hayes gains the upper hand in this fight.ugh this started as he was the victim of an assault, he quickly becomes a participant in an altercation. the officer continues to observe the scene and wait the arrival of our response teams. you see mr. hayes now has gained the upper hand in this altercation. and as the response team comes in, you see them secure the participants fairly quickly. efficiently. and they'll be headed off to segregation. >> having received treatment for minor injuries, hayes is secured back in his cell. >> you were on top of him, how -- >> there was a point you had to stop. you didn't. he was on the chair cowering from you. that's no longer an assault on you. now you're beating the hell out of him. all right. that's why you're going to see the d-board. that's what happens. >> deputies will question the other inmate who has asked not to be identified on camera. then members of the jail's disciplinary board will determine what sanctions, if any, will be handed down. >> i don't know what happened. i was just

in hayes valley on hayes street i'm here to express my unanimous support for in project and it's extension the approximate development and beer garden has been integral if the success of the launch of my own small business and the team that operate that bar in any professional opinion some of the best operators i have come across in any professional experience it is a place that i patron misses with friends and out of town gift is adds a tremendous tremendous opportunity and draw bringing people from within the city and outside the city to the hayes valley community there incredibly supportive operators and give back so much from my own selfish beer and sausage loving needs as a small business owner as a fellow restaurant operator here to speak out in full support of the extension of this >> (clapping.) thank you. >> thank you. next speaker, please. >> >> hi, i'm jimmy lived in hayes valley for 12 years with any wife we're stronger sports supporters of expectation of the beer garden everything that was said is absolutely true how wonderful as professional operators and activation oversees

in hayes valley on hayes street i'm here to express my unanimous support for in project and it's extension the approximate development and beer garden has been integral if the success of the launch of my own small business and the team that operate that bar in any professional opinion some of the best operators i have come across in any professional experience it is a place that i patron misses with friends and out of town gift is adds a tremendous tremendous opportunity and draw bringing people from within the city and outside the city to the hayes valley community there incredibly supportive operators and give back so much from my own selfish beer and sausage loving needs as a small business owner as a fellow restaurant operator here to speak out in full support of the extension of this >> (clapping.) thank you. >> thank you. next speaker, please. >> >> hi, i'm jimmy lived in hayes valley for 12 years with any wife we're stronger sports supporters of expectation of the beer garden everything that was said is absolutely true how wonderful as professional operators and activation oversees

in hayes valley on hayes street i'm here to express my unanimous support for in project and it's extension the approximate development and beer garden has been integral if the success of the launch of my own small business and the team that operate that bar in any professional opinion some of the best operators i have come across in any professional experience it is a place that i patron misses with friends and out of town gift is adds a tremendous tremendous opportunity and draw bringing people from within the city and outside the city to the hayes valley community there incredibly supportive operators and give back so much from my own selfish beer and sausage loving needs as a small business owner as a fellow restaurant operator here to speak out in full support of the extension of this >> (clapping.) thank you. >> thank you. next speaker, please. >> >> hi, i'm jimmy lived in hayes valley for 12 years with any wife we're stronger sports supporters of expectation of the beer garden everything that was said is absolutely true how wonderful as professional operators and activation oversees

>> no. >> reporter: but at the end of the show -- >> hayes and emma. >> reporter: vine star hayes grier werewolf waltz? a life-changing event for me. >> reporter: it was the first night ever derek hough has not won the teen dance competition, george if fun fact from jesse there. okay, hayes grier, emma slater join us. i was just telling you caused a lot of upset in my house. my daughter harper heard you got kicked off saying no! it can't be. >> thanks, harper. >> you had such a great waltz last night. how did it feel to go out on a high note? >> it was good. i was able to go out with a bang. it was nice to win the team dance. that was good and end derek's streak. had a lot of fun and i had an amazing partner and took a lot away from is. >> emma was your best friend, you said. what did you learn working with her. >> how to dance. >> british slang. >> a lot of british slang for sure but she's been great. i couldn't ask for a better partner. >> he really came along, didn't he? >> oh, so much. i think out of everything on the show it's kind of safe to say he had the most improvement. i took

wayne haye, al jazeera, the pill fiends. >>> families from north and south korea have met for a rarefter more than 60 years apart. harry fawcett explains. >> reporter: in a hotel just north of the border that split north korea from south and their people, deepest emotions rush fort. the prevailing one is love. this woman was three month's pregnant when her husband disappeared during the korean war. we met mother and son preparing for their journey south of the border. >> translator: back then we were only just married. we hadn't even called each other darling, not even once. >> reporter: they joined nearly 400 others on the journey north. more than 66,000 south koreas are on the list of applicants, 63,000 have died waiting. the system exists for all of this to happen more regularly. it all depends on the political climate. >> 66,000 remain among about 30,000 are inside waiting to meet each other. so we have certainly tried our best. >> reporter: soon the buses were making their way up the coast. it's hard to imagine the emotional impact of these meetings, coming after decades of wait

bill: steven hayes, from the hilda. martha: then u.n. ambassador susan rice appeared on five sunday morning talk shows after the benghazi attacks to make it clear the video you heard discussed was the crux of the reason. it was the catalyst for sparking the deadly violence that took the lives of those four americans. benghazi record revealed a memo directing her to quote underscore these protests are rooted in an internet video and not a broader policy failure. that came from ben rhode. the white house insists ask. but nuke more well edited -- but mike morrell edited those talking points. >> when she talked about the video, it was not something the analysts said. reporter: gregory hicks who serve offed under the ambassador chris stevens testified before the house oversight committee that no such protest ever happened. hick wahicks was at the base in tripoli. his last word, quote, we are under attack. hicks said he was floored when he herd the administration's take on this. >> would a highly decorated career diplomat told you there had be

hayes had three assists as well. ryan spooner with the goal here. bruins got their first win 6-2 on the road. >>> it is just about 4:40 right now. coming up on wbz this morning, a lesson school nurses hope they never have to use. >> the trauma training that could save lives in the event of a school shooting. >> tax payers still on the hook for lanes in tunnels. >> ready to hit the slopes already. the ski resorts that >>> welcome back. the owner of a restaurant started -- >> something is going on there. >> anyway, the own er of a restaurant chain making a big change when it comes to tipping plus one car maker unveiled a cool new auto pilot feature. >> the largest retailer is dragging down the market. jill wagner joins us from the new york stock exchange with the money watch. >> reporter: i love the giggles on a thursday morning. good morning, chris and kathryn. wal-mart shares plunged by 10% yesterday. loss of $20 billion in market value. in the latest earnings wal-mart predicted the sales will fall next year taking a big hit from online retailers. w

kabc's rob hayes has the story. >> reporter: lapd memorial services sadly are not rare events but whateath of an officer who was never an officer. >> 4,000 block. >> actor martin milner became a household name playing officer pete malloy. the show "adam 12." >> 1 adam 12. >> miller died last month at the age of 3. hundreds packed the auditorium at lapd headquarters to remember him. >> the real adam 12 got its name here. >> countless actors have portrayed lapd officers but few have received this kind of treatment from the department which considers milner a major influence on the force today. >> that is the image that drew us all to this place. >> lapd chief charlie beck is referring to pete malloy's persona, the clean cut compassion natser? during the tush lent timed it aired. milner beck says not only drew better people into policing but changed how many lapd officers approached their work. >> pete malloy was a professional, a great moral compass that always did the right thing in the show and in many ways a generation of police officers the way that they think about their job was for

. >> hayes has traded and sold guns almost his entire life. >> now i'm going to load the gun. it's loaded and ready to fire. would you like to shoot it? >> reporter: uh sure. >> excellent you did a good job. >> reporter: did i get it? he has a collection you wouldn't believe, weapons of all shapes and sizes, from modern to ancient, from walls of guns to actual tanks. the history buff has run the missoula montana gun shows for decades. one of the oldest and largest gufgun shows in the country. but now otto pollack says his gun show is under attack. the city of missoula is considering a new ordinance which would require background checks for nearly all private gun sales including those at gun shows. >> this is an ordinance amending the missoula title 9, requiring criminal background checks on all gun sales and transfers. >> reporter: in montana it's a radical proposition, background checks at gun shows are currently not required by the state. >> in 47 years not once has the atf the fbi, the state attorney general's office the city police the sheriff's office, not once has the mi

chris hayes. >>> and good evening from new york. i'm chris hayes.untry experienced its 45th school shooting in this year alone and the 294th mass shooting of the calendar year of 2015 according to the broadest definition of the term. a massacre at a community college in a remote part of southwestern oregon which left ten people dead and seven wounded. there is still at this hour a lot we don't know about what happened. we do know the gunman, a 20-year-old male, is now deceased. not long ago president obama came to the white house briefing room to deliver a blistering response to today's events, one that may be remembered as one of the most powerful and angry speeches of his presidency. we bring it to you now in full. >> there's been another mass shooting in america, this time in a community college in oregon.

hayes' career high leads the b.'s to their first win of the year. 6-2. >> play of the day is brought to you by: >> call it the bat heard around the record. there it is slugging the jays to their first alcs since 1993 with the go ahead three-run shot. bautista's bat flip under a the home run get our play of the day. winner take all in l.a.with mets and dodgers fighting for a spot in the nlcs against the cubs. >> thank you. >> 7 news at 6:00 will be >> ahead on nbc night lienis the president announces a longer and bigger troop commitment to the war in afghanistan. but will it make a difference. our richard engel reports. why former house speaker dennis hastert will avoid trial keeping possible details of essentialual miscouldn't alleges going public. a warning about the new credit cards you may have recently received in the mail when we see you tonight for nightly news. itself. >> this is our time for news at 6:00 on this thursday, thank you for being with us. >> it's a pleasure, i'm elizabeth norieka in for kim khazei

rupert wingfield-hayes, bbc news .ala: i'm joined by michael green, the senior vice president at the center for international studies. what is your assessment of what is evolving in the area. 12 knock aithin miles. the reef was under water a year ago. we have been doing this for 200 years. when countries claim waters beyond the international norms. is full of geostrategic significance. it is a rising china that build therfields in this area of islands, incredibly intimidating for the philippines, vietnam, and front-line states. the u.s. will power being questioned. will the u.s. who wouldn't normally does and demonstrate these are international waters? we dated, and china is making noise about it. .hey had to do it the allies and partners in the region the u.s. has, from japan, the philippines, australia, and countries in between, they were calling out washing the desk calling out washington to demonstrate china would not militarize the islands around them without some stance from the u.s. now they want to get back to

wayne haye reports. >> reporter: the deal which has been years in the making was finally signed at ay in the capitol. it was one of the top priorities of the president when he took office four years ago, and 50 years of military rule came to an end. >> translator: today is a very important historic day for myanmar. we have been able to launch a new road to a peaceful future. >> reporter: but it's a nationwide agreement in name only. eight armed ethnic groups signed the deal, but seven others didn't. they included the independence army. there has also been fighting correctly in other areas. the president says the door remains open for all groups to sign the agreement in the future so the suffering can end. >> translator: there have been armed conflicts in our country since we won independence. tens of thousands of troops from both sides have lost their lives. hundreds of thousands of people living in the conflict area have suffered immensely from the fighting. >> reporter: political talks will be focused around the desire for a federal system. there will also be talks on being monitor

. >>> i'm wayne haye reporting from the philippines where the former typhoon continues to dump rain on island of louson. the only way to get better is to challenge yourself, and that's what we're doing at xfinity. we are challenging ourselves to improve every aspect of your experience. and this includes our commitment to being on time. every time. that's why if we're ever late for an appointment, we'll credit your account $20. it's our promise to you. we're doing everything we can to give you the best experience possible. because we should fit into your life. not the other way around. >> we're here to fully get into the nuances of everything that's going on, not just in this country, but around the world. getting the news from the people who are affected. >> people need to demand reform... >> ali velshi on target weeknights 10:30p et ♪ >>> welcome back. the top stories on al jazeera. israeli forces have used tear gas and water cannon to disperse palestinians protesters in the occupied west bank. a palestinian man was shot dead after stabbing an israeli soldier. >>> syrian observatory f

hayes and leyla scott. carter was killed on a walking trail near fairfax earlier this week. they're drifters and caught with the help of surveillance footage and gps system in the car they're accused of stealing. >> we knew to look in all directions. you never know which flight of travel anyone will take. in this case, we located and contacted many gas stations, private businesses and so forth throughout the community and it is because of this effort that we were able to obtain this photograph. >> sheriff deputies are working with portland police to bring the three back to the bay area but it likely won't happen until next week pending a court hearing. >>> police in san hose are on the look -- san jose are on the look out for a suspect who escaped before he was about to be booked. it is 30-year-old david juanoy with a thin build with a tattoo on the right side of his neck. two bail bonds men tracked him down and took him into the lobby of the main jail for booking. some how he happened to run away while sti

. >>> i'm wayne haye reporting from the philippines where the former typhoon continues to dump huge amountsrain on the island of luzon. ♪ >>> we begin this news hour with developments in israel and the palestinian territories where it's been another day of tenning. in the past few hours there have been demonstrations in the occupied west bank. rallies too in gaza. this demonstration was held by women linked to the armed group islamic jihad in support of a palestinian uprising. a palestinian man was shot dead after a small demonstration near hebron. he had stabbed an israeli soldier there. and the israeli military says another palestinian man was killed after driving his car into an israeli soldier and citizen south of beth hah lem. 46 palestinians and 8 israelis have been killed in the violence. the u.n. secretary general ban ki-moon has held talks with israel's president, is due to meet with benjamin netenyahu later, and travel to the palestinian territories later on wednesday. >> violence only undermines the legitimate palestinian aspirations for statehood, and the longing of israelis for

we have an excellent working relationship with chief hayes-white and her staff. san francisco fire department is one of the premier and happy to have them here. we own the 63-acre reserve and maintains the open space and originally planted in 1886 and there are a primarily tree species there and we maintain the reserve, ensure the safety of visitors and buildings and neighboring homes. several buildings including the hospital and the central utility plan behind the report provides the power for the complex. the regeneration medicine building built on the cliff -- it's the unique building on the side of the mountain and the adjacent to the reserve. ucsf [inaudible] san miguel housing complex is in the area and houses students and families and adjacent to neighbors hopes. we are committed to have the reserve as a resource and staff is responsible for the maintenance and collaboration with other departments. daily maintenance is performed in house by two full time forestry technicians and professional landscape and tree companies and regular maintenance includes mai

i'm chris hayes. today in the longest running special committee in the history of the nation, former secretary of state hillary clinton took the stage as the witness of the house select committee on benghazi and as the object, many would say, of the gop obsession with tarnishing clinton as much as possible. no matter how hard republicans tried, image and optics, not substance, were very much the center piece of the proceedings that went into the night. the chairman, congressman trey gowdy, spoke to reporters after the adjournment. >> she stayed to the end and i didn't hear a single word of complaint. she's an important witness. you can't investigate benghazi without talking to the former secretary of state. but as i said this morning, she's one important witness out of what is more than 50 important witnesses and there are a couple dozen left to go. in terms of conclusions, i don't draw conclusions until the end and there are more witnesses to talk to. so we keep going on until we're able to interview

hayes is very skeptical as i was myself. i asked dr.ayes about blankets, the idea that colonizers deliberately infected native peoples with blankets contaminated with smallpox. he explained to me that viruses, people with smallpox, were susceptible to heat and humidity, and conditions had to be just right for transmission, including smallpox which could be conveyed by way of scabs from victims that were bundled in cloth materials. but this had to be under the right circumstances, cool temperatures and low humidity. since that fateful meeting with dr. hayes, i have had the manual by myseases side every time i write about diseases. the major take away is that each disease has a unique nature, and we cannot just expect each and every disease to corrupt like wildfire. this led me to read more deeply on the history of diseases, epidemics, human health and medicine, and led me to become quite skeptical of all aspects of the virgin soil thesis. the work of the historian david jones has also been important in the development of my thinking. thi

i'm chris hayes. after nine people were murdered in last week's school shooting in oregon, the democratic presidential candidates are answering president obama's call to break the cycle of inaction on gun safety. putting the issue front and center on the campaign trail and giving hillary clinton a rare opportunity to come at bernie sanders from the left. at a town hall meeting in new hampshire clinton made a strong case for new government action to take on gun violence in america. >> on the republican side mr. trump was asked about it and said things like that hp in the world. governor bush said stuff happens. no. that's an admission of defeat and surrender to a problem that is killing 33,000 americans. it's time for us to say wait a minute, we're better than this, our country is better than this. >> among other steps her plan would tighten the loophole for gun shows and internet sales, close what's being called the charleston loophole, which allows someone with an incomplete background check to still

i'm chris hayes. it had been billed months ago as a celebration. a gathering in houston of jeb bush's big donors where they would have a chance to mingle and take pictures with a pair of former presidents who also just happen to be jeb's father and brother. instead, that closed-door conference which wrapped up today with remarks by george w. bush is being cast as something more like a funeral for jeb's foundering campaign. now, bush still has plenty of advantages in his quest for the gop presidential nomination, a marquee name, access to a massive donor network, a well-funded super pac, and more endorsements than any other republican candidate. but if the bushes and their backers once expected a coronation, well, what they've gotten thus far is closer to a catastrophe, and they know it. the patient is either in intensive care and in need of some good doctors who can save him or being put into hospice and we're going to see a slow death, one k street lobbyist backing bush told politico. a bush fund-raiser told the "washington post" that "it feels ve

fox news legal analyst peter johnson jr., steve hayes and laura ingraham.'m watching this and this is on the heels of jeb bush comparing marco rubio to obama this week. is this a french work week, suggesting he resign. what is he trying to gain here? and i didn't think he got the better of the exchange. >> i don't think he did either. obviously a lot of personal enmity between the two. i think he thought he was his protege and he was marco rubio's mentor along the way. marco rubio responded to a lot of attacks tonight in a very positive, strong way. on his voting record not only from the moderator but from jeb bush. also on one of his tax plans. john harwood got it wrong. and had to be corrected by marco rubio. and so he came back on the defensive but in a strong way. and showed a lot of moxie and a lot of resolve that we haven't seen from him in any of these debates yet. that being said, bush was not bad tonight. he's still in the race, i believe. he didn't hurt himself terribly, but rubio came on real strong. >> let me go back to this issue of the media,

i'm chris hayes. it's the day after. and by acclimation or something very close to it presidential candidate hillary clinton won with a commanding, impressive performance before the house select committee on benghazi. and while we will take a longer look at conservative reaction in a moment, this headline might just sum it up. the conservative reviews are in. benghazi hearing a bust. from the moment the gavel struck last night, finally ending an 11-hour hearing, the former secretary of state was more -- than usual to focus solely on the democratic nomination for president. today in her first post-hearing speech before an exhilarated home style crowd the dnc women's leadership forum in d.c., clinton took a victory lap. [ cheers and applause ] >> it's been quite a week, hasn't it? as some of you may know, i had a pretty long day yesterday. but i finally got to answer questions, something i've been pushing for literally a year. and i am just grateful. i recovered my voice, which i lost a little bit. as i said at the start,

chris hayes is up next. >>> the morning after, let's play "hardball." >> good evening, i'm chris matthews up in new york, paraphrase an old commercial, the republicans sure thing of jeb bush is now the gop's lost cause. marco rubio and ted cruz delivered and the republicans are coming down to the brutal awareness that it's going to take one powerful, compelling original campaign to knock hillary clinton out of the 2016 driver's seat. one thing for sure, we saw a changing of the guard last night and it all happened in a few short minutes. jeb bush tried to take marco rubio on for his voting history in the senate. let's watch the action. >> but marco, when you signed up for this, this was a six-year term, and you should with be showing up for work. what is it like a french workweek? you can campaign, or just resign and let somebody else take the job. >> i don't remember you ever complaining about john mccain's vote record, the only reason you're doing it now is that you're running against me and somebody has told you that attacking me is going to help you. >> no one cares about missed votes

the hayes blanketing much of southeast asia will keep malaysian schools closed. quality levels deemed very unhealthy. let's get over to have haslinda amin. is there any improvement on the horizon? haslinda: not at this point in time. here we are, still talking about -- the government says you can expect the haze to continue to persist through november. people still struggling with the thick haze, in malaysia, the air quality is close to hazardous levels. schools are shut for the next two days, except those in outlying areas. we're looking at live pictures. more activities have been canceled, like a marathon involving 30,000 people. by the way, three airports in malaysia were forced to close over the weekend because of thehaze, not surprising that it is causing a lot of tension. we are talking about singapore, malaysia, large parts of malaysia, all of singapore shrouded in hayes. streets wearing masks. to cancely, we had the finals of the first day of the swimming world cup. as if it's not bad enough, the philippines have seen the hayes for about a week now. risha

investigators say morrison hayes lamply, shawn michael lan gold and a woman is responsible for two people being killed. >> when the second homicide occurred, wooded area, victim died from gunshot wounds, there were two many similarities in the time, location and manner. there were too many similarities to ignore. police say the gun used was stolen a few days before the deadly crime spree began. police say taken from an unlocked parked car near fisherman's wharf. >> the vehicle owner believed he locked his vehicle. at this point, it appears he did not and the vehicle was unlocked. he had the weapon in his vehicle. >> police arrested the trio who they say were driving the volkswagen jet a in portland, oregon, on wednesday. it had some of the backpackers camping equipment and the gun stolen on september 30th. they say the trio's violent acts are over. crime scnes. from golden gate park - -to portland. here's the the timeline. ==take vo== police say the suspects stole the gun out of an unlocked car last wednesday -- september 30th...near fisherman's wharf. audrey carey was found dead in golde

. >> chris hayes is up next. "hardball" starts right now. hillary and bernie, did both win? let's play "hardball." >>> could it be that hillary clinton did what she had to do last night, grabbed the democratic mother load? is it true that bernie sanders used his first grade national audience to enlist many new recruits. you heard the conventional wisdom. major headlines are strong declaring hillary clinton the victory. hillary clinton dominates first democratic debate. "time" magazine hillary clinton takes control in first democratic debate. washington post. democratic bait turns hillary clinton's way after months of difficulties. politico, clinton crushes it. donald trump also ruled that clinton came out on top. here he was with katy tur today. >> i think she did her job. i think she got through the debate. i thought she won the debate. >> the data from social media tells a different story. it shows that bernie sanders attracted far more interest during the debate. according to google sanders was most searched candidate followed by clinton then webb, o'malley and chaffe. to

hayes had three assists including this nice feed to ryan spooner for the goal. the b's win this one 6-2. it's their first win on the road. >> there you go. do you feel good about that? >> i feel better. 0-3 to start not good . >>> coming up, lamar odom is still fighting for his life after he was found unconscious. >> details about what happened plus jon keller takes a closer look at fame and fortune. >> why some nurses are learning techniques meant for the battlefield. >> when does the cool air arrive? this weekend. 50s on saturday, upper 40s on sunday. it's going to be a nice fall day today. we'll time out some showers to end the week tomorrow people of the coffee drinking world, dunkin' has a dark roast coffee that's deliciously roasted just right for a bold start and smooth finish that's never bitter. put down the dark roast you've been putting up with >>> kids may find hospital visits less frightening with the help of a robot. >> meet justin, a very advanced robot. this is making kids smile here in new england. he dances, reads poetry and can talk about famo

bernie sanders appeared on this network with chris hayes saying essentially the same thing as hillary clinton. chris hayes did discuss with him his voting -- bernie sanders' voting record where he's been for some gun safety bills and against others. but richard martinez, the president said tonight that he, of course, was going to be accused of politicizing the issue and then he took that straight on and said this is an issue that needs to be politicized. >> we, first of all, i want to say i agree with everything that andy just said. and i can tell you i have a sense of urgency. the longer it takes us to make common sense changes to our gun laws, the more people are going to die for reasons that are completely preventible. and, you know, 26 and 27-year-olds were shot and killed in the sandy hook elementary school. if we had taken the steps we needed to take after that shooting, there would be a lot more people that wouldn't be dead today. you know, there's not one single solution that's going to solve all of these problems. but universal background checks on all gun sales is a good pla

steve hayes? >> so for the republicans i'm giving $55 to marco rubio. 25 to ted cruz. 10 to chris christie. 5 each to ben carson and donald trump. i mean, i think carson and trump have a path but it's a narrow path despite the fact that they are leading national polls today and doing well in the early states. rubio, to me, feels like apple stock in the late 1990s. he has talent. he has a lot of things going for him. and people are beginning to see it the more he gets a stage to present it it ted cruz, i thought, had a really terrific debate the other night and sort of stood out from the crowd in a way that he hadn't in the previous two debates. i imagine he does get a lot of looks from the people who eventually move on from ben carson and donald trump. >> it's your first time in the casino. >> yeah. my first gamble here. >> okay. welcome. >> i have not done well in actual gambling. >> we will see how do you here. >> i also have rubio on top. '$0 on rubio. 30 also on bush, yeah, i know. but campaig

chris hayes is up next. >> no more biden his time. let's play "hardball." good evening. i'm chris matthews. joe biden wants to run for president and made clear he wants to challenge hillary clinton for the democratic nomination. what is stopping him is not the commitment but the timing. >> as my family and i have worked through the grieving process i have said all along what i have said time and again to others that it may very well be that that process by the time we get through it closes the window on mounting a realistic campaign for president. that it might close. i have concluded it has closed. >> biden said the clock simpry ran out to mount a successful campaign. >> unfortunately, i believe we're out of time. the time necessary to mount a winning campaign for the nomination. but while i will not be a candidate i will not be silent. i intend to speak out clearly and forcefully to influence as much as i can where we stand as a party and where we need to go as a nation. >> so simply too late. if it weren't too late he made it clear he would be defending the obama reco

chris hayes is up next. >>> the republican right in full mutiny. let's play "hardball." ♪ >>> good evening. i'm chris matthews in washington. history was made as two political parties came apart facing all out demands by the republican right kevin mccarthy with drew his candidacy for speaker. >> we have been going through this campaign talking to a lot of members. the one thing i have always said to earn this majority we should put this conference first. and i think there is something to be said for us to unite we probably need a fresh face. i will stay on as majority leader. the one thing i found in talking to everybody if we are going to unite and be strong we need a new face to help do that. so nothing more than that. i feel good about the decision. i feel great to have my family here, my colleagues. i think we are only going to be stronger. >> now a midst of civil war with full rebellion as the leading presidential candidates are with trump, carson and fiorina. here is how john fleming described what took place. >> we came in the way we normall