ten eyes. the motion to approve the minutes has passed. >> thank you, madam clerk. the minutes are approved. >> would you please call the next item? item five election of chair and vice chair for 2025. this is an action item. >> thank you, madam clerk. nominations are now in order for the office of the chair. commissioner madam, i would like to nominate our extraordinary chair matt dorsey to continue to serve. >> thank you. commissioner randleman. >> is there a second shot? commissioner sherril are there any further nominations? if so i think nominations are now closed. madam clerk, can we please check for public comment on nominations for the office of chair? >> there are no public. there is no public comment in chambers

>> so so vice chair dorsey thank you chair chin so i think i agree with the sentiment that chair chan is expressing. it is hard in this role to say no $2 but i've also been around this building long enough to see that tax litigation can create some really big uncertainties and when i first started in the city attorney's office actually it was then city attorney louise rennie was settling. gross receipts tax case for $80 million that could have been had that gone to trial up closer to 600 million. so i'm sensitive to some of the uncertainties that litigation may create even when we think our city attorney thinks that we may prevail on things. so i'm inclined to support this. >> thank you. >> and so with that we'll go to public comment on both items. >> yes, we are now opening public comment for both items two and three if we have any members of the public joining us today who wish to address this committee. >> madam chair, we have no speakers seeing no public comments. public comment is now close and colleagues, i would like to move this forward to full bore with recommendation and a r

vice chair dorsey thank you. i just wanted to say i appreciate the blue flagging this and also spelling out what the improvements were too because i think when it's a 2021 building it does raise obvious questions why we are making adjustments and i think it's the point is well taken that there may be times where it's legitimate but it would be good to know that sooner. the other thing i would say is i appreciate hsa for engaging with my residents well on this you know this is in my district and i'm happy to support it. >> thank you and with that let's go to public comment on this item. >> yes, we're not opening public comment for this item number six if we have any members of the public who wish to address this committee. >> madam chair, we have no speakers seen no public comments. public comment is now closed. and with that i would like to make the motion to amend as provided by department of homelessness in support of housing on page four lines six ,five and six and i move to amend item to full board with recom

vice chair dorsey i and dorsey i remember engardio and engardio i church and i janai we have three eyes the motion passes and with that mr. clerk do we have any other business before us today i madam chair that concludes our business. >> thank you. and we will return today. as for our first budget and appropriation committee hearing starting at 130 if i may. >> yes, i'm sorry. i just want to take a brief moment of your time to introduce my new deputy director of real estate, lisa giovanni lee. she's replacing claudia gorham who recently retired. >> oh, congratulations. welcome on board. we look forward to seeing you in this chamber. >> we look forward to working with you. nice to meet you. thank you. >> with that weight i was in as 130 today and as our budget appropriation committee the first one and we'll have just one item on the agenda hearing so we see that we were return then and no other business before us. >> that's correct madam chair. thank you. and the meeting is adjourned >> [indiscernible] it was something i remembered learning in middle school, but it was a far away concept

deputy director for planning to present this item so i could have floor is yours. >> good morning chair dorsey vice chair mailman s.f. governs sharing my slides. >> as chair dorsey mentioned we were awarded this $20 million community change grant from the u.s. environmental protection agency for a package of transportation projects for treasure island in december. we have an award agreement and the grant is considered obligated. no local matches required and the period of performance is three years starting in this past january. the grant is funded through the environmental and climate justice program of the epa. so funded by the inflation reduction act. so there is some uncertainty around it at this moment. however we're moving ahead with this action item in anticipation of being able to move forward. the treasure island connects program delivers priority recommendations from the treasure island supplemental transportation study that we conducted with one treasure island which was funded by the transportation authority. we work very closely with one treasure island and the treasure island com

project where we will land in terms of both budget deficit in the coming weeks so to speak. >> vice chair dorsey oops, sorry. >> thank you. chair in this church and touched on something that i was going to ask about that i've talked about before just that the thing that feels to me like the biggest uncertainty out there is the federal and what they're going to be doing. i think in so many respects we're in uncharted water and i note that the your presentation says that we're assuming no changes from the federal. >> i would i don't know if that's and i don't think any of us know if that's a good assumption or not. i don't know given the uncharted waters that we're in and given the fact that some of this i think is subject to city attorney litigation that i think that san francisco is affirmatively sued with some other jurisdictions around what the federal is doing. >> would it be helpful to have a closed session on what we might be looking at? i just you know, i don't know that i would imagine given that it is some somewhat involved in litigation i'm not even sure to whom i'm asking this question

chair chen i appreciate you letting me move this forward and that concludes my remarks. thank you. supervisor dorsey supervisor mumia, you have any comment? no. okay. thank you colleagues if there are no other questions. okay, let's go to public comment. >> thank you, madam chair. land use and transportation will now hear public comment on agenda item members of one and two which are called together they are related to the central so transit center district commercial development requirements. if you have public comment for these two items please come forward to the lectern for your two minutes. >> hello david wu with some of filipinos. we want to thank the planning department d the mayor's office and supervisor dorsey for hearing the community's concerns regarding this legislation and maintaining the key site commitments for affordable housing and other neighborhood amenities. this will help to ensure that as these sites get developed there will be space for low income and working class families in 100% affordable housing that truly meets the needs of the soma community. the original central soma p

chair chen i appreciate you letting me move this forward and that concludes my remarks. thank you. supervisor dorsey supervisor mumia, you have any comment? no. okay. thank you colleagues if there are no other questions. okay, let's go to public comment. >> thank you, madam chair. land use and transportation will now hear public comment on agenda item members of one and two which are called together they are related to the central so transit center district commercial development requirements. if you have public comment for these two items please come forward to the lectern for your two minutes. >> hello david wu with some of filipinos. we want to thank the planning department d the mayor's office and supervisor dorsey for hearing the community's concerns regarding this legislation and maintaining the key site commitments for affordable housing and other neighborhood amenities. this will help to ensure that as these sites get developed there will be space for low income and working class families in 100% affordable housing that truly meets the needs of the soma community. the original central soma p

i'm joined by vice chair supervisor matt dorsey and members supervisor joanne gaudio

i just want to express that my sentiment and concur what was expressed by supervisor dorsey ,our vice chairittee i regretfully want is to say that i think the committee actually has a chair sentiment and that we have a consensus of how we're going to approach items like as such. so colleagues, i urge you to to evaluate in. feel free to ask any of the member of the committee questions should you see any items that come out with our recommendation? it really is actually still a indication that we are in consensus as this item is coming out with that recommendation. >> i hope that you will see less of it but regrettably i don't think that's the case because we are going to be tougher and tougher days ahead. thank you. >> supervisor sherril i want to add my voice to my colleagues supervisors dorsey and chan whose remarks i will not repeat but i wish to echo these contractors require adequate resources and support to be successful but there must also be clear accountability when agreed upon performance metrics are not met or one of agreed upon performance metrics are not realistic. supervisor do

chen i commissioner dorsey dorsey i commissioner and guardian in gardell i commissioner fielder felder i commissioner mahmood mahmud i commissioner randleman madam and i chairgar i melgar i vice chair slaughter sardar i commissioner sherril sherril i commissioner walton walton i there are 11 eyes the motion to approve the minutes has passed i thank you madam clerk please call the next item. >> items five through eight comprise the consent agenda staff is not planning to present on these items but are available for questions. >> okay. thank you madam clerk. we do not need public comment to on consent item so unless one of you has an item that they want to pull up let's have a motion please to approve the consent agenda. okay by commissioner mahmood seconded by commissioner mandel men madam clerk, please call the roll on the motion to approve the consent agenda just yes let's do same house, same call. >> thank you. let's go to our next item please. madam clerk. >> exciting item nine regional transportation revenue measure polling results this is an information item. >> okay. >> what we've been waiting for. thank you so much. >> we have our chief deputy direct

chair. >> i first want to thank mayor lori and supervisor dorsey for their partnership on this important piece of legislation that will bring more housing downtown and make use of our city's excess vacant office spaces. thank you to to chair melgar for helping move this legislation forward and land use committee and of course to supervisor chen for working with us to craft today's amendments in the committee we added language to refer this waiver to the inclusionary technical advisory committee tac as part of the feasibility review that occurs every three years. in discussions with supervisor chen we have agreed to go further to add a clear boundary on this program. i'm glad we could come to this compromise that responds to the concerns raised by many community organizations about making this waiver indefinite. so today i am introducing an amendment to place a 7,000,000 square foot cap on the total square footage subject to this development fee waiver in addition to two small technical amendments that accommodate the cap in the legislation. the reason being is by setting a cap on square footag