margaret mitchell has a short supplementary _ minister. _ just heard. specifically on their government signing a - just heard. specifically on their| government signing a certificate just heard. specifically on their- government signing a certificate on the fact there were no other documents after you had successfully petitioned for more documents and they said there was nothing relevant. he signed that on behalf of the scottish government? and there are a few parts to this. everybody else wants to come in as well so _ everybody else wants to come in as well so ask— everybody else wants to come in as well so ask it all at once.— well so ask it all at once. would it be the respondent _ well so ask it all at once. would it be the respondent who _ well so ask it all at once. would it be the respondent who was - well so ask it all at once. would it be the respondent who was the i be the respondent who was the permanent secretary of the interested party who was the first minister or who would be if not signing it who was responsible for what wa

thank you, i think - margaret mitchell has questions as well. , ., ., margaret mitchell has questionsd make it public, we would _ what we could make it public, we would be — what we could make it public, we would be hitting the ground running. semi question is to you, and i understand and agree entirely that democratic accountability and this parliament's ability to hold any government of the day to account, if it feels— government of the day to account, if it feels it _ government of the day to account, if it feels it has acted unlawfully, if it feels it has acted unlawfully, if it feels— it feels it has acted unlawfully, if it feels it — it feels it has acted unlawfully, if it feels it has acted unlawfully, if it feels it has abused its power, or if it is— it feels it has abused its power, or if it is merely so incompetent that it is tantamount to that. you've suggested that you think the powers or there _ suggested that you think the powers or there is _ suggested that you think the powers or there is a present government that are — or there is a present government that are not usi

i don't know if you saw this they fired ai researcher margaret mitchell, the second termination insideutspoken critic of the ai practices. then you have a report out from our own about the disorder behind its program for black college students, jon. i mean, not to get too granular on the internals of google's hr but it certainly is ringing loud around the valley. >> yeah. got to say at least they had a prime program for black college students, so many in tech, in media, that haven't made any significant pushes in the direction of the underrepresented, so there's that as much as they are trying to argue for progress and for their contributions to it, these actions speak so loudly when you are losing women, women of color who are highly placed in your organization in a way that's public it's something that management certainly, i hope, will answer for in a more detailed way than thus far >> yeah, and, jon, it's worth noting the importance of the fact these women -- these women of color were in the artificial intelligence division. carl, there's been so much conversation about the power o

just to follow on from margaret mitchell's questioning._ mitchell's questioning. the evidence we have received showed that there were voices who supported a robust response _ were voices who supported a robust response to — were voices who supported a robust response to the revelations of the me too— response to the revelations of the me too movement, as did the presiding _ me too movement, as did the presiding officer of parliament, the head of— presiding officer of parliament, the head of the uk civil service, the permanent secretary. msps and all parties _ permanent secretary. msps and all parties spoke up. a response, so do you agree _ parties spoke up. a response, so do you agree that putting in place a sexual— you agree that putting in place a sexual harassment procedure was absolutely necessary but also in line with — absolutely necessary but also in line with the consensus view across the political spectrum in scotland? well, _ the political spectrum in scotland? well, as— the political spectrum in scotland? well, as far as current