2,335
2.3K
Oct 25, 2014
10/14
by
WHYY
quote
eye 2,335
favorite 0
quote 14
thank you and be careful.
"citizenfour."
>> who are you?
i work for --
what is your name.
edward snowden.
i go by ed.
edward joseph snowden is the
full name.
>> charlie: poitras received
the pulitzer for her work on the
snowden leaks and co-founder of
the intersef.
thank you and be careful.
"citizenfour."
>> who are you?
i work for --
what is your name.
edward snowden.
i go by ed.
edward joseph snowden is the
full name.
>> charlie: poitras received
the pulitzer for her work on the
snowden leaks and co-founder of
the intersef.
2,063
2.1K
Oct 25, 2014
10/14
by
WHYY
quote
eye 2,063
favorite 0
quote 14
tools for over a decade.
>> charlie: we said in the
last couple of weeks, a case
where the head of the f.b.i.
said on 60 minutes, you know,
that they were very concerned
about the fact that, you know,
these things -- that they had no
access.
they didn't have the encryption
code.
>> i have a lot of friends who
are cryptographers.
if you have a system that has
back doors, it's naive to think
only the u.s. can break the back
doors, that other gochts can
break them and you have a
system, an internet that's
insecure by design and there are
a lot of people who think that's
tools for over a decade.
>> charlie: we said in the
last couple of weeks, a case
where the head of the f.b.i.
said on 60 minutes, you know,
that they were very concerned
about the fact that, you know,
these things -- that they had no
access.
they didn't have the encryption
code.
>> i have a lot of friends who
are cryptographers.
if you have a system that has
back doors, it's naive to think
only the u.s. can break the back
doors, that other gochts can
break them and you have...
2,168
2.2K
Oct 25, 2014
10/14
by
WHYY
quote
eye 2,168
favorite 0
quote 14
some cases you said yes and in
some no.
is that fair?
>> everyone goes through the
contact and confrontation with
the government saying, this is
what we intent to publish, do
you want to comment on it and do
you have any concerns about what
we're publishing?
in terms of stories i've worked
on, i'm trying to think -- there
were some redactions of stories
that i've worked on that have
happened because the government
made a persuasive argument that
they should be redacted, but in
general, you know, these
decisions are made in newsrooms,
the guardian of the sometimes.
>> charlie: these decisions
are made in newsrooms all over
the country, had nothing to do
with edward snowden.
>> sure, this is the process.
everything has gone through that
process in terms of harmony.
we have been careful in terms of
some cases you said yes and in
some no.
is that fair?
>> everyone goes through the
contact and confrontation with
the government saying, this is
what we intent to publish, do
you want to comment on it and do
you have any concerns about what
we're publishing?
in terms of stories i've worked
on, i'm trying to think -- there
were some redactions of stories
that i've worked on that have
happened because the government
made a persuasive argument that
they should be redacted, but in
general,...
1,931
1.9K
Oct 25, 2014
10/14
by
WHYY
quote
eye 1,931
favorite 0
quote 14
here's a trailer for
"citizenfour."
>> laura, at this stage, i can
offer nothing more than my word.
i am a senior government
employee in the intelligence
community.
i hope you understand the con
text, this is extremely high
risk.
know every border you cross,
every purchase you make, every
call you dial, cell phone tower
you pass, friend you keep, site
you visit and subject you type
is in the hands of a system
whose reach is unlimited but
whose safeguards are not.
in the end if you publish the
material, i will likely be
implicated.
i ask only that you ensure this
information makes it home to the
american public.
thank you and be careful.
here's a trailer for
"citizenfour."
>> laura, at this stage, i can
offer nothing more than my word.
i am a senior government
employee in the intelligence
community.
i hope you understand the con
text, this is extremely high
risk.
know every border you cross,
every purchase you make, every
call you dial, cell phone tower
you pass, friend you keep, site
you visit and subject you type
is in the hands of a system
whose reach is unlimited but
whose safeguards are not.
in the end if...
1,815
1.8K
Oct 25, 2014
10/14
by
WHYY
quote
eye 1,815
favorite 0
quote 14
go public as the source, to
acknowledge he is the source.
>> people say, are you going
public?
>> i think it's soon.
i think as soon as they try to
make this about me, which should
be any day now, i'll come out
just to go, hey, you know, this
is not a question of somebody
skullicking around in the
shadows.
these are public issues, not my
issues.
these are everybody's issues and
i'm not afraid of you.
you're not going to bully me
into silence like you've done to
everybody else.
and if nobody else will do it, i
will.
and hopefully, when i'm gone,
whatever you do to me, somebody
else will do the same thing.
it will be the sort of internet
principle of the hydra.
go public as the source, to
acknowledge he is the source.
>> people say, are you going
public?
>> i think it's soon.
i think as soon as they try to
make this about me, which should
be any day now, i'll come out
just to go, hey, you know, this
is not a question of somebody
skullicking around in the
shadows.
these are public issues, not my
issues.
these are everybody's issues and
i'm not afraid of you.
you're not going to bully me
into silence like you've done to
everybody else.
and...
1,785
1.8K
Oct 25, 2014
10/14
by
WHYY
quote
eye 1,785
favorite 0
quote 14
hasn't been actual changes yet.
you know, in terms of i have
been working on post-9/11 stuff
for a long time and i think one
of the dilemmas i've seen is a
lot of the policies we're
engaging in, i would argue they
don't necessarily make us safer.
if you look at the iraq war
which i documented, you know, i
think that we're seeing now some
of the unintended consequences
of that occupation and what
happened and the kind of
instability in the region.
so i think that i'm not fully
convinced that the security that
the government says that they're
providing in these policies for
hasn't been actual changes yet.
you know, in terms of i have
been working on post-9/11 stuff
for a long time and i think one
of the dilemmas i've seen is a
lot of the policies we're
engaging in, i would argue they
don't necessarily make us safer.
if you look at the iraq war
which i documented, you know, i
think that we're seeing now some
of the unintended consequences
of that occupation and what
happened and the kind of
instability in the region.
so i think that i'm not fully
convinced that the...
1,916
1.9K
Oct 25, 2014
10/14
by
WHYY
quote
eye 1,916
favorite 0
quote 14
that has absolutely changed.
we're seeing that shift.
we're seeing more change in the
technology companies and in our
government in the sense that the
tech knoll companies realize
that the customers do want to be
able to communicate privately
and they want to build tools
that will satisfy that.
so i think we're going to see
more and more technology
companies coming forward and
offering ways to encrypt
communication.
i also think there's a movement
of the free software movement
that have been building these
tools for over a decade.
that has absolutely changed.
we're seeing that shift.
we're seeing more change in the
technology companies and in our
government in the sense that the
tech knoll companies realize
that the customers do want to be
able to communicate privately
and they want to build tools
that will satisfy that.
so i think we're going to see
more and more technology
companies coming forward and
offering ways to encrypt
communication.
i also think there's a movement
of the free software movement
that have been...
2,176
2.2K
Oct 25, 2014
10/14
by
WHYY
quote
eye 2,176
favorite 0
quote 14
the -- i guess you could say the
effect that you feel you're
being monitored or surveilled.
>> charlie: what do you hope
this accomplishes?
>> for me, it's a documentary or
story about journalism, about
what happens, journalists
working on a story.
it's very much a story of the
era of crackdown on forces and
whistle blowers and journalism
we've seen in the last years
where you have people like my
friend and colleague james risen
who's being subpoenaed and
potentially will go to jail
because he's not going to
testify against a source, and
the government is doing a lot of
these things.
we know they subpoenaed the
phone records of the a.p.
so i think it's a portrait of
journalism done in difficult
circumstances and i think it's a
story about somebody willing to
take personal risks, sacrifices
to expose information they think
the public has a right to know.
the -- i guess you could say the
effect that you feel you're
being monitored or surveilled.
>> charlie: what do you hope
this accomplishes?
>> for me, it's a documentary or
story about journalism, about
what happens, journalists
working on a story.
it's very much a story of the
era of crackdown on forces and
whistle blowers and journalism
we've seen in the last years
where you have people like my
friend and colleague james risen
who's being subpoenaed and
potentially will go to...
2,518
2.5K
Oct 25, 2014
10/14
by
WHYY
quote
eye 2,518
favorite 0
quote 14
>> he's definitely an idealist.
he's somebody who very much grew
up on the internet.
he is the generation that came
of age on the internet.
and he came of age and says this
in the film where the internet
was a free place and he believes
it was one of the most beautiful
things humanity could ever have.
that you could have a means
where people from all over the
world, all ages, communicating
freely with each other.
i think that really motivated
him.
but to see that be something
that's sort of taken away from
people and used for other
means -- means of surveillance,
commercial means.
so i think he saw something that
he thought was really profound
and should be protected and that
was slipping away.
>> charlie: so that was his
motivation?
>> i think that's the core
motivation, yeah.
>> he's definitely an idealist.
he's somebody who very much grew
up on the internet.
he is the generation that came
of age on the internet.
and he came of age and says this
in the film where the internet
was a free place and he believes
it was one of the most beautiful
things humanity could ever have.
that you could have a means
where people from all over the
world, all ages, communicating
freely with each other.
i think that really motivated
him.
but to see that be something
that's sort...
1,762
1.8K
Oct 25, 2014
10/14
by
WHYY
quote
eye 1,762
favorite 0
quote 14
consciousness globally around
what states are capable of
doing, what intelligence
agencies are capable of doing.
so i think he's raised that
awareness.
i think one of his main goals is
he shows things like we live in
a democracy, we have a rule of
law and a constitution and there
were things happening in secret
consciousness globally around
what states are capable of
doing, what intelligence
agencies are capable of doing.
so i think he's raised that
awareness.
i think one of his main goals is
he shows things like we live in
a democracy, we have a rule of
law and a constitution and there
were things happening in secret
1,838
1.8K
Oct 25, 2014
10/14
by
WHYY
quote
eye 1,838
favorite 0
quote 14
the reporting that we've done.
>> charlie: they argue, for
example, they'll argue that
somehow people will know what
sources they have, not in terms
of individuals, but they will
know their means and that that
somehow will result in them
having to go through a process
of having to redo whatever means
they had, spying on enemies of
the state, so to speak.
>> i mean, i would say -- i
mean, there are stories i've
worked on and doing the
reporting and there are two
stories that talk about one of
the things they're doing in
terms of targeting.
they've gone and targeted
engineers at telecoms, so the
people who are sort of the
keepers of the passwords and
gateways into the
telecommunication systems.
we have documents that show
actual names of people who work
for belgian telekom in germany
the reporting that we've done.
>> charlie: they argue, for
example, they'll argue that
somehow people will know what
sources they have, not in terms
of individuals, but they will
know their means and that that
somehow will result in them
having to go through a process
of having to redo whatever means
they had, spying on enemies of
the state, so to speak.
>> i mean, i would say -- i
mean, there are stories i've
worked on and doing the
reporting and there are two
stories that talk...
1,840
1.8K
Oct 25, 2014
10/14
by
WHYY
quote
eye 1,840
favorite 0
quote 14
and names of engineers, these
are people not suspected
overanything.
the only reason you see h.q.
which is a british intelligence
agency and the n.s.a. are
interested in is because these
people are, you know, an access
point to get to their networks.
and, i mean, yeah, i have
published those kinds of stories
and it does reveal that they're
doing something so if you have
an individual goes to their
linkedin page and the h.q.
or n.s.a. will send back
malicious software that will
affect the engineer's computer
and they go and type in a
password and then the n.s.a. or
h.q. has their password.
this is happening in allied
countries and in europe.
i think this reporting should
happen and there should be
questions about the extent of
these technologies.
and names of engineers, these
are people not suspected
overanything.
the only reason you see h.q.
which is a british intelligence
agency and the n.s.a. are
interested in is because these
people are, you know, an access
point to get to their networks.
and, i mean, yeah, i have
published those kinds of stories
and it does reveal that they're
doing something so if you have
an individual goes to their
linkedin page and the h.q.
or n.s.a. will send back
malicious software that will
affect the...
1,828
1.8K
Oct 25, 2014
10/14
by
WHYY
quote
eye 1,828
favorite 0
quote 14
of question that things are
ongoing and threats -- you know,
i think -- i believe that what
the n.s.a. is doing is a threat
to democracy.
>> charlie: what it continues
to do?
>> what it continues to do is a
threat.
in terms of my profession as a
journalist, if the government
can find out who i'm talking to,
then how can i protect the
source, you know?
and i think that -- and it's not
just me.
there are many, many --
of question that things are
ongoing and threats -- you know,
i think -- i believe that what
the n.s.a. is doing is a threat
to democracy.
>> charlie: what it continues
to do?
>> what it continues to do is a
threat.
in terms of my profession as a
journalist, if the government
can find out who i'm talking to,
then how can i protect the
source, you know?
and i think that -- and it's not
just me.
there are many, many --
269
269
Oct 25, 2014
10/14
by
WHYY
quote
eye 269
favorite 0
quote 14