but my bet is a lot of that will be coming from youtube. youtube has been doing really well. there are a lot of questions about youtube recovering from a whole brand safety scare earlier in the year. the evidence suggests they are. we have seen meaningful price increases. we have seen almost every single advertiser back on youtube, so that is certainly a highlight. beyond that, i think it is overall health in the ad business. clearly, there are a lot of other bets out there. the revenue is growing. a lot is continuing. at least when i have seen so far, there is no real standout success. but clearly revenue growth is a good sign. to start being meaningfully prosperous, we will need a lot more growth yet. emily: alphabet now totaling $3.4 billion, and spending has dropped dramatically over the year. million last