42
42
Jun 13, 2015
06/15
by
ALJAZAM
quote
eye 42
favorite 0
quote 7
that's it.
stay toournd tuned, ray suarez and
"inside story" start now.
>> the nine justices of the
supreme court include one
justice in her 80s and seven in
their 70s.
the next president may get to a
point two three even four
justices shaping the nation's
highest court for a generation.
is black robes gray hair, it's
tonighttonight's "inside story."
that's it.
stay toournd tuned, ray suarez and
"inside story" start now.
>> the nine justices of the
supreme court include one
justice in her 80s and seven in
their 70s.
the next president may get to a
point two three even four
justices shaping the nation's
highest court for a generation.
is black robes gray hair, it's
tonighttonight's "inside story."
945
945
Jun 13, 2015
06/15
by
ALJAZAM
quote
eye 945
favorite 0
quote 7
the time of the constitution was
about 50 years old.
they didn't expect that.
the way the escort is built
presidents are -- what they try
to do is find the most ideologic
individual who's young enough,
who's old enough to have some
experience but young enough they
can survive another 40 years.
you look at the last set of
nominees, roberts was 50, kagan
was 50, alito and sotomayor was
also 50.
what the presidents were
incentivized to do is find
somebody who is very ideologic
and already has these entrenched
views.
most of the justices in the
supreme court worked in a
presidential administration,
whether it was reagan or ford or
obama, most worked in a
presidential administration, i
don't think you want third
parties deciding how to
the time of the constitution was
about 50 years old.
they didn't expect that.
the way the escort is built
presidents are -- what they try
to do is find the most ideologic
individual who's young enough,
who's old enough to have some
experience but young enough they
can survive another 40 years.
you look at the last set of
nominees, roberts was 50, kagan
was 50, alito and sotomayor was
also 50.
what the presidents were
incentivized to do is find
somebody who is very ideologic
and already has...
925
925
Jun 13, 2015
06/15
by
ALJAZAM
quote
eye 925
favorite 0
quote 7
there are four justices
clustered around 80 years old.
we're talking about the
reasonable assumption the next
president whoever that may be
could have a big impact on the
makeup of the court for a long
time to come.
joining me are allen porter
mendenhall and gabe ross,
executive director of fix court
who advocates for change and
trups in the operation ofbetransportcy.
transparency.
>> if you accept this concept
that there's a 4-4 split with
kennedy in the middle as a swing
vote then you know the court's
twg to be tipped one way or the
other.
only four presidents in history
have not nominated a candidate
to the supreme court.
two of those died and their
immediate successors nominated
somebody.
jimmy carter is the most recent
president not to.
you can be pretty certain that
the next president will get to
nominate somebody and given that
four justices will be in their
80s during the next
administration's four year term
i think the likelihood is even
high are.
and the opportunity to...
there are four justices
clustered around 80 years old.
we're talking about the
reasonable assumption the next
president whoever that may be
could have a big impact on the
makeup of the court for a long
time to come.
joining me are allen porter
mendenhall and gabe ross,
executive director of fix court
who advocates for change and
trups in the operation ofbetransportcy.
transparency.
>> if you accept this concept
that there's a 4-4 split with
kennedy in the middle as a swing
vote then you...
1,276
1.3K
Jun 13, 2015
06/15
by
ALJAZAM
quote
eye 1,276
favorite 0
quote 7
apolitical element of the
justices job.
but we have so many years of
press accidents in the doctrine
of sare decisis an old common
law doctrine and now you have
precedence on top of the
constitution.
and unless you can get
underneath all those precedents,
i don't know you can get to the
apolitical constitution.
>> gabe is suggesting term
limits and when you look at
something like justice kennedy
who has been around for 27
years, antonin scalia who has
been around osimilar length of
time, they get to cast a pretty
long salad owe across political
history.
people didn't live that long in
1789.
were we really planning to have
a court like this, first gabe.
>> no, i don't think the
founders were.
the average life expectancy at
the time of the constitution was
apolitical element of the
justices job.
but we have so many years of
press accidents in the doctrine
of sare decisis an old common
law doctrine and now you have
precedence on top of the
constitution.
and unless you can get
underneath all those precedents,
i don't know you can get to the
apolitical constitution.
>> gabe is suggesting term
limits and when you look at
something like justice kennedy
who has been around for 27
years, antonin scalia who has
been around osimilar length of
time,...
1,270
1.3K
Jun 13, 2015
06/15
by
ALJAZAM
quote
eye 1,270
favorite 0
quote 7
have a chance to get a 6-3
majorities, given scalia's
conservative voting record.
>> do you believe that justices
gain their requirements, unless
they have to leave they keep an
eye on the politics of it, who's
in the senate and who's in the
oval office?
>> i definitely think that they
do ray.
and it's a shame really.
there shouldn't be any partisan
politics at the supreme court.
we know that hasn't been the
case there has been
partisanship at the highest
court but politics is supposed
to be out of the court.
what we see the court advocate
for is a standard 18-year term
for supreme court justices.
so every two years there would
be a new justice coming in, two
times nine justices so that
would be an 18-year term.
so that's what we've been
advocating for and that's what
we hope the next individual
have a chance to get a 6-3
majorities, given scalia's
conservative voting record.
>> do you believe that justices
gain their requirements, unless
they have to leave they keep an
eye on the politics of it, who's
in the senate and who's in the
oval office?
>> i definitely think that they
do ray.
and it's a shame really.
there shouldn't be any partisan
politics at the supreme court.
we know that hasn't been the
case there has been
partisanship at the highest
court but politics is...
1,156
1.2K
Jun 13, 2015
06/15
by
ALJAZAM
quote
eye 1,156
favorite 0
quote 7
i can't blame the president for
wanting to do it.
i can't blame senators who are
under pressure from special
interest groups and these sorts
of things to want to nominate
somebody who is going to comport
with their long term vision for
america and fort for the courts.
whether that is good
structurally is another
somewhere question.
what i'm hearing gabe say about
the age raises a good point
about the constitution which
provides no mechanism for a
supreme court justice who is
incapacitated in some way say in
a vegetative state is in a coma
or some sort of situation like
that.
there's no mechanism
constitutionally for removing
that person from office if that
person can't voluntarily do so
and i think the one thing is --
>> gabe quick response.
>> a number of the justices i'm
not going to name names here
necessarily but a number of the
justices we've heard stats or
i can't blame the president for
wanting to do it.
i can't blame senators who are
under pressure from special
interest groups and these sorts
of things to want to nominate
somebody who is going to comport
with their long term vision for
america and fort for the courts.
whether that is good
structurally is another
somewhere question.
what i'm hearing gabe say about
the age raises a good point
about the constitution which
provides no mechanism for a
supreme court justice who is
incapacitated in...
848
848
Jun 13, 2015
06/15
by
ALJAZAM
quote
eye 848
favorite 0
quote 7
don't think you want third
parties deciding how to
interpret our laws.
>> this latest era that gabe
defines really start with
clarence thomas who was young
was ideologic could be expected
to be around for a long time on
the bench?
>> well, i do think it started
about that time.
and clearly it's become the
trend.
i think in the past 30 years or
so justices started to search 20
years or so.
president saying i think it's
good thing to nominate somebody
who's only he going to be on the
court for a decade or so, the
whole system is structured to
incentivize someone who can stay
on for a long time.
i can't blame the president for
don't think you want third
parties deciding how to
interpret our laws.
>> this latest era that gabe
defines really start with
clarence thomas who was young
was ideologic could be expected
to be around for a long time on
the bench?
>> well, i do think it started
about that time.
and clearly it's become the
trend.
i think in the past 30 years or
so justices started to search 20
years or so.
president saying i think it's
good thing to nominate somebody
who's only he going to be on...