the star witnesses, macneill's own daughters.sponsible for convincing prosecutors to bring charges against their father. >> ever since the day my mom died, i was concerned that my father killed her. and i've been fighting to get justice for this case ever since then. >> reporter: but the defense maintains michelle macneill died of a heart condition. as the medical examiner initially ruled. >> she certified the cause of death as being due to hypertension, cardiovascular disease. >> reporter: and the prosecution can't prove michelle was murdered at all. >> there is not evidence in this case that points to guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. >> reporter: now a jury of five men and three women deciding there was proof beyond a reasonable doubt of his guilt. the story jurors heard from prosecutors over the course of the 14-day trial was almost too strange to believe. it began on an april morning in 2007 in this gated community south of salt lake city, utah. a distraught-sounding martin macneill called 911. >> my wife has fall in in the b

macneill.n of justice, guilty. >> the verdict as you heard, that gasp and crying as we were told uncontrollably. martin macneill's family there. they long suspect he was behind the murder of their mother. >> we are joined by criminal defense attorney in philadelphia. jean, let's start with you, macneill's daughters waited for this moment. they believed this is justice for their mother. give us an idea about the feeling in the courtroom. >> reporter: victor, it was so intense. it was like you could feel people's hearts just beating outside of their bodies. the jury walked in with stoic silence. they did not look at the defendant as they passed by him. they sat and then the verdict was read. the judge said i don't want any outburst, but the daughters had fought so hard for the prosecution. it was excited utterance. the judge did not say anything. this was a very respected doctor here in provo, utah. it was the daughters and sisters to say no, this was not an accident. this was not a natural death

martin macneill will soon decide his fate. closing arguments today are recapping the evidence presented during the four-week trial. prosecutors told the jury that macneill had the motive and the means and the opportunity to kill his wife michele on the morning of april 11th, 2007. >> between 9:30 a.m. and about 11:00 a.m., no one really knows about martin macneill's whereabouts, and he had been at work that morning, certainly. and we know he was back at work by 11:00, because he places a phone call at 11:00 from his office. and had placed a phone call about 9:30, about 9:26 or so, i believe, from his office. but there's about an hour and a half period of time where no one really knows where martin is. >> in his closing argument, the defense pounced on one central fact in the case, three medical examiners all determined michele macneill died of natural causes. >> she had conducted her

macneill said he was innocent. his lawyers argued michele macneill died of a heart disorder. both sides spoke after the verdict. >> i'm disappointed. but i don't have comments. >> reporter: the prosecution put macneill's daughters on the stand, as well as two former inmates with macneill, saying he confessed to the murder. the defense maintained there was not enough evidence to convict macneill. martin macneill faces life in prison. he is scheduled to be sentenced on january 7th. >>> for more on this, let's bring in our chief legal analyst, and co-anchor of "nightline," dan abrams, who was covering this trial from the start. 11 hours. a lot of people think it should have been an open and shut case. >> 11 hours, not that quick for this kind of case. eight-person jury. so, a little easier to get unanimity among them, rather than a 12-person jury. the key question in this case, are the jurors going to be convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that she died at his hands. that was it. the medical examiner said we can't determine whether this was a murder for sure. initially they said

for robin macneil it was a milestone. first presidential trip as an nbc white house correspondent. he was assigned to cover president john kennedy's speech in dallas that afternoon, an anticipated rebuttal to the president's conservative critics. city officials beefed up security ahead of the visit. the previous month in dallas, united nations ambassador adlai stevenson was met by angry right-wing protestors to spat on him and struck him with signs. and thousands of anti-kennedy flyers accusing the president of treason had been distributed downtown in the days before his arrival. despite that backdrop, supporters turned out in droves outside the president's hotel in fort worth that morning where thofs give a speech before heading to dallas. it was a breakfast event for the chamber of commerce and first lady jackie kennedy stole the show, receiving a standing ovation upon her arrival. >> a few years ago i said that -- i introduced myself in paris by saying i was the man who accompanied mrs. kennedy to paris. i'm getting so

macneill of murdering his wife.ol their emotions. >> we the jury having reviewed the evidence and testimony in the case find the defendant as to count one murder guilty. >> we're just so happy he can't hurt anyone else. we miss our mom. we'll never get her back. but that courtroom was full of so many people who loved her. i looked around, and it was full of everyone who loved my mom. i can't believe this has finally happened. we're so grateful. >> wow. incredible. five daughters testifying against their dad. time for the legal guys here to look at where this case is going and look who i have here in person, richard herman! >> in the house! with the great fredricka whitfield, live and in color! >> usually out of new york and las vegas, today in atlanta. criminal defense attorney, good to see you, richard. avery, we have to get you down here, too. >> it looks incomplete to me. >> ha-ha-ha. joining us from cleveland, good to see you. really, we're having fun seeing one another, but this is a heartbreaking case we're ta

they suspected macneill of killing their mother so he could be with his mistress.g on january 7. >>> number two, typhoon haiyan is weakening as it heads towards vietnam, which is good news because it left death and utter destruction in so much of the philippines. the local red cross is estimating 12 million people were killed when the typhoon rolled ashore, flattening buildings and they expect the toll to go higher. >>> the olympic torch is making history. it's outside the international space station on its first space walk. two russian cosmonauts carried it into space earlier this hour. just a few minutes ago really. the torch will return to earth tomorrow to continue its relay leading up to the 2014 sochi olympics. >>> and number four, the fda is moving to take trans fats out of the food you eat. now, it's in a lot of processed foods -- frozen pizza, desserts, microwave popcorn, and maybe even the coffee creamer you used this morning. the major source of trans fat, partially hydrogenated oils. it increases the shelf life of the food and enhances the flavor, but t

macneill can answer that. there was an issue as to whether she was bent over the tub or whether she was fully in the tub and i think the way the testimony came in she was fully in the tub and that there's enough evidence that i would say not only drowning but death at the hands of another. i don't know who the other person is. >> okay. all right. so doctor, you know, i'll take this one to steve. steve, they say that the doctor had told that the doctor defendant husband two timing with a couple of mistresses had a -- told her doctor that she could take x, y and z medicine and that she took too much medicine. let's assume she took too much medicine. shouldn't the doctor, the other doctor have known that, you know, he recollectedn't give this much medication to a woman or risk drowning or not drowning but having a heart attack. >> the evidence has come out so far is that the drugs that were given were there in therapeutic amounts and if that's true, therapeutic amounts various drugs would not cause her to pass ou

it was planned all along, he said, and macneill left plenty of clues along the way. prosecutors proved macneill plied his wife with a deadly dose of drugs after insisting she have a face-lift. then, held her head under water in the bathtub until she drowned. all so he could marry his mistress, gypsy willis. >> who's in the bathtub? >> my wife. >> there's an hour and a half period of time where no one knows where martin is. rush home, take care of your business, give michelle the drugs, fix her up a bath, get her in the tub, hold her head down for a little while and help her out. >> reporter: defense attorney randy spencer spent a year preparing for the trial, devastated by the outcome. >> of course, i'm disappointed, but i don't have any comments right now. >> reporter: macneill faces 15 years to life for the murder of his wife of 30 years. >> what do you want to say to michelle right now? >> i love you, michele. i'm glad we could do this for you, and i felt her with us in there. >> just a short time ago, and now other news on a case we're watching, the u.s. navy chr

macneill can answer that.whether she was bent over the tub or whether she was fully in the tub and i think the way the testimony came in she was fully in the tub and that there's enough evidence that i would say not only drowning but death at the hands of another. i don't know who the other >> okay. all right. so doctor, you know, i'll take this one to steve. steve, they say that the doctor had told that the doctor defendant husband two timing with a couple of mistresses had a -- told her doctor that she could take x, y and z medicine and that she took too much medicine. let's assume she took too much medicine. shouldn't the doctor, the other doctor have known that, you know, he recollectedn't give this much medication to a woman or risk drowning or not drowning but having a heart attack. >> the evidence has come out so far is that the drugs that were given were there in therapeutic amounts and if that's true, therapeutic amounts various drugs would not cause her to pass out. >> i hear that the myocardial infr

the others did so off camera, still incarcerated and fearing for safety by snitching on macneill. inmates testified macneill confessed to killing his wife, but without actually saying it. >> he said he gave her some oxy and sleeping pills and got her to get in the bathtub. >> did he say what he did next? >> later on, he just said he had to help her out, and i asked him what that was, and he said he held her head under the water for a little while. he said that she was in the way, that she wanted the house and the kids. he said they couldn't prove that he, you know, did anything. >> reporter: prosecutors charged dr. macneill killed his wife of 30 years by drowning her in the family bathtub after plying her with a potent mix of medications, also he could marry his mistress, gypsy willis. >> i said hey, man, i apologize about your wife. he goes, i'm glad the bleep is dead. >> did he talk to you about the relationship he had with her before she died? >> they were going downhill. they are trying to get his money. she was not going to let him keep cheating on him, keep cheating on her.

still incarcerated and fearing for their safety by snitching on macneill. inmates testified that macneill confessed to killing his wife but without actually saying it. >> he said he gave her some oxy and some sleeping pills and then got her to get in the bathtub. >> did he say what he did next? >> later on, he just said he had to help her out and i asked him what that was and he said he held her head under the water for a little while. he said that she was in the way, that she wanted the house and the kids. he said they couldn't prove that he, you know, did anything. >> reporter: prosecutors charge dr. macneill killed his wife of 30 years by drowning her in the family bathtub after giving her a potent mix of medications so he could marry his mistress gypsy willis. >> i said i apologize about your wife. he said, no, i'm glad the bitch is dead. >> did martin talk to at all about the relationship he had with his wife before she died? >> there was going downhill, that they were trying to get his money and she was not going to let him keep cheating on him, keep

macneill's former mistress testified.she moved into the family's home days after macneill's wife died. aphrodites jones is here this afternoon. the host of true crime on investigative discovery. you think he did it but you don't think he will get convicted? >> i think he did it without a question. all his behavior, shep, everything he does, does and did from the time she died to now, speaks volumes about guilt. but there is november evidence to convict this man? is there proof? we don't even know how she died. the medical experts can't conclude that this was a homicide. which is shades of casey anthony. >> what was the problem with the medical examiner? not being able to -- they said is it possible this is how she died? is it possible he did what we came? and he's like, it's possible but that's a hypothetical. >> exactly. the rope is she had drugs in her system and did have a heart condition, and there is a natural cause between the drugs and the heart condition that could have led to her death. there was only one medical

macneill says he is innocent.imony resumes on tuesday, prison inmates who served time with macneill after his 2009 fraud conviction are expected to take the stand. prosecutors say macneill gave a detailed confession to one of the men. and allegedly boasted that police would never be able to prove it was murder. for "good morning america," aditi roy, abc news, los angeles. >> such a fascinating case. so many twists and turns. we will continue to cover it. >>> meantime, time for a check of the weather and over to ginger zee. hey, ginger. >> hey, there. as a reminder, daylight saving time ends as we go into the overnight and into early sunday. so, we'll get that extra hour of sleep. we'll be good. we'll be all rested. bags are gone. let's go ahead and look at the forecast, though. close to record highs in miami. 89. ft. lauderdale, if they make it to 90, they would tie a record. that's ahead of the cold front. that will move through central florida, bringing scattered showers and thunderstorms. atlanta, under 70. nas

. >>> and martin macneill. former doctor on trial for the murder of his wife. today prosecutors call on their secret weapon. farmers presents: fifteen seconds of smart. so you want to drive more safely? stop eating. take deep breaths. avoid bad weather. [ whispers ] get eight hours. ♪ [ shouts over music ] turn it down! and, of course, talk to farmers. hi. hi. ♪ we are farmers bum - pa - dum, bum - bum - bum - bum ♪ >>> shocking revelations about the 2012 campaign. among them, advisers re considered replacing joe biden with hillary rodham clinton because she was so popular in the polls. this is a soon to be released book. that isn't the only clinton drama. it also talks about the long strained relationship between barack obama and bill clinton. the new york time obtained a copy and summarized it this way. when the two golfed together in september 2011, an effort aides hoped would bring them closer, they didn't even finish 18 holes. obama grimaced and applied, i like him in dose. the author's write. things clintons very well. and counsellor to president clinton

macneill will be sentenced january 7th. his attorneys did not say whether they will appeal. >>> a grand jury indicted 11 people in connection with a confrontation between an suv driver and swarm of bikers in new york. one of those indicted, an off duty police detective riding with the bikers on september 29th, footage of the incident went viral after being posted online. the bikers accused of assaulting the suv driver in front of his wife and two-year-old daughter after he hit three bikers with his vehicle. >>> the iran nuclear talks will likely end today without an agreement, that according to reuters. six of the world's major powers, including the u.s., are in geneva, negotiating the future of iran's nuclear program. if no deal is reached, talks could continue in a few weeks. britain's foreign secretary says there's been good progress, but flexibility is needed to broker a deal. >>> he vowed to block all presidential nominations until he gets answers on the benghazi attack. senator lindsey graham made that after an explos

macneill says he is innocent.timony resumes on tuesday, prison inmates who served time with macneill after his 2009 fraud conviction are expected to take the stand. prosecutors say macneill gave a detailed confession to one of the men. and allegedly boasted that police would never be able to prove it was murder. for "good morning america," aditi roy, abc news, los angeles. >> such a fascinating case. so many twists and turns. we will continue to cover it. >>> meantime, time for a check of the weather and over to ginger zee. hey, ginger. >> as a reminder, daylight saving time begins tonight. after 2:00 a.m., it goes forward. we'll get extra sleep. we'll be good. we'll be all rested. bags are gone. let's go ahead and look at the forecast, though. south florida, really the only place ahead of that front still. still, miami, close to 90 today. let's look at what it looks like this morning. not in miami. we're going to hollywood beach. ft. lauderdale's high is 90. you see areas close to record highs. but not behind the

>> i would say, at the point when i came to stay with the macneills. >> reporter: she says it was macneill'sove her into the family home shortly after michele's funeral. did you ever think to yourself, this would be a terrible idea, for me to come in and be the family nanny? >> yes, i did. >> reporter: and did you say to him, martin, no way. are you kidding me? >> i did. i thought it would be better if things had -- everyone had time to regroup. he was rather insistent that he needed help. >> reporter: do you still love him? >> i care about him on a deep soul level. i'm concerned about him. i hope he's well. he's a kindred spirit. and i loved him very much when we were together. >> reporter: if you had never met martin macneill, do you believe michele macneill would be alive today? >> i believe michelle died of natural causes. so i believe that has no bearing on michele's life. >> reporter: if you had never met him, she would have died exactly the same way? >> i believe so. >> gypsy willis was investigated in connection with the death of michele macneill. but never charged. her lawyer told m

kill macneil. that macneil killed his wife. listen to his testimony, here. >> he had different shoes on and stuff like that. i just kind of cracked a joke to him saying can i get a paver those shoes? he said no, you can't. i said how do you get away with that? and he is like can i get away with a lot of things, he said i'm getting away with murdering my wife. >> i'm getting away with murdering my wife. prosecutors are trying to persuade the jury that macneil forced his wife to get a face lift so that he could knock her out with pain killers. they claim he left her to die in a bathtub so that he could be with his mistress. the defense claims macneil's wife died of a heart condition. according to the salt lake city tribune the newspaper there, the cell mate who testified today received a plea deal in a theft case next change for cooperation on this. but, according to court records he told investigators he wanted to testify because of his, quote, morals. now, amanda knox and her murder case is in its

martin macneill is now awaiti ntencing in the dth of michele macneill. precutors had argued that macneill drugged and drowned his wife in the bathtub of their home in apr of007 so he could be with his stress. more on that story the next hour. >>> we head to switzerland. talks between secretary of stat john kerry and severoreign ministers from sever other countries. ann curry is live in geneva with more. good morning to yo ann. >> good morning to you, craig. >> rorter: six othe wod's foreign ministers have unexpected gathered among stng signs a nuclear deal with ir may be near. the this mornin the french foreign ministerroke ranks and said publicly that france won't accept wt he called a sucker's deal. he also revled the debat is ov the way to reduce iran's capability to make atomic reps use maria te yum and rish uranium. so far no wordrom the other foreign ministers but john kerry did meet with aoreign minister afte his meing. nbc news has leaed that iran is readyo sign the crent aft on the table of the first stepgreement and waiting for the dlomats in t

one said he got to know macneill in the chicken coop an 18-man cell and macneill told him he'd neverer my wife, if i did, they don't have any evidence. >> reporter: another inmate claimed he use the the "b" talking about his wife. >> i said what did you do? he said the [ bleep ] drowned. >> you understand by informing on somebody while you're in prison has the potential to reduce your sentence? >> reporter: macneill's defense tried attacking the credibility of the inmates' testimony by insinuating they could get something in return for helping prosecutors which they denied. >> why are you here? >> because i got something to say and it's the truth. >> reporter: two more inmates are said to testify before gypsy willis, when court resumes this morning, then it is on to the defense case, which is expected to be short, in fact the jury could start deliberating dr. macneill's fate by the end of the week. ted rowlands, cnn, provo, utah. >> all right, ladies and gentlemen, you just saw it, it was supposed to be the knockout punch but did it miss its mark, let's bring in danny cevallos, crimi

captioning sponsored by macneil/lehrer productions >> that's on me. i mean, we fumbled the rollout on this health care law. >> ifill: in an extended news conference, a contrite president offers a temporary fix to those losing their health insurance and confronts other issues dogging his second term. good evening. i'm gwen ifill. >> woodruff: and i'm judy woodruff. also ahead this thursday, the grim recovery efforts continue in devastated parts of the philippines, but the picture is still one of loss and despair. >> ifill: we have the first tv interview with the new head of the bureau of alcohol, tobacco, firearms and explosives. b. todd jones talks about the challenge of reigning in gun violence. >> we're really operating with 20th century technology in the 21st century. >> woodruff: and robert macneil returns to talk about his latest novel. >> ifill: those are just some of the stories we're covering on tonight's pbs newshour. >> major funding for the pbs newshour has been provided by: ♪ ♪ moving our economy for 160 years. bnsf, the engine that connec

macneil to the stand.that when the prosecution rests the defense says it has three more witnesses, it is possible among them, possible, we don't know, that the doctor could be one of them. do you call him? >> i would be shocked if he is called to the stand. he has a fraud conviction. so much strange behavior after his wife dies he will be cross-examined solely bit by bit. allegations he might have tampered with evidence. he might have faked performing cpr he could notwithstand the cross-examination. i don't believe he will be called. harris: dan schorr, wearing two hats, what you do if you were the defense and i know what you do with the prosecution, you said you would tear him abart. good to see you both, thank you very much. >> thank you. >> some tiny tigers just 13 weeks old, they are getting a big test today at the national zoo. we'll tell you what these little guys are up to next. >>> big day in the national zoo because of brand new sumantra tiger cubs. they are 13 years old and have to take a swim te

inmate number one said he befriended macneill while the two were in a texas prison where macneill servedther fellow inmate from the utah county jail, also told jurors, macneill made damning statements. >> he said i'm getting away with murdering my wife. >> did martin talk to you about the relationship he had with his wife before she died? >> a little bit, yes. it was going downhill. they were trying to get his money. and she was not going to let him keep cheating on her. >> did he say whether he actually was cheating on her? >> oh, yeah. he told me about his girlfriend. >> reporter: the defense tried to discredit the inmates. >> you agreed to the deal that you wanted? >> that i wanted, no. he agreed to help me out a little bit. >> what was the help you anticipated? >> i wanted to have my record expunged. when they said they could help out a little bit, i said, i still want to do this. >> reporter: court is in session right now and more dramatic testimony could come together as testimony could come today, as macneill's purported mistress, gypsy willis, is expected to take the stand again.

macneill appeared fixed, purposely containing himself is the way people described him being in court. the defense had said the evidence against him was circumstantial and it had taken the prosecution some years to build the case. michelle died in 2007. what didn't come out in court is the macneill's arrest warrant contained an ex-girlfriend's explosive accusation that he killed a brother in a bathtub and that he tried to murder his mother some years ago. macneill will be sentenced on january 7th, and he faces up to 15 years to life. >> there were two girlfriends. any word of an appeal yet? since it was a circumstantial case, as you mentioned? >> you know what, this came very late in the night. we actually haven't heard from either the prosecution or the defense in their public statements made immediately after. we suspect because it was circumstantial there is room for that. we will see what happens before the sentencing. back to you. >> all right, thanks so much. on that late verdict reached last night. thank you. kelly. >>> we're talking some fox extreme weather out there. the red c

captioning sponsored by macneil/lehrer productions >> woodruff: the food and drug administration said today companies may soon have to eliminate artery-clogging artificial trans fats from their products. good evening. i'm judy woodruff. >> ifill: and i'm gwen ifill. also ahead this thursday, wall street's all a-twitter. the social media giant goes public, turning 140-character messages into a company now valued in the tens of billions. >> woodruff: and in one colorado county, health insurance costs are much higher than in the rest of the state, complicating the push to get the uninsured signed up for new plans.

macneil. dr.neil doesn't have a actually track record from it comes to his veracity and truthfulness. it will come down to her credibility and the battle of experts. he is claiming he was allegedly sleep walking during these alleged activities. jon: usually identity of victims of sex crimes is not reported but alexis summers has been quite public wanting this case prosecuted. brian to another case now. there are new reports that one of the stars hit vhi reality show, "mob wives", ordered armed thugs to abduct a man off a new york city street so she could shake him down for cash and jewelry, supposedly, she had given the guy $10,000 the story goes. he was supposed to get tickets to an nba all-star game and resell them and make a lot of money. how do you go about proveing a case like this, brian? >> thanks i didn't book my nba hotel room where this gentleman was supposed to reserve those rooms. i would have paid way too much. but, look i think these charges ought to be dropped or at least they shoul

nearly six years after michelle macneill was killed.rosecutors argued martin macneill knock it out his wife with drugs after cosmetic surgery, then helped her into a bathtub where she drowned. the motive, to continue seeing a mistress on the side. macneill faces life in prison, he will be sentenced in january. >>> well, there is growing tension now between the united states and its closest ally in the middle east, if secretary of state john kerry and other u.s. allies try to reach a deal with iran on curbing it's nuclear clear program. now the u.s. sa now. >> reporter: israeli prime minister benjamin netanyahu is not happy with the direction these talks in geneva are taking, condemning talks on easing sanctions on iran. netanyahu has pushed to increase sanctions on iran and to prevent any nuclear ambition they may have. he has held this position for nearly two decades now and the championing the world plus, in the past few days, he's issued several strong statements condemning the u.s. a and international attempts to ease sanctions ther

. >>> still to come martin macneill on crime for the murder of his wife.vering his story. today a special report when prosecutors called on their secret weapon. but with a mortgage. and the furniture's a lot nicer. and suddenly, the most important person in my life is someone i haven't even met yet. who matters most to you says the most about you. at massmutual we're owned by our policyowners, and they matter most to us. as you plan your next step, we'll help you get there. because what you don't know, can hurt you.urance. what if you didn't know that posting your travel plans online may attract burglars? [woman] off to hawaii! what if you didn't know that as the price of gold rises, so should the coverage on your jewelry? [prospector] ahh! what if you didn't know that kitty litter can help you out of a slippery situation? the more you know, the better you can plan for what's ahead. talk to farmers and get smarter about your insurance. ♪ we are farmers bum - pa - dum, bum - bum - bum - bum♪ ♪ nothing, that's what? that's why i take prilosec otc each mornin

martin macneill?s. >> reporter: for more than two hours thursday, with four witnesses, including one of the defendant's former colleagues, macneill's attorneys built a time line to show the utah physician's whereabouts on the day his wife died. >> we had two interactions that day. the first one was as he was leaving to pick up his kindergartner from her morning kindergarten, about a block or two away from the developmental center. >> reporter: prosecutors say macneill killed his wife, michele, by giving her a deadly dose of painkillers and putting her in a tub while she was recovering from plastic surgery. macneill says he is innocent. the state says his motive was to continue an affair with gypsy willis. >> you continued holding yourself out as husband and wife? >> i believe so. >> reporter: did you get a marriage license? >> we did get a marriage lines license. we didn't actually get married, though. >> reporter: willis back on the stand thursday this time as the prosecution's last witness, reading

martin macneill. this is a blow to prosecutors who claim macneill drugged his wife and drown her in a bathtub so he could be with his mistress. today, the state plans to call inmates macneill met in prison who claim he admitted to them that he killed his wife. >>> is holiday shopping on your mined? walmart is already out to get a jump on black friday and cybermonday. they're kicking off their online deals today, people. that is a full three weeks before the traditional black friday. that seems crazy, doesn't it? not so much when you consider thanksgiving falls on the 28th. there are six fewer shopping days this year. they're pushing it up. making my anxiety rise. >> six fewer? >> six fewer. >> good. >> i understand where you're going with it but people make hay while the sun shines. >> less is more when it comes to shopping. >> you know how shoppers are. >> still i will shop on the very last day. >> i agree. >> are you a last-minute shopper. >> nothing like a deadline. >> less is more. >>> coming up o

macneill never told you that he killed his wife, correct?me he killed his wife. >> reporter: the prisoners said they took a liking to the doctor during his time in prison and had no animosity toward him. >> i never had a problem with doc. >> do you have any problem with him now? >> i don't have a problem with him now. i really hope he didn't do it, to be honest. >> reporter: jean casarez, utah. >>> we're hearing more alarming story from michelle knight about the 11-year ordeal at the hands of ariel castro. she said she was treated like an animal by her abductor, constantly chained to a pole. >> you just laid on the concrete floor in the dark? >> well, it was kind of like being like this, because i couldn't lay down. because the pole would hold me up. >> because of the chain around your neck? >> yes. >> were you able to sleep some? >> no, i just mainly passed out from the chain being around my neck. >> this really just takes your breath away, doesn't it? more from that interview coming up in the next half our of "early start." >>> an emotiona

martin macneill has been convicted of killing his wife. huge for prosecutors in making their case. his wife's sister and niece were there as well. they're going to join us now from provo, utah. linda cluff is michele macneill's sister, jill haar per smith, michele's niece. thank you for joining us this morning. >> you're welcome. >> you're welcome. >> linda, starting with you, can you, please, tell us about who your sister was, up until now, she's just been the function of this murder case, but who was lost? we know she was beautiful. we know her daughters felt she was so devoted to them and a great mother. how did you know her? >> she was a wonderful sister as well. growing up with her, she was such an achiever. she was great in school. she was fun-loving, had many friends, one that would always go for any activity, cheerleading, drama, just had so much potential that we all looked up to her in administration, and she just had so much potential, and just had a funny sense of humor as well. she could make anybody laugh. she was one that ha

martin macneill will also be allowed to speak.o you. >> it will be interesting to see if he does say anything there. >>> still to come on "new day," before you even think about making a friendly wager on one of today's football games, you need to sthee this. >> are you videoing? >> yes. >> you got to -- >> how one couple's high-risk bet ended with an arrest and a really angry wife. >> you know, veterans day coming up, and that's one of the times that we say thank you to all of you who serve our country, and service members aren't the only ones who work really hard on the battle field. >>> for a lot of people in the military, service dogs are a key part of daily operations. and as this week's veterans in focus show us, returning home is a whole lot sweeter when you're with your best friend. >> reporter: 8-year-old diego doesn't say much. in fact, he never barks. this yellow lab spent the better part of his life talking with his nose and helping his country in the process. now retired, this former military bomb-sniffing dog has a ne

macneill. they're expected to testify that dr. macneill said that he was glad his wife was dead. you. jon: let's talk about this with our legal panel, criminal defense attorney john man orwellian along with rebecca rose woodland. there was also testimony from a former alleged mistress, anna osborn walthal who said that about two years before his wife died dr. macneill said, quote: there's something you can give someone that's not detectable that causes them to have a heart attack. two years later, lo and behold, his wife is dead. rebecca, it's an awful lot of circumstantial evidence, but is it enough to convict? >> what we're looking at here, jon, is evidence the prosecution is putting on that will go to motive. so what the prosecution has to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that this man committed murder. murder is the intentional killing with a motive. so the prosecution's putting these people on, person after person, methodically to show the motive. not only did he have a mistress prior to the mistress that came into the home, today claim weeks after his wife had passed away, b

macneill maintains he is innocent.ne of his former inmates say he approached macneill, after finding a magazine article about his wife in the prison library. >> i said, doc, they say you murdered your wife. he was like, i didn't murder my wife. if i did, they don't have any evidence. >> he just mentioned that they couldn't prove it. that medication she was taking, given him, prescribed. >> did he say whether he did or didn't kill her? >> he just said, they can't prove it was me. >> reporter: all of the inmates said macneill told them he didn't kill his wife, two said he used derogatory words to describe her. >> i said, man, they told me that you killed your wife. and he said, if they could prove that, do you think i'd be sitting here talking with you? so, i said, what did you do? he said, [ bleep ]. >> he referred to her as a [ bleep ]? >> yes, sir. >> okay. >> reporter: the jury is expected to hear from one more fellow inmate today. and prosecutors will wrap up their case today or tomorrow. and that's when the defense

plus, robert macneil is with us to talk about his latest book. i'm judy woodruff. >> ifill: and i'm gwen ifill. we'll see you online and again here tomorrow evening. for all of us here at the "pbs newshour," thank you and good night. >> major funding for the pbs newshour has been provided by: ♪ ♪ moving our economy for 160 years. bnsf, the engine that connects us. >> and with the ongoing support of these institutions and foundations. and... >> this program was made possible by the corporation for public broadcasting. and by contributions to your pbs station from viewers like you. thank you. captioning sponsored by macneil/lehrer productions captioned by media access group at wgbh access.wgbh.org >> funding of this presentation is made possible by the freeman foundation, newman's own foundation, giving all profits to charity and pursuing the common good for over 30 years, united healthcare, and union bank. >> at union bank, our relationship managers work hard to know your business, offering specialized solutions and capital to help you meet your g

but macneill says he is innocent. >> your mom was happy. she was feeling a little sick.u said, right? >> i don't remember her saying she was feeling a little sick. i remember her being up and getting ready for the day. >> you remembered it on the day of her funeral, right? >> i don't remember her feeling bad at all. she was feeling great. >> reporter: the defense maintains michele macneill died of a heart disorder, which is what the original examiner concluded. but the chief medical examiner amended the cause of death to undetermined. saying drug toxicity may have played a role, too. and the investigation was reopened. >> if you learned that the defendant or somebody had told others that he had drugged up michele macneill and convinced her to get in the tub and held her down, would that scenario be consistent with how michele macneill died here? >> certainly is possible. >> reporter: testimony resumes today, with fellow inmates of macneill expected to take the stand. for "good morning america," aditi roy, abc news, los angeles. >>> we're going to turn to legal affairs an

plus, robert macneil is with us to talk about his latest book. i'm judy woodruff. >> ifill: and i'm gwen ifill. we'll see you online and again here tomorrow evening. for all of us here at the "pbs newshour," thank you and good night. >> major funding for the pbs newshour has been provided by: ♪ ♪ moving our economy for 160 years. bnsf, the engine that connects us. >> and with the ongoing support of these institutions and foundations. and... >> this program was made possible by the corporation for public broadcasting. and by contributions to your pbs station from viewers like you. thank you. captioning sponsored by macneil/lehrer productions captioned by media access group at wgbh access.wgbh.org

with this guilty verdict, martin macneill looking at 15 years to life. he will be sentenced in early january. fred. >> thank you so much, ted rowlands. >>> hawaii is about to become the next state to legalize same-sex marriage. the house of representatives approved the measure last night. the senate passed it late last night. governor neal abercrombie plans to sign it into law. illinois lawmakers also signed to make same-sex marriage legal. >>> a french satellite is about to come crashing to earth any day now. any day we'll find out why no one has any idea where it will hit. ♪ norfolk southern what's your function? ♪ ♪ hooking up the country helping business run ♪ ♪ build! we're investing big to keep our country in the lead. ♪ load! we keep moving to deliver what you need. and that means growth, lots of cargo going all around the globe. cars and parts, fuel and steel, peas and rice, hey that's nice! ♪ norfolk southern what's your function? ♪ ♪ helping this big country move ahead as one ♪ ♪ norfolk southern how's that function? ♪ so i tried depend it real

plus, robert macneil is with us to talk about his latest book. i'm judy woodruff. >> ifill: and i'm gwen ifill. we'll see you online and again here tomorrow evening. for all of us here at the "pbs newshour," thank you and good night. >> major funding for the pbs newshour has been provided by: ♪ ♪ moving our economy for 160 years. bnsf, the engine that connects us. >> and with the ongoing support of these institutions and foundations. and... >> this program was made possible by the corporation for public broadcasting. and by contributions to your pbs station from viewers like you. thank you. captioning sponsored by macneil/lehrer productions captioned by media access group at wgbh access.wgbh.org  >>> this is "nightly business report" with tyler mathisen and susie gharib brought to you in part by. >> thestreet.com. up to the minute stock market news and in depth analysis. our quant ratings service provides objective independent ratings daily on over 4300 stocks. learn more at the street.com/nbr. >>> numbers game, the department of

macneil. if we remember he came out and told coworkers that his wife fell in the tub that makes absolutely no sense because it contradicts what was found on the crime scene. a person just doesn't fall in a tub, face up, with all their clothing on. if this was an accident, she would have been bent over the side. she would have had bruising, something consistent with a fall. if he would have kept his mouth shut and not said anything, that's right there would have been a good defense. because he did, i think they're going to lose. harris: brian, i want to push in with that. you think there is another reason telling they might lose, all inmates from the time the doctor spent 21 months in a federal prison down in texas because of fraud. these inmates he talked with, not a good sign they keep calling them to the stand. why not? >> well, here's the thing with jailhouse snitches. you know when i was a prosecutor i hated working with these types of witnesses because they have got credibility problems.

. >> reporter: the 2007 death of -year-old former beauty queen miche mack 23450e8 was -- macneill was never ruled a homicide a jury in thmonth-long trial of her husba dr. martin mcneil called it fit-degree murder. we the jury having reviewed e evidence and testiny in the case find the defendant guilty. [ screaming ] >> we are just so happy he can't hurt anyone else. >> reporr: mcneil, a provo doctor and forr mormon bishop said hwasn't home when his wifeovercome b painkillers, following plastic surgery, he insisted she undergo drned in the family bathtub. he called it an accint. his demeanor was oddly panicked for a doctor >> fallein the bathtub. >> who's in the bathtub? who's in the bathtub? my wife! >> okay. is she conscus? >> she's not. she's not. i'm a physician. >> reporter:t wasn't until his ownaughters pressed their spicions for five years that macneill was charged with muer. the motive, they said, to continue a affaiwith gypsy will, his lg time misstress. they said his faer pretended she was a stranger he justet. >> remember, i love you mo than y love me. >> reporter: before hi

macneill died, allegedly murdered, dr.roposing to gypsy in front of a crowd of people. >> okay, we look for jigypsy ye again on the stand. we'll continue this conversation as you're following this trial out of provo. we can watch you on hln at 7:00 p.m. eastern time. >>> and now this -- >>> a miami dolphin is accusing a teammate of bullying, and now another nfl player is stepping forward, saying it's the apparent victim's fault for letting it happen. i'm brooke baldwin. the news is now. >>> just in to cnn, new research shows autism could be detected in the first months of life. find out what this means for the mysterious disorder. >>> a young hunter is paralyzed from the neck down. and decides he wants to die. hear why his decision is so rare. >>> plus, patriotic or poor taste? a football team's new uniforms showing blood splatter to honor those who fight. >>> and the market for marijuana expected to grow faster than smartphones. is america changing right before our very eyes? >>> and we roll on. i'm brooke baldwin. i have

here's cnn's ted rowlands. >> go on the record in the matter of state of utah versus martin macneill.e in the hands of a jury this afternoon after crucial closing arguments. prosecutors are expected to push their theory that the doctor had an elaborate plan to kill his wife, 50-year-old michele macneill, first convincing her to haves could metdic surgery and then using her medication he drugged her so he could drown her in a bathtub. >> it is complex, a number of facts that need to be tied together. that's what we're attempting to do now. >> dearest when your letter arrived -- >> reporter: the motive was macneill's girlfriend, prosecutors say, gypsy willis. she was brought back on the stand thursday as the state's final witness. prosecutors had her read portions of love letters she and macneill sent each other while both served time in federal prison for lying to investigators after michele's death. willis says their relationship was over but the letters were comforting. >> i found myself in prison for two years as a result of being with this guy and that was terrifying to me. >> miss