so the sound will come and go from the court of. will come and go from the court of appeal. course not there and this is a video link. the three seniorjudges are sitting. you will remember mr calocane was sentenced injanuary. i think the sound is back and they have established mr calocane can hear what is going on in the court. thank you. we are handing down our judgment in writing, the written judgment in writing, the written judgment is accompanied by a written press summary. both documents will be available at the end of this hearing. we will now deliver, thank you, a short oral summary of the reasons for and our decision. the oral summary does not form part of ourjudgment, nor is it in substitution for it. this reference by the solicitor general concerns the sentence imposed on the offender valdo calocane on the 24th of january 2024 at nottingham crown court for three counts of manslaughter by reason of diminished responsibility and three counts of attempted murder, to which offences the offender earlier pleaded guilty. thejudge, mrjustice turner, sentenced the offender

allowed gorbasenko to participate in the competition for a position in the northern commercial court of appeale he... is preparing for another interview, the members of the supreme court of appeals have apparently already prepared questions for him about unjust decisions with signs of raiding and about sky-high real estate and probably fictitious divorces, as well as connections: with his father, who pays taxes in the occupied crimea and, according to the peacekeeper, could be involved in the military aggression of the russian federation against ukraine. so, in order to justify himself, gorbasenko filed several complaints to the supreme council of justice and the prosecutor general's office about alleged interference in his judicial activities. vrp conducted an inspection and announced the decision last week. according to the results of the review of the report of the judge of the commercial court of the kyiv region, gorbasenko, no facts were found to have intervened. in their activities as judges, as well as actions that pose a threat to the independence of judges and the authority of justice

what the court of appeal has to decide is whether the trialjudge was right in coming to that conclusionould have effectively tweaked the sentence to add the possibility of caldocane going to prison despite the evidential concerns that the trial judge the evidential concerns that the trialjudge had that it could be detrimental. the key thing for the families in this is the evidence. before the prosecution and sentencing, calocane, while being severely unwell, he had taken some substantial planning steps in relation to carrying out the killings and they argue that those steps showed he did not necessarily act under the mental effect the time of the killings, and therefore there is an element of punishment which needs to be added to his incarceration, his detention at the moment. i think the bigger point is what the families really want is not necessarily this outcome to go their way. of course they would like to see it go their way but what they really want is a public inquiry because they feel calocane's management and the legal issues around that and how he has been prosecuted and sente

it is very difficult for a sentence in a criminal court to be overturned by the court of appeal. al having a look at the evidence for itself and coming to a different conclusion. the court has to be satisfied that the judge fell into, in the jargon, gross error, that somehow thejudge missed in the jargon, gross error, that somehow the judge missed something that was critical to the case. during the ruling this morning, which was effectively a summary of what is going to be quite a long judgment, lady chiefjustice made very clear that when the trialjudge in nottingham looked at the evidence of what happened on that appalling day lastjune, it was apparent to thejudge that, from day lastjune, it was apparent to the judge that, from the evidence that was presented to him in court, and he can only go on the evidence before him in court, that there was no dispute that valdo calocane had acted in the midst of an acute episode of psychosis, brought on by paranoid schizophrenia, that he was effectively out of control of his own actions, and therefore, in the circumstances the court had no

court of appeal or the cc rc. ., ., ~ ., ., ., , cc rc. page two of this document. scroll down. this i cc rc. look at page two of this document. scroll down. this isi cc rc. look at page two of this - document. scroll down. this is your thoughts _ document. scroll down. this is your thoughts on — document. scroll down. this is your thoughts on the proposal is at the 6th of— thoughts on the proposal is at the 6th ofjuly. thoughts on the proposal is at the 6th ofjul . . thoughts on the proposal is at the 6th ofjuly. yes. this is a direct answer to _ 6th ofjuly. yes. this is a direct answer to the _ 6th ofjuly. fies this is a direct answer to the chairman's questioned, isn't it— answer to the chairman's questioned, isn't it the _ answer to the chairman's questioned, isn't it the case that second sight were _ isn't it the case that second sight were to _ isn't it the case that second sight were to play no part going forwards. there _ were to play no part going forwards. there were — were to play no part going forwards. there were conversations

so, blayne, what can you tell us about the move by the georgia court of appeals this morning? >> well, jose, i think the bottom line of this is that this kind of long almost side show that has been taking over the fulton county trial for the better part of the first half of the year is not over. it is now just entering round two. so what we learned is that the georgia court of appeals has agreed to hear an appeal on this. you'll remember, of course, just a reminder to our viewers, this was the issue we were talking about in fulton county, fulton county district attorney fani willis there on the screen was accused of financially benefiting from a personal relationship which she was having with her then special prosecutor nathan wade, who you see walking into the courtroom right there. well, at the end of -- in the middle of last month, basically, the judge rules that fani willis could stay on the case. she could continue her prosecution of the former president and his co-defendants, but nathan wade had to go. he resigned that very same day and many people said this is the end of

thus, without further clarification, the members of the supreme court of appeals decided that the candidateble for the position of judge and recommended her to the lyubashiv district court of the odesa region. another quick interview with no extras issues, the members of the committee of the supreme court conducted with yulia bulanova, a candidate for the position of judge of the shevchenkiv district court of kyiv. according to the anti-corruption center. she is the daughter of the rector of the zaporizhia national university and people's deputy of the eighth convocation mykola frolov. any court is a very responsible, accountable court. activists have many questions about bulanova's property, for example, in 2022, her brother, who works as a lawyer, gave her an apartment in kyiv with an area of ​​93.5 square meters. the market value of the property, according to the experts of the countermeasures center corruption - more than uah 8 million. in the declaration , 100 uah is indicated. the members of the commission, on the other hand , had no questions about the brother's ability to earn money

thus, without further clarification, the members of the supreme court of appeals decided that the candidate suitable for the position of judge and recommended her to the lyubashiv district court of the odesa region. one more quick interview without additional questions, the members of the ccc conducted with the candidate for the position of judge shevchenkivskyi kyiv district court, yulia bulanova. according to the anti-corruption center, she is the daughter of the rector of the zaporizhia national university and a people's deputy of mykola's 8th convocation. any court is a very responsible, responsible court. public activists have many questions about bulanova's property. for example, in 2022, her brother, who works as a lawyer, gave her an apartment in kyiv with an area of ​​93.5 square meters. the market value of the property, according to experts of the anti-corruption center, is more than uah 8 million. in the declaration, 100 uah is indicated. in the members commission, instead of questions, nor about the capabilities of the brother. there was no way to make money on such a valuable g

the northern commercial court of appeal, where gorbasenko wants to go, overturned his decisions. efore, the shareholders believe that the judge's actions have signs of raiding and illegal interference in economic activity, and have reported this to the higher qualifications commission, which must determine whether the judge will continue his career. instead, gorbasenko decided that the appeal of the shareholders to the vkk than. what else than interference in his activity, from pavlo gorbasenko's report on interference in the judge's activity. i consider it necessary to report the interference in my activity as a judge, regarding the administration of justice, as well as the manifestation of contempt of court. spamming the higher authorities, the prosecutor's office and the courts with complaints and lawsuits is commonplace for gorbasenko. in an odious oase, he challenged the negative conclusion of the public virtue council. then he tried to challenge the decision of the vkk itself in the supreme court. experts. the actions were considered as an attempt to evade the qualification

we've seen it in the fourth district court of appeals and tenth district court of appeals and what theing we don't have the merits to rule on this. we don't have the -- they're advocating responsibility. they're not shooting the cases down because of their merit. they're just saying it's not really up to us right now. we saw it recently in wyoming. the tenth district court of appeals, sorority, kappa kappa gambler gamma and would redefine the word woman and has multiple definitions and unquestionably not defined as what she said and definition of so broad that it could include cisgender men as women she says. the tenth circuit court of appeals. stuart: i don't know what you do with that. >> i know, they said they can't rule on this at the time. stuart: there's a book, swimming against the current. >> i sure do. stuart: a 30 second pitch. >> gosh, how crazy is it now to be able to add author to my many titles so what a fun process to write this book and it is a more in death penalty account as to -- in depth act to what we faced at national championships and broader picture here. we spe

have been going through -- let me start with the beginning of the time in 1994 when you went on the supreme court. you had been in court of appeals, chief judge, sentencing commission, clerk of the court, most people thought you were really prepared. when you went on the court did you feel prepared for a new job? >> what did i feel? >> well, harry blackman my predecessor told me you will find this unusual assignment. stark fear. that's what everyone feels. anyone who is appoint today the supreme court knows that lighting had to strike twice in the same place before you're appoint today the federal supreme court and you thought you could do the job, you thought so and then you were there and you wonder inside can i really -- can i really. i don't care how far back you two or when, whatever but somewhere within them, those first two or three years they're wondering around thinking just that. and that's why david sutter said takes three years minimum. william douglas said it takes five years and you sort of adjust. well, they'll just have to put up with me and i'll do the best i can and that's virtually any job that you will get in

this court of appeals is saying, hold up, we're going to let the defense offer their arguments as tod be disqualified based pop things that she did during the course of this case. and if ultimately the court of appeals decides she is off this case, that throws this case into absolute chaos because who takes over? do you have to start again? is it fani willis' office or some other jurisdiction within georgia in that jurisdiction, if that course -- not court, but if those lawyers take it up, what happens? do they even follow through the9 with the case e? but even if fani willis is allowed to stay on it, there's one key piece in this order from the court of appeals, no date has been set. where did we just hear that within the last 24 hours? we heard that in florida -- stuart: documents case. >> if there's no date set for the appeal, this could drag on very, very long. could it go until the election in maybe. my gut tells me that they decide to hold the hearing on this before the election, but there's no date on the calendar. this is a huge win for trump. lauren: he's going on the campai

then last week the new york state court of appeals voted 4-3 to overturn his conviction, citing what led egregious errors, finding that the judge erroneously allowed women who weren't part of the case to testify to so-called prior bad acts. >> these women were testifying to things they alleged harvey weinstein did that didn't have anything to do with the substance of the criminal charges. prosecutors meant to try and show a pattern, but the court of appeals said it went too far. >> juju: the news shocking and devastating to weinstein's alleged victims, including two of the women who were among the first to come forward, italian model amber gutierrez. >> i felt like everything was not real. >> juju: and actress ashley judd. >> harvey weinstein exploited, gleefully, asim though of power and is a serial sexual predator. everyone knows it that. >> juju: in 1997, judd, then an up-and-coming actress, was shooting the movie "kiss the girls." >> if you're looking for someone to blame, blame me. >> juju: when she says harvey weinstein invited her to a meeting at his beverly hills hotel. when s

campaign finance laws and justifies the underlying verdict, that is an egregious mistake the court of appeals in new york when they get this case, they ought to reverse this almost immediately because of this and so many other mistakes made in this c case. >> how many mistakes? >> i lost count of how many errors were made by this judge and the prosecution. the judge let in all kinds of irrelevant 11 evidence that has no bearing of charges on the president but obviously there to blacken the character of donald trump. if the judge shouldn't have even been on the case. he should have recused himself because of his personal family dealings, his daughter's involvement in making political contributions and violation of the ethics rules in new york. so many mistakes and errors made i don't see how the court of appeals could not overturn this verdict. >> was turned to by mcdonald was a monica probably? former assistant secretary for public affairs and the trump white house monica, your reaction to the building guilty verdict? >> i don't think it's a surprise given what we have seen over the last coup

stuart: clay, i'm sure you saw this but we learned today that the georgia court of appeals agreed to ew the ruling that allows fani willis to stay on the trump election case. you're a lawyer, and if she's removed from the case, then the whole case is kind of mute for a long time to come. they've got a start all over and a huge win for trump, isn't it? >> yeah, trump is winning a lot of these legal proceedings right now. i believe the georgia court of appeals will remove fani willis because i think it's quite clear that at a bear minimum, there's a strong appearance of impropriety associated with her relationship with nathan wade, the man who has already had to be removed from that case. i think fani willis will be removed from the case by the georgia court of appeals and the mere fact that they're hearing it is a big win for donald trump and comes on the heels of yesterday afternoon's ruling from judge aileen cannon in south florida and postpone that had documents case. that's never going to go to trial i don't think given the supreme court's continuing examination of presidential imm

in the end, the northern commercial court of appeal, and in particular lyudmila kropyvna, legalized theseizure of assets. this decision was later overturned by the grand chamber of the supreme court. at the same time, they began to investigate where the judge had the funds for the house that was being sold for 1 million dollars. and was there a bribe? kropyvna believes that during the search of her estate the detectives made a violation and filed a corresponding complaint with the supreme council of justice. the third disciplinary chamber of the supreme council'. justice finally sent for release the judge of the poltava district court, larisa bogomolova, who is suspected of treason due to alleged cooperation with the russian fsb. according to the law enforcement officers, she called on the employees of the berdyansk district court, where she used to work, to support the russian occupiers and cooperate with them, and those who refused, she handed over to the fsb. bogomolova gave the occupiers information about the transfer of three azov fighters from mariupol to the mangusha district. th

continues like this, then everyone is the chances that in a few months, not even years, the supreme court of appeals will reach the numbers of the previous supreme court of appeals kozyakov, who was actually dismissed for the failure of the judicial reform, when only 15 of the 3,000 judges who passed the qualification assessment were dismissed. several judges at once, who have negative conclusions of the state administrative court, for example, the judge of the pavlograd city district court'. serhiy babiy of propetrovs'ka region. in 2018, babia's wife bought a toyota chr car for almost uah 800,000. babii says that part of the amount belongs to his wife allegedly her mother gave it, he paid the other, but in the declaration the judge for some reason did not indicate either the mother's gift or his own. it was said, i give my mother the old one, and she helps me and you 50-50 50-50 to buy a new one. all. in 2013, the wife of serhii babiya purchased shares of the ebrd public joint-stock company for almost uah 110,000. according to the foundation, at that time it had no official income, the judge did no

again, going to the court of appeals and saying, will you give this another revisit and the court of appeals now saying yes, trump's attorney in georgia, steve stayed out said he's looking forward to presenting his arguments about why will should be disqualified and why this whole case should be dismissed. >> what does it mean for the timeline of when this case could go to trial means it's probably not going to trial anytime soon. it's really unlikely that this case is going to make it over the finish line anytime before election day, guys, the judge in this case, judge scott mcafee, has not even broached the question of a trial date. he still has a present the dental immunity issue in front of them, so they're already in a holding pattern when it comes to the trump of it all waiting to see what the supreme court decides over the summer on the presidential immunity issue. and it's hard to imagine that he's going to want to move full speed ahead with a case with the trial involving donald trump when there's still this huge matter of the disqualifies occasion hanging over everyone's hea

of the woods. a state appeals court has agreed to look at whether the d.a. in charge of trump's criminal case in georgia should be disqualified. trump's legal team amping up efforts to get her and then potentially the whole trial thrown out as his current hush money trial takes a break. >>> plus, a mid-may primary throwing even more uncertainty into an already volatile race for president. the lights flashing red for donald trump after a shockingly strong showing by nikki haley who dropped out of the race months ago. >>> and it's a first since the october 7th hamas-led attack in israel. could the u.s. pause an arms shipment, include thousands of weapons including bombs, and will israel pause plans for a major assault on rafah as a result. but we begin with the potentially big win for donald trump in fulton county, georgia, where the state appeals court just granted his request to consider whether district attorney fani willis should be disqualified from his election interference case. the decision comes nearly six weeks after donald trump and eight of his co-d

court of ukraine, serhiy holovaty. yes, the story is extremely serious, well... we congratulate the fair decision of the kyiv court of appeals, so we understand how important the position is, even, if not the chairman, then the acting chairman of the constitutional court of ukraine, well, accordingly, they found out and, so to speak, in the case and found out that a prescription was illegally imposed on the zk. volodymyr tsybulko, political scientist joins our ether. sir volodymyr, congratulations, glory to ukraine. greetings hero. glory, well, the news arrived: zaluzhny officially became the ambassador of ukraine to great britain, zelensky released him from military service due to his health with the right to wear a military uniform, we already knew that zaluzhny could become ambassador to great britain , but this appointment actually took a very long time, and there are certain assumptions that all this time zaluzhnyi was preparing for diplomatic work, recruiting, so to speak. diplomatic experience already so prepared, ready to go and form a team, what do you think, here are your assumptions, why did this process take so l

court of appeals for the fifth circuit, which is responsible for 11 of the 55-plus cases on the supremert docket, which is a stunning number. one of the things that happened, in a world in which courts can decide for themselves not just what agencies mean but also which issues are of "vast, economic or political significance" which is the test for a major question, litigants will try to bring their cases to the friendliest possible judge they can find. two things have happened in the last decade that have put the turbo boost into this. the first is as federal courts have become more polarized, we've had ideological outliers appointed to do -- to the federal courts. the real impact is on the lower courts, and president trump's judicial appointees. i think it's more the judges on courts of appeals. the fifth circuit has 17 active judges, six of them are trump appointees, 13 total are republican appointees and there's no administrative issue to small -- too small. they said the nuclear regulatory commission lacks the ability to create temporary licenses for the disposal of low-level radioa

now, jackie, georgia state law professor anthony michael crisis the georgia court of appeals usually has attorneys submit written arguments. more often then not about 2 out of 3 times they will have written arguments submitted rather than oral arguments but he says because of the high-profile nature of this case the court is most likely to hear from the attorneys delivering oral arguments. jackie? >> jacqui: we will watch for it, thank you. >> john: out to florida where the federal judge overseeing donald trump's documents case has world to push the trial date back for the time being. back to where? we know not at this point. in them rick mcnichol is live with more in miami, was the judge's reasoning or because it's a big decision. >> it is. good afternoon, john. in simple terms judge eileen gannon said we have to work through some legal issues before a new trial date is set. now the original date was set for may 20th. but both the prosecution and the defense told the judge that the case would not be ready to go before a jury this month. now we are 12 days away from the may 20th deadl

appeal. in a coat of my totally different case in terms of what has happened but may be similar from this point the harvey weinstein case, it courtf appeals overturn his conviction because the prosecution brought in witnesses who were not directly related to the case. is stormy daniels is not directly related to the falsification of business records that they potentially could have irreversible point on that? >> that is one of many points they have but the thing about harvey weinstein is if i'm remembering right his trial was about three years before his conviction out reversed. of trump gets comfort from the court of appeals in 2026 i don't think it will be cold comfort. be one you are probably right about that. andy, thank you. good have you with us. >> gillian: thank you for answering my question we appreciated. court is now back in session and the trial against former president trump, the defense is calling for a mistrial over stormy daniels' testimony, how will the judge rule? we will break that down coming up next with two criminal defense attorneys, stick with us. limu, someone needs to customize and save hundreds on car i

my private life has nothing to do with the merits of that prosecution. >> joyce, will the appeals courtee? >>. >> well, look, mr. wade is entitled to his opinion, but prosecutors are held to and have to hold themselves to a higher standard of conduct. the decision here, you know, may well be that there is some problem, but the trial judge saw fit to cure any issues by saying that willis could stay on the case as long as wade didn't. that was a good split the baby solution, and it wouldn't be unexpected if the court of appeals affirms the trial judge here. >> and just the fact that the appeals court decided to take this didn't just swat it away. what does that tell you about where this could be headed? >> yeah, i don't read any substantive into this decision. i think this case is high profile. it's political. georgia has elected state appellate courts. it's not surprising that they would feel obligated to hear this case rather than just let it ride. >> joyce vance, thank you so much. stay with us, we'll bring you back. let's turn to donald trump's hush money trial and stormy daniels's an

jurisdiction to enter judgment of conviction, and he's going to be very concerned that even if the court of appeals doesn't stay or put things on pause because trump's team can still ask the court of appeals to put things on pause independent of what judge mcafee wants to do. but even if they allow him to keepen doing pretrial matters, just simply doesn't have jourkz to actually enter judgment of conviction. >> so his hands are essentially tied and there is no trial date right now. >> there is no trial date right now, but i do want to suggest there is a possibility we could get other defendants who are tried before the election or at least before 2025. keep in mind this motion -- excuse me, thisep appeal take-u up by the georgia court of appeals only involves a few defendants who joined the motion to disqualify fani willis. there are other who didn't join it and essentially waived their right to make this motion to disqualify because they missed the deadline. and some of those defendants including people like john eastman have said they want to be tried before 2025. they don't wantor to be tried wh

the northern commercial court of appeal, where gorbasenko dreams of going, overturned his decision.shareholders believe that the judge's actions have.

for a trial date in the rico case against donald trump, earlier this month, georgia's state court of appealsould consider the appeal seeking to disqualify willis for engaging in a workplace romance that ended more than a year ago. but just a reminder, since there was no finding of a conflict of interest, as for that claim of appearance of impropriety as nathan wade testified in february -- >> it wasn't a secret. it was just private. my mother knew obviously. we weren't trying to keep anything a secret. there's nothing secret or salacious about having a private life. nothing. >> and nathan wade joins me next. stay with us. n wade joi mnse next stay with us this is a hot flash. this is a hot flash. but this is a not flash. for moderate to severe vasomotor symptoms due to menopause... ...veozah is the first and only prescription treatment that directly blocks a source of hot flashes and night sweats. with 100% hormone-free veozah... ...you can have fewer hot flashes... ...and more not flashes. veozah reduces the number and severity of hot flashes day and night. don't use veozah if you have cirr

. >> in new york in 1987, new york's highest court, which is called the court of appeals. it's not called the supreme court. that's our trial court. here in new york, we call the highest court the court of appeals. in 1987, the court of appeals issued a decision that said jurors are not allowed to take the actual written charge with them into the jury room. now, whether that makes sense in today's world doesn't matter because that's what the law is. so anybody who says otherwise is misstating what the law is and frankly, jurors are smart. when they need help, they did exactly what they did yesterday. they rang the bell, and they said, judge, can you give us the instructions again. and they'll do that again and again as long as they need to, until they reach a verdict. >> we could hear a bell any moment. we heard a bell two minutes before air yesterday. they're coming up on eight hours and 14 minutes of deliberations. they might have another question or a verdict soon. we'll find out. let me ask you, duncan, about the counts. there are 34 counts and i've got a trusty graphic

now, in the majority of cases of the georgia court of appeal, simply takes written arguments from theorneys on both sides because of this case is so high profile, anthony christ, the professor you saw in that report, he anticipates that there will be oral arguments. >> neil: jonathan, thank you. meanwhile, back to the focus tomorrow, manhattan of course stormy daniels do back on this stand, tron back in the courthouse. all of this at a time, a lot of people are trying to politically pain points -- trump -- what kind of impact will this have on the former president. maybe they might be surprised to hear the limited impact it could have because we know the history on a former sitting president. that's after this. (psst! psst!) ahhh! with flonase, allergies don't have to be scary. spray flonase sensimist daily for non-drowsy long lasting relief in a scent free, gentle mist. flonase all good. also, try our allergy headache and nighttime pills. when we say it'll be on time, they expect it to be on time. turn shipping to your advantage. keep those expectations with reliable ground shipping.

disgraced film producer harvey weinstein is appearing in court for the first time since the new york court of appealsappeals court ruled last week that he did not receive a fair trial in 2020. the 72—year—old remains injail because of a separate rape conviction in california. if you're just if you'rejustjoining us, looking at pictures from new york, here, the courtroom in new york where the disgraced film producer harvey weinstein is appearing. he will be retried after the rape conviction was overturned. that is coming from the manhattan district attorney office. harvey weinstein will be retried after that rape conviction was overturned. we will bring you more news as and when we get it. stay with us on bbc news. hello there. we're seeing a change across southern parts of the uk. eventually, some heavy rain and thunderstorms moving in here. we also got overnight some more mist and fog, low cloud developing more widely. and for some areas of scotland in particular, it was a struggle to clear that all day. in marked contrast, in norfolk here, we've seen temperatures over 20 degrees in the sunshine. but

for participation in the competition at occupying the post of judges at the northern commercial court of appealy , you can get a promotion and reset some facts of your personal and professional biography. gorbasenko also spams the prosecutor general and the supreme council of justice with complaints and complaints about alleged interference in his work. in reality , he is banally trying to justify himself, because appeals about his lack of ... professionalism and mistakes made during the consideration of cases have been received by the highest quality of the commission. it is about one of the critical infrastructure enterprises on kyiv region - bila-tserkivsk heat elektrocentral. the shareholders insist that in the pad case, the judge made many unjust decisions, took measures to secure the lawsuit by suspending the effect of the decisions of the general meeting of shareholders. in another case, gorbasenko did the same based on a statement signed by the defendant's representative and undertook to consider another lawsuit, again, signed not by the plaintiffs, but by the defendant's representative

now the attorney general referred this sentence to the court of appeal this sentence to the court of ne should be given something called a hybrid life sentence instead. now what that would mean if they'd agreed, if the justices had agreed, is that he would serve his sentence in the psychiatric hospital where he is until he is deemed to be fit, to then go and serve the remainder of the sentence in a normal prison. now, lawyers for the attorney general had argued that caloocan's extreme crimes warranted a sentence with an element of punishment. now, in explaining the decision of the justices , baroness carr said justices, baroness carr said that calocane had no previous convictions, had struggled with his mental health since 2019, and that all of the experts in that original trial had agreed that original trial had agreed that at the time of the assaults, calocane had been in the grip of a severe psychiatric episode . baroness carr said as episode. baroness carr said as well that the court could not ignore that medical evidence, and that the judge in calocane trial was entitled to concl

court of appeals of the d.c. circuit from 1997-1998 and for justice antonin scalia of the supreme court of the united states during the 1998 term. after two years in private practice in washington, d.c., she became a law professor joining the faculty of notre dame law school in 2002. she was appointed a judge of the united states court of appeals seventh circuit in 2017. president trump dominated her as an associate justice of the supreme court and she took her seat on october 27, 2020. [applause] i want to begin, justices, with just recognizing this time that we are in, both civic learning week itself, and the centrality of those themes, but also the time we are in in the country. we are approaching the 250th anniversary of the nation's founding in a couple of years, and unlike the bicentennial nearly half a century ago, there are a lot of debates about who we are as a country and where we are headed. one of the things true across the board, left and right, is there has been a declining level of confidence and fa

of six years. but that's not where it ended. the prosecution then appealed that six-year sentence to the supreme court. was shockingly inappropriate in the circumstances, and the supreme court of appeal decided to substitute it with a sentence of 13 years and 5 months. [soft music] reporter: the parole hearing of oscar pistorius will be held in pretoria today. the correctional supervision and parole board for the kgosi mampuru prison will meet to consider whether he is suitable for social integration or not. this is the second time the parole board is meeting to decide whether oscar pistorius should be released on parole. kelly phelps: parole in south africa can be considered when a person has served 50% of their sentence. the parole placement for mr. oscar pistorius has been confirmed. as of january 2024, oscar's out of jail. robyn curnow: oscar pistorius was released, quietly, smuggled out, under the cloak of darkness. nobody saw him leave prison. nobody saw him arrive at home. michael sokolove: two lives were lost. her life was lost. his life has been wasted. scott roder: i think with, you know, the