the state health minister in hindsight said he would not have allowed them off area massive understatement and that was one of four cruise ship switch have been allowed to dock in sydney. the response has been chaotic or the government and to governments seem to be contradicting themselves. we had the state premier in new south wales thing schools remain open and parents are encouraged to keep children home. you have to wonder about the coherence of the public response in australia. >> what about the economic, monetary and fiscal response? paul: that seems to be more muscular. there was the package announced a couple of weeks ago that looked like a popgun compared to what other countries started doing that has amped up as well. it is about $33 billion u.s. strong measures including