commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore.ommissioner sugaya. >> i think he'd like this project so i vote. >> commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously and places you on item 13 for the next case at 1518 slope for conditional use authorization >> good afternoon commissioner president wu and commissioners i'm with the plaintiff the request for conditional use authorization to establish a beauty supply store as sally you beauty supply with 16 hundred square feet within the shopping center the space was occupied by jamming before he play which is volunteering relocating and the placing is an 0er7b9d shopping center that provides a variety of goods and services to the adjacent neighborhoods and anchored by lucky supermarket. the existing density of the formula retail uses is that 6 percent of retail. there are no other beauty supplies stores within this and it supports the high ratio of formula retail and based on those ouldz in the case support the department recommen

commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. and commissioner antonini will be joining us shortly first, it the consideration for continuance item one case at 1010 bush stre 1010 bush street conditional use authorization is for case numbers d d and d and case 2010 at the 2820th century lake street conditional use are proposed for june 20th, 2014, i have no other items proposed for conditions i have one speaker card >> karen jones. >> other mike please. this is item one a-1010 bushy own the building next door i'm new to the process but this is the second continuance i'm trying to plan my summer vacation is there a limit to how much time something can be continued i want to be sure and there's no before and after but mr. magaziney. >> the project planner. >> okay. great. >> is there any public comment on items proposed for continuance seeing none, public comment is closed. commissioner moore >> move to continue as noted. >> second. >> commissioners, on that motion as proposed. commissioner antonini. commissioner borden. commission

no >> commissioner borden. >> no. that commissioner hillis. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong >> no. president fong. no >> that motion fails 2 to 5 is there an alternative motion there is no alternative motion it will be approved in its current form. >> thank you, commissioners shall we move on to the next item it is item 15 for the next case at the 1423 ocean avenue a mandatory discretionary review on may 1st time f first, the commission continued the matter to this date by a vote of 5 to zero and commissioner antonini upper recused and commissioner antonini i recommend you request that recall again and president fong in order for you to participate in today's hearing you have to acknowledge you've reviewed the materials. >> yes. i was planning to participate pending a communication with the city attorney but there is still a little bit cloudy i'm no longer the owner of any dental practice, however, 0 over $100 to the practice an outside contractor so this is a gray area in my mind and until we get complete clarification i'm going to have to ask for a rue re

commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you under our discretionary review calendar. item 14 for the case d at the 1110 ashburg after may first, they continued the matter by a vote of 6 to zero commissioner fong upper absent at this item and for you to participate you'll have to say you've reviewed the materials and that's correct i watched it on sfgovtv and am ready. >> if we can say add consulted the secretary on how to consultation the hearing this is the third hearing we just decided to allow for the staff for 3 minutes from the dr requester and open this up for public comment. >> okay. >> good afternoon. commissioner president wu and members this case is a discretionary review for 1110 ashbury street to allow the property owner project sponsor to work on the design and incorporate feedback. as a reminder the dr was filed by the resident directly from the adjacent property to the north. the dr re

>> aye. >> borden? >> aye. >> hillis? >> aye. >> fong? >> aye ft. wu? >> aye. >> that motion passes unanimously, 6-0, that will place you under commission matters, item 3, draft minutes for june 12, 2014. >> is there any public comment on the draft minutes? seeing none, public comment is closed. commissioner fong? >> move to approve minutes. >> second. >> on that motion to adopt the minutes for june 12, 2014, commissioner antimony, borden, hillis, moore, fong, and president wu? >> aye. >> so moved, that motion passes unanimously 6-0 and places you on item 4, commission comments and questions. >> commissioner moore? >> i would like to make a comment on the item we just approved in consent and that is the incredible transformation of value, the addition of this small one of a kind retail store has made to the building which was very controversial when we approved it here. that particular store has almost transformed the building. it amazing because all of a sudden the attention goes to ground floor which is very active. it's a very nice sto, i'm vegetaria

commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. that commissioners before i jump into the items for continuance i want to advise the members of the public we've received a request if supervisor wiener's office to take his item out of order the committee moved item 16 the affordable housing density inclusion planning code amendment to the regular calendar to accommodate his schedule. commissioners, first on your calendar is your consideration for items for continuance item one at 1998 polk street request for conditional use authorization and items 2 ab for the case at the 66 third street requester request for a conditional use authorization are proposed for june 27, 2014, the next item application information on anti description housing policy is proposed for continuance for july 10th and item 4 at the 1010 bush street request for kwifgs is proposed for continuance there are no speaker cards. my public comment on the continuance calendar? okay. seeing none, public comment is closed. commissioner antonini >> move to continue items 1,

commissioner borden. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissions fong and sxhifgs are expected to arrive commissioners, first on your calendar is the items from the evidence for continuance item one u and t the form retail is for continuance and an amendment to the planning code section 303 formula retail uses ordinance introduced by supervisor mar that proposed for continuance until july 17, 2014. i have no other matters for continuance and there are no speaker cards. are there my questions or comments on the items seeing none, public comment is closed >> commissioner moore. >> move to continue items one and 2. second >> second at about on that motion commissioner antonini. commissioner borden. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 5 to zero and places you under our consent may be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the commission. there will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of the commission, the public, or staff so re

. >> commissioner borden. >> i thought it was an interesting policy decision i didn't remember it coming on the other project you recommended for the dollar per year that's definitely new. in terms of this project it is important we look at the changes in the massing they've been responsible and i think the way the building has been improved it's terrible there are a lot of windows that have to be covered it's not an unusual phenomena >> commissioners a motion and second to approve with conditions. >> commissioner antonini. >> commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero. and places you on item 12 for the next case. at the 21020th century 1 on webster street request for conditional use authorizatiusea >> good afternoon, commissioners commissioner president wu glen in department staff this is on webster street and encompass 9 lots. the project is a planned unit development and 6 unit conditional use authorization to reuse the institutiona

commissioner borden >> commissioner hillis. commissioner moore and commissioner sugaya and you commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero. that places you on items 17 a and b for the next case at the 456, 7th street mandatory discretionary reviews. >> good evening commissioner president wu and members of the planning commission i'm presenting a you mandatory discretionary review for a don't guess of a single-family dwelling a proposed new 3 story 2 family the address is 4 hundred and 5627 street. the current building is owner accompanied and contains 9 hundred quiet with one bedroom and one bath no off-street parking and the two family dwelling with one unit on the ground floor about 9 hundred and 23 square feet and the second unit occupies the second and third floors with 2 thousand 2 hundred and 61 square feet e square feet with 2 off-street parking spaces. the proposed building has been reviewed by your design team and the rtd said it's consistent with the residential design

. >> commissioner borden commissioner hillis. commissioner moore commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you on item 12 a and braxton building inspection commission on bush street a request for kufks and we're consider requires for variances. >> good afternoon commissioner president wu and members of the board. i'm with the staff. the project is located at 1430 bush street and a conditional use authorization to construct a hundred and 15 at all mixed use construction and with the rent a car at the current location. you may recall it was heard by planning commission on september 9th of 2013 and just to bring to our memory the project that was shown at that time, in september. one hundred and 15 foot tall building with 32 unit facing a alley and at that time, there was a few members of public that spoke in opposition and if the commission continued to further work on the design. and there were concerns about a central courtyard in which the unit that faced the courtyard

amount to the front but acknowledge the adjacent neighbors this has not done that >> commissioner borden. >> i'm primarily voting for this if with we have a better way we could debate this 65 times over i'm happyly entertain another motion if there's a think a alternative idea but no one wants to take a position that's the issue i'm having here. commissioner moore >> i want to add one comment that applies to all of us ada is a human right and something that expresses itself in code and you can't avoid that this is a technical knowledge and i mentioned three-quarters of an inch i happened to consultant with someone that's an ada person skyline architect and just excuse me. ly speaking could this be done there was a clear answer to, yes this is a very large home and has a lot of spaces to do something we're not talking about the minimal dimensions to meet the code required for ada and access availability. it's not here as a group knowing the fact it was the triggers for the r a that's basically why their pulling back that leaves us with the other responsibility of thinking about the neighb

commissioner borden >> commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong. commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero >> the commission will take a 20 minute break. >> thursday, may 22, 2014. i'd like to remind please silence all electronic devices. that may sound off and and when speaking before the commission, if you care to, do state your name for the record. commissioners we left off under your regular calendar on item 11. the mission alcohol beverage special use ordinance amending the alcohol beverage special use district. diego sanchez i'll be talking about the special use district alcohol beverages, however, i'm i'm to provide supervisor campos office with time to present on the motivator >> good afternoon, commissioners the amendment to 9 special district is pretty small a narrow exception allowing the miniature golf course to serve alcohol beverages and bowling alleys enjoy this similar section and approached by a company and the business was conceived the people have been in the ne

commissioner borden >> commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong >> commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero. >> the commission will regular hearing nor thursday, june 12, 2014. like to remind the must be of the audience to vines my mobile device. commissioners you've left off on item 15 the production and distribution and repair informational presentation. >> good afternoon, commissioners steve with the planning staff this is a great way to celebrate how far this sector has come and talk about the place in the eco system what is the distribution repair that's a term of arts that cluster a wide range of activities p is about production making things whether arts, clothes. buildings, distribution is about motorcycling things around people and utilities and mending things cars and furniture. what are some of the characteristics or p dr it can't compete that san francisco it can't afford to build new spaces the rents are not high enough to justify construction it is typical denser s

. >> commissioner borden. >> i'm not familiar about the state bonus law. >> i'm sure director ram can explain this there's a stating that allows developers to with a certain affordability level to get a density illustration or bonus that includes height we've not implemented it here i guess it is being discussed in the working group. and but it's a little bit like the state in-law unit i've not been great about it but mr. ram can elaborate >> i can ice this one we actually have a sdrugs discussion if the developers provide affordable units we're allowed to give them more density but we have the inclusionary housing requirement we are looking at brown where it might happen and that's sort of thing but that housing density law has been in place for a number of years and we're looking at to implement it. >> it doesn't actually have a threshold number obviously to be implemented that's the difference here couldn't the dispensary theoretically, you know, file for a project application and say i want to increase the state law technically. >> i believe the developer could make a contention b

and steve sarver and borden. come up and if you could line up on our left, what would are your right, the aisle. thank you very much. >> go ahead. >> hello, my name is michael lusano and i am a recently on the board of san francisco, organizing project and inner faith action and more importantly i am a 62-year-old native san franciscan who is back where i grew up on tenth avenue and supervisor eric mar's district. and i was compelled to come today because attending the meeting last week at the board of public health, i was discouraged is the polite word after the meeting because it was basically roughly, 15, in favor and one gentleman against. and i just want to fully support and afopm or pr and i want to support closing this loophole. thank you. >> thank you very much. i appreciate that. >> next speaker. >> good morning, supervisors i'm meril, director of healthcare and coverage and access, it is eleven non-profit community healthcare, and more than 10 percent of the city's population, and i am here today to sup

. >> commissioner borden. >> confusing second year commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and places you on public comment i have in speaker card >> any public comment seeing none, the meeting is >> i love teaching. it is such an exhilarating experience when people began to feel their own creativity. >> this really is a place where all people can come and take a class and fill part of the community. this is very enriching as an artist. a lot of folks take these classes and take their digital imagery and turn it into negatives. >> there are not many black and white darkrooms available anymore. that is a really big draw. >> this is a signature piece. this is the bill largest darkroom in the u.s.. >> there are a lot of people that want to get into that dark room. >> i think it is the heart of this place. you feel it when you come in. >> the people who just started taking pictures, so this is really an intersection for many generations of photographers and this

commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero. zoning administer >> take the closed public hearing and take the matter under advisement. >> commissioners that will place on item 13 as 18 street. >> good afternoon commissioner president wu and members planning staff this is the request for an conditional use authorization at the 18 union street a 3 story mixed use at the aaron that was developed in 1933 features resident and ground floor and at the rear of the first floor it features a t mobile as well as an at&t facility. the t mobile is a single-family antenna mounted to the base and it consists of the antennas mounted along the intersection of octavia and union streets it is up to 6 panel machines on the rooftop and larger equipment cabinets inside the building and the screen will be used it on the rooftop in order to screen the antennas as well the equipment the northeast part of the building is component of two a

you requested to hear more information about the transportation contact and commissioner borden and so just wanted to give you more information about that. as part of the mta's effectiveness project the i'm sorry copies of the - . as part of the mta's transit effectiveness the express line as identified as part of the network a series of transit only lanes in the locations are implemented to the reduce traffic time i'm going to i'm going to turn it over to david from the transmission authority to talk about the other projects as part of the county transportation study. i apologize. i was told he would be here today. if we could come back to this i don't have his slides. so i'm on slide 8 as a reminder those are the changes on may 8th we went over. and i'm going to go over the changes to the other documents. first, the planning code and the map ordinance. the first proposal is to maintain the existing zoning of m-1 for the parking lots 004 and the other one which are not owned by project support. when we started this process we were focused on the negotiations and the owned property so

commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero. >> the commission will welcome planning commission regularometers for dumb. please be advised commission on matters that are within the commission's jurisdiction and are not on today's agenda. and when speaking before the commission, if you care to, do state your name for the record. . commissioners we left off in our regular calendar for case 2010 x at the 2051, third street for the planning code large project authorization >> and commissioners doug with the plaintiff. the project is a large authorization for the proposed development on third street. this project was granted a continuance so the project sponsor will be able to rise the project and sufficiently address community input. there the project authorization it's seeking the modification of the planning code for open space and provisions inform the dwell unite this includes the demolition of two warehouse buildi

. >> borden. >> aye. >> hillis. >> aye. >> moore. >> aye. >> is a guy y'all. >> aye. >> president wu. >> so moved, that motion passes unanimously 7-0. i have no speaker cards on comments. >> is there any general public comment. >> seeing none, general public comment is closed. meeting adjourned. >> good afternoon. welcome to the san francisco full board of supervisors tuesday, june 24, 2014. madam clerk call roll >> supervisor avalos. supervisor avalos? supervisor breed. supervisor campos. president chiu. supervisor cohen. supervisor farrell. supervisor kim. supervisor mar. supervisor tang's. supervisor wiener. supervisor yee. mr. president, all members are present thank you ladies and gentlemen, please join us in the pledge of allegiance of america and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> thank you. >> excuse me. sir, you are out of order. >> (inaudible). i'm sorry to a >> colleagues, we're back in session with the approval of the minutes motion that i supervisor cohen and second by supervisor mar the may 2014 mi

commissioner borden >> commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you on item 10 for case and intention to initiate the development related to formula retail uses and to consider an adaptation of an ordinance at a later hearing >> good afternoon. commissioner president wu and commissioners in the an exciting day for the staff after implementing the formula retail controls we're ready to unveil our policy recommendations. the action is simple we having ask you bring those to life but to describe the full action of controls and to hear from you. the broad consensus the noticeable process is working it has expand and seems to be an effective method to provide public input your proposal recognitions this and seeks to build upon the framework. we will expand the process in some geometric areas while reducing some in some circumstances the retail depiction will expand in some and reduce in others. we believe this is a murder and ba

i'd like to add that into my comment >> commissioner borden. the court: yeah. i want to associate myself with many of the comments it was important this new community be a san francisco community and kind of not like mission bay that was mentioned earlier and have those more narrow streets that have that community and city feels that's important. i also have a question about the props i'm excited about a new process am i to understand the fire department has not seen this before? >> it's a little of each commissioner payrolls so back in 2010 those plans were circulated to the fire department. however, i will admit that the level of kind of staff handholding, if you will, that occurs around the street with dpw was not the same level i will admit i think that's part of what got us into the situation not really starting. and then that kind of revealed itself. i don't know and working with the fire department i i know they have their goals and priorities and obviously safety and emergency response is one of them but i think that looking at how that coincides with p

great your report >> commissioner borden. >> i want to agree i remember i served on the search committee for the new president for sf state it's amazing people didn't get hit trying to catch the train people be wouldn't safely cross the intersection and it sets apart from the campus and park merced this is much better so i highly support in and i think it's a great direction. >> commissioner sugaya. >> yes. >> couple of things one to clarify on this slide you showed the yellow or orange crossing are those the ones that commissioner antonini referred to as possibly underground on 19. >> i forget when color one is existing the one that commissioner antonini is referring to say between eucalyptus and winston and near mercy high school in that location the station will be at the level of the stones town parking lot and i actually i've seen it before they used to have a legal crossing and it was dangerous so they now have a fence i've seen the students run across and it makes me cringe so this is a natural desire line. >> you caution you you're going tunnels i mean maybe this is a part of tow

commissioner borden. >> this site is a difficult site of its type and scope. i grew up with cvs having grown up on the east coast and that was our local stand alone drug store. there is a cvs when you gross the golden gate bridge to marin. it's easier to park and all that sort of stuff. so i think while there will be people driving on that side of 19th avenue who will go to that store, i don't think people will cross and that's why there's two 76 stations across the street from each other because people don't want to go out of their way to be convenienced to -- people don't want to be inconvenienced. i wasn't really -- it never seem to compute in a way that i understood because it's a highly traffic corridor and a large space that -- if we were asking to build net new, i don't think they'll be support on this commission to build the store if this site did not exist as it is. i think that's very much the case and if you were looking across the street on a vacant lot t -- a vacant lot, it would be the same thing. it is, in terms of what semi said, i think union

i follow-up on what commissioner borden said whenever we can look at the situation existing now for unite that are inclusionary at the 12 percent by state law it probably would be good to study what could be implemented as some sort of bonus for complying and help our legislation especially, if it gets challenged by someone who didn't elect to do the bonus but they might exchange it under prop c. i had one other question i'm not sure you have the figures alter our fingertips in terms of how many units under construction for approval to be built in san francisco i'm not saying we don't need to do this but it's good looking good to look at what we have in the pipeline >> there are both 40 thousand units that are approved but 25 or so are in the 3 big project areas treasure island development authority board and park merced and the shipyard arrest there's about 6 to 7 thousand under construction and another 10 thousand in our pipeline going there to approval progress and so con sefbl about 16 thousand to be built in the next year. >> that's right and the shipyard is going to take a long time