ann marie. >> ann marie, answer to this group. is the response to the obama administration to putin's aggression sufficient? >> yes. >> you didn't answer. >> yes. >> let her answer. >> yes. so this was about syria. so -- i mean, we're all here in a debate and we actually believe in reasoned deliberation and we believe that if you hear facts and well-expressed opinions based on facts, it can change your mind. that is the premise of this evening. i knew you would quote that against me and i did believe it when i wrote it. i absolutely thought this is critical in terms of sending a message to putin. i have since spent half the summer talking to russian experts talking about what in fact is driving putin and i absolutely think at this point that had we done what i was suggesting, it wouldn't have changed putin's calculation. >> so don't do what you're suggesting now. >> no. >> wait a minute. >> but equally -- equally importantly, it might have changed -- it might well have tore pea deed our negotiations with iran. much as we should be

ann? >> excellent segue. >>> if you are a fan of the movie "the godfather," this house may look familiar. it was the setting for the movie's opening scene. it's now for sale, asking price $2,895,000. the five-bedroom english tudor inn staten island, new york includes a mancave, a gym, and even an english pub. for all your godfather junkies it has a saltwater pool in the yard where the movie's mob patriarch died. interested? >> it's an offer i must refuse. [ laughter ] >> no disrespect. [ laughter ] >> nice. >> couldn't do it. >>> i can deliver this, though. another 49er done for the nfl season. we'll tell you who. and! see this fella, ann? this guy will never pay for a meal again in madison, wisconsin, after what he did today. ,, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,, for over 60,000 california foster children, the holidays can be an especially difficult time. to help, sleep train is holding a secret santa toy drive. bring your gift to any sleep train, ...and why not?? tick, tick, tick... ...time running dow the

anne-marie? >> thank you, don. >>> a frightening scene during a protest near police headquarters in minneapolis. after protesters attacked a car, the driver accelerates dragging a protester along the pavement. the driver is questioned. >>> this is one of the busiest travel days of the year. a major storm on the east coast is going to make a mess of things. many tried to get a jump on the weather by leaving a day early. moderate to heavy rain and snow is expected from washington to boston. >>> as the storm approached, airlines began canceling flights. this morning so far, 222 flights have been canceled. major airlines dropped their ticket exchange fees for passengers in the northeast. meteorologist eric fisher of our boston station wbz is following the fast-moving storm. >> we've been talking about it for a couple of days, and now it's a storm. it's a quick moving one but impacting us right through the holiday, and it's changing plans, and we've seen that already. so moving up the east coast as we

i'm anne-marie green. now that the leftovers are in the fridge, millions of americans are already crossing off items on their holiday shopping list. consumers are expected to spend nearly $616 bill from november through december and while black friday is considered the official start to the holiday season many retailers are trying to kick start their earnings by opening up on thanksgiving. don champion is in times square this morning where shoppers have been at it since last night, don. good morning. >> reporter: good morning, anne-marie. no sleeping for shoppers coast to coast today, millions of them started spending on thanksgiving day, which could take a bielt out of black friday's bottom line. a crowd of about 200 people were ready to go when the toys "r" us here in times square opened its doors at 5:00 p.m., some waiting hours to get inside it's real good. hopefully i'll be able to get everything i need to get today. >> reporter: while shoppers complete their lists, stores are opening earlier in order

i'm anne-marie green.>> well, this morning scientists at the european space agency are attempting a first and cosmic exploration, landing a spacecraft on a comet. the unmanned rosetta spacecraft reached the comet in august after a ten-year chase. scientists finally gave the final go-ahead for rosetta to release its lander for the journey to the comet. cbs space consultant bill harwood will have a little more later on in the broadcast. >>> well, this morning that early mid-winter-like storm is blanketing much of the country in an unseasonable cold and sometimes and the misery is headed east. this is denver. the high temperature is expected to be in denver. just 10 degrees. the slick condition caused dozens of car accidents. in some parts of texas in oklahoma, lows are expected to fall in the teens today. folks in austin got a taste of cold yesterday. meteorologist eric fisher of our boston station wbz has more on the big freeze. >> well, the arctic express continues its march southward and eastward. we've g

i'm anne-marie green. well, overnight a gunman opened fire on the campus of florida state university. multiple shots were fired in the school library at the heart of the tallahassee campus. at least three people were wounded. video appears to show police communicating with people still in the library. >> we have a shooting in the library. stay where you are. we'll be coming to get you more clearing and take care of everybody. >> james buechelly of our tallahassee station wctv joins us on the phone. what's the latest on the situation? >> reporter: i'm here on the campus of fs unh there are literally hundreds of students being taken next door. they're now allowed to go backes in and grab any possessions that they left. three people have been sent to the hospital. at one point he shot at the campus p.d. they returned fire. we don't know who the suspect is. the latest, at least three people in the hospital for injuries. we talked with a lot of students. they said they heard noises, what they didn't think were

please note executive secretary ann hinton is present ?oo ?a we have the agenda and i have been informed that item c under new business will be taken off the, has been requested to be taken off the agenda. could i have a motion to approve the agenda with that change? >> so moved. >> second. >> it's been moved and seconded that we approve the agenda removing item b under new business. all in favor, aye. opposed? ayes have it so the motion is carried. thank you. next we have approval of the consent agenda with all items. >> so moved. >> seconded. >> it has been moved and seconded that we have approval of the consent agenda. all in favor? opposed? the ayes have it so the motion is carried. thank you. next item on the agenda is approval of the october 1 commission meeting minutes. is there any changes? has everybody had a chance to look at the minutes? >> i move we accept the minutes as submitted. >> it's been moved and seconded that we approve the minutes as circulated. all in favor? opposed? the ayes have it so the motion is carried. next item o

i'm anne-marie green. well, violence erupted in ferguson, missouri, overnight. the trouble began soon after it was announced. the grand jury did not indict white police officer darren wilson in the shooting death of black teenager michael brown. at least a dozen buildings and cars were set on fire. there was gunfire and looting. after the decision was made public you president obama called for a peaceful response. >> first and foremost, we are a nation built on the rule of law. and so we need to accept that this decision was the grand jury's to make. >> and in ferguson, danielle, what is the latest there. >> reporter: anne-marie, well, the national guard has moved in. the main strip here, in ferguson is still on fire this morning. it seemed like in a matter of minutes, what were peaceful protests gave way to violence. police officers say they were hit by batteries and rocks. reporters took cover from gunfire. police say they arrested at least 29 people. police say this is much worse than the scenes we saw

i'm anne-marie green. it is starting to seem like there is nowhere to go in this country to escape the early taste of winter. by tonight much of the nation will be feeling temperatures either at or below freezing, and that is without factoring in the windchill. and on top of the bitter cold temperatures, some areas are also getting their first look at snow weeks before the official start of winter. don champion is here in new york city where a snow alert was issued last night, don? >> reporter: yeah. good morning, anne-marie. that alert was more of a precaution. we did not see many flakes here. it was mostly rain. there was some snow in the northeast, though. a little more than an inch fell north of new jersey. this is part of a storm system that's expected to be gone by the start of the morning commute here. a heavier coat of snow came down on the philadelphia suburbs less than a day after temperatures were in the 70s. in ohio highway travel became hazardous. highway road conditions in cleveland led to se

director's report, anne hinton. >> good morning, president james and commissioners. just a few things to report today. one, we keep bringing, i keep bringing up, others bring up the older americans aktd and the push we were having in congress to try to move that forward. it's looking now like nothing is going to happen in the lame duck session. i was on a conference call yesterday and it's sounding like it may not come back up in a real solid bill until 2017, so we'll update you on that and let you see. the white house conference on aging, though, is still going forward. they are still speculating that the convening of people, which will be a very small convening, will happen in july. we will keep an eye on that. clearly we want to do a san francisco response to that event and will be engaging you thinking about how we might be doing that and getting you all involved in that as well. i also wanted to mention we are getting closer and closer to the opening of what we refer to as 2 goth. it's a building at the corner of goth and otis and it's been empty for a while, it

i'm anne-marie green. israeli prime minister benjamin netanyahu said he will respond harshly to a deadly attack on a jerusalem synagogue. two palestinians used knives, axes and guns to kill four worshippers. six other worshippers were wounded. police are looking for other suspects. this is the latest in a series of attacking by palestinians and israelis on the growing tensions over contested holy sites. secretary of state john kerry called the attack an act of pure terror and senseless brutality. palestinian president mahmoud abbas condemned the attack. >>> and this morning, much of the country is engulfed in a deep freeze. a very archic freeze. a record chill brings record temperatures from the midwest all the way south to the east. there are freeze warnings from texas to georgia gg and the cold weather system has triggered heavy snow in the great lakes region that could last more than a week. buffalo, new york, is expected to get 2 feet of snow, but some areas could see 3 feet. the windchill in kalamazoo

patty ann?he 18-year-old minnesota terror suspect accused of trying to travel to syria to join isis is out of jail this morning. a magistrate releasing the 18-year-old without bail into the custody of his parents. he will be required to turn over his u.s. passport. the 18-year-old is charged with conspiracy to provide material support to isis. prosecutors have already appealed the magistrate's decision. >>> best-selling crime novelest pety james died this morning. james penned more than 20 books, including children of men, the murder room, and death comes to peberly. millions of her books are sold around the globe. some applied for television and film. just last year, james said she was working on another detective story. her agent said she died peacefully in her home in oxford, england. p.d. james was 94 years old. >>> in case you haven't noticed, black friday has morphed into black thursday. people already lining up at some stores nationwide hoping for deals and markdowns. rob lowe from our af

i'm anne-marie green.mericans go to the polls today in what is possibly the most costly midterm election ever. a large number of races for the house and various governorships are too close to call but the big ties are for the senate. with 36 seats at stake. republicans need six seats to take control of the senate. our background tracker finds out if republicans have a better chance of taking control. susan mcginnis is in washington. good morning. >> anne-marie, good morning. if republicans gain those six seats or greater in the senate as they are expected to, the gop will control the house and the senate for the first time since 2005. now, that prospect has democrats doing all they can to get voters out to try to save their majority. voters take to the polls today in an election that will determine which party controls the senate. turn outin midterm elections is notoriously low, but some polling stations have prepared for large numbers. >> this is not -- fighting for voters there's so many incentives. >> r

i know anne had, we had passed well, approved legislation to fund -- is this one of the committees we wanted to be taken out of the paycheck to support this group as well as another group? remember anne warned, we passed legislation --. >> that was for the california senior legislature. >> that was just for california, okay. >> anne warren, that's an entirely separate group. >> thank you. okay, next we have the case report. >> good morning, xhirs, petition with catholic charities representing case. we have several committees still working on our legislative and advisory and budget requests that we're going to be presenting to anne later this month. we have about 4 or 5 different categories we're working on, so more to come. our next meeting is monday, november 10th. it's going to be at project open hand on the second floor. our meeting is going to be about self-care, you know, burnout, stress, morale, and how to help employees and their leaders deal with those kinds of issues especially this time of year with the holidays coming and it gets really busy. in december we have our annual

i'm anne-marie green. this morning there is a new political landscape in washington. the midterm elections can only be described as a route republicans throttled democrats, seizing control of the senate and expanding their control of the house. cbs news projects republicans picked up at least seven seats in the senate. the republicans ousted democratic incumbents in arkansas, north carolina, and iowa. they won in south dakota, virginia, and iowa. it is the first time the gop has held the majority in the senate since 2006. it >>> and a man >>> and a man likely to become the new senate majority leader is the current minority leader, kentucky's mitch mcconnell. he easily won re-election in one of the country's most watched races. mcconnell trounced alison lundergan grimes. the republicans control the house. the gop picked up ten seats and come january will hold the largest majority there since 1949. now that they control president obama's final two years in office will get a little more complicated. susan mcg

i'm anne-marie green. well, it is reported this morning that the japanese air bag manufacturer takata knew its air bags were dangerous ten years ago but covered up the results of secret tests. two former takata employees told "the new york times" the testing was stopped after three months and the evidence destroyed. don champion is here in new york with more. don, good morning. >> good morning, anne-marie. that was four years before takata told federal regulators it first tested its air bags. the faulty air bags have been tied to four deaths and forced a recall of more than 14 million cars worldwide. the secret tests were conducted at takata's facility in michigan on weekends and holidays. the defects can force the air bags to deploy with too much shards caution pieces of metal to go into passengers. last night it responded to the report saying it raised additional concerns about takata's handling of the air bag issues and is one of the reasons it's compelling them to produce documents and answer questions

i'm anne-marie green. this morning the decision of aid to dying is being rekindled for a 29-year-old woman determined to take her own life. we learned your night that brittney maynard, the terminal cancer patient who was the face of the right to die-movement, chose to take a lethal dose of a drug ore the weekend. >> i'll die upstairs in my bedroom that i share with my husband, with my mother and my husband by my side and pass peacefully with the music that i like in the background. >> that is how brittney maynard died on saturday. according to a statement from compassion and choices, a right to die advocacy group, maynard passed away peacefully surrounded by family and friends. last month she went public with her battle against brain cancer and her decision to die on her own terms. >> i can't even tell you the amount of relief it provides me to know that i don't have to die the way that it's been described to me that my brain tumor would take me. >> maynard and her husband moved from california to oregon,

when lou ann and betty ann's world was shattered with a single phone call. >> he said there's been afour cars at an intersection. >> now i'm panicking freaking out. he said what kind of a car does she have. i said it's a kia. he said it's a kia here. desperate to get to their daughter. >> i'm thinking she's laying in a highway unconscious and they wouldn't say where she was exactly. >> reporter: and then the story took an unexpected but even more frightening turn. >> finally i was like, look, you got to tell me exactly where you are and what the hell is going on now. then his whole demeanor changed and he was like, now you wait a minute. >> she was white as a ghost. >> okay, we have her at gunpoint and we're going to kill her if you don't give me $1700. i never felt terror before in my life. this was absolute terror, having your child's life in your hands. >> reporter: little did they know they were on the receiving end of the latest technique in an otherwise old low tech phone scam, con artists claiming to have kidnapped a loved one to make you pay up. 25 million americans lose more

i'm anne-marie green. this is the "cbs morning news." hanks. i'm anne-marie green.e "cbs morning news." sir, we're going to need you on the runway. (vo) theraflu starts to get to work in your body in just 5 minutes. (vo) theraflu breaks you free from your worst cold and flu symptoms. (vo) theraflu. serious power. some people think vegetables are boring. but with green giant's delicious seasonings and blends, we just may change their minds. ho ho ho green giant! if it doesn't work fast... you're on to the next thing. clinically proven neutrogena® rapid wrinkle repair. it targets fine lines and wrinkles with the fastest retinol formula available. you'll see younger looking skin in just one week. one week? this one's a keeper. rapid wrinkle repair. and for dark spots rapid tone repair. from neutrogena®. >>> bill cosby is facing new, but familiar allegations of rape this morning. she says the comedian gave her pills and forced himself on her in 1976 after a show in las vegas. an attorney for cosby calls it scandal a media frenzy. >>> a private service will be held for t

i am anne-marie green.tions by vitac -- www.vitac.com and i'm frank >>> good morning everyone. it's monday, november 19. i am michelle griego. >> i am frank falco. nearly 5:00. we will answer that question with traffic and weather. where did it go? >> feels like groundhog day, doesn't it? yes, here we are again. we are looking at the possibility of a few raindrops headed our way. not today. we will tell you when we expect the rain coming up. >>> monday back to work. we have the usual overnight roadwork. they cleared the full freeway closure in san leandro. so we will tell you if it's slowing things down. we have one accident on the altamonte pass. >>> linda yee reports a century old church is on the vege verge

. >> this is ann fulton with hewitt. >> claim audit process. this is a review again from what we reviewed during our audit process. there were questions in our out of sample claim. this is an example, an emergency room claim if we identified an error in subsequent x-ray claim, that would be considered out of sample. >> we had a question on why we stratify our sample, the size really impacts the claim process egg -- processes utilized. the large claims have more control in place. you have administrators doing predisbursement audit and doing claim reveals and medical necessity reviews. the lower dollars are automated with the processes. we find that the side of the claim there are different characteristics as a result of the size of the claim. so we felt like we needed to break out and look at payment thresholds. that is why we needed to stratify the different claims in processing and we stratify the position without the sample because we are trying to keep it affordable obviously this audit and this is a good way, we feel like with our confidenc

anne-marie? >> thank you, susan. >>> coming up on the "morning news," rape allegations shut down a greek fraternity. and the gas prices at the pump. this is the "cbs morning news." from flu symptoms.ld and e (vo) theraflu. serious power. up to 27% more brush movements. patented sonic technology with get healthier gums in two weeks. innovation and you philips sonicare save when you give philips sonicare this holiday season. a man who doesn't stand still. but jim has afib, atrial fibrillation an irregular heartbeat, not caused by a heart valve problem. that puts jim at a greater risk of stroke. for years, jim's medicine tied him to a monthly trip to the clinic to get his blood tested. but now, with once-a-day xarelto®, jim's on the move. jim's doctor recommended xarelto®. like warfarin, xarelto® is proven effective to reduce afib-related stroke risk. but xarelto® is the first and only once-a-day prescription blood thinner for patients with afib not caused by a heart valve problem, that doesn't requ

i know ann has. ann, vern? >> absolutely.h i don't know if you are going with chubs to the dog park or heading on that plane to san diego? >> i will get on the plane to san diego. i'll try to get chubs to the park. i have breaking 49er news regarding linebacker navorro bowman. >> the stanford utah outcome. i got pictures. ,, female narrator: it's posturepedic versus beautyrest it's posturepedic versus beautyrest with up to $400 off. serta icomfort and tempur-pedic go head-to-head with three years' interest-free financing. mattress price wars are on now at sleep train. ♪ your ticket to a better night's sleep ♪ football... ...hey, next w's cal/stanford big game? got major cache now... ...a lotl be on the line... >>> plenty of hits from college football. next week cal, stanford, big game. a lot will be on the line there after what happened to david shaw. cardinal hosting utah today. 1st quarter, kevin hogan will play fake and toss and leeward that's a touchdown. 7-0. wilson ties it at 7. then the game puts you to sleep through r

i'm anne-marie green. winter is not set to arrive for more than a month but much of the country will start to get hit with bitterly coal temperatures and some will see snow. it's already snowing in north dakota. a massive storm is being pushed by the remnants of a major pacific typhoon. winter storm watches and warnings are posted from idaho to michigan. >>> in minnesota, they're getting ready for the snow. folks in minneapolis could get a foot with below freezing temperatures that could last for days. some parts of the country could see single-digit temperatures and arraign fisher, meteorologist of our boston station wbz says the weather is moving south. it's starting to work its way deeper toward the south. as we head toward the middle of the week. not just the rockies and plains but deep down across parts of the ohio valley and well into south texas. we'll look at temperatures as much as 40 degrees below normal. as we head toward friday will end up being florida, a little cooldown but certainly not what

i'm anne-marie green.uffalo, new york, is used to dealing with a lot of snow, but this morning, the city is paralyzed by a monster lake-effect storm that threatens to bury it in up to six feet of snow when all is said and done. at least four deaths are blamed on the storm. it's part of a nationwide system that's wrapped the country in a deep freeze. yesterday temperatures in all 50 states fell to freezing or below. and the storm is being called one of the worst in memory. the storm -- the snow, rather, is so deep and conditions to severe that a 135-mile stretch of the new york state throughway is shut down. drivers and cars, trucks and buses are stranded. some for more than 30 hours. the niagara university women's basketball team has been stranded on the throughway for about that long. the team was returning from a game in pittsburgh when they got stuck early tuesday morning. they've been in touch with police but haven't seen any help. they're in good spirits, but they're running low on food and water. ali

and i keep quoting anne marie. is all been unfair basically we're asking and to hold up this argument. and to think that she should have been on our side. for the solution to the crisis in the ukraine lies in part in syria it is time for the u.s. president obama to demonstrate he can order the offensive use with another intervention. the results will change the strategic oculus battling in damascus but moscow not to mention beijing and tokyo. >> let's talk about that. anne marie is right that putin went into crimea because of what happened in the ukraine. but what about since them the peace was hilo du deterred of that incredibly suffering? but every day putin puts with pins into the ukraine plans the troops into the ukraine in violation of his own agreement in the west only response is possibly more sanctions and a few weeks. we could not be bothered to provide some capacity to protect themselves weapon leap -- weaponry your training? that is the least we could do. >> i am not doing any work tonight i love that. a

patti ann, $1.8 billion is about the same as my shoe budget.u think the money will be worth did? worth it? >> it is hard to say. think of how many people you could feed for that money. on the other side people say space exploration ladies to technological discovers applied to everyday lives and medical advances and whatnot. i think there is something to all of that. the disappointing thing is that after this thing hit the comet, it didn't anchor. now the european space agency is looking like it may have just bounced off and they lost all contact with it. they are not even sure they will drill and get the surface -- the samples from beneath the surface they were hoping for. >> if it doesn't anchor, if they can't get the samples should someone be fired and who should it be? >> maybe for other reasons. i am a super geek. i love space. i am into space movies. i like space mountain, the ride, at disneyland, epcot center. >> that says a lot about you. >> i am skeptical about space travel. i don't know if we get value out of this crap. i don't know th

i'm anne-marie green. well, this morning that nasty mix of rain and snow that made for a miserable thanksgiving getaway in the northeast has just about wrapped up, but yesterday's monster storm certainly left its mark. hundreds of flights were canceled and driving was treacherous on one of the busiest travel days of the year. don champion reports. >> reporter: by last night new england hit with messy ice forcing some folks to rethink their holiday plans. >> plans changed with the weather. i usually travel but staying home this year. >> reporter: from virginia to pennsylvania and new york, roads were a mess. >> rwhen you encounter snow or ice-covered roads the most logical thing to do is to slow down. roads and highways were a hazard up and down the busy washington and boston corridor as millions made the thanksgiving trek to family and friends. according to aaa 89% traveled by car but many flew. flights were canceled, thousands delayed. >> it's tough to sit and wait and not know what's going to happen but

thank you, anne. >> my pleasure."andrea mitchell reports." already 41 companies are investing almost $80 million dollars, and creating 1750 jobs. from long island to all across upstate new york, more businesses are coming to new york. they are paying no property taxes, no corporate taxes, and no sales taxes. and with over 300 locations, and 3.7 million square feet available, there's a place that is is right for your business. see if startup-ny can work for you. go to startup.ny.gov. we know in the cyber world, threats are always evolving. at first, we were protecting networks. then, we were protecting the transfer of data. and today it's evolved to infrastructure... ♪ ...finance... and military missions. we're constantly innovating to advance the front line in the cyber battle, wherever it takes us. that's the value of performance. northrop grumman. that's the value of performance. ameriprise asked people a simple question: in retirement, will you have enough money to live life on your terms? i sure hope so. with hea

i'm anne-marie green. this morning a woman who was kidnapped off a philadelphia street is safe and reunited with her family. and the man seen grabbing her on surveillance video sunday night is under arrest. last night carlesha freeland-gaither's family left a maryland hospital where she was treated for unspecified injuries. she's said to be in good condition. she was rescued in a baltimore suburb. as kris van cleave reports, her family is relieved and grateful. >> i'm taking my baby home, thank you. >> she thanked the public for the happy ending to her daughter's nightmare. her daughter was found wednesday, three days after her apparent abduction was captured. >> her abductor has been arrested. >> reporter: they tracked the woman to maryland where someone used her atm card. police chased the car and her abductor to jessup about ten miles southwest of baltimore. >> the agents at that point moved in, utilized one of their vehicles to block him, to prevent him from leaving the parking airy. >> when the subjec

anne, did you have a question? >> just a comment. thank you, commissioner seriina, for reminding me of that tip situation and commission ow for clarifying because what has happened and as far as i know it's only been the finance committee, my recollection is that it's only been with finance, because secretly the finance agenda was enormously interesting many commissioners would come to the meeting. so there would be in fact more commissioners attending than the three that were on the committee. but there were times at the very last minute, and the chair was not a member of the committee necessarily, so at the very last minute we'd get to the finance committee meeting and two wouldn't be there. and then the chair of the committee could then in fact ask, as commissioner ow was saying, if the ones that were there wanted to serve for that purpose. as i said, i think finance is the only one that i've seen this happen on. it may have happened with other committees and i'm not aware of it. typically we would not schedule a meeting if we kne

anne. >> reporter: the clock is ticking for the raiders. their

i hesitate to keep quoting anne marie.his is all quite unfair the he's an extremely formidable person but we've been asking reed to hold up this argument -- fareed to hold up this argument all by himself since anne marie has been on our side. 2013, "the solution to the demrice ukraine lies in part in syria. t's time for barack obama to demonstrate that he can authorize the offensive use of force" -- close your ears, fareed -- "other than in secret drone attacks. he result would be seen in damascus, beijing and tokyo." >> he's doing it now, so putin must be trembling. obama has now 500 strikes in syria? >> let's talk about putin for a second. i think it's worth talking. anne marie is exactly right, that putin went into cramia because of -- cr ifert mea because of what happened in ukraine. what's happened since then? how do you deter putin from going further than he had already gone? fareed is talking about all the incredible suffering the russian economy is going through and certainly it is. the only problem is every day pu