eric murphy: that is true, your honor. judge: whether he has standing -- is that -- i may be a little confused here. you have to address standing because it is jurisdictional, if without that party, you would not have a case. if you have other parties that clearly do have standing, one does not have to address it. to we have to address it? >> i do think you do. the rule you are talking about only applies when they are seeking the same relief. his relief is more -- the relief the plaintiffs sought was just as applied -- he wanted broader injunctive relief variant you can put it on the death certificates of any future clients. the general rule, when they are not seeking identical claims -- judge: as applied to one death certificate, but without it, you cannot attack more broadly -- eric murphy: the injunction. it would have to essentially be more forward-looking. with respect to -- i am happy to talk about the third-party standing point. with respect to that, i think it is pretty straightforward. the easiest route, the third

white white house and the family of , eric garner -- the staten island man who died after a new york city police officer put him in a banned chokehold. billy murphy, an attorney for freddie gray's family, addressed the mourners. >> most of us are not here because we knew freddie gray. but we're all here because we know lots of freddie grays. amy: we will speak to reverend jesse jackson after headlines. not far from the upheaval in baltimore, loretta lynch was sworn in as the nation's first african-american woman attorney general at a ceremony in washington, d.c. >> is a little girl from north carolina who used to tell her grandfather to f on the back of his mule so she could see way up high granddaddy, can grow up to become the chief law enforcement officer of the united states of america, we can do anything. amy: lynch released a statement on the situation in baltimore, vowing to -- "bring the full resources of the department of justice to bear in protecting those under threat, investigating wrongdoing, and securing an end to violence." the justice department is investigating freddie gray's death. the prime minister of nepal has warned the death

murphy is the gray's family attorney. >> why would anybody rationale trust their process. >> the troubles here fit disturbingly into the national narrative, black men dying after encounters with the police. from eric garner walter scott in south carolina but baltimore is different. the police department is 48% black. the troubles here exacerbated by economic devastation. the city ranks tenth in the nation for income inequality with nearly a quarter living below the poverty line. in freddie gray's neighborhood more than a quarter of homes are vacant. this week's disturbance has only made the economic divide deeper. jobs lost in the neighborhood malls closed conventions canceled. lost revenue city wide as the orioles cancel their second home game in a row. and they take a step to play wednesday's game in an empty stadium. many residents say they are committed to healing. this clotheing tailer says he's not giving up on baltimore. >> i have no fear. i'm just working. that's the reason why i'm here. >> for these residents -- >> baltimore has been home to me for 15 years. >> -- and so many others here this city is still their heart, still their home. peace peace and happyiness ♪ >> the violence we've a

eyes and they especially trust eric holder in light of his past performance on these kinds of issues. and so they welcome this investigation with open arms. >> billy murphy. >> back with our panel. sonny, in terms of the investigation, where does it go from here? >> think billy -- i think billy murphy makes a good point. i'm uncomfortable with baltimore police department investigating its own. we've seen that is not the right way to do it. you should have a separate investigative team investigating this. it has been ten days and we haven't heard from the police. and they do have the same rights that everyone else has, but they have lawyered up and haven't spoken and now how do you expect the baltimore police commissioner to investigate his own. and you have to have someone come in with a fresh set of eyes to look at this case. >> and harry, to that sort of independent civilian review? >> i have no problem with the -- the attorney general coming in and taking a look at it. they did a good job in the eric holder case -- in the other case in ferguson. i have no problem with eric holder u.s. attorney coming in and investigating this case and i don't think th

eyes and they especially trust eric holder in light of his past performance on these kinds of issues. and so they welcome this investigation with open arms. >> billy murphye your time tonight? thank you. back with our panel, sunny hostin lawrence kobilinsky and terry hauk. in terms of this investigation, where does it go from here? >> i think billy murphy makes a very important point. i am uncomfortable with the baltimore police department investigating this investigating its own. we've seen time and time again that that really isn't the right way to do it. you should have an independent investigative force or team investigating something like this. i mean like you said it's been ten days. we haven't heard from the police. obviously, as harry said they do have the same rights that everyone else has, but they've obviously lawyered up. they haven't spoken. so how now do you expect the baltimore city police commissioner to investigate his own? you've got to have someone else come in with a fresh pair of eyes a disinterested pair of eyes and look at this case. >> harry, traditionally, there is great resistance among police forces around the country to that s