that is essentially the board saying, thus mark zuckerberg saying he supports mark zuckerberg. we need to start having that independent leadership on the board of directors going forward. emily: that said, mark zuckerberg was asked this question on a press call yesterday. take a listen to what he had to say. >> for the board's composition -- i don't particularly think that specific proposal is the right way to go. but i'm quite focused on finding ways to get more independence into our systems in different ways which is one of the big proposals i'm talking about that i discussed in the note is around this independent body for appeals. emily: so, jonas, no sign that mark zuckerberg wants to change anything. as we know, he holds the majority of shares and forcing that change upon him will be very difficult. what is your response to him? jonas: i appreciate that he seems to be looking for opportunities to bring that level of independence into the board of directors, or at least into the company in some capacity. i respectfully would have to disagree. i think we are seeing clearly t

mark zuckerberg and cheryl sandbergs' backs.public statement last week the board said to suggest they knew about the russian interference or tried to prevent investigations into what happened is grossly unfair. in the last 18 months facebook with the full support of its board has invested heavily in more people and better technology to prevent misuse of its services including during election. we should note zuckerberg and sanders are members of the same board standing behind them. my next guest has long been sounding an alarm for a change n the structure at facebook. for years, julie, you've been clamoring for a change in the share structure given the power that zuckerberg himself holds. what do you think now? julie: well, i think they should have changed the share structure in 2015 when we first filed the shareholder resolution. you know, this is the problem with corporate governance when you have an insider board and really mark zuckerberg has the power to fire any one of his board members at any time whafment that does is, as

so, mark zuckerberg's decision not to appear here at westminster today to me speaks volumes.e right assessment on what can properly appear on its platform... it has become a serious threat to modern democracy... do you accept that facebook needs to be regulated...? at the weekend, documents were seized by a commons official from an american executive whose firm, the maker of an app hunting down bikini photos, is in a legal dispute with facebook. why didn't facebook disclose that as a company...? the man who ordered this highly unusual move described one seized e—mail which he said suggested facebook had known about russian interference for years. an engineer at facebook, noted by the company in october 2014, that entities with russian ip addresses have been using a pinterest api key to pull over three billion data points a day through the ordered friend's api. now, was that reported to any external body at the time...? facebook later released a statement saying the engineers who had flagged their concerns subsequently looked into this further and found no evidence of specific

>> good morning, lauren and gerri, facebook ceo mark zuckerberg says it's unfair after his company isng treated after they struggled russian activity and timely manner. >> i said before that we were too slow to stop russian interference and slow to get on top of it. we stumbled along the way but to suggest that we weren't interested in knowing the truth or we we wanted to hide what we knew or try to prevent investigations is simplien -- simply untrue. >> tried to hide and down play the scoab of russian interference problem from anyone. shares of facebook down a percentage point. .6% this year. lauren: okay, i got they got hit more than that. how is apple moving to the movie business. >> tech giant is partnering with movie studio a23, expanding on original content, investment that began with original tv shows, the new york-based studio will produce multiple films for apple, apple planned to invest more than $1 billion if original content in the past year and so far apple shares are up. gerri: 824 is super cool. how much did the david hockey painting pulled off? >> $93 million, most exp

plus, where is mark zuckerberg? u.k.awmakers are angry that the facebook ceo did not turn up to answer questions tweeting out a photograph of his empty chair. the chinese backed silicon valley designed car's makers will hope to speak past tesla in china. we talked to the ceo about the race to the chinese ev market. to the top story. apple shares were hit hard after trump implied he might include iphone in the tariffs. tim cook is spending the day with ivanka trump touring schools. this provides an extended conversation with the president's daughter and senior advisor before trump holds a key meeting with xi jinping in but with our rights -- in but authorities -- buenos ares. our next guest has a bayreuth redone apple on $220 and with us from -- -- our next guest has a buy apple.for tom, let's start with you. you are watching china very carefully saying it is the biggest single threat to shares of apple. how seriously are you taking this threat for president trump? >> i think today, you have to assume everything out of ch

plus, mark zuckerberg's on defense, how the facebook ceo is responding to new attacks and the calls for him to step down. we'll talk about that and millions of americans hitting the road, taking to the skies, ahead of this thanksgiving holiday what you need to know, before you leave the house. >> susan: let's give back to the markets and the dow cutting gains at the close being dragged and weighed by shares of johnson & johnson, mcdonald's and also jpmorgan. phil flynn is watching the action in the oil markets from the cm e, gerri willis on the floor of the new york stock exchange, gerri let's first get to you. gerri: well what a turnaround we've had in the last few moment s the dow now negative as you say just barely, the s&p 500 still in the positive as is the nasdac right now. let me tell you what traders are telling me on the floor of the exchange here is that it was really a rollover in oil. oil prices, sent the major indexes plummeting, from its high today, the dow was up 200 points, and it's worse as you can see, down one point and change. let's look at the technology the big sto

mark zuckerberg does not play well in front of these guys.bezos was hated by the liberal, he was hated by conservatives. now he says we will deal with the dod. he is the darling. mark zuckerberg can't figure out the political process so i think it's best to keep them out of the limelight. >> but then why bring up cheryl? she is to politically connected. she is from washington, the political world, she will not appoint harry reputation on the line by sitting on that chair. that is my opinion and why i would think she is not stepping in in this role. so zuckerberg -- >> i did nothing facebook readership can win either way. no matter who you put, they will not win. this is a bunch of politicians that just want to get soundbites. they want to make themselves look good and they want to make facebook look like the great big bad enemy. i don't think they can possibly win. what they're probably looking for anything a lot of social media is looking for is, as much as i hate regulation, they want somebody outside to say, here is the line. because other

i think a lot of people watching to see what mark zuckerberg, what the leadership will do.own with him today. i asked him about the allegations. he defended the company and the leadership. take a listen. i want to start with some of the revelations that came from the new york times piece. >> sure. >> reporter: let's look at russia. did you and other leaders try to minimize russia in spreading propaganda on the platform? >> no. here's what happened. in 2016 there was no doubt that we missed something really important. right? the russian effort to try to have these coordinated information operations on facebook and also the internet was not something we were expecting. elections are always high security events. and we were expecting certain kinds of cyber attacks. we found them. the russians were trying to hack into specific accounts and we told the people and the fbi and all that. but we weren't on top of these coordinated information operations. so we've spent a lot of the last couple of years now basically building up our systems and strengthening them to be able to addres

mark zuckerberg says he has her back. we will discuss. counting the cyber monday cash. the shopping extravaganza is expected to be the biggest yet. we will crunch the numbers. apples title of world's most valuable come -- publicly traded company is no more. monday, the market cap of microsoft overtook apple for the first time in eight years. last month, apple's value topped $1.1 trillion, but since then the share price has been shaved. there have been concerns about weak demand for the iphone. let's bring in mark. not amazon now, but microsoft surpassing apple. it is pretty unbelievable. a year or two ago if somebody said duty do you think -- said do you think microsoft would top apple, nobody would believe it especially in the current climate where a lot of people think apple has endless growth. if you look at the past two months, there have been so many concerns and issues with apple in terms of iphone sales, concerns about the prices of the high-end iphones, the 10 at us and the tennis max, -- the 10s and 10s max, and tv and voice. will it turn around, and when? emil

lawmakers from five countries pressuring mark zuckerberg to testify.the ceo has other plans. ♪ a moment of joy. a source of inspiration. an act of kindness. an old friend. a new beginning. some welcome relief... or a cause for celebration. ♪ what's inside? ♪ [laughter] possibilities. what we deliver by delivering. blake: the "wall street journal" says, lucky is out at facebook'' and "wall street journal" says it was probably over his conservative views. >> i think it's dangerous where we see it going in the tech industry. where you are seeing the polarization between political parties making people disagree on things that should be bipartisan. people should agree national security is important. but it's becoming for many people some kind of partisan issue. >> his new venture is using technology top help police the u.s. borderers. he made a controversial comment in regards to google and his employees petitioning to pull a contract with the pentagon. >> it's worth noting that google is a very large percentage of google employees are not' u.s. citizens. a

nobody elected mark zuckerberg to have this power. we have to be careful what we ask the companies to fix. if doing so, we might grant them powers that down the road we would have rather have kept for ourselves in a democratically accountable way. >> what would you say? in terms of options that congress has, in terms of how we can prevent this from happening again, what are the options? what's on the table? >> it's limited. i think one, congress doesn't really understand how the companies work. he's right. these are quasi government. he's right. who knows in the future when all this information is available to one person who is running it. the question is can they do privacy legislation and do things like europe which has been stringent on all the companies, not just facebook. can they do it? california has new privacy legislation that's stronger. can we do it from the states and will the national scene be pressured into doing it? or will it be haphazard? that's the problem. i think privacy legislation on national levels should be the

it was a different tact and tone from mark zuckerberg.uch more direct then we have heard in prior years. what you think the strategy is? sarah: i think he is trying to paint the picture of how difficult it will be, but he is asked but he is excited about the future. he says facebook's stories in the whole stories product a cash not just that is going to be tough to monetize those things, but eventually more people will be using that. he was trying to give a sense of how big these things could be, that you should think of messenger like imessage. he's trying to give people a picture of how to think about the future of the company. emily: you laid out a great argument on why we should still believe in facebook, but what about all of the skepticism and what about all of the mistakes they have made? what about some of the lackluster engagement with their core product, which is now the newsfeed? richard: i would echo sarah's comment. instagram is a huge business, huge. i look at instagram and go "this is the modern day cure for boredom." mark

of mark zuckerberg.is for a while. there are been pushing this for a while. there a re lots of been pushing this for a while. there are lots of things about facebook‘s data and how google look at your data and how google look at your data and how google look at your data and locate you, use concerns about how facebook are currently aiding the news and what a dude "fake aiding the news and what a dude " fa ke news" aiding the news and what a dude "fake news" to whether or not facebook and the huge amount of data they hold around us could have been influencing global politics and caused violence in some countries. a lot of racist attacks. also may be smart away some general elections referendums, also was of old have gone around the globe. mark zuckerberg did income. a recent facebook executive to go —— richard allen. it is a very arresting image. mps from from countries that actually asking questions and he is not there. it is interesting. don andl not there. it is interesting. don and i come from differe

emily: you started this with mark zuckerberg and you are an early backer of the facebook.ook is in a sort of existential crisis right now, the next pivot toward messaging and video, the how optimistic are you towards this in general, given the saturation and privacy concerns? given the existential crisis. yuri: i do not agree it is an existential crisis. i think it is a little bump in the road. i think that facebook and instagram are amazing products. with more than one billion people each, so you cannot really dismiss it as an existential crisis. [chuckling] but i think that facebook always was and is an evolving system. and they have always been responding to challenges. and the challenges that they are facing can be solved through a combination of human interaction, human attention, and artificial intelligence. so, you know, there are always bad actors who are testing different products. um, but i think i feel confident that this will be taken care of through technology. it is a technology company. emily: run by humans. who have to make the right decisions, right? does

it forced several executives to leave the company and drew friction between ceo mark zuckerberg and long-time chief operating officer cheryl sandburg. zuckerberg blames sandburg and her team for the blowback on the political scandal. a research firm accessed private data during the 2016 campaign and used it for political research. this report came days after the "new york times" detailed how facebook struggled to respond to russian disinformation operations. according to "the times," the company hired a research firm to spread information about facebook's critics, including philanthropist george suros. the criticism of his company and disinformation was warranted, but sandburg said the timing of the investigation was unfair and simply at times not true. stamos, whose name came up in the report, wrote an op-ed responding to it. he said cheryl sandburg was angry when he wrote the op-ed on facebook but no one told him not to investigate it further. and alex stamos, who is an msnbc contributor and also a professor at stanford university joins us. it's great to see you again. >> thanks, kasie. >>

i spoke to mark zuckerberg, and he said they did do the right thing. take a listen.ant to start with some of the revelations that came from the "new york times" piece. >> sure. >> let's look at russia. did you and other leaders try to minimize russia's role in spreading propaganda on the platform? >> no. look, here's what happened. in 2016 there's no doubt that we missed something really important. the russian effort to try and have these coordinated information coordinations was not something we were expecting and we were expecting certain kinds of cyber attacks, and we found them, and the russians were trying to hack into specific accounts and we told the people and fbi and all that, but we were not on top of the coordinated information operations. we spent a lot of the last couple of years now basically building up our systems and strengthening them to be able to address this. we have been very focussed on this. anybody that wants to say that upon learning about this, we have not been very focussed on address it, and anybody who says we have not made a lot of prog

. >>> on the record, mark zuckerberg says he has no plans to step down as facebook chairman >>> bitcoin fighting to come back this after losing nearly a third of its value in just the past month. >>> potential deal news to talk about involving a dow component. we have the full deal-tails ahead on this wednesday november 21st as "worldwide exchange" begins right now ♪ >>> good morning welcome from where in the world you may be watching. i'm brian sullivan happy thanksgiving eve here's how your money and the global markets are setting up their day and give thanks because futures are higher right now. listen, dow futures are up 84 points this is not a giant comeback but the fact we're in the green may be reason to give thanks given we lost about 1,000 points on the dow in just two days. you guessed it bonds holding steady, about 3.08% on the ten-year. the bond yield had been a huge story most of the day, most of the year i should say, because that 3.25, we wereinflation. let's see if asia was able to come back at all and not really the nikkei 2.25 down hang seng up shanghai up. mixed trade

mark zuckerberg saying he is here to stay.next, liz asks one day [inaudible] the countdown coming back right away. then went beyond. beyond clumsy dials-in's and pins. to one-touch conference calls. beyond traditional tv. to tv on any device. beyond low-res surveillance video. to crystal clear hd video monitoring from anywhere. gig-fueled apps that exceed expectations. comcast business. beyond fast. that's it. i'm calling kohler about their walk-in bath. nah. not gonna happen. my name is ken. how may i help you? hi, i'm calling about kohler's walk-in bath. excellent! happy to help. huh? hold one moment please... [ finger snaps ] hmm. the kohler walk-in bath features an extra-wide opening and a low step-in at three inches, which is 25 to 60% lower than some leading competitors. the bath fills and drains quickly, while the heated seat soothes your back, neck and shoulders. kohler is an expert in bathing, so you can count on a deep soaking experience. are you seeing this? the kohler walk-in bath comes with fully adjustable hydrot

so, mark zuckerberg's decision not to appear here at westminster today to me speaks volumes.ght assessment on what can properly appear on its platform... it has become a serious threat to modern democracy... do you accept that facebook needs to be regulated...? at the weekend, documents were seized by a commons official from an american executive whose firm, the maker of an app hunting down bikini photos, is in a legal dispute with facebook. why didn't facebook disclose that as a company...? the man who ordered this highly unusual move described one seized e—mail which he said suggested facebook had known about russian interference for years. an engineer at facebook, noted by the company in october 2014, that entities with russian ip addresses have been using a pinterest api key to pull over 3 billion data points a day through the ordered friend's api. now, was that reported to any external body at the time...? facebook later released a statement saying the engineers who had flagged their concerns subsequently looked into this further and found no evidence of specific russian

the board still has ceo mark zuckerberg.blic statement last week, the board said to suggest that they knew about russian interference or tried to ignore or prevent investigations into what happened it is grossly unfair. in the last 18 months, facebook with the full support of the board has invested in more people and better technology to prevent misuse of its services, including during elections. zuckerberg and sandberg are members of that same board standing behind them. my next guest has been sounding the alarm for change in the power structure at facebook. julie goodridge is the ceo of northstar asset management and they currently hold over 37,000 shares in the company. they have been clamoring for a one share one-vote policy at facebook, something zuckerberg has worked to avoid. she joined us from boston on monday. corporate governance when you have an insider board. mark zuckerberg has the power to fire anyone of his board members at any time. it takes away the sense of autonomy that other board members have. if they ar

. >> the social network is under pressure the journal reports that mark zuckerberg adopted a more aggressiveent style in light of the company's recent troubles reportedly told top company lieutenants earlier this year the social network was at war and planned to lead the company accordingly. paper says the new approach has driven several key executives from facebook and at times has created tensions with coo cheryl sandberg for that, we turn to kara. it was the times, now the journal. can you shine any light on the degree to which sandberg's tenure is threatened >> i don't know that it is threatened, the journal said she's worried about her tenure when i was writing about the kevin cysttron department, he talked about that war meeting. i think everybody was put off by the declaration that it was wartime, as if he was in some godfather movie. needed a war con significant lee ari. that was problematic for a few executives and you saw departures with that attitude. this reaction to problems that were raised in "new york times" is a bad reaction, to focus on being a victim is a real problem for

on misinformation and fake news they left an empty chair for the chief executive of facebook mark zuckerberg his nonappearance some suggested said it all they wanted to quiz him about his network's practices facebook has been heavily criticized over its use and treatment of users data it was left to the company's vice president of policy solutions to answer the m.p.'s questions they wanted to know about political adverts and possible interference in the twenty sixteen us elections and the brig's at those the company insists it complies with data protection laws but admits that it has made mistakes we've never seen anything quite like facebook where while we're playing on our phones and apps our democratic institutions are forming civil conversation seemed up ended by frat boy billionaires from california so mr zucker birch decision not to appear here at westminster to me speaks volumes. we've damaged public trust through some of the actions we've taken again just for the record on the issue of the hiring of this outside firm this is a good work himself said that was not what he expected of u

cascade platinum. >>> mark zuckerberg isn't going anywhere.d by cnn if he would consider stepping down, he said, quote, that's not the plan. after a very bad year for the social media giant, the cambridge analytica scandal, lingering questions about russian interference and this month's report about the company's internal dealings, it's clear that something at facebook needs to change. joining me now is our guest. good to see you, thank you for being with us. >> thank you, thanks for having me. happy thanksgiving. >> mark zuckerberg doesn't have to go anywhere. he designed facebook in a way that he controls the majority of the voting shares. the idea he's going to get forced out of a company he doesn't want to leave probably won't happen. >> i think that's right. mark zuckerberg has absolutely crafted this organization into one he controls. there's nothing necessarily wrong with that. i think everything ceo attempts this. he's a good person. a good father. a philanthropist. good husband. somebody who is in a very difficult position now who has

it founder mark zuckerberg is facing new growing scrutiny.er recent reports alleging management turmoil as the company faces multiple controversies, including the cambridge analytica data harvesting scandal. "washington post" media columnist, margaret sullivan, is calling for him to step down. "if zuckerberg really wants to be responsible for what happened here, he will step aside as chairman and encourage some stringent internal oversight. as part of that true transparency to the public and the press. facebook, whether it wants to admit it or not, is in serious crisis." peter doocy live in washington. the stocks in the lesser meds have bounced back a bit for facebook but it's been a chilly morning for them. >> every lawmaker on capitol hill has a facebook page. but now some of them are very alarmed by reports that facebook basically did opposition research on their harshest critics, and other reports that suggest that the p.r. battle may have taken precedence over fixing facebook laws so they can to be taken advantage of again of russian bad

the whole thing just reeks of a company of mismanagement, frankly on the part of mark zuckerberg and cheryl sandberg, and the significant thing i would point out there, mark zuckerberg has been under the lights for 18 months for all of the controversies that facebook has dealt with. cheryl sandberg has avoided that and now this is when people are saying what responsibility does she bear for the company's failures? >> i want to remind folks what zuckerberg said himself in his senate testimony last year, specifically about the russian influence. here he is. >> for as long as russia has people who are employed who are trying to perpetrate this kind of interference, it will be hard for us to guarantee that we're going to fully stop everything, but it's an arm's race, and i think that we're making ground. >> so it seems like russia, prooifs p privacy issue in general, it always feels like facebook makes promises and then the record catches up and they have to explain. >> there's two tragic ironies here. the first is that facebook got in trouble because in 2015 and 2016 they were caught am

that was part 2 of cnn's exclusive interview with mark zuckerberg.nerated by a lengthy "the new york times" investigative piece about the company and its practices, which included according to the times, hiring a republican opposition research firm to discredit facebook protesters, in part, by linking them to liberal financier george soros. the by line was times national security correspondent matthew rosenberg who has done a great deal of reporting on facebook. thanks for being here. i want to get your reaction to lori's interview, hearing from mark zuckerberg admit it was slow to respond to attacks from russia. is that admission enough? what do you make of that? he >> yes and no. look, when this was unfolding in 2016, nobody had a full picture or idea of what was going on. zuckerberg nor facebook has answered -- when they finally knew what had happened, in september 2017, first under pressure from journalists, under pressure from congress, they admit, well, the russians bought about $100,000 worth of ads from us. then it takes another two months, w

mark zuckerberg has full control over facebook. his control on the board. he's there to stay. he was asked about sheryl sandberg and mark said he thought she was doing a good job. there are questions about the leadership there and whether they should have known more about the political activities of their own company. repeatedly when we were on a call with facebook we asked them did you know why you hired this fire? they said they had not. that took people by surprise that they don't know enough about their company's activities. >> tony, thank you for joining us and thank you to the panel for joining us. tomorrow night at 10:00 tune in to "revolution." >>> recapping breaking news. president trump said he wrapped up robert mueller's questionnaire. right now the president is en route to california after blaming catastrophic wild fires on california. an update from the ground there is straight ahead. he ground the is straight ahead. here we go. discover. i like your card, but i'm absolutely not paying an annual fee. discover has no an

not plan on sitting down. >>> after a year of apologizing for facebook's missteps, facebook ceo mark zuckerberg is sounding a lot more defiant. an article claimed facebook wasness transparent enough about -- officers not transparent enough about hackers during the election. in an interview, zuckerberg dismissed questions about his performance and the leadership of coo sheryl sandberg. >> there are a lot of questions about sheryl sandberg's role in the latest controversy. can you definitively say sheryl will stay in her same role? >> yeah. look, sheryl is a really important part of this company and is leading a lot of the efforts to address the biggest issues that we have. so when you look at a lot of the progress that we've made over the last 12 to 18 months on issues around elections or content or security, sheryl is leading a lot of that work. she's been an important partner for me for ten years. i'm proud of the work we've done together. i hope that we work together for decades more to come. >> you are ceo and chairman of facebook. that's an extraordinary amount of power given that you rule

maybe maybe. >> maybe mark zuckerberg is onto something here. paul: is it going to last?don't know, part is on anger on the left, they're kind of acknowledging it now in an effort to improve pr relations but they should, they should continue to point out that it didn't really affect the outcome in 2016. as far as business model generally, they have had phenomenal run by having all of us trade our personal data to them in exchange for free services which many people around the planet enjoy, so i think consumers ought to be very skeptical of any washington deal that tries to rein in facebook whether on privacy or anything else, probably great for facebook and not so good for potential competitors. paul: what about the content differentiation, do they have to behave more like a publisher? >> the question is if the government will force them to. they are loathe to do that, they don't want to make decision whether something is quote, unquote fake or misinformation versus real or conveying actual news. partly that's going to unleash criticism that they have censoring which they

i can't speak for mark zuckerberg.l you that is incredibly and intensely spacer she is incredibly and intensely interested in india. he has created a larger routines that are looking at this issue. he is also looking at another of other areas, including creating a war room in washington, dc looking at elections. in terms of misinformation, there are another thing to me to talk about ever get the opportunity. to specifically, though, around whatsapp, and the lynchings, and all the trouble is we have seen in india, the indian government has said that whatsapp can't be bystander but this it that responsibility. are they right? before and so the question, let me pretested. i worked on facebook and no more than happy to answer questions on behalf of whatsapp, but this is my personal interpretation of what i have seen. . facebook is whatsapp, so... again, these are two organisations that are somewhat internally. i am a facebook representative, not necessarily whatsapp. i'm happy to talk about this. it is learning process for

mark zuckerberg admitted to congress he had been slow to respond to fake news. he also been slow to respond to the lynchings in india? so this is an interesting way of looking at it. the first thing i would like to say is that as a social media platform, we have always been upfront with the mistakes that we have made. we go back to 2016, a certain amount of mistakes were made, as far as the elections were concerned. we learn from what we have undergone, and i think, to answer your question, as a platform, facebook is incredibly interested in actually being part of the solution. it is incredibly interested in making sure that the quality of content on the platform is of a very high nature. it is incredibly interested in fighting this movement. specific to those lynchings, i haven't seen mark zuckerberg give a television interview. i can't speak for mark zuckerberg, but i can tell you it is incredibly and intensely... he is incredibly and intensely interested in what is happening in india. i know for a fact that he has created a large number of teams which are loo

mark zuckerberg talked about hiring more bernese speaking experts.l don't know how many have been hired. that is your problem across the board. you need many more humans, don't you? and you need much better algorithms. we do. and it is a continuous process of learning. i think we are increasing the number of people who are looking at this problem and we are always doubling that number. we are going from 8000 to around 20,000 as an acknowledgement that there needs to be greater human interface. as far as the algorithm is concerned, there isa as the algorithm is concerned, there is a continuous process of improvement and we are trying to get better at it but we do realise this is not a solution that only facebook can implement that is probably a challenge that is going to persist. ms information, i know for a fact in india asa ms information, i know for a fact in india as a journalist was there when i was india as a journalist was there when iwas in india as a journalist was there when i was injournalism in the 90s. it is probably can't be for a very l

really, mark zuckerberg has the power to fire any one of his board members at any time.t that does, as you probably understand, is takes away the sense of autonomy that other ared members have, if they at all concerned about maintaining their relationship with the company. i think it is problematic. emily: do you sense an opportunity now to re-agitate for this? and do you have plans to do so? julie: well, we have the same shareholder resolutions file. just so folks know, and probably everyone listening to this does, mark zuckerberg has primarily class b shares, which give him 10 times the voting power. and so, what that means is he controls 51% of the vote but he only owns 30% of the stock. so that is a problem for other shareholders. for example, in the shareholder resolution we filed last year, asking for there to be one vote per share, so to only have one class structure, class a, what ended up happening was we only got, overall, 21% of the vote. but if you looked at all of the other shareholders who voted in favor of our resolution, that were not insiders, we actuall

the headline stories this hour facebook investors push for a mark zuckerberg to quit chairman following a series of scandals the latest being the firm's links to a p.r. agency accused of anti semitic attacks against billionaire george soros. coming up on the program a rare look at the asia pacific summit where leaders fail to run a joint declaration that trade rivalry between the u.s. and china is laid her. on the popular russian card is accused of being a kremlin propaganda tool designed to influence children's minds right around the world. a.t.m. here in moscow this monday november the nineteenth wherever you may be tuning in from a warm welcome to our team international our top story facebook supremacy mark zuckerberg is under pressure from the firm's major investors who want him to step aside as chairman their patience is wearing thin following a series of scandals over the past year which have played the social media behave with. facebook is behaving like it's a special snowflake it's not it is a company and companies need to have a separation of chair and c.e.o. that concentration

mark zuckerberg says he has her back. we'll discuss if that's enough. counting the cyber monday cash. the annual shopping extravaganza is expected to be the biggest yet. we will crunch the numbers. emily: apple's title of world's most valuable publicly traded company is no more. during monday trading microsoft's market cap overtook apple for the first time in eight years. just last month the iphone maker's value topped $1.1 trillion but since then the share price has been shaved in the broader tech sell-off amid concerns about weak demand for the flagship iphone. let's bring in our bloomberg tech from l.a. not amazon but microsoft surpassing apple's market cap. what do you make of it? >> pretty unbelievable. maybe a year or two ago if someone said do you think microsoft will pass apple in market cap in two years nobody would really believe that especially in the current technology climate where a lot of people think that apple has endless runway of growth. but if you look at what's happened over the past two months here there have been so many concerns

the man taking mark zuckerberg's place was facebook‘s european policy director, richard allen.billionaires from california. so mr zuckerberg's decision not to appear here at westminster to me speaks volumes. don't you see that by using the same tactics of misinformation, rather than being accountable, that you have lost public trust and cannot be trusted to police yourselves? i'm not going to disagree with you that we have damaged public trust through some of the actions we have ta ken. againjust for the record on the issue of the hiring of this outside firm, mark zuckerberg himself said that was not what he expected of us. he was not personally responsible for the hiring. an engineer at facebook notified the company in october 2014 that entities with russian ip addresses had been using a pinterest api key to pull over 3 billion data points a day through the ordered friends api. if russian ip addresses were pulling down a huge amount of data from the platform, was that reported or was that just kept as so often seems to be the case, just kept within the family and not talked ab

concerns like all the way to the top on mark zuckerberg and how -- on howdberg handle mark zuckerberg and cheryl central -- sheryl sandberg handled election meddling. cathie: we got the first signs in the last quarterly report that it has impacted engagement slightly, but not as much as many might have thought. we are also seeing in terms of top brands, facebook is losing its status there. when that happens, we usually have a. -- we usually have a period of business and stock. havegoodness they instagram, whatsapp, messenger, and other properties to monetize. we think they will be continuing to lower the ad load's on facebook proper and trying to write that ship -- right that ship. emily: how optimistic are you that instagram and the rest can pick up the slack? cathie: it will be hard. facebook is incredibly important to them. i would not be surprised to see more disappointments. they are coming off of rapid growth and we know television advertising is starting to find its way online. there are not many places to go. facebook is one of the biggest. google, twitter, amazon in fact is g

calls for mark zuckerberg to step down after claims the social media giant hired a p.r.p dirt on competitors. o dig up dirt on competitors. the community doesn't just have small businesses, it is small businesses. and that's why american express founded small business saturday. so, this year let's all get up, get out and shop small on november 24th. i got croissant. small business saturday. a small way to make a big difference. (boy) got it. (dad) it's slippery. (boy) nooooooo... (grandma) nooooooo... (dad) nooooooo... (dog) yessssss.... (vo) quick, the quicker picker upper! bounty picks up messes quicker and is two times more absorbent than the leading ordinary brand. (boy) hey look, i got it. bounty, the quicker picker upper. new aveeno® cracked skintell you cica ointment. what to wear. with shea butter and triple oat complex. for fast relief and a protective barrier for lasting relief. wear what you love, aveeno®. not in this house.? 'cause that's no ordinary family. that's your family. which is why you didn't grab just any cheese. you picked up new kraft expertly pai