affirming the planning department ceqa determination. >> okay, this item was continued from our last agenda. we have adam here from supervisor mandelman's office, sponsor of there legislation and also mr. aaron star from the planning department if anyone has any questions or comments. if not, let's go to public comment on this item, mr. clerk. >> thank you. if you have public comment on item 1, please come forward to the lectern. >> good afternoon supervisors. i'm [indiscernible] executive director for the castro community benefit district and here last week and want to come again to reaffirm the cdb board support for this ordinance and this zoning change and we feel it is critically important to bring the castro ncd into alignment with the rest of the neighborhood as far as zoning is concerned and important for the success of the castro theater. >> thank you. >> thank you for sharing your comments. next speaker, please. >> i'm ralph and here to support what andrea said. >> thank you. could you say your name one more time on the mic? >> ralph hibbs. >> thank you so much. anyone else

the state board released the ceqa do you means for the bay delta plan update on the minna river for on september 28. that includes an analysis of the voluntary agreement. the document does not [inaudible] tell me river. that will be cover in the a separate document to be released next year. however it does include a description of the tuolumne river va. large document. it is 5,000 pages. our staff will be reover the next couple months. with comments due to the state board on december 15th we will keep you aware of updates and we have staff working on it not with respect to the tuolumne river agreement but we are mentioned. we are monitoring things close low and when woe are information we'll update you and provide it to you. >> thank you. >> public comment on that. public comment on that. members of the public when wish to make remote comment. do we have any member present to provide comment on 6b? do we have callers with hands raised. >> there are no callers that wish to be recognized. >> public comment on 6b is closed. >> next item >> item 7 consent calendar. are there members of com

and it was based on the ceqa document completed in late 2022 and adopted at this time. that had an increase in housing within the city. and what was in the eir was increase over the next 20 yers of about 100,000 units which lines up with the major's 5,000 per year. changes . so, staff analyzed that. and saw that there was a relatively small increase in the demands. but real increase in demands this is would occur over time in multifamily residential use. based on those 2 issues the planning department asked you to revisit the assessment. and the water supply assessments are legally required to do identify if there is available water for i project. and -- it is a document to be used in the environmental review process this is not an approval of project this . is just approving the water supply assessment to allow the eir project to move forward. we did conclude there is sufficient supply for this project. begin there is uncertainties out there. this project not tip the balance on this. our recommendation to approve the water supply assessment and pass it on to planning.

for base rent of 312 per year and, firm the ceqa determination. >> same house, same call. the resolution is adopted. let's go to roll all for introductions. up to introduce now business is president supervisor peskin. gi will mitt my legislation and first like to adjourn the mote nothing memory of a fierce champion for the south of market community especially the soma youth and families. ken fig ras passed leaving a gaping hole in the philippine open communities of tim was raised in san francisco. attended san francisco schools making him an example of home grown leadership the rec center up to his retirement in 2016. work in the soma and part of the original staff of gene friend rescue center coaching youth baseball and bask. encourages youth to participate in sports. and from health and safety in so manyasm tim fought for funding ensure youth had access to funds for fees and equipment and supporting a few in prosecute sports. >> for the little league field. for actual little league tim fought to fund and organize the soma sluggers securing a dog fence around the will fie

you cannot fast-track from the planning department and get rid of ceqa. we need to think about that and the-- >> thank you for sharing comments. next speaker, please. >> good afternoon chair melgar and supervisors peskin and preston. [indiscernible] rep coalition. rep strongly urge the committee to make significant amendments to focus on equity and if not possible please reject the legislation and work with communities to move forward the implementation actions in the housing element approve bide the board earlier this year referenced in the letter rep sent to committee last week. our communities need a affordable and dignified housing. 57 percent of the housing must be affordable to low and moderate income houses. [indiscernible] we can't continue to fall further behind and need commitment to insure we don't. the rep coalition helps the committee reject the legislation and commit working with communities on new legislation to influence the housing element to further fair housing and center racial and social equity. >> thank you. next speaker, please. >>

the colombo market arch within sidy walton square, 600 sfrunt street as a landmark and affirm the ceqa determination and make the appropriate findings. >> roll call. >> melgar aye. peskin, aye. preston, aye. ronan, aye. safai, aye. stefani, aye. walton, aye. chan, aye. dorsey, aye. engardio, aye. mandelman, aye. there are 11 ayes. >> the ordinance is passed first reading. next item, please. >> item 17, resolution to initiate a amendment to the landmark designation of the san francisco fire station number 44 located at 1298 girard street. >> same house same call, the resolution is adopted. next item. >> item 18, resolution approving authorize a groont of two easements on city property located at 4840 mission street. the first consist of 198 square feet of land at the northwest edge of the parcel for electrical equipment and the second easement of 395 square feet of land at the northern edge of parcel for gas equipment between the city and pacific gas and electric for the purpose of providing electrical and gas utilities for 100 percent affordable housing at no cost for term until pg&e s

. >> yea and from ceqa as well for the new transit project law. okay well, there was a pan dem nic there this has the feel of those giant projects that seems to go on and on and on and on. and so i don't know that it worth a full board update i would like to may be the mta and staff and t astaff and i can have a meeting and -- understand what is going on. i know the mta board has interests and has a committee working on this. >> thank you very much. the dest solution is it freeze don't do anything. you can vote, yes or no tell not be the future. i understand that the in the comments and mta the guys are trying to -- pay you to do what you do. >> its too late they had time to realize when they are doing. weapon iegz transportation. the weaponizations. of different key fields for humanity to proceed. they will die ugly [inaudible] you should not [inaudible]. i don't continuing is good temperature is not. think positive now just for the time i will say hold on. good job hold on. wait. the stupid 2 minutes going to be upsetting soon. no. >> we have re

conditional use authorization on second floor jufirming the planning department determination under ceqa and make findings of consistency with the general plan, the 8 priority policies and planning code and section 101.1 and findings and public necessity convenience and welfare under planning code section 302. >> we are joined by supervisor mandelman. >> thank you, i like to make the meter shorter. we learned last week there was amendment recommended by the planning commission that had not been prepared and we just got that amendment we would appreciate two weeks to be continued on this item . >> we'll continue the item till october 16 because next week is indigenous people day so not meeting. but we still have to take public comment because it is agendized. mr. clerk, let's go to public comment. >> thank you. anyone here in the board chamber who has public comment on item number 3? please come forward to the lectern. it appears we have none, and reaching out now to give a opportunity to our remotely connected callers to indicate they want to speak on the item and i don't see we have spe

you cannot fast-track from the planning department and get rid of ceqa. we need to think about that and the-- >> thank you for sharing comments. next speaker, please. >> good afternoon chair melgar and supervisors peskin and preston. [indiscernible] rep coalition. rep strongly urge the committee to make significant amendments to focus on equity and if not possible please reject the legislation and work with communities to move forward the implementation actions in the housing element approve bide the board earlier this year referenced in the letter rep sent to committee last week. our communities need a affordable and dignified housing. 57 percent of the housing must be affordable to low and moderate income houses. [indiscernible] we can't continue to fall further behind and need commitment to insure we don't. the rep coalition helps the committee reject the legislation and commit working with communities on new legislation to influence the housing element to further fair housing and center racial and social equity. >> thank you. next speaker, please. >>

for base rent of 312 per year and, firm the ceqa determination. >> same house, same call. the resolution is adopted. let's go to roll all for introductions. up to introduce now business is president supervisor peskin. gi will mitt my legislation and first like to adjourn the mote nothing memory of a fierce champion for the south of market community especially the soma youth and families. ken fig ras passed leaving a gaping hole in the philippine open communities of tim was raised in san francisco. attended san francisco schools making him an example of home grown leadership the rec center up to his retirement in 2016. work in the soma and part of the original staff of gene friend rescue center coaching youth baseball and bask. encourages youth to participate in sports. and from health and safety in so manyasm tim fought for funding ensure youth had access to funds for fees and equipment and supporting a few in prosecute sports. >> for the little league field. for actual little league tim fought to fund and organize the soma sluggers securing a dog fence around the will fie

eric brooks, our city san francisco and san francisco ceqa defenders. one minute under all these different changes and dynamics happening is kind of unacceptable, but we'll go with it. i heard loud and clear from every single neighborhood group, environmental group, eastern neighborhoods groups, you name it, the people i'm working on this coalition in coordination for none of them want you to amend this legislation. they want you to scrap it, gut it, and do substitution that is written by supervisors who actually give a damn about their constituents, not the mayor office. with all the new laws coming down from the state, we can int afford to center the mayor to be the driver of the process and know it is a tough election year but need the supervisors to do the work. that is why we elected you. >> thank you. let's have public comment from the other microphone now. >> good afternoon. i like to address supervisor mandelman. he was trying to amend the mayor's housing legislation to exempt rent controlled homes in two plus unit buildings, but this amendments

landmark buildings from use size limitation and night time entertainment on the second floor and ceqa and make appropriate findings. roll call? item 9. supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor engardio. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor supervisor peskin. >> no. >> and supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> there are 9 aye's and one no with spries supervisor peskin in decent. >> ordinance is passed >> next item. >> item 10 an ordinance to amend the administrative code remove the authorization for carbrevolving funds and reduce the max amount of the cash revoling fund for the port. >> supervisor safai. >> aye >> supervisor stefani. >> air >> supervisor walton. >> aye >> supervisor chan >> aye >> supervisor dorsey. >> ayech >> supervisor engardio. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor supervisor peskin. >> aye. and supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> there are 10 aye's. >> the ordinances are pa

condo requirements using residentialing density exemption in rh districts and affirming the planning ceqa findings public necessity voens and welfare urined code 302 and consistency with the yes or no plan in the 8 priority policies. >> thank you. that was a mouthful. and mouthful because this is a very complicated piece of legislation. and so i would like to update folks of what is going on with this legislation and what i suggest that we do today. last time we met i introduced a bunch of the amendments that were at designed to preserve the special use district on the west side that we all passed unanimously. that stroll line the conduction of 4 plex in our sud. begin legislation, there is a bunch. technical discrepancy about stuff that really don't much to do with the intent of both legislations. so this is stuff around you know the 317 criteria. setbacks, percentage of open pace. the configuration of that open space. and the lot area width. front setback. and group housing well is technical intreps and agree going forward we want as much clarity in the code as possible. in order to do

priority policies of planning code, section 101.1; adopting california environmental quality act (ceqa) findings; and to authorize the director of property to enter into amendments or modifications to the lease that do not materially increase the obligations or liabilities to the city and are necessary to effectuate the purposes of the lease or this resolution. members who joined remotely and wish to comment, press star 3 to enter the speaker line. a prompt indicate you raised your hand and when system indicateess you have been unmuted there is your signal to begin your comments. madam chair. >> thank you. we have claudia from real estate. >> good morning thank you chair chan and supervisor mandelman. the proposed resolution approves the lease of city land, little more then 4,000 square feet created when alemany boulevard was widened and sidewalk added. the lease is to our planet recycling. one of the few small business recycling centers in the city and used for parking and storage. in support of the center adjacent on the caltrans property. our planet recycling initially started uses

require significant ceqa and long environmental permitting process. so -- it is xivens. over 200 million dollars. >> the pipes the -- the as they are now no long are there they would go down? >> this it is they come over >> water would not flow through them but they are historical significance they may stay. would be there for looks? if that is how we proceed it new >> and so when you think of 2 huh must have been really. it is aloft. the way we do things that seems like it is doable. if we look at going for 100 years or a lot of things that better take into consideration with that 200 million i would assume? might be a better way to go and longer >> yes, our staff agrees they analyze third degree and that is their preferred option. operation maintenance and longevity of a shaft and i tunnel. we are early. looking how to reduce the risk of failure while we plan this project in form it takes. we are trying to see if there is a lower cost pipeline alternative. nought tunnel and shaft other alternative. >> question sns >> i noticed with the moccasin powerhouse with issues a

for base rent of 312 per year and, firm the ceqa determination. >> same house, same call. the resolution is adopted. let's go to roll all for introductions. up to introduce now business is president supervisor peskin. gi will mitt my legislation and first like to adjourn the mote nothing memory of a fierce champion for the south of market community especially the soma youth and families. ken fig ras passed leaving a gaping hole in the philippine open communities of tim was raised in san francisco. attended san francisco schools making him an example of home grown leadership the rec center up to his retirement in 2016. work in the soma and part of the original staff of gene friend rescue center coaching youth baseball and bask. encourages youth to participate in sports. and from health and safety in so manyasm tim fought for funding ensure youth had access to funds for fees and equipment and supporting a few in prosecute sports. >> for the little league field. for actual little league tim fought to fund and organize the soma sluggers securing a dog fence around the will fie

. >> yea and from ceqa as well for the new transit project law. okay well, there was a pan dem nic there this has the feel of those giant projects that seems to go on and on and on and on. and so i don't know that it worth a full board update i would like to may be the mta and staff and t astaff and i can have a meeting and -- understand what is going on. i know the mta board has interests and has a committee working on this. >> thank you very much. the dest solution is it freeze don't do anything. you can vote, yes or no tell not be the future. i understand that the in the comments and mta the guys are trying to -- pay you to do what you do. >> its too late they had time to realize when they are doing. weapon iegz transportation. the weaponizations. of different key fields for humanity to proceed. they will die ugly [inaudible] you should not [inaudible]. i don't continuing is good temperature is not. think positive now just for the time i will say hold on. good job hold on. wait. the stupid 2 minutes going to be upsetting soon. no. >> we have re

from nipa. >> yea and from ceqa as well for the new transit project law.y well, there was a pan dem nic there this has the feel of those giant projects that seems to go on and on and on and on. and so i don't know that it worth a full board update i would like to may be the mta and staff and t astaff and i can have a meeting and -- understand what is going on. i know the mta board has interests and has a committee working on this. >> thank you very much. the dest solution is it freeze don't do anything. you can vote, yes or no tell not be the future. i understand that the in the comments and mta the guys are trying to -- pay you to do what you do. >> its too late they had time to realize when they are doing. weapon iegz transportation. the weaponizations. of different key fields for humanity to proceed. they will die ugly [inaudible] you should not [inaudible]. i don't continuing is good temperature is not. think positive now just for the time i will say hold on. good job hold on. wait. the stupid 2 minutes going to be upsetting soon. no. >> we have remote

satisfaction of certain conditions and to be readjusted to the then fair market base rent and affirm the ceqa determination and the appropriate findings. >> same house, same call, the resolution is adopted. madam clerk please read item 22-24 together? >> item 22-24 are 3 resolution that authorize grants for recreation and park department. 22 authorizing a $250 thousand inkind grant from the san francisco parks alliance for design and construction for the maintenance and upgrades to the dahlia dell hillside garden. 23, authorize $3.7 million san francisco bay water quality improvement fund grant from the united states environmental protection agency for the india basin shoreline park project for term through december 31, 2026 with additional authorization to enter into the associated grant agreement. item 24, authorizes a $300 thousand inkind grant from the stern grove festival association for the design and construction of a donor recognition instillation for the project term. >> same house, same call, the resolutions are adopted. next item, please. >> item 25 resolution to approve the first

once the eir is complete return to commission for adoption of ceqa and are project approval. i like to request the commission to direct staff to proceed with environmental review for the marina improvement and remediation project. thank you for your time and attention on this complex project. my team and i had happy to respond to questions you may have. >> thank you monica. ment before i move to public comment, any clarifying questions or statements you want to make? >> we rill move to public comment on item 8. for those on the webex you can dial star 3 to raise your hand. i will call three names at a time. when i call your name if you can please stand and speak in that order as much as can pay attention to what i'm saying and you can wait over here or there but be prepared. i'll call groups of 3. as reminder, please stick to 2 minutes. i'll let you finish your sentence, but i have word that president anderson is able to be rude on my behalf. look at the clock that will give you a sense of your timing. i will start with patricia and are then stephanie and then aaron. i double

getting ceqa determination and completing transactions within 20 1/2 months is pretty aggressive.ressive. >> i guess we'll see with term sheets and see how you are going. that's fast. >> it is fast and what we are hearing from our planning and colleagues, is that they are able to process things more quickly than usual, but you are right. . >> thank you for the report. this program has been fast tracked and i hope to see it on the ground soon. i'm agreeing with most of the terms but just wondering why we would possibly decrease the deposit from $100,000 and wave the additional fees. . >> the extension fees? >> yes. >> it's really the project and the work flow on this project. i think initially there is not going to be a big outlet on the port's part. we may not need $100,000 upfront. that's all it has to do with in the beginning of the process that we don't expect there is going to be a lot of port costs, so we didn't think we would need an initial deposit of $100,000. but it doesn't raise their obligation to expect from the port until we finish. >> why would we wait? >> i think it

from nipa. >> yea and from ceqa as well for the new transit project law. okay well, there was a pan dem nic there this has the feel of those giant projects that seems to go on and on and on and on. and so i don't know that it worth a full board update i would like to may be the mta and staff and t astaff and i can have a meeting and -- understand what is going on. i know the mta board has interests and has a committee working on this. >> thank you very much. the dest solution is it freeze don't do anything. you can vote, yes or no tell not be the future. i understand that the in the comments and mta the guys are trying to -- pay you to do what you do. >> its too late they had time to realize when they are doing. weapon iegz transportation. the weaponizations. of different key fields for humanity to proceed. they will die ugly [inaudible] you should not [inaudible]. i don't continuing is good temperature is not. think positive now just for the time i will say hold on. good job hold on. wait. the stupid 2 minutes going to be upsetting soon. no. >> we have re

building code for three or four stories after 1988 with the inspection respect under the california ceqa how will this report (clearing throat) how that ordinance is amended. >> so that he ordinance refers to the existing facade program. >> right. >> that primarily looking at with the is part of a ordinance it is mentioned in there. but no emphasis no guidelines on though to look at that. >> so, i mean, it seems like we should do leveraging it type of what you said owners ignore the requests; right? this ordinance is on for amendment wearing looking at being constructed after 1988 humble opportunity to review specialist finding from the report that requires. >> absolutely. >> the whole thing from those inspections. >> that's correct, yes we're going to take all of that finding from this thing and incorporate into that that new or revised building code section. >> what are some of the suggestions being made from this report? >> and yeah. >> (multiple voices). >> yeah, so the recommendations again tofu can't avoid using staged glass to look at the installation of 1257b8d glass no contact w

historic preservation commission approved the relocation on the project categorical exemption for ceqa, and the 16th of november, we got approval of the certificate of appropriateness for the relocation of the [indiscernible] for the project. march 21, 2023 the state grant for $1.5 million was executed and june 2023 we requested a 12 month extension from the state. august 2023 the state confirmed no objections to the time extension. so, as of now, which is june 2023, we public works assembled a team of as-needed consultant to continue to advance the project and the first phase with the program validation phase based on the design from the previous design from the friends of harvey milk plaza, august 2023 a program validation report issued. october 2023, the as-needed consultants were authorized to proceed advancing design. and this is projected timeline when we will move forward and how we move forward with design. between march 2024 and june 2024 we would have 90 percent of the construction documents and june 2024 to september 2024 would have pricing and the permit package for the pro

entertainment with conditional use authorization on the second floor to affirm the planning department's ceqa determination and make the appropriate findings. >> roll call. >> on item 24-ronan, aye. safai, aye. stefani, aye walton, aye. chan, aye. dorsey, aye. engardio, aye. mandelman, aye. melgar, aye. peskin, no. preston, aye. there are 10 ayes and 1 no with supervisor peskin voting no. >> the ordinance passed first reading. let's go to roll call for introductions. >> first member up to introduce new business, supervisor ronan. submit. thank you. supervisor safai, submit. stefani, submit. thank you. supervisor walton, submit. thank you. supervisor chan, submit. thank you. supervisor dorsey, submit. thank you. supervisor engardio, submit. thank you. supervisor mandelman. >> sorry. [laughter] but i will be brief. earlier today i asked the mayor about implementation of sb43 and i do believe that the challenge we will experience with implementation of sb43 is we just don't have the right placements for folks with severe mental illness. there is a lot of conversation in this meeting even about b