and in the chornovol case, the executors and the organizer are established. well, she is adze pukach, that's for sure, this is the organizer. that is, the customer is not kuchma. the customer has my deep conviction. the federal service of russia, the fsb, well, if only because in order to bind kuchma, yes, kuchma, who declared that ukraine should join nato, literally two months later got this murder, which was hanged on him, yes, he is guilty of creating a regime in which his opponents or critics were persecuted by the power vertical, but at least no ... impressions were obtained anywhere that he ordered him killed, that he spoke ill of him under various procorative situations, right? but i apologize, major melnychenko eventually appeared in moscow, on red square, and demanded from kuchma from kupny, for his tapes and received them several million dollars, and refused to come, the russians paid him for these no ukrainians, and when after the victorious maidan his. .. we invited him to testify, he categorically refused and only appeared in yanukovych's ukraine

ukraine there were many, if you take it, i don't know if it is possible to qualify the death of chornovolmpletely clear whether it was a murder or not, you know it for sure, i am sure that... you all everyone saw these cases, and you know the details of these cases, hetman, chornovol, the same yury kravchenko, and gongadze, and sheremet, and varankov, this former member of the state duma, that is, we seem to have some executors, and all executors receive either terms, and the version with sheremet had a history when the executors were apparently not those, or there was not enough evidence. in regard to that, antonenko and duke kuzmenko were hanged all this, and there is no evidence that they did it, why do we always have a problem with the investigation of political murders? well, political murders are one of the most difficult, for the reason that a politician always has many enemies, dozens of versions of a possible customer immediately arise, and secondly, as a rule , such murders are generously financed. and is preparing well if we are dealing with the psb, and i am personally convinc

i am sure that you have seen all these cases and you know them. details of these cases, hetman, chornovol, the same yury kravchenko, and gongadze, and sheremet, and varaninkov, this former deputy. in the version with sheremet, there was a story when the performers turned out to be probably not those, or there was not enough evidence that all this was hanged on antonenko, on duke kuzmenko, and there is no evidence that they did it, why do we always have a problem with the investigation of political murders, well, political murders. are one of the most difficult for the reason that a politician always has many enemies, dozens of versions of a possible customer arise instantly, and secondly, as a rule, such murders are generously financed and well prepared. if we are dealing with the fsb, and i am personally convinced that the gangadze case, the shermet case, the voronenkov case, the i can't remember now, the journalist was killed in kherson before the war. er, and the matter, fayon, this, this is one and the same kidney, one, the murder bureau, which is located in moscow, in the premises of

we tell through the fates of our heroes, tyra, ratushny, tetyana chornovol and many hundreds of thousands of other heroes who are now defending ukraine and who came out for the independence of ukraine and our european elections, starting from the maidan. work on creation documentary tape lasted more than a year. oleg garenchar, who lives and works in the united states of america, became the director and screenwriter of the film. the picture consists of archival footage taken from 2013 to 2023. the chronicle must be written. this is very important because it is not just about memory. it's about stories about people. stories about events that we already have to be aware of, and such films, they help ukrainians, and i hope, viewers abroad, to understand what is happening to us and what is happening around us. the creation of the film was made possible thanks to the non-governmental organization all-ukrainian democratic forum with the support of yousite, a media program in ukraine. which is carried out by the international organization internews and the exchange development fund of the us emb

tyra, tatyana chornovol and roman, they are undoubtedly heroes, they are undoubtedly those people whorificed for their tribe... and the novel also sacrificed life. the film tells about triumphs and defeats, challenges and victories, achievements and transformations that happened to each of us during these 10 years. there are all the events, starting from the maidan and ending with the current state of the war, and the main life of these three people, the life and death of one of them, the real heroes of ukraine. it's on the one hand, yes... historical just retelling the events and on the other hand very emotional because these events are retold through people's lives, i think that's the key to understanding. work on the preparation of such a large-scale documentary work lasted almost a year. in the end, the film will be released in two versions: in ukrainian and in english, because, as the creators emphasize, the main goal is to reach the foreign audience and show the path that ukraine and... ukrainians have overcome during this decade. the more films there are about the war in ukrain

ukraine, activist roman town hall we tell through the fates of our heroes, tyra, ratushny, tetyana chornovol many hundreds of thousands of other heroes who are now defending ukraine and who stood up for the independence of ukraine and for our european elections, starting with the maidan. the work on the creation of the documentary lasted over a year, by the director and screenwriter. the film was directed by oleg garenchar, who lives and works in the united states of america. the picture consists of archival footage taken from 2013 to 2023. the chronicle must be written, it is very important, because it is not only about memory, it is about stories about people, stories about events that are already happening. we have to realize that such films help ukrainians as well, and i hope there will be viewers abroad, to realize what is happening to us and what is happening around us. the creation of the film was made possible thanks to the public organization all-ukrainian democratic forum with the support of yousite, a media program in ukraine, which is implemented by the international organization

there are a lot of them. in 30 years, one can list vadym boyko, and georgy gongadze, and vyacheslav chornovol, many of these there were murders, as a rule, some executors answered, and sometimes they did not answer, but we never saw the masterminds on the dock, well, given the fact that we now have a person involved in the case, in relation to whom there are quite a few. evidence, to get closer to the suspicion, i think that there is probably some kind of trail behind him, or there is none, and which will make it clear to us whether to answer sergey, you say yes or no, to the question of whether this will be case number two regarding shremet, let me remind you, which ended in nothing, nothing, that is, everyone whom they suspected and loudly announced at press conferences, well, with due to the lack of evidence base, he is now at large and is not. criminals, even more military, volunteers, doctors, continue to protect the country, will this be story number two, like sheremet, let's see, i hope not, sergey, thank you, yanina, yanina sokolova, andriy yanitsky were guests of our program today, t

paramother yulia taira paevska, also the heroes of this film are activist and journalist tetyana chornovol, as well as mother of roman ratoshny, svitlana povalyaeva, public activist and writer. in particular, 10 years are revealed through the fates of these four heroes. that ukraine went through in the struggle for its independence, it is told here from the beginning of the revolution of dignity to the first phases of the full-scale russian invasion of ukraine. the tape was created by espresso tv channel with the support of internews network and the us embassy in ukraine. i also want to note that this film started to be created last year, in particular, by the express tv channel. i decided in this way, so to speak, to commemorate 10 years since the beginning of creation, and i want to point out that this is a documentary drama that was created from archival materials. archive videos, and in general, the atmosphere at the film premiere in ternopil is quite interesting, the guests are already listening to the presentation of this film, and the pre-premiere screening is about to begin. i woul

mother, poet and activist svitlana povalyaeva, journalist, politician and military officer tetyana chornovoldic yuliya paevska with the call sign taira. for all of us with you, these 10 years were here, we all lived through these events, we remember them well, we know them well, we passed them through ourselves, and for the western audience, many facts of this film will be new. ago the main purpose of this film is to show this context, what happened during these 10 years, and why the russians are killing ukrainians today. in the tape, the destinies of the heroes are intertwined with key events in the recent history of ukraine, all in order to remind and imprint in the viewers' memory the difficult lessons of the past. every revolution, especially the revolution of dignity, is a transformation, a transformation of people, a transformation. society in general. history is forced to repeat itself because no one listens to it. when will we constantly remind people and explain everything cause and effect connections, i am sure, then there will be much less chance of war in the future. oleg garench

, then, for example, there are almost none of them of solved murders, the story of the murder of chornovol it has not been revealed, the story of heitman's murder has not been revealed, the story of the murder of anatoly yermak, a colonel by his brother, hryhoriy melchenko, hryhoriy amelchenko, an anti-corruption officer, who, by the way, was just engaged in the sale of ukrainian arsenals, has also not been revealed. i want to remind you that there was a history of political murders in the era of independence, apparently, it began with the murder of journalist vadym boyk, who was simply doused with gasoline in his apartment, that is, you can say that where there is politics, there is very low the disclosure of the murders, uh, now, if we talk about, well... lines of conflict that can be exploited by the enemy, then on the surface , iryna farion's conflict with the izovites is quite well-known, which she did not like, that the azovites do not always speak refined literary ukrainian, and sometimes they even use profanity, because it helps better in battles than literary language, it turns ou

the story of chornovol's murder has not been revealed.ry of the murder heitman has not been revealed, the story of the murder of anatoly yermak, a colonel by his brother, uh, hryhoriy melchenko, hryhoriy melchenko, uh, an anti-corruption officer, who, by the way, was just engaged in the sale of ukrainian arsenals, has also not been revealed, i want to remind you that it was in general is the history of political... murders of her era independently.

dozens of murders of various kinds, including journalists. including public figures, the murder of chornovolthis is, if we talk like this, very retrospectively, if we talk about very ancient times, even if we take the times there, starting from in 2014, after the revolution of dignity, i apologize, even then, there were a huge number of questions for law enforcement agencies, and the last one was the murder of sheremet, accusations of yes, antonenko, accusations of dugars, accusations of others, yes, yes, people who, which then simply fell apart , and i understand you, i understand why people don't believe, why people, even when it comes out... starts talking, a lot of very people just don't believe it, and even if it's true, even if it's true, even if law enforcement has done a huge work, i believe that specifically in in this case with the murder of iryna farion , the law enforcement officers did a great job, uh, well, i believe that they did, but in this case , i don't think that they didn't do anything there, but just this mistrust, it is, unfortunately... so far until now, the result th

leader of integral nationalism, the murder of volodymyr ivasyuk for songs, the murder of vyacheslav chornovol, for the movement that he wanted to revive and put as one of the main opposition alternatives to the government, and the murder of mrs. iryna farion for her word and for language, what is the goal, what is the goal... to divide ukrainian society on the basis of language is the easiest thesis and antithesis that was thrown by russia, the russian special services before and is being thrown now, and it was obvious to me the first minutes when i learned about it, shocking ... knew about the fact that the russian federation is obviously behind this, that the customer, obviously the customer must be looked for there, that the trace of this young guy was found, our ukrainian law enforcement agencies, the mbs and the sbu, we must give credit to them, that in such a way, let's say yes, a short enough time, and we hope, as the lawyer said, that this should be an impartial investigation. in these questions, both a quick and a quick investigation, which would give the maximum objective answer, th

in my acceptance speech, i it was not for nothing that vyacheslav chornovol mentioned roman's sureties, because the soviet system of crooked justice or justice operated in the same way as the ukrainian one operates today. i have the impression that... the current customers of this court lived 70 years ago. judge haradin does not allow the lawyers to speak and rebuffs them, but despite this, the lawyers themselves are trying to defend roman chervinsky, i suggest you listen to andriy yosypov, a lawyer. literally in a few hours, as soon as chervinsky was released, this kind of request for the application of precautionary measure. this is actually an indicator of the fact that customers are afraid of this matter. chervinskyi's words, that the clients of this case are afraid that chervinskyi could move freely and talk about the fact of his persecution and about his own clients, that's the story. attempts to close the mouth, i apologize for such wording, maybe for some reason it is unacceptable for a lawyer, but it depends on emotions. today , they are trying to change roman chervinskyi's pr

were a lot of them in 30 years, you can also list vadym boyko, and georgy ganaadze, and vyacheslav chornovolwere many of these murders, as a rule, some executors were responsible, and sometimes they were not, but we never put the customers on the dock... well, given that we have now there is a person involved in the case, regarding whom there is a lot of evidence, in order to... get closer to the suspicion, i think that behind him there is probably a trail, some kind, or there is none, which will let us understand whether to answer to serhiy, whether you say yes or not, to the question of whether this will be case number two regarding shremet, i will remind you that it ended in nothing, nothing, that is, everyone who they suspected and loudly announced at press conferences, well, given the lack of evidence base, they are now at large and are not criminals, but rather military volunteers. doctors continue to protect the country, will this be story number two like sheremet? let's see, i hope not, serhiy. thank you, yanina. yanina sokolova, andriy yanitskyi were guests of our program today. i t

kovalyaeva, journalist, politician and military officer tetyana chornovol and paramedic yuliya paevska, with the call sign taira. for all of us with you, these 10 years, they were here, we all lived through these events, we remember them well, we know them well, we passed them through us, and for the western audience many facts of this film will be new, so the main purpose of this of the film, it is precisely to show this context so that... in the film, the fates of the characters are intertwined with key events of the recent history of ukraine, all in order to remind and imprint in the memory of the audience the difficult lessons of the past. every revolution, especially the revolution of dignity, is a transformation, transformation of people, transformation of society, in general. history is forced to repeat itself because no one listens to it. when will we be constantly. to remind people and explain all cause-and-effect relationships, i am sure, then the chances of war will be much less in the future. oleg garenchar, who lives and works in the usa, became the director and screenwrit

mother, poet and activist svitlana povalyaeva, journalist, politician and military officer tetyana chornovol and paramedic yuliya paevska, nicknamed tyra. for all of us with you , these 10 years were here, we all experienced these events, we are good. we remember them, we know well, we passed them through ourselves, and for the western audience many facts of this film will be new, so the main purpose of this film is precisely to show this context, what happened during these ten years and why the russians are killing today ukrainians in the story, the destinies of the heroes are intertwined with key events recent history of ukraine. all in order to remind and imprint in the memory of the audience your. lessons of the past, every revolution, especially the revolution of dignity, is a transformation, transformation of people, transformation of society, in general. history is forced to repeat itself because no one listens to it. if we constantly remind people and explain all cause-and-effect relationships, i am sure, then the chances of war in the future will be much less. oleg garenchar, who li

dozens of murders of various kinds, including journalists, including public figures, the murder of chornovolll, that's it, to say the least retrospectively, if we talk about very old times, even... if you take the times there, starting from 2014, after the revolution of dignity, i'm sorry, but even then, there were a huge number of questions for law enforcement agencies, and the latest is the murder of sheremet, the accusations, yes, antonenko, the accusations of dugar, the accusations of others, yes, yes, people who, which then simply fell apart, and i understand you, i understand why people do not trust... why people, even when a law enforcement officer comes out, starts talking, a lot of people just don't trust it, and even if it's true, even if it's true, even if the law enforcement officers did a great job, i believe that in this particular case with the murder of iryna farion , the law enforcement officers did a great job, uh, well, i believe that in this case they didn't it seems that they did nothing there. but simply this mistrust, it, unfortunately, still, still does, does the resu

the story of chornovol's murder has not been revealed. the story of heitman's murder has not been revealed. the story of the murder of anatoly yermak, the colonel of the brothers, hryhoriy melchenko, hryhoriy melchenko, an anti-corruption officer, who, by the way, was just engaged in the sale of ukrainian arsenals, has also not been revealed, i want to remind you that it was in general, it is the story of political murders of the independent era. it probably started with the murder of journalist vadym boyk, who was simply doused with gasoline in his apartment, that is , it can be said that where there is politics, there is a very low disclosure of murders, er, now, if we talk about conflict lines that may be, to be exploited by the enemy, then... on the surface, the conflict of iryna farion with the azov people is quite well-known, which she did not like, that the azov people do not always speak refined literary ukrainian, and sometimes even use profanity, because in in battles, it helps better than literary language, it turns out, er, th

of them over the past 30 years, you can list vadym boyk, georgy ganaadze, and... um, vyacheslav chornovolthere were many of these murders, as a rule, some perpetrators were responsible, and sometimes they were not , but we never saw the customers on the bench... those present, well , given the fact that we currently have a person involved in the case, regarding whom there is a lot of evidence to get closer to the suspicion, and i think that there is probably a trail behind him , some, or there is none, but which will let us understand whether to answer sergey, whether you say yes or not, to the question of whether this will be case number two regarding shremet, let me remind you that it will end... with nothing, nothing, that is, everyone whom they suspected and loudly announced at press conferences, well, given the lack of evidence bases are now at large and are not criminals, because more military, volunteers, doctors, continue to protect the country, will this be story number two like sheremet, let's see, i hope not, sergey, thank you, yanina, yanina sokolova, andriy yanitskyi, were gu

political, there were a lot of them in 30 years . and vadym boyko, and georgy ganadze, and vyacheslav chornovolthere were many of these murders, as a rule, some executors were responsible, and sometimes they were not, but we never saw the orderers on the bench, well , given the fact that we have now there is a person involved in the case, regarding whom there is a lot to...

said certain things that the national democrats liked, he was on good terms even with vyacheslav chornovol and by the way, chornovola street appeared in odessa a long time ago, but on the other hand, he wanted to play along with this savka pro-russian electorate , yes, that's why a tarpan was put up in memory of kateryna at the expense of a completely pro-russian figure, despite the protests of ukrainians, that is, it was a method of literally political struggle, a method of feeding one's electorate, since the situation has changed, then, well, i would say that they gradually remind me of those people who, if we, the ukrainian public, remind me of such, you know, those who want to be cleansed. well taken away, well, why aren’t you satisfied yet, well, then keep something else, that is, they have a very hard time giving up their treasures, so to speak, and why is it so hard for them to say goodbye to it after it already becomes, as they say, the information is better known, i am not talking about odesa, for example, but i will move to podilsk, so one... a known looter, a bandit who worked a

her with some contract and political murders, it is enough to remember the murder of vyacheslav chornovolhow many years have passed, that's the same the case is actually hanging, can't it be that the same thing will happen now with this one, with this one, with the murder of irina farion, i'm sure. i really believe in that, i would really like to, let's say, believe that law enforcement agencies must find and punish the perpetrator of the crime, and the ukrainian authorities must recognize the mastermind of this crime, the russian federation, because it was not a shot to the temple of iryna farion, it was not a shot to the temple of the ukrainian language, it is a shot to the temple of ukrainian statehood, because comrade putin really wanted to show himself as an old kgbist. the whole world, that his personal enemies, and just as he was a personal enemy, i knew very well, i was friends with my step-sister, freedom fighter irina farion, with whom we were on the maidan and on many anti-yanukovych rallies, gatherings, meetings, and therefore for her it was a personal enemy, as well as for hi