it is mark lacroix former senior.s been a year with sunshine task force where the sunshine ordinance for this close session from january 12, 2022 that was noticed in disciplinary in separation cases. in the fire commission's defense they wrote a letter head to the sunshine ordinance task force that they're discussing members separations during this close session. the sunshine task force determined that there were violations of the sunshine ordinance that took place in the session and they ordered the record to be made public. so that's what you're voting on today, i do believe. i would like to read from the government guide one short paragraph it's under rules of commissioners and vs to do with quasi judicial proceedings. quote, commissioners should not talk about orders commissioners should make their decisionses on the basis as evident presented them rather than the views their fellow commissioners. so the commissioner admitted that they were talking about member separations well before the separations hearings was