so he was he was as as later economists such as john maynard kane said you can't be a good economist if you're only an economist. by which he meant it if all you think about is cost and benefits and you have this kind of sociopath if at the center of your theory, you're not going to do economics very intelligently and adam smith set this pattern, but it was such a temptation to make it easier. you know, i don't want to read those books at philosophy. oh, i don't want to study history. oh, i don't want to no shakespeare make it easy make it easy and now it's become as easy as it can be and this is true of both marxist economics when i was a kid. i was a marxist and i was so thrilled by marxism because all you needed to know. was that tree of all hitherto existing societies is the history of class struggle. and end of your education and all you need to know in economics is cost modern economics is caused and benefits. so i think we need to get back to an educated. economics and your went from being a marxist to attending freedom fest the libertarian convention. today although i would i