his name's carl raines. carl raines? yeah. all right, thanks. this is carl raine'' last known address. (dog barking nearby) wait a minute. hey, got a visual on our suspect. that's him. got a visual on our suspect. he's headed for that truck. he's headed for that truck. (gunfire) you got him? where's your partner? where's your partner?! why'd you kill benjamin paxton? was... was paid. paid by who? hey! hey! hey! he's gone. damn it! you heard him. hired to kill ben paxton. for febreze fabric refresher. they agreed. [ experimenter 1 ] relax, take some nice deep breaths. [ experimenter 2 ] what do you smell? lilac. clean. there's something that's really fresh. a little bit beach-y. like children's blankets. smells like home. [ experimenter 1 ] okay. take your blindfolds off. ♪ hello? [ male announcer ] and now new and improved febreze fabric refresher with up to two times the odor elimination so you can breathe happy, guaranteed. ♪ [ barks ] [ laughs ] ♪ ♪ [ dog barks ] ♪ [ male announcer ] it all starts with a windows 7 pc. ♪ [ jerry ] attention sh

carl paladino who was an art project about how nuts you could be while still running for office, carlhe bestiality e-mails guy, who sent out a political mailer spiked with a trash smell, carl paladino beat him in the republican primary by 24 points. new york state did not figure out carl paladino was an art project until they already had him as the republican nominee for governor. now we have herman cain. polls indicate right now that nothing that herman cain is doing is hurting his poll numbers among republicans at all. the cumulative effect of all of this stuff i think means we are now going to collectively sort of turn the telescope the other way around and recognize what this has all been about. honestly, many liberals are praying republicans don't turn the telescope around and don't figure out this joke, that this art project goes all the way. whether or not that's possible, we leave to the administrations of my friend eugene robinson, pulitzer prize winning columnist for the "washington post" and msnbc political analyst. gene, am i throwing a hot potato into your lap here? >> ra

. >> tony stewart beat carl edwards. but before the race, first lady michelle obama dr. jill biden, getting mixed reaction. the two were there to take part in an initiative to honor military families. >> how nice of them. >> here you go. >> please welcome our grand marshals, sergeant andrew barry and family. first lady of the united states michelle obama and dr. jill biden as they deliver the most famous words in motor sports. >> gentlemen, start your engines! >> that wasn't that bad. couple guys booed. >> they're with children. >> overreaction. >> it was kind of rude, but they looked like very nice -- very nice of them to be there. >> the real story, tony stewart beats carl edwards. he wins the race. that's all very exciting. >> who cares? >> you just showed -- lots of people care. >>> still ahead, senators john kerry, joe manchin, keep it on

>> a agree with carl. think if it's romney and we're going to ohio is health care a mandate off the table? i know romney going to argue he's going let states decide it but i think it kind of muddies the issue. i do think ohio set itself up as a key swing state again. >> and have you tch. after the brake, james rosen breaks down remembers and our special election night panel. stay with us. you never know when, but thieves can steal your identity. turning your life upside down in a matter of seconds. hi. hi. you know i can save you 15% today if you open up a charge card account with us. you just read my mind. [ male announcer ] just one little piece of information and they can open bogus accounts, stealing your credit, your money, and ruining your reputation. that's why you need lifelock. lifelock is the leader in identity theft protection. relentlessly protecting your personal information to help stop the crooks in their tracks before your identity is attacked. protecting your social security number, your b

>> this guy was my fantastic, magnet, bossy, difficult, older brother carl. he was the red state to my blue state. all you have to understand to know about how complicated and difficult this relationship was my first memory of my brother was with when he sail me out a window when i was 2 years old and in the san antonio emergency room with a cut on my eye brow. he gave me the gift of a hard head. he went from there to being the youngest member of the john berk society and coming into my room to smash my joan biaz records because she was on the list. he was complicated, but saying all of that he was mysterious. he grew up to be a trial lawyer turned apple orchardist. part of the madening sibling thing was understanding the control freak nature that my brother had. for example, every year he would send me a box of fruit. the fruit he grew in his gorgeous orchards in washington state. the fruit came with the carl tax where you would get 25 telephone calls before the fruit came, such as, fruit is coming next week, are you going to be home? this is said in a texas

>> a agree with carl.ink if it's romney and we're going to ohio is health care a mandate off the table? i know romney going to argue he's going let states decide it but i think it kind of muddies the issue. i do think ohio set itself up as a key swing state again. >> and have you tch. after the brake, james rosen breaks down remembers and our special election night panel. stay with us. >> bret: back to our special election night coverage. joining me now to talk about what may have been driving results is james rosen. dangerous tonight. james. >> good evening, bret. we've been talking about ohio. it offered something for everybody tonight. buck eye state voters rejected the individual mandate and the unions prevailed in persuading ohioins to repeal the law restricting collective bargaining rights and i think that weighs in part of the reason for that is that unemployment rate in the state of ohio we'd like to see stands right now at about 9.1%. let's take a look at jobs right now. they've lost almost 108,00

here is carl. >> thanks. now to los angeles, dozens of adorable beagles who spent their lives trapped in cages, got a first taste of freedom. >> reporter: at l.a.x., a special delivery in time for the holid holidays. >> hi, baby. >> reporter: this precious cargo from half a world away, 40 beagles rescued from a research lab in spain now safely in los angeles, headed for a foster home and a new life. >> these dogs have sort of served people their whole life. they have been used and abused for animal testing, and you know, now they get to be free. and we get to give them a life. >> reporter: volunteers say these beagles and the dogs rescued before them have never really had a chance to live. >> we are headed somewhere where we can run free. >> reporter: they were more project than pet. the dogs spent their lives caged in a science lab, some have never seen the sun, much less a park. >> about to be their first steps on the grass or outside ever. their entire lives. very exciting. should i start? let's do it. >>

>> i'm 150 pounds. >> carl!> most modern houses are designed to take the weight of a solar panel instaglation. >> i don't have to worry about panels falling in on me? >> hopefully not. >> hopefully not. >> if you have a good contractor, they'll do their due diligence. they'll do their homework. it's better for the industry if everyone does their homework and does the calculations to make sure the system is going to last 20 years, 30 years. >> that is another question. what is the lifetime of the system? do you have to have the solar panels replaced periodically? >> no, actually the solar panels last a really long time. there are solar panels in operation from the 1950's and the 1960's. the inverter is a piece of hardware that has a lifespan between 10 years. they usually warranty between five and 10 years. that may need replacement down the line. the solar panels will last a good long time. this is what we have intalked here at british motors. what we have, there is no moving parts here as we are talking about.

i'm carl quantinilla.ing meal. >> we can't quit talking about the turkey. >> you said it's a good turkey, bind isn't bad either. 18th annual troy drye. coming out here. bring toys, gifts, clothing, books, whatever you want to bring to help the needy. starts monday on the plaza here on "today." we've done it for 18#ryears. jerry seinfeld, celebrities involved as well. >> if you can't go to the plaza, visit our website, today.com. >> and drop toys off at nbc experience store across the street. >>> let's get another check of the parade forecast from al, on the upper west side. t-30 to the parade. >> weather is perfect. blue skies no, wind. temperature around 40. mary j. blige, a little chilly this morning, mary? >> yes, a little. >> you'll be on the big apple float. first time in the parade. >> first time. i watched it for years as a child. and just growing up. and i'm here right now. it's amazing to watch all of the floats before they come down. all tied down. just nice. >> your new album is out. film versio

>> a agree with carl.hink if it's romney and we're going to ohio is health care a mandate off the table? i know romney going to argue he's going let states decide it but i think it kind of muddies the issue. i do think ohio set itself up as a key swing state again. >> and have you tch. after the brake, james rosen breaks down remembers and our special election night panel. stay with us. at bayer, we're re-inventing aspirin for pain relief. with new extra-strength bayer advanc aspirin. it has microparticles, enters the bloodstream faster and rushes relief to the site of pain. it's clinically proven to relieve pain ice as fast. new bayer advanced aspirin. [ whooping ] ♪ it was the best day ♪ it was the best day ♪ ♪ it was the best day 'cause of you ♪ we make a great pair. huh? progressive and the great outdoors! we make a great pair. right, totally. that's what i was thinking. all kinds of vehicles, all kinds of savings. multi-policy discounts from progressive. call or click today. [husband:] getting cold ou

carl cameron, what else do we know? >>carl: we may find out more by the end of the week. the aides said this is no way he would bow out but today he changed the tune on the conference call. he continued to denight allegations of an affair but said "we have to do an assessment whether this will create too much of a cloud in some people's mind as to whether or not we would be able to support us going forth." and adding this to sexual harassment allegations he denied, it has been a horrible month, telling his aides he would let them know. there are whispers about the possibility of people quitting the cain campaign and speculation of dropping out is rampant. he is assessing and we will know. >>shepard: and it sounds he is canceling events; that right? >>carl: they canceled plants for a media dinner this new york city on sunday night. the guests would have been or included barbara walters and greta and a host of others and is delivering a foreign policy speech in michigan that will be overshadowed by the allegation on the personal life. >>shepard: and romney is down in florid

. >> i'm carl quintanilla. black friday got off to an earlier start this year with a lot of stores opening last night and people are more than happy to take advantage of it. >> maybe in some cases getting too excited considering that pepper spraying incident in los angeles. a fire captain says the suspect did it to gain an advantage over fellow shoppers. we're going to have more on that straight ahead. >> also ahead a rare glimpse of jerry sandusky. he was spotted on thanksgiving day as new questions come out about the role pennsylvania's gurchtor played in the child sex abuse investigation. >>> on a lighter note the day after thanksgiving means you're probably wearing your elastic pants, but you have more than your share of leftovers. coming up, we'll tell you how to turn that boring turkey and stuffing into tasty new meals. >>> let's begin in los angeles where a woman pepper sprayed her fellow black friday shoppers at a walmart. kristen dahlgren is there. good morning. >> reporter: good morning. shoppers here

>>carl: the speech in new hampshire on friday. it was suggested maybe he was under the influence of pain medication or alcohol, and the rick perry will not dignify the suggestions or allegations with a response, and, today, he said he thought he gave a great speech. >> we are into the slogans, man, live free or die, bring it. this is a cool state. come on, live free or die? you know, you got to love that, right? the good news is that little plan i just shared with you doesn't force the granite state to expand your tax footprint. you know what i mean? like 9 percent expansion. >>carl: he is giggling because that is a not so veiled tweak at him contain's 9-9-9 plan. that's rick perry unplugged he gets animated and i have covered him for years and i have seen him act like this in other circumstances and it does not get a bad review from the folks in the room in new hampshire and it got a strong review from the "washington post"'s reporter who said it is vintage rick perry, but, when you put it all together as many have on the web and

today my guest in the studio is carl. the world survey libyan leader muammar gadhafi is dead after nearly a year of violence he was captured. by a furious crowd now the dictator is gone and so is the nato support force the allies around the packing their bags. while the world speculates if the intervention was the right thing or not. should not support the just one side of. premature to withdraw now all of the good that the supporters. so wouldn't it have been reasonable to stay and secure peace in the region for allied force. business to. the president of the nato parliamentary assembly carl. one of the key points of the current major strategies to save guard democracy in the world when libya's gadhafi started to show the rising opposition to the alliance decided to intervene in just a few months because the new regime in the country taking almost no casualties the libya mission is now considered a model of a successful peacekeeping operation but many fear the alliance may soon the role of the world's policeman and start

wednesday my guest in the studio is carl lambert's. the role survey libyan leader muammar gadhafi is dead after nearly a year of violence he was captured and massacred by a furious crowd now the dictator is gone and so is the late show support for the alliance taliban's are packing their bags to fly back while the world speculates if the intervention was the right thing i would not let me say later should not support the just one side of our hardest final good premature to withdraw now when not all of the good that the supporters are. so wouldn't have been reasonable to stay and secure peace in the region towards allied forces has more important business to attend. to the presence of the nato parliamentary assembly carl latter . one of the key points on the current need a strategy democracy in the world when libya's gadhafi started to shelter a rising opposition to the alliance decided to intervene in just a few months the coalition secured a new regime in the country taking almost no casualties believe me a mission is now considered a

they will attend a historic basketball game aboard the aircraft carrier uss carl vinson.gan state and north carolina will play. players practiced on the carrier yesterday. this video shows how crew turned the flight deck into a basketball court. the game is called a celebration of service. president obama will be among the thousands of special guests in the stands. >> and you are also going to see sailors men and women of uss carl vinson executing great teamwork. also in the stands, a lot of wounded warriors who have given a lot of sacrifice to this nation that is what we should all remember, the veterans. >> the carl vinson happens to be the carrier that buried terrorist leader osama bin laden at sea earlier this year. >>> 225 pg&e employees will be laid off. since the san bruno ex-explosion pg&e has split its operations into two units. -- it has hired 90 engineers, mappers for the gas unit the cuts are difficult event by one priority ensuring safety and reliability. the majority of the cuts will cut from the information technology department. >>> an attack at a parking

because he is a professor of middle east studies at the university of haifa and in london we cross the carl charo he's a middle east blogger all right this is cross-eyed i mean we all know my guest can jump in anytime they want but first march it is egypt's revolution progressing well events are changing fast and it's hard to say right now but in egypt has remained unrelenting for more than a week now the country's health ministry says at least forty people have been killed and almost two thousand were injured in clashes between security forces and protesters calling for the end to the military's heavy handed the riot some of the fiercest since the ouster of president hosni mubarak last february has plunged the country into the kind of turmoil that mark that early days of the arab spring unquote vision to get thousands in those in charge in egypt would be well advised to take people's political demands and justify concerns seriously and to act fast to create the right environment for the upcoming elections. but several political parties have already suspended their electoral campaigns well

junior's ceo testified before congress and his spokesperson says customers don't go carl's juner to lose weight z said we like to think our target market is young, hungry guys, 18-34-year-old men, not marketing diet burgers. they're big, very craveable bergers. people want to treat them selfs to. they she said carl's junior has a poster listing nutritional information and for now, wants to avoid expense of changing menus until it has to. so what about you? do you want to know how many calories under fried calamar snismt. >> it's important. go have a health problem. >> i think ignorance is blisms if you just don't know how many calories you're not going beat yourself up. >> this is -- i don't think it's a federal government's responsibility. >> some say it did change their ordering habits. >> i found out how much a mocha frapp was. >> and. >> orders were flying and it seemed popular. >> they're going to go back when you have a lasagne. >> the law is still in limbo, however, they've agreed to provide a brochure listing all nutritional information. restaurants with 20 locations should

carl cameron has a preview. and a study shows doctors are prescribing drugs to kids that are unnecessary. and could be very dangerous. [ male announcer ] when these come together, and these come together, one thing you can depend on is that these will come together. delicious and wholesome. some combinations were just meant to be. tomato soup from campbell's. it's amazing what soup can do. is the pain reliever orthopedic doctors recommend most for arthritis pain, think again. and take aleve. it's the one doctors recommend most for arthritis pain... two pills can last all day. ♪ free gold ! we call that hertz gold plus rewards. you earn free days, free weeks and more fast. that's a plus. upgrade your ride. that's a plus. rewards with no blackout dates so you can redeem anytime. and it's easy to redeem your points online. already a gold member ? just select gold plus rewards in your profile and start rewarding yourself now. just go to hertzgoldplusrewards.com to join. hertz gold plus rewards. journey on. at bank o

you will see your city-sponsored ship, the uss carl vinson. you will see five ships from the united states navy, three ships from the coast guard, and four ships from canada, i believe. [laughter] i had a senior moment. i apologize. i said they keep me young, but i asked my age. i apologize for that. you will hear some loud noises as the ships come by. they are rendering a salute. in my mind, it is a salute to all of you for opening up your city to the navy, marine corps, and coast guard. thank you, ladies and gentlemen, and thank you to our neighbor to the north. [applause] >> thank you. we appreciate that. now i will bring out our announcer, lt. galaman, who will actually narrate the parade of ships for us. >> helena world do you follow that line of people. there's only one way to do that. we have a lieutenant and the coast guard, navy, and from the country of canada. we will begin to narrate this. we're so excited for the official start of today's festivities. there will be in rendering of honors with a 15-gun salute from the aircraft carri

and as carl mentioned, he doesn't.ething very important here is that the prosecutors, henry ruth and the other watergate special prosecutors, did not know as much about watergate as we do now. in the last 30 years there's been so much released that shows now the inconsistency between what the president is saying about his actions regarding the irs, for example, and what we know to be true. in fact, you can go to the wall here in the nixon library and see evidence of him ordering the creation of the enemies list, which as i read today in the testimony he denies ever having done or he says he cannot recall having done. >> it's -- >> pardon me. >> timothy, he's talking about the irs when he said "i never put together a list of people to be audited and be attacked by the irs." he's clearly talking about the irs, as you understand it? >> that's certainly what he was saying. in fact, because they were pointing to a political memorandum that they had access to, the prosecutors had access to. but the prosecutors back then did

they will attend a historic basketball game aboard the aircraft carrier uss carl vinson.gan state and north carolina will play. players practiced on the carrier yesterday. this video shows how crew turned the flight deck into a basketball court. the game is called a celebration of service. president obama will be among the thousands of special guests in the stands. >> and you are also going to see sailors men and women of uss carl vinson executing great teamwork. also in the stands, a lot of wounded warriors who have given a lot of sacrifice to this nation that is what we should all remember, the veterans. >> the carl vinson happens to be the carrier that buried terrorist leader osama bin laden at sea earlier this year. >>> 225 pg&e employees will be laid off. since the san bruno ex-explosion pg&e has split its operations into two units. -- it has hired 90 engineers, mappers for the gas unit the cuts are difficult event by one priority ensuring safety and reliability. the majority of the cuts will cut from the information technology department. >>> an attack at a parking

>>shepard: thank you, carl. and, now, an analysis, professor at george washington university, graduate school of political management and political columnist for "the hill," and worked on several political campaigns and was a media spokesman for the republican national committee. how rough is this? why shouldn't the women be able to tell their side of the story? >>guest: this is torture for herman cain and the campaign. the confidentiality agreement was probably breached by someone at national restaurant association. there have been accusations he has done that, but clearly someone there providing something to "politico" reporter whose did the story so at this point i don't know if it really is fair to say tit for tat but the women should be able to keep their anonymity. but i do think it is fair at this point for everyone to get this out there. the herman cain campaign should do that and national restaurant association should be able to put out the documents that were filed from 12 years ago that gave the basic

and now to carl cameron live with us now. carl, we will start with the latest herman cain accuser. how much influence does gloria gloria allred have? >>carl: this client came to her and asked for her help and the woman worked for the national restaurant association back in the 1990's and attended a trade convention in chicago in 1997 and sat at a table with herman cain and a month later she claimed she lost her jobbing sought help finding new employment and got together with him and then the incident occurred. she did not file a complain and she is not seeking any legal remuneration but wants to do this to make sure that it doesn't happen to any other women. here is a little of what she had to say. >> i'm coming forward to give a face and a voice to those women who cannot or for whatever reason do not wish to come forward. >>carl: the cain campaign said herman cain has never sexually harassed anything and the charges are false and they took a shot at the lawyer saying that she's a well-known democratic donor and something of a self promotor suggesting that this is more about the po

and now we will bring in carl cameron. i don't know, carl ... this is not one thing this is a series of things. it's fund to watch. >>carl: well, not if you are a rick perry supporter or for people in the audience, there were groans of sympathy and laughing because they thought it was cute. for a republican running against president obama with a party that wants to see someone who can take it to the democratic incumbent blowing an easy line from your own policy plan is not a good thing but rick perry has done a complete blitz today going on every morning show available, doing the rounds on cable and he will continue to do so as he attempts to put it behind him. he has an opportunity on saturday with another debate in south carolina and there are lots of do overs available. there are 13 scheduled between now and mid-april. so, lots time and, still, less than seven weeks before the first votes but there will be debates before then to put together a better performance. >>shepard: and the other conservatives in this panel facing all sexual allegatio

cda ho t's birstosug hehief ol polical rresnden carls st caron ve iesef mnes, li iol , anes hasenrl b n folcawingn i e st my fs,m the tay. io an asgoodfter bonolng cstl fhe t. oder repter: h clret. weave had numous ep r:conv hsati witt.th cai we e

this is the carl vinson today. into a polished, floating basketball court with seating for 7,000 where this evening in the shadow of downtown san diego, a first of a kind event. number one university of north carolina plays michigan state, a rematch of the 2009 ncaa championship. that game won by unc. the winner this time, the crew of the carl vinson. >> we all can't believe this is actually happening. >> reporter: ship serviceman jason petty. >> now that we're here the goose bumps are popping up. everybody can't wait for the popcorn to come out. we're excited. >> reporter: excited about the game, excited that basketball fan in chief president barack obama will be on board. navy man and basketball fan petty can't believe his eyes. this flight deck -- >> it's dangerous. >> very dangerous. in wartime this is a place where you can easily die. >> reporter: but today -- >> we get to enjoy ourselves. >> reporter: service officer tammy lariman was first in line for a ticket. are there bets going on on this ship? >> not al

know they won't have a are they likely when using the internet i mean i'm going to morrow says hey carl did you hear my question karl. yes yes i heard your question and i think there's a lot of anxiety in this that's reflected by what david is saying as well and i must congratulate him because he's doing his very best to kind of impersonate the character to an article zionist and he's carrying it out of a very very a very successfully i mean what he's saying is utterly despicable about his procession of people which he threw it off as a comment like that as muslims they are not muslims there are muslims and christians in it and they're fighting for a better future the fact that he and others in israel and maybe in the west would portray it as some kind of decline and going back as a middle ages only to france this sense of anxiety about what they're calling garner but this is a very constructive sense of an arche if we don't like this diet form of politics in these we're writing off hundreds of years of kind of the history of western democracy look at the french revolution look at the m

and egypt know what they want exactly and and are still continue continuing to fight for it ok to carl in looking at western media mainstream media covering these events here i can't help but feel that they face when they're not ready yet they're not ready for they're just out let me go to the car to let me go it's all right so you've got a car in london first here i still get this and this impression that you know that you know look at all these disturbances maybe they should call off the elections because you know they won't have us and election will you please i mean you know they may have going to morrow say carl did you hear my question karl. yes yes i heard your question and i think there's a lot of anxiety in this that's sort of selective by what david is saying as well and i must congratulate him because he's doing his very best to kind of impersonate the character to try not to cause zionists and he's carrying it off very very very successfully i mean why his saying is utterly despicable about his perception of people which he threw it off as a comment like that as muslims the

>>carl: well, he certainly is and going after the iowa caucus. but not entirely clear if he will go in to try to win. it is unclear to many rivals how a local panel could decide to give exemptions to federal immigration laws. and whether it is romney or michele bachmann or other republican rivals they are all attacking gingrich today for supporting what they call "amnesty," but he denies that is the case. the poll shows gingrich is leading in iowa 27 percent to 20 percent over romney. and romney today campaigning in iowa picked up endorsement of south dakota senator thune a well-known social conservative who also took a shot at gingrich today. romney is ramping up the presence in the first caucus state on the eve of thanksgiving and, yet, he still counts himself as something of an underdog. >> i have not seen the details of the proposal but what he described in the debate was providing amnesty for certain individuals and if he wants to describe it in more depth i will look at what the specific proposals are. >> it is an issue people have strong o

carl camerrn has a look at his chances to survive the very public moment, where many decided perry lacked intelligence to be president. president. rick perry appeared on every network e could today trying admittedly embarrassingg agency he'd cuu as part of his says: i stepped in t last night, that's for sure/ therees agencies of govt hat i woulddlike to forget & ccrtainly forgot one last night and it's the dept of energy. it was perhaps the moss awkward fifty three secs in televised presidentiil debate history.perry says: when i get there that are gone. commerce,,education, and the -- what's the third one there? let's see.the third agency of government i would -- i would do away withh education, the..."mos says: "commerce""perry says: can't. the third one, i can't. appears on letterman tonight and will attend saturday's debate in south carolina... newt gingrich again got raves for ridiiuling the media's questions & debate rulesbartiromo says::"wwuld you like to exxlain in simpll speek to the american people what you would do after you reppal the president's health care legislation?"gingri

chief political correspondent carl cameron has details as well as update on the rest of the field. >> bret: >> reporter: she is the first woman to publicly accuse herman cain of sexual harass in the the '90s as a top lobbyist for the national restaurant association in d.c. >> i am coming forward to give a face and voice to women who cannot work for whatever reason do not wish to come forward. >> reporter: sharon bialek introduced as registered republican with lengthy resume. she says she met cain at restaurant convention in chicago in 1997 and lost her job a month later. when she asked cain for help finding new work, she says, he got physical. made no mention of witnesses. >> he suddenly reached over and he put his hands on my leg. under my skirt and reached for my genitals. he also grab my head brought it toward his crotch. i asked him to stop and he did. >> reporter: cain has been accused by four women. well known los angeles attorney and democratic donor gloria allred represents bialek who file nod complaint at time but has sworn affidavits from two friends saying she relayed the i