any motion? >> i move to approve. >> all right. >> second. >> second. >> there is a second. >> on that motion, same house same call? >> all right. >> that means that the motion passes, congratulations we are going to move on to the last permit of the night. fog lifter cafe this is the ocean avenue, second sunday locations and just like the ave, they would like to have a limited live performance permit, and they probably would use theirs a little bit differently as they are a cafe and not a bar, but, here to talk more about that, is jawad, swirky. >> could you speak in the mic. >> hi, i am the owner of thing for lifter cafe and i am applying for a permit just for music, that it would be like acoustic guitar and we will have the lighting on site and we will have the lights and the (inaudible) is low and the cleaning and i just have a park outside and so it just looks nice. and so, we are looking forward to approve. >> great. any questions for mr. swirky? >> no, this sounds pretty easy. thank you ve

pacheco any public comment on the minutes seeing none, mr. pacheco if you could take roll. >> we have a motion from commissioner fong commissioner fung to adapt itself november minutes. >> commissioner president lazarus commissioner honda and commissioner wilson is absent the vote is 3 to zero the minutes are adapted. >> then call item 4a and b appeal both filed by mr. donny against the department of building inspection with the disapproval with the subject on e street and their appealing the denial of a permit to erect a building garage super s structure with 44 hundred ground floor feet and the denial of the permit to alternate a building to a second level of a backyard wansz the surveillance and i understand mr. donny is he in the room can you step forward to the microphone. >> i know mr. donny he is stuck in traffic i'm here for another item i don't know if switching it will be okay. >> commissioner shall we hold this off and give mr. donny a chance to get here. >> yeah. if he's on his way. >> with the presidents consent what we had a req

any other comments? >> thank you, and very briefly, i have yours and that could not be quite as eloquent and the only thing that i would like to take to your attention and the loop and from my experience it is a safety issue, because you have got the single down in the west in the central subway, you have two bowls and so if anything happens, you head to one of the cross passages and you head for the other tunnel and you exit. and so, as long as there is a single bowl, you should be, and you should not be studying that any further. >> thank you. >> next speaker? >> i had no idea this was going to be on the agenda, but it just shows the support from the neighborhoods, and the people at large, that take the subway system, that are in support of the expanding this t-line and fisherman's wharf and i hope that the commissioners will take the next step from this report and move it forward. thank you. >> thank you, anyone else, like to speak for the public? >> public comment is closed. >> thank you, for this gr

>> she was appointed in august 2010. >> any complaints against her? >> no. other that what surfaced today. >> okay. all right, thank you. so colleagues, i -- this question opportunity for questions have been very helpful. i'm supporting the appointment of p wendy jordan. she's been a fair person, easy to talk to and able to listen. whether she takes a meeting or doesn't take a meeting, that's up to her personal interest. the difference between being a trustee and a member of the board of supervisors is we are elected to serve people and our constituents and we have the responsibility to be accountable to folks. what's interesting is when you're a fizz fiduciary is you're supposed to be a political. our number one role [inaudible] when we retire. so i'm vested to make sure that this fund grows and i'm sure many of you are interested in making sure this fund grows. i am not interested in scheduling another meeting to sit at a whole. i think if the ethics commission finds her to be in any kind of violation i think we can take up the matter then. i want to remin

any questions that i can answer? >> i was wondering how many organizations that you distributed and you said approximately 150. okay. >> commissioner sims. >> one, was there any rationale with the board of supervisors this year for their resistance to match the mayors? >> i think they had other targets items that they had taken a higher priority over matching the cost of doing business. i know it was discussed at the open budget hearings and non-profit partners expressed dismay at not getting the add-backs as was done many times in the past. it was a different set of priorities coming from the board of supervisors this year. >> okay. any questions? hearing nonely call for the vote. >> all in favor? >> aye. >> opposed? ayes have it and so the motion is carried. >> thank you. >> thank you, commissioners. >> next we have public comment. do we have any public comment on this? hearing none, announcements? public comment? we have already done that. can i have a motion to adjourn. >> so moved. >> second. >> it's been moved

any further discussion? let's take a vote. >> on the motion to approve this permit with a good neighbor policy and this is both extended hours and [inaudible] commissioner frost aye commissioner lee aye commissioner hyde aye commissioner moshoyannis aye commissioner [inaudible] president can aye >> all right good luck >>, >> one last one should show one must permit >> visit for the metronome dance collective. thus confer limited live performance permit. metronome as you may know having dance studio teaching all kinds of stance the last 30 years. they have in the past had [inaudible] entertainment to an ownership change they did not renew that and they been doing occasional events with one night event permits and then also doing some other stuff. another coming into compliance by getting applying for a limited live performance permit. just a quick note, the building that the [inaudible] was built in 1949 and doing the music therefore a long time. not that longer lease 30 years. another carbon building was bui

i move it. >> do have any questions? >> my only question is given the diversity if you will or the variety of funding sources, a project like this is awarded under the city's local business program and the city -- >> under the city's federal program. their goal is just different instead of program, but it tries to achieve the same bottom line. >> i was going to ask, i'm sorry i didn't want to interrupt you, is this the federal department of transportation? >> yes. the community type trying to balance the car issues with pedestrians and bikes and traffic safety. >> very important. thank you. okay, i don't have any other questions. would someone like to make a motion? >> i move. >> commissioner mondejar moved and second by mr. singh. can you call the roll. city clerk: commissioner mondejar, yes, commissioner singh, commissioner bustos absent. rosales, the vote is 3 is one absent. >> the item passes. >> the next item is 6. public comment on non-agenda items. >> i have one public comment from francisco decosta. >> i believe

members of any of the other departments who are going to be making a presentation in any capacity about this be particular issue? >> no other presentations, but they're here to answer questions. >> okay, that's good. >> planning department is here as well. >> okay. thank you very much. i am going to open this item up to public comment. i have one speaker card from marita. >> i want to thank you for approving the guidance. that's what it is, a guidance and it's very well done, but it needs to be used and i appreciated your talk about rehab on public housing and how it has been ignored all these years. this is an example of how the rolling, rising sea levels problems into the building code, the planning code before these buildings are bit, if they're necessary, is very important. it saves money and livability for the people that will be living there. also in the response initially the city has repeatedly said that ceqa authorizes the city to mitigate and adapt, but it never says they actually do that and i was wondering if anybody knows of any projects in the city where the authority to m

o is there any public comment? and seeing none, roll call vote. >> on item 15. >> supervisor avalos supervisor breed supervisor campos supervisor cohen supervisor farrell supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor yee absent this item passes. >> okay item number 16. >> allocate $720,000 plus to the prop k for the sfmta for geary bus raptd and the initial planning subject to the cash distribution program and this is an action item. >> okay any comments seeing none, is there any public comment? please come forward we'll close public comment and have a roll call vote. >> on item 16. >> supervisor campos. >> supervisor breed supervisor campos supervisor cohen supervisor farrell supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor yee absent this item passes. >> supervisor mar. >> thank you supervisor avalos i want to thank chester and thank you for vote o voting on early actions to near terminations improvements along the geary that services many districts i think w

does the fda have any concerns about that? >> i am not familiar with that matter. >> so material, meaning even in the peanut issue, a disclosure would be for -- required because of safety? >> typically with respect to allergens, yes. there is a statute, a 2004 statute and that requires disclosure of the big 8 allergens. if you were to find another allergen you would typically require disclosure of it rather than ban the food. >> who does the research? my constituents will say dupont and can we really trust these companies that benefit so much? >> the data that i supplied to us are supplied to us by the companies doing the consulting and they will do studies, sometimes they will pay to have the studies done. we will say that is true across all fda regulated products. fda does research but it does not do research on the scales that would be required to support voluntary submissions much less marketing applications. >> let me ask one more question. does the food and drug administration have the authority to implement a mandatory

any other comments? let's take a vote. >> on the motion to grant this permit with the good neighbor policy and also a subtest of the venue and the neighbor's apartment on a motion, commissioner frost aye commissioner lee aye commissioner joseph aye commissioner hyde aye commissioner moshoyannis aye commissioner tan aye that motion passes. please give each other's numbers and is a cultures up with the move on to the last two items on the agenda which is the next one is commissioner comments and questions. are there any commissioner comments or questions >> i just want to thank the staff are making the police report in blue it so much easier to find our packet now that it's in blue. thank you that's really cool >> anything else? >> merry christmas happy new year to everybody. >> i guess i should say to generate six will be my last commission meeting here. i'm stopping to go to school. i'm leaving a few months early to go to school in portland. >> which also means to all those viewers out there, if you are

and the laytons have not kept any of these promises. and in addition, i attended the dr, where smith, and the other immediate neighbor was denied the rights to attest, the layton project and the dr was a procedural mishap and you have seen the pictures of the house and the proposed housing. they are asked for modifications of a few feet, to the proposal, and ordered to preserve the integrity of their lifestyle. and therefore, i respectfully, request the board to support these efforts. i am a long time resident of the city, and friends of the mckency millers. and it just seems like a situation, you know, everybody in this room is a caring person with a kind heart and somehow, the train of procedure, and intention is just gone off the tracks, in this case. and you know the thing about the neighbor to the south not being heard was one excellent point and i, i am just not you know, nobody means any harm here, but we saw a sand born map up on the wall, no measurements on it and it meant nothing and that is sort of the quality of what i have

any directions or any, omission? s none from the... >> none from the commissioners? any members of the public who wish to comment on the draft minutes? >> is there a motion to approve the minutes. >> moved. >> moved by commissioner wald and seconded by commissioner stephenson, and i know that in the past we have often been approving the minutes sort of by acclamation and just looking over her wonderful guidelines that she put together and i see that we are expected to do a roll call vote. so if you want to do that, . >> approval on the minutes, commissioner gravanis? >> yes. >> commissioner stephenson. >> yes. >> commissioner wa*ld. >> yes. >> commissioner wan. >> yes. >> the meeting minutes have been approved. >> next item are public meants, members of the public may address the commission on matters that are within the commission's jurisdiction, and are not on today's agenda. >> are there any members of the public who wish to speak in we have speaker cards for specific items but if you want to speak on anything that is not on the agenda, i here no one, so next item

is there further comment, corrections are there any public comments? >> note >> all those in favor of the minutes of november 18 please say aye. opposed? the minutes have been accepted >> item 3 is the reference report >> good afternoon commissioners. on the ebola update i have dr. [inaudible] here and i wanted to do an update and see if you have questions for him he is available. we have a great job of planning and also preparing for ebola. our staff, we have been looking at this as a major preparedness activity and so we have already have identified over 15 individuals who could be utilized if [inaudible] any other significant response to e bola issue. i think that's a good practice for us. also, cdc has sent out a document on the 35 treatments centers throughout the country and we are monitoring some individuals as they come back at most at low risk, and so, i just want to acknowledge dr. cardigan [sp?] an office app and this has been a full department response including san francisco general hospital and all the hospitals all the clinics are pairin

nor would any revisions provide any new information provided presented in the draft eir subsequently do not require the need to redraft the eir of the ceqa guidelines. we believe therefore that the eir is adequate and proficiency decision makers and the public with the information required pursuant to ceqa to understand the pursuant impact of the proposed project. on this basis we request the commission adopt this before you with the context that the report are adequate and the procedures for which the eir was prepared comply with provisions of ceqa and guidelines and chapter one of the administrative code. this concludes my presentation object this matter unless commissioners have any questions. >president cindy wu: thank you. okay. we will take public comment. dan' campbell and rob pool. >> good afternoon, commissioners, danny campbell, sheet metalworkers, i'm here on behalf of employees who support the sheet metalworkers and we support the eir and move this project forward. thank you have a nice day. >president cindy wu: thank you. >> good afternoon commissioners, rob pool housing

any further discussion? any public comment? i don't see any, let's take a vote. >> commissioner hyde? >> aye. >> commissioner lee? >> yes. >> commissioner moshoyannis, are you... >> abstained. >> commissioner frost. >> aye. >> president tan. >> aye. >> all right. >> so thanks for those action and we are going to move on to item three which is the report from the staff and executive director, director king. >> good evening, commissioners i am going to be short and sweet. i wanted to update you on the late night/early morning transportation test work that i always forget to put that in. as you know we have been meeting since i don't know, i guess this summer, or late or early fall on basically trying to come up with a road map for integrated plan and president tan has been present for most of those meetings to move this city into a more efficient and late night transportation and we are ininclusive of the early morning and the workforce issues as well as for the folks who are in the industry after closing time and so we are havin

alley that occurred it created these 300 foot buffers where any within 200 feet of any residential enclave you can't have nighttime entertainment or 24-hour animal services like kennels even if the underlying zoning permits it. there is an overlay buffer to protect those enclaves. >> you are right it does not apply to the llp. >> so the llp. >> and so it will be permitted in that if the underlying zoning permits them. >> so within the wmug, that is mixed use, general? >> yeah. >> it is similar to what it was there before, which is slr. and which is service. and light industrial and residential. >> yeah. >> i am courage and i was not part of the source and maybe commissioner hyde will answer this better, what was the rationale behind why the limited live was not permitted or should not be permitted in a wmug, given the mixed use and if not, fully residential and i think that, like you said, the they are trying to protect the residential. >> my understanding was again, harrison street was really kind of the dividing line for entertainment uses north of harrison it is really a focus on, you k

any questions? >> all right. >> your security team and you have one or two on the weekends who is in charge. >> right now i am in charge of that but we are going to have an extra security person, when we will, and when we have a dj on the weekend and so at least we are going to have it, and on, i am going to consider and on the night clubs and so i think that that is, that is the what i am going to do. >> are you going to have one person who has more experience? >> yes. >> is there a supervisor? >> in other words, if the police come, who do they deal with? >> yes, we will have the supervisor on the week ends. yes. >> so what kind of training are you expecting out of this supervisor to have? >> i expect the supervisor to make sure that, you know, there is no noise coming on from the outside. >> and yo

questions you may have. >> any public comment on this item. >> do any of the representatives including the gentleman have any rebuttal okay commissioners the matter t is submitted. >> i'll be bold to deny the appeal on the basis it was properly issued. >> second. >> okay mr. pacheco. >> we have a motion month commissioner president lazarus to uphold the permit on the basis it was properly issued on that motion commissioner fung commissioner honda commissioner wilson thank you. >> the vote is had to zero the permit it up legally on that basis. >> move our or on to item 8 versus the department of building inspection with the planning department approval the property on 40526th street to robert edmond to erect a building with 17 hundred and 50 secret of ground floor area we'll start with the appellants. >> good evening, members of the board i live on 27th street and thank you so much thank you for the opportunity to voice any concerns and the concerns of fellow residents all of whom were on or after march 13 of 2013 by the live in four units that are negatively impacted by the site plan o

any public comment. seeing none, then commissioners, the matter is submitted. >> i personally did not hear anything that was new or different from the previous testimony and p i do not believe this request meets the requirements for the hearing. >> i'm of the same opinion. >> i agree and unfortunately from the last meeting that we had i know it's hard for you guys to go through this process, bull the ground for the threshold for rehearing was that any new information that would cause us to open up this. i have not seen any information that would cause to reopen this up. >> i'll move to deny the rehearing request on the basis that it doesn't meet the requirement of the board. >> thank you. chief, call testimony roll please. >> we have a motion from the president to deany this rehearing request. commissioner fung. >> i. >> commissioner honda. a: i. >> commissioner wilson. >> i. >> the vote is four to zero. this hearing request is deanied and notice of decision will be released. we'll move on to item 9. the

>> any hotel. any hotel subject to hotel tax currently falls under the current exemption rate and would fall under the revised exemption rate. >> thank you. >> did i answer that? >> uh-huh. >> we don't have any budget analyst report. we will open this up to public comment. anyone wish to comment on item 7? >> good morning, supervisors, my name is darren overby, i am been the owner of pacific trade winds hospital on nearly 22 years. this morning we have representatives from 8 san francisco youth hostels which makes up the sf youth hostel coalition. may i ask the coalition supporters to stand? there are of course many other supporters that were not able to attend because they are either running our hostels or running the small businesses located in the neighborhoods where our hostels are located. for example my business has 4 employees who were not able to attend and there were 4 business owners who expressed interest in attending if they could. san francisco international, the usa hostels. hostels a

i am happy to answer any questions you might have. >> okay. any questions? >> no questions. >> thank you. >> thank you very much. any public comments? seeing none public comment is now closed. supervisor tang. >> again just happy to see and want to continue i had the opportunity to speak to both of you before this meeting just to make sure we understood what your priorities were going forward and again i think she brings such invaluable background given all of her city work, not only as a deputy city attorney and also in the legal realm that she did outside of the city and community service so i'm happy to reappointment mara rosales to seat four for the commission on community investment and infrastructure and pass it on to the full board with full recommendation. >> okay. and i totally agree with that and the comments that you made of her i totally agree with that and even though you're a lowell grad and she and i am not and that's okay. at least we're from the city. okay. so without objections this motion is moved. [gavel] . thank you. mr. clerk can you pl

so i'm available for any questions. you mind if i call students to speak. >> if that's how you wish to use your time, sure. >> good evening ladies and gentlemen, my name is kevin. i have come here today to discuss about the rewarding opportunity that i have stumbled upon because of charity cultural services scepter. i recently lost my job in june and i have learned that they provide tuition free culinary program, including bartending classes. i immediately signed up for the classes early august this year and notified that the classes weren't going to begin until september due to uncompleted construction work on that unit with the bar. i learned that the previous lessons were all head at far east cafe but the owner needed to open up the restaurant two-and-a-half hours early ahead to have time so that we can use the space. it was a torture for someone who needs to work late at night. they expected the space allocated for bartending classes to be completed soon, thus made the decision to move the classes back to the center

any other public comment? >> good evening, mary harris. i understand and i'm just doing this for clarification because there were some people interested but they are watching on tv. they didn't want to come down, that side on mission stay the same on the boundaries? >> particularly, there is a pocket on the northern end of mission, no, they stay the same. >> okay, i wanted to clarify that and just say thank you. some people in the omi have said that they would prefer that we were in the ingleside and i told them that we have a fixed car that is always in our area. they think because the ingleside station is closer. but we actually do get good service and we as a neighborhood organization that as long as we stay whole as a community, both ocean view, merced and ingleside, that wherever you decide is fine with us. thank you very much. >> thank you, ms. harris. yes, sir? >> hi, my name is michael cameron. i also live in the tenderloin and i'm also pretty much in agreement with the line that. but larkin street, the drug dealers would just move

are there any questions? >> seeing none, no questions at this time. >> thank you, let's take the public comment on this item? >> public comment is opened. seeing no comment, public comment is closed. >> could you call the next item. >> a roll call vote. >> yes. >> item number 4. >> cohen. >> aye. >> farrell. >> absent. >> taning? >> aye. >> weiner aye. >> the item passes. >> thank you, could you call the next item. >> introduction of new items. >> thank you. >> are there any supervisors or commissioner tang has a new item for introduction. >> thank you. so, today, i wanted to request that the transportation authority conduct a strategic analysis report and by way of background, what our office is looking and hoping to do in partnership with the ta is really to examine some of the transportation needs and specifically, in connection to certain nodes that would help to better our out lying neighborhoods as well as the sunset district and others. >> and so we work with the community to put together the sunset di

any members of the public wishing to speak. public comment is closed and the hearing has been held for item 43. 44 and 45 let's take a roll call vote on items 44 and 45 tang aye weiner aye yee aye. >> supervisor avalos, aye, supervisor breed aye supervisor campos aye supervisor cohen aye, farrell aye kim aye mar aye there are 10 ayes. >> the resolutions are unanimously adopted item 46 was considered by the committee at a rescheduled meeting on on december 4th at 3:00 p.m. and recommended with the same title and forwarded by a committee report. report and renumbering all sections amending the business and tax regulations code and applications fees and making the environmental findings. >> supervisor mar. >> thank you president tang. colleagues, this item is a major historic act i call it act. it will help us reduce tobacco sales by one half and i wanted to thank the early cosponsors but also recent and current cosponsors david campos and former president and this is an important piece of legislation that's youth driven that came

obviously those trips happened without any incident. we also know based on information from officials there that the last maintenance check for this specific aircraft, everything checked out fine. that happened just last month. but airbus is being very cautious with how they are categorizing what happened here. they are not going too far. they are staying very far away from speculation. only saying they are essentially trying to gather more information and willing network with investigators. right now on your screen you're looking at dimensions of what an a 320 are. you can see the wing span there. we can tell you when you come bare the a320 to the boeing 777 this is a smaller aircraft so as you can see there were fewer people on board this aircraft than for example malaysia 370. malaysia 370 had 239 people. by comparison this aircraft had 162 people. so a slightly smaller aircraft. but really the key here is finding the wreckage and as we know the search has halted because they've run out simply of -- they ran out of daylight. but find

as always we never had any findings in any audit.ys been a clean audit and you will hear about that later so it's a very good report. now i would like to have steve rule give the construction update. >> good morning directors. steve rule with turner construction providing construction management oversights ises. it's been a good month. we got rain this month including today so that slowed some things down but not terribly. they're dealing with it well and since we got the slap down in november we're out of the mud so that helps a lot when the weather hits so we add a couple of things to the overall schedule. i added this milestone points which we can review the description and milestones on the next sheet and we will keep these updated. for example, the critical ones

>> at this time, i don't have any information as to any of the occupants.ane crash into the home. we have several homes that received some damage and some more significant than others. we had heavy fire and damage. the plane crashed in front of a home and several other homes had some other damage and at this point i don't have any status reports of any of the occupants that were home. neighbors indicate that, based on the cars in the driveway, that it's likely that the folks were home at some point this morning and nothing has been con firmed or verified the status. we did have information that there were at least three people on the plane. the plane did crash. the occupants in that vehicle didn't survive the crash and fire so at least three fatalities and ntsb and faa and others are on the scene at this point. >> mr. perringer, you are confirming the wjla report that the three souls on board that embraer did, in fact, die? >> that's correct. they did not survive the crash. >> can you tell me whether this is still a rescue mission because the live images sh

i'm available for any questions you may have. >> any public comment? seeing none, then commissioners, the matter is submitted. mr. duffy, commissioners are you willing to entertain him again? >> yes. >> as long as he entertains that. >> sorry commissioners for the time. just one point of clarification, i heard mr. calvin there saying that the -- it would take the walls down prior to any -- the addendum being issued. you can't start the work until the addenda has to be issued before you take the walls down so we won't know what the foundation is until the a ddenda is issued. >> well you can have multiple addenda. >> they could do something but the structure is usually on the first addenda. >> i don't know if it's set up like that, but we could make see. we could work on the addenda details. we could do a demolition addenda, that could be an idea. thank you commissioner fung. >> thank you for your help. >> thank you. >> timically it's an evaluation of the foundation. if they want to keep that foundation we want to make sure it's code compliant. that's wh

any questions? well thank you for bringing this forward. even though the balboa station isn't in my district it's just close enough to the district where it has a lot of impact and i am certainly supportive of the extension. any public comments on this item? seeing none public is now closed. [gavel] supervisor campos. >> thank you. i would like to move this item forward with a positive recommendation. and by the way what an incredible voice. thank you for the presentation. >> deputy city attorney john gibner. >> just one suggestion to the committee. on page three of the resolution the resolution refers to the rules committee makes appointments to the body. i think this was probably in the original 2012 resolution also, and what has happened with this body as all advisory bodies that the board makes the appointments. the rules committee considers the applications and nominations so i would just suggest and we can work with the m ta on massaging the language and clarify it's the board making the appoi

has the town made any attempt to do anything?enforce the code, but so far it hasn't been done. >> reporter: they say the town has done nothing more than fine ansell. but in a statement, ross township told us, they've taken and will continue to take appropriate legal action. >> the court order is to clean the debris up in the yard. >> reporter: in reply, ansell has simply ignored the court order. and unlike ebenezer scrooge, there's no happy ending. no christmas miracle in sight for fairley road. >> we decided that we would rent our home for probably way lower than it should be. >> reporter: is it going to be a financial hardship, trying to move? >> oh yes. it will. it's a move for our lives. you know, to have normalcy again. >> reporter: can you still enjoy it, the season? >> yeah, if you go somewhere else. >> yeah, you have to go somewhere else. >> so, when everything else fails, what would you do? let us know on twitter, use #abc2020. >> when we come back, a mother finally able to spend christmas with her family for the first t