cory nicolet (on recording): ok. hotel and gotten out of town, but how? the deputy assumed tim rented a new car after he wrecked his first. and so he went over to the main car rental company in town, enterprise. cory nicolet (on recording): so you know who i'm talking about? i have an idea, yeah. dennis murphy (voiceover): sure enough, the rental associate on duty said tim dean had been there. he was the walk-in from texas who didn't have a credit card on him. he walked in and then i told him that he couldn't rent because he just had cash on him. and he was really upset about that, and he just left. dennis murphy (voiceover): left but for where? back home to texas or somewhere else? this was about 48 hours before josh and amber would be executed in sodus, new york. back at his station, deputy nicolet thought back on that long chit chat he'd had with tim dean. and there on that body cam video was a back and forth that stopped him cold. dennis murphy (voiceover): new york, the scene of the crime. deputy nicolet relayed