well let's bring in senior analyst from the jerusalem center for public affairs thanks for joining us good to have you all know it's been a controversial law so far as not to say the least critics are saying this marginalize is degrades israel's israel's arab community would you agree with that statement. no i think that's an inaccurate statement in fact the bill factually doesn't change the protected status of israel's minorities whatsoever all this bill does is to allow israel to join scores of other states around the world who have defined a national character of the majority of those countries now the problem with states around the world like saudi arabia and iran and other muslim majority countries is that they don't protect the minority rights in their own country israel does the opposite it protects its minority rights its religious and its cultural freedoms and in fact that's why i think you heard prime minister. israel is the only country the middle east that does that while at the same time finally defines in law israel's character as the nation state of the jewish people it