thank you artur volodymyrovych. next, yuzhannina nina petrovna, please, your amendment 445.e, nina petrovna. dear colleagues, immediately after september 12, we started discussing with our colleagues, together with local self-government, we communicate with literally all regions and representatives, where we have a representative office. european solidarity, work was carried out in a circle, work was carried out on how to find the right one decision, and, well, it seems to me that in the ministry of finance, like nowhere else , in another place, they understand how difficult it was for us to make decisions in the 15th year about directing such a large share of the pdf to local budgets, please understand, dear prime minister wanted to centralize all taxes at the central ri for any government, this was the main task, and when the decision was made to decentralize, this is, by the way, one of the steps to be taken on the way to joining the big european family, we took this step, you now you are crossing it out, thank you, yuzhaina's amendment 445, it was rejected by the committ

next amendment is number 370, people's deputies ariyev, gerasimov, or goza, who will report, artur volodymyrovych, ariy volodymyrovych, please, i understand, putting something to a vote in a hall in which no more than 50 people's deputies are present, in principle there is no sense , and it's a shame we can't have budget discussions before it will start to become simply ugly, and ugly is what is happening now, when they are trying to hide it in the budget. very such costs that people will not like, under, but will make the sign beautiful for the needs of national security defense. i want to emphasize one thing again: we are now at a crossroads , either we start reforms and restore the trust of our partners, who finance more than 50% of our expenses, or we risk losing the country altogether, so let's... let's get real work, thank you, it will be position of the committee, ok, i am putting to vote amendment number 370 of people's deputies, colleagues, the committee has rejected it, please vote, no need to put it, okay, fine, please, dmytro oleksanovych razomkov from the procedure, thank you, oleksa

was rejected by the committee, please vote, in 20 years. not accepted 395 gerasima, please, artur volodymyrovych, thank you, dear colleagues from the servant of the people, who is still left in the hall , there are not many of you, 32 people at the moment, but nevertheless, why cannot we vote for this bill, i emphasize, in we have an army in the ministry of culture, on it allocate so much money that you could buy 184 mavics. 91 million are allocated to the ministry of justice. it would be possible to buy 910 mavics. ministry of finance - 272 million 2727 maviks. we went further. well, the ministry of education and science of ukraine, there are textbooks, it's sacred, but 47 million, we now understand, went to awards to outstanding personalities in the field of science and culture. well, where else? now, as for the foundation. state property of ukraine, but money is allocated for them instead of buying 431 mavics, well, we need drones, you understand we need to save people's lives, gerasimov's amendment in 395 was rejected by the committee, please vote. for 20 the decision was not taken 397 amend

decisions, not for god's sake, 27 decisions were not made bonddar, but from the procedure, artur volodymyrovych, from the procedure, please, dear ruslan oleksiyovych, look, today, as far as i remember, the conciliation council did not vote for us to work for more than four hours today, it was discussed, but not voted, the conciliation board did not make such a decision, that is why from the point of view and security, from the point of view and any other, i do not even mention gzot, yes now, which does not concern the people. deputies, well, as we know, that's why it's a big request, let's end this story now , because i want to say that the monomajority is almost not present in the hall and to announce a break, thank you very much, thank you, thank you, artur volodymyrovych, i was also talking about the procedures andriy viktorovych, did it seem to me, andriy viktorovych, motovylovych, please look, we want to make a statement from the servants of the people faction that other factions are now tying the head of the committee, there the budget calls her the prime minister, but this is mockery , p

'll just talk about everything important, the fact is that here, let's give this one, then artur volodymyrovych, and then we'll talk. you say, that means let's go on this one, so it's 726, it's education again, and i want to emphasize this issue again, that today, when we talk about education, it's a question not only directly of educators, it's a question of our survival, it there is a question of survival of the nation, that is the issue of giving birth to children who will have a place to study is what we need today, that's why the salary of an educator cannot be like this, by the way, for others who... you know, who else in our country receives 4-500 hryvnias , conductors in ukrzaliznytsia, who transport the whole country and save it, thank you, please, next 727, 728 gerasimov, two minutes, please , yes, thank you, dear colleagues, i just very briefly wanted everyone to listen to what i will say now about this budget, so we understand that now is a large-scale invasion, but nevertheless, we must prepare documents more professionally. first, this budget continues the practice of suspending t

now just put it, as they say, on the floor and don't violate the regulations , thank you, artur volodymyrovychok, i heard this information, i don't know how reliable it is, you know that during the meeting , may i conclude, i know that during the meeting of the verkhovna rada it is possible to hold committees only by order of the verkhovna rada, the verkhovna rada did not vote on such an order today, therefore, i ask the apparatus to inform the chairmen of the committees who have now decided to convene their committees during the session of the verkhovna rada about that they violate the regulations of the verkhovna rada of ukraine and that those who did it should immediately return to their workplaces. thank you, let's go further, let's go further, and then you, you smart people's deputies, please. let's go further 313, 314, 315, 316, 317 amendment, razumkov, please, dmytro oleksandrovich, thank you, ruslan oleksiiovych, and, reksana andriivna, yes, serhii, yes, march, yes, of course, yes, mylich. i think that you can ask him, they receive additional funding, to the ministry , where they will

of the fraction by my groups, please, please, gerasimov from the procedure, what happened, artur volodymyrovych, give gerasimov, dear ruslan oleksiyovych, i would like to draw your attention once again to the fact that we did not hear almost a single word of the committee's decision from the podium, we heard a speech that could have been from the faction, no questions asked, take the floor, pass it on to danylo oleksandrovich, let deviates from the faction with political statements, but we wanted to hear the decision of the committee from the podium, you have already paid attention to this , please ask the heads of the committees or the speakers from the committees once again to give us the opinion of the committee, not an essay on a free topic, thank you, thank you, arthur volodymyrovych, i cannot but agree, so i am addressing: to the persons who are speaking on behalf of myself and the committee, two minutes from myself, two minutes from the committee, dear colleagues, let's stick to it, the rules are the same for everyone, you just finished 2 minutes 35 seconds, yours was a very long time, b

thank you, artur volodymyrovych, i answer all your questions. everything is correctly said, which is considered under article 157, with the features that are provided for, but in the procedure of a full review. those two other issues that you are talking about, additional issues and speeches, it is not in the 157th, and therefore, i think that it was wrong violation, and as for the speech of people's deputy honcharenko, indeed. part three, paragraph three, part one of article 30 of the regulation, says that speeches of people's deputies, members of the main committee with the announcement and consideration of a separate opinion are allowed, if it was not provided to the people's deputies together with the conclusion of the relevant committee. i report to you that the dissenting opinion was submitted only this morning, and therefore it could not be valid, it was not heard in committee, there was no action on it there are no questions, so i think we will move on, please, artur volodymyrovy, what are your procedures, dear ruslan oleksiyovych, in th

i am removing the edits including 877, please, thank you, please, 20 minutes of speech to artur volodymyrovych, please, dear mr. chairman, dear colleagues, dear ukrainians, now in this hall, despite the fact that there are not many deputies, but the largest ones remained here, including approximately 19 of the servants of the people, from the monomajority, the draft law is being considered, which at first glance has a noble goal, but which, unfortunately, completely kills the decentralization reform. and we have to understand that this reform is precisely one of the key ones on our way to the european union, because decentralization, the power of communities, the capacity of communities in the european union is the basis, and it is the key principle of the life of every state that is a member of the european union today community, that is why we and the noble but the method chosen for this is very wrong, i want to say so mildly , you know, we, in the verkhovna rada, i think almost every deputy, i personally, as the co-head of the european solidarity faction, received a letter from the associat

artur volodymyrovych gerasimov.lease, dear colleagues, while in the hall at least a little. there are factions of the servant of the people, i want to appeal to you, listen to why you absolutely cannot vote for this law , the number one reason, here is not only defense, and look at what journalists are already writing, i quote, bureaucrats are asking for money for their salaries, under cover defense spending, i'm just showing, and reason number two, they tell you that there is no pdf here, or its there is not much, but... the key point: 207, almost billions of domestic borrowings, which are the key element of revenues in this bill, they are just taken, and they are secretly taken quite a lot. from pdf of local communities. and why is it so interesting? because after reading the conclusion of the main legal department of the draft law, it is proposed to supplement the so-and-so section of this law, paragraph 15, regarding the procedure for using the remaining funds for subvention from the state budget. 253 amendment,

and therefore, if the deputies dear colleagues, just for information from the eu faction , artur volodymyrovych gerasimov was sent on a business trip, so please understand the position of the committee on these three amendments. thank you, dear ms. iryna, advisers and assistants, members of supervisory boards, are not authorized to perform the functions of the state. can't make any decisions, don't sign them and therefore don't fall under the criteria you mentioned. besides, it is contradictory. a number of directives implemented in this law. thank you. thank you, dear colleagues, i am putting these amendments one by one. the sixth amendment, authored by gerashchenko and his colleagues, was rejected by the committee, please vote. for 78, no decision was made. on the amendment by factions, state amendment 21, also authored by gerashchenko and his colleagues, the committee rejects the argument, have you heard why i am asking you to vote for 71, the decision has not been made and amendment 28 , authored by gerashchenko and his committee colleagues, it is rejected, please vote, amendment 68 is reje

his colleagues, 550 and lionov does not insist, 551 bondar does not insist, 553 gerasimov artur volodymyrovych exactly what aryev is, so 553 and there's one more, right? and this is gerasimova 553 and i apologize, you have already spoken, marry her my way 553 you have already spoken, i apologize , spoken, yes, yes, spoken, sorry, yes, yes, sorry, yes, yes, yes, 554 mom does not insist, 555, purtova does not insist , 556- krulko does not insist, 557- tymoshenko and colleagues do not insist, 550. petrunyak does not insist, 559 does not insist, 560th razumkov and colleagues does not insist, 561st mokan and colleagues does not insist, 562 aleksiychuk does not insist , 563 aleksiychuk z colleagues do not insist, 564 aleksiychuk and his colleagues do not insist, 565 kiselevsky does not insist, 566 bondar does not insist, 567 majurasho does not insist, 568 the beekeeper does not insist. 569 laba does not insist, 570 laba does not insist, 571 beekeeper does not insist, 572 mother does not insist, 573 mazurashov has already spoken, 574th krulko does not insist, 575 tymoshenko and colleagues does not in

a vote, he said at the committee. for 241, the decision has been made, from the procedure artur volodymyrovych, please, dear ruslan oleksiiovych, we just missed a part, we just went like this, i have a big request, let's go to the table and we will already go through the table, there if not i'm wrong, there is 73 corrections now, but we were just talking about let's go to 73, are you nina petrivna or who will be hancharenko, please, 73. thank you, dear friends, i would like to remind all of us what the state budget of ukraine is. the state budget of ukraine is a tool for fulfilling promises, programs, it is a tool for the development of the state, and it seems to me that now is the time to remember, in fact, with what promises, especially since if it were not for martial law, we would have these days you held parliamentary elections and we would all be summing up by now, and what has been done? well, friends, i have in front of me the program of the servant of the people, with which she went to the elections, i just want to understand where this program is reflected in the state budget, i do n