let's take an example of meta- data. amazon's kindle reports back every page that you read, how long it takes you to read it, what passages you underline, and everything that you read on kindle. it's as if ceo is snooping over your shoulder. is that an invasion of privacy? >> no. this enormous data exists. >> yes. >> amazon.com, i order all of these books and they send me as eleanor says books like it, would you like to buy this. it exists. it goes into this huge pool. and nsa can access it if they have a reason to believe that someone is connected with terrorism. then they can go into it. >> then they can turn it over to a law enforcement agency. then they can go in. >> with a warrant. >> there is no privacy. >> the question is can nsa access? it already exists. >> it exists. if they want to target someone, they have to go to the court. >> exactly. >> the fisa court. >> yes. and get essentially what amounts to a warrant. >> this is the mystery courtroom. >> because we have the luxury of having this conversation is becau

and meta data story came out at the same time.s have been interwoven in a bunch of public discourse about it. the meta data story does touch upon americans in a massive way with phone records but not the content. the p.r.i.s.m. story is about foreigners. and it is about content. those things have become glued together, much to the harm of a rational national debate. >> i'm starting the conversation about the politics of all of this. congressman, you voted against the patriot act back in 2001. and we'll talk more about that. but president obama, as somebody who has presided over the expansion of these programs, had a much different outlook back in 2007 when he was running against effectively president bush. here's what he said back in august of 2007. >> this administration also puts forward a false choice between the liberties we cherish, and the security we provide. i will provide our intelligence and law enforcement agencies with the tools they need to track and take out the terrorists without undermining our constitution, and ou

and the meta data program, were established under the court under president bush in 2006 and 2008.hough candidate obama had problems with it, president-elect obama was briefed on it and embraced them as they existed when he came to office. >> general, one of the things that i think has been written about from both the left and the right -- peggy noonan wrote about it this weekend -- is that there is a lack of confidence in the government, which has evolved over a variety of administrations. so, when you say trust me, this data, the meta data are stored and we're not going to go into it unless there's a court order, unless it's because of a terrorist plot, and then if a judge orders that, it's then turned over to the fbi and then they can pursue and look at the content. >> right. >> so, we've got the numbers, but we're not looking, we're not reading. but people no longer, after bengha benghazi, after irs, certainly, and after a lot of other things, don't have confidence in their government, and that is leading to a disaffection and a disconnection that going forward is very troublin

again, that for the meta, not for the content. my question to you is when a lot of people hear of what's going on, they hear it's meta, they sort of think, that's a slippery sloan, ain't it? is it? >> well, it is a slippery slope. i don't want people to accept that meta data is not sensitive. >> it's intn settled. that's been settled. right there. case in '79 sugged if something is held by a 3rd pare, it can be accessed without a warrant. >> no, but again, that was a case involving a discreet amount of information about a sainte-paul group of people. -- a sainte-paul group of people. -- a small group of people. there is a huge difference. there is a case from last year called u.s. vs. jones in which the court actually said that it's one thing to gather a small amount of meta information, in that case it was location information, over a small period of time, a short period of time and quite another thing to gts it over a along period of time involving many people. so i think there is a dwiemps i difference between a discreet amount

we also have to look at the meta data. meta data follows you when you get on the internet, when you go into target, anything. the idea that the government would ignore meta data is really irresponsible. i would say those that are concerned about these calls and the nsa having these calls, they have a point in that there is some lack of trust in the government. do we know, are there appropriate controls in place? is the fbi and the nsa, are they doing what they need to do to protect snem can we trust them? or do we have another irs scenario on our hands? >> i know. we've heard from both senators udall and widen ringing alarm bells for the last couple of years. this isn't new but it's another example according to them. hang on both of you. let me give an example for viewers. let's say i call my mom, want to wish her a happy birthday. somewhere in the bowels of the nsa there is a record of the phone call. it's not what i said, not even my name but, ben, you said it, it's your phone number. >> yeah. >> it's my mom's number. it

today among other news organizatio reporting the collection of so-called meta data.s "washington post" story is quite dierent dealing with service providers? >> i think you are exactly right. the pror distinction to ma. in some ways, my first two reads of the story about the prism program that has been in existence seems to be magnitudes of order, more significant than the verizon story as you say we've been talking about all the time. it appears, if you read the piece closely, it appears to be getting into content rather than just collecting and analyzing meta data. meta data tt is cold and numeral, if you go through it and only analyze, it's requiring eyes on analysis of actual connt of actual communications which we were not seeing. we were not listening into these conversations in the case of verizon an tse other providers. >>ou: chris? >> it's remarkable. all i can say about politics is this -- it's always true when it rains it pours. i've never seen six months this heinous too start second term. i can't imagine how it could get worse for the president. iaid tha

front, i don't think collecting millions and millions of americans' phone calls -- now, this is the meta data, this is time, place, to whom you direct the calls -- is making us any safer, and i think it's ultimately, perhaps, a violation of the 4th amendment. i think we should have this debate. i'll introduce a bill this week to narrow the reach to those who have a link to terrorism. a similar amendment passed in 2005. it had support from people like

they're using the big word the meta data word. we're just gathering this stuff up and not really looking at it. how do we know that and who is looking at it? we have government contractors now who seem to have access to a lot of personal things belonging to million of americans and they're not directly working for the government. it seems like there's no real control over the information coming in and who has access to it. that is a big scooter issue. >> what do you think -- security issue. >> what do you think, mortimer? >> i think the head of national security has basically indicated dozens of terrorist attacks have been interdicted as a result of the information and intelligence we got out of that and given the world we live in we have to see whether there's a way of preserving that access. now they are not listening to conversations or looking at the material. it goes through a special court with independent judges and congress has approved it. this is something in this modern day in age we have to find some way of dealing wit

it can be meta data or content. depends op the circumstances. >> is there a data base that anybody knows of that -- >> i don't know of a data base that has that specifically addressed in geolocation apart from everything else and other investigation activity that's a geolocation data base. >> post jones, does the fbi believe that there should be a lower or differed standard for law enforcement to access geolocation information from smart phones or other mobile devices than the standard for attaching tracking devices under jones? >> i have to get back to you on that. i apologize. you gave the questions, and i did not get briefed on. it's my own fault for getting briefed on the questions so i'm better able to answer it. >> i appreciate. mr. chairman, it's terribly disappointing to come to this point, talk about something that's in the headlines of every newscast, i gave the questions in advance. >> and they noted i would be asked them, i might add. it's my fault. >> your staff did great work, i guess, but it's terribl

information has come out in the last week and that is that, of this, you know, tank, this tank of meta data that contains so much it's only been queried 300 times during 2012. that is an important fact to get out to the american people. and i don't think it compromises our security to have that kind of information in the public domain. >> right. so you're saying they're collecting it but not necessarily culling through it and using it. i understand the point. what about the 50 attacks that general alexander talked about today that he says were thwarted because of the nsa gathering this meta data. do you think the nuance here that the gathering all this meta data of who was calling whom, of all these phone numbers, was critical in stopping those attacks or not? just a small part and they could have stopped them anyway? >> well, i think what the general has said that of those 50 thwarted attacks 90% of them were stopped in the 702 program, the program called prism that only 10% were stopped in the meta data program, and of the 10%, you're right, i think the agencies have been a little am

it is meta information. you get "a" you have to go to a judge.by a computer looking for patterns. it's data mining. if it's finds a pattern that to see a judge again and look into the individual. that i think is reasonable. the prism sounds a lot different because it sounds as if we're not sure if it involves content. i think the word prism has a bond connotation. it's the villain on the island is working on the prism program. it's kind of spooky tone. i'm not making it up. i'm not making it up. its twin of prism. i think it's very interesting. >> chris: we have to take a break here. we'll continue our excursion. is our government protecting us on or is it getting out of control sn sflrx -- out of control?othe arts inveors coullose tens of thousands of dollars in hidden fees on their 401(k)s?! seriously? seriously. you don't believe it sear it. ... ... we have every type of retirement account. none of them charge annual fees and all of them offer low cost investments. why? because we're not your typical wall street firm that's why. so you keep mo

for now the meta data. a lot of people have concerned about what fan any limiting principles there are that would prevent the government from ultimately storing all information about all americans. meaning collecting more and more of the meta data and holding it for long periods of time and in some time inner. tooty. does the department of justice or fbi have a view on the constitutionality and storing it so long so it doesn't perform query on the information? >> i think i understand the broader question. i would say that the justice department believes that the program in place, 215 program that has been upheld by the fee is a court is certainly constitution constitutional. i would limit it to the set of facts, they are a set of facts with the protections on privacy that i think the department of justice as well as the fisa court believe is constitutional. >> at some point do you sympathize with those saying this is meta data you can collect it, store if are long period of time and the fact it can later be

"mo' meta blues," everybody. pick this up. [ cheers and applause ] "mo' meta." you are on the back there. [ laughter ] that's the photo you chose? what happened there? somebody just -- someone stole one of your albums? you're in the bin right there. [ laughter ] >> questlove: yeah, i don't know. it was cold. >> jimmy: it was cold. yeah, yeah, yeah. it was cold there. we got a fun show tonight. he's a legendary comedian. i love it -- and even just running into the man or seeing him anywhere. i would watch him go shopping. [ light laughter ] i would follow him around. he's the funniest human. >> steve: he's hilarious. >> jimmy: and he's going to do some stand-up on our show. >> steve: oh, come on! [ cheers and applause ] >> jimmy: when does that happen? the legendary jerry seinfeld is here! [ cheers and applause ] the greatest. >> steve: come on. [ applause ] >> jimmy: plus, our video game week continues with the demo of the sony playstation 4. this is the -- this is the one. [ cheers and applause ] and they got a new game called knack. oh, i'm going to show you t

it relates to meta data, such as a telephone number or the length of a call. john miller is a former deputy director of intelligence. he says the key is not content but numbers that might link terrorists to u.s. citizens. >> everybody knows if they're listening in on american citizens without a very special order or ruling with their lawyers, they're going to jail. >> britain's guardian newspaper first reported that a court order is directing verizon to give the nsa a copy of meta data on customers even if they're expected of no wrongdoing. the act that was amounted after 9/11 gives the government sweeping legal authority to make demands on phone carriers, but some believe untargetted surveillance goes too far. >> i can the american people deserve to know whether their government is scooping you will up of their phone records regardless of whether they did anything wrong. >> verizon has not commented on the report. danielle nottingham, cbs news, the white house. >> verizon has 121 million customers in the united states. >>> it was a capitol hill institution, o

to verizon seemed to reveal, this is indeed about meta data. it's about fact of call. nsa is getting from the telecom providers records that they create for their own purposes. these are essentially billing records that the telecom providers are sharing with nsa. fareed, nsa puts them in a very large database. and then sits and waits until it has a predicate related to terrorism, an arguable proposition that a reasonable man would look at and say, yeah, this is correct to ask that database a question. let me give you a concrete example. we raid a safe house somewhere in yemen. we pick up a cell phone we've never seen before. there's pocket litter in the possession of the individual clearly indicating he's affiliated with al qaeda, he's a terrorist. we take that new phone number and we simply ask that database does this phone number show up in connection with any of the phone numbers, any of the phones events that we have gathered here? and if, for example, a phone number in the bronx kind of raises its hand and says, well yes, i've been in cont

what is wrong with that. >> meta data can be sensitive. it can be reflected in your phone calls or e-mails. it can say a lot about who you associate with, about your mental health, your financial status, what you eat, where you go and it can be intensely private. >> are you surprised that lawmakers have not responded to the fact that this is going on? >> well, by and large the members of congress were not aware of how broad this company was. they were somewhat mislead that it was targeted at bad guys and didn't understand that it was scooping up vast amounts of data on americans. we see a lot of republicans and democrats calling for investigations now. >> don't you have to look at data that encompasses a lot of people, as far as you know so far, hasn't done anything wrong? >> well, there's no public evidence that these programs have ever caught an actual terrorist. when you see a terror prosecution on the news, it's because they used traditional investigation methods or based on suspicion. >> isn't the problem that we have the ability to d

---la meta, segun un portavoz, es detener a los criminales y ofrecer un ambiente mas seguro.lanca ---pese a que se declaro una tregua; en el salvador continua la inseguridad y violencia por las pandillas. ---una abuela salvadoreÑa cuya hija y nieta fueron asesinadas ... roll open under ...ofrece una perspectiva que sirve de "llamada de atencin" sobre la situacin en el salvador. take 2 box ---jaime peluffo convers con ella y nos trae el reporte.. jaime.. take anchor live cu - peluffo asi es, la seÑora gloria merino sigue sufriendo por el brutal asesinato de su hija y nieta, y hoy reflexion sobre la causa y el futuro de su pas.. :01 - :06 :07 - :14 trt: 1:49 o.c. "de donde llegan, quienes son." nats.. la seÑora gloria merino todava sufre por la muerte de su hija y nieta. s.o.t. gloria merino/víctima de violencia 5:23:02 es bien duro porque estar platicando una horas con ella y como tres horas después la estaba muerta.o de4 aÑos, y lorena blanco de 25 fueron asesinadas un 4 de noviembre del 2011 en moncagua, departamento de san miguel, el salvador. s.o.t. gloria merino/víctima d

realmente increÍble para ser mÁs preciso, 15.2 millones de dÓlares, mÁs del doble de lo que fue la metaen cada punto de la ruta estarÁn presentes, representantes de las fundaciÓn de telet"teletÓn usa" univisiÓn, y del hospital, de esta forma, con los donativos se empezarÁ un programa para ayudar a los niÑos que mÁs lo necesitan, me parece una ayuda hermosa que "teletÓn usa" da, y ademÁs de lo que se va a hacer, el centro de rehabilitaciÓn en texas. >>> quÉ bueno. nosotros en "despierta amÉrica", vamos a ir siguiendolos uno a uno, cuÁntas paradas son? >>> son 7. vamos a visitar diferentes hospitales, son 7, empezando por el miami children hospital, y cerrando en grande, como dige, con la Última parada en estados unidos, que se va a poner pronto la primera piedra, le contarÁn de eso. >>> sÍ, para que la audiencia lo entienda, por quÉ escogieron estos hospitales. >>> sÍ, porque son a nuestro parecer las instituciones mÁs honorables y serias que atienden a niÑos con alguna discapacidad, con cÁncer o autismo en estados unidos, enfocados, evidentemente en la comunidad hispana, la comunidad la

we know about the nsa, meta data gathering.d not know about operation prism, but there's some reason that this material is pushed out here right now. it does not look -- it's truly a strange piece of timing. >> well, i think they see a certain weakness in this administration, and they are taking advantage of it. lou: "they" being who? >> well, i think china. certainly, they with their policies in the south china sea, aggressive bullying tactics, their declaration of recognized international water, which comprises 2.6 million square miles, which we cannot let stand. there is no compromise on that issue. i can tell you our allies are going ton watching how president obama handles this delicate issue. lou: how do you expect them to handle it? we're talking about south korea, we're talking about, obviously, japan. we're talking about perspectively and potentially an immensely important ally in india. >> right. well, what he has to make clear is that the united states-and-a-half vie stood for freedom of navigation and the right of i

they talked about meta-data. ask anyone on the street if they understand what that is. people are saying i'm on the internet all the time, on my cell phone, i have to have the expectation that someone is listening. the question is what is going to happen with this information? nobody has really answered that question. >> thanks to mr. snowden, i think there is going to be more transparency about the existence of these programs. nobody is sitting there and listening to everyone's phone conversations. >> i don't think that's clear. >> that's a burden of responsibility on the government to explain more. the president is feeling the heat. on friday he metaphor the first time with his -- i think it's his privacy and civil liberties accountability board that was created in 2004. never functioned. reconstituted in 2007. never met. i think now we're having the debate that we should have had ten years ago. we have the luxury of having it now because we feel pretty damn safe compared to after 9/11. >> one of the reasons that president obama has plunged in the poles, i think his d

. >> nuestra meta es asegurar que llegamos a un acuerdo con el pdt. >> primero el proyecto debe ser aprobado la cámara de representantes. >> ahora como se garantiza que tendremos una frontera que nadie va a cruzar. >> senado continúa con la votación por una serie de enmiendas , el poder judicial de la cámara bara incluira que la policai actue como agentes de migración. >> lo que esta en juego es el futuro de millones de indocumentados que tienen que enfrentar circunstancias dificiles en estados unidos . >> no podemos dejar a los hijos así. >> me aucerdo cruzando en el desierto , estabamos caminando bien rápido. >> yo cruce solo y pensé que no podría llegar a mi destino. >> muchos escaparon de la violencia y la pobreza . >> en el caso de margarito cruz ya son 20 años que vive el margen de la ley. >> cuando pienso y hablo es puro inglés . yo he de nada sirve el patriotismo cuando en la práctica si documentos es como si nostos unidos . >> llva su méxico en el corazón , lleva 24 años en estados unidos ya sabe qu ehara si la reforma migratoria le regala la legalidad. >> ver a mi mamá , si esta vi

as you heard before, the meta data is only the telephone number and contact, the time of the call ands authority, therefore, does not allow the government to listen in on a person's phone call, even that of a terrorist. >> the deputy director went on to describe the multiple layers of oversight involved, arguing that the government has achieved the right balance of security and privacy. critics are calling the hearing nothing more than a platform for the nsa to make its case. writing for salon, the writer concluded it may as well have been titled "everything fine, stop making a scene." edward snowden continues to claim the government is not telling the truth. asked yesterday in a website, he still was asked if he makes the claims that he could wiretap anyone, he answered yes, i stand by it. joining me is co-host of msnbc's "the cycle," ari melber, i think it is a fascinating subject, regardless of where you're a democrat or republican. there are no clear lines here, the question is who do you believe? the nsa or the deputies or do you believe the anti-hero, maybe-hero, exiled in hong

tenemos miedo de que muchas personas por todas estas cosas que estÁn poniendo capaz no lleguen a la meta en noviembre, nosotros queremos asegurar, de cada oportunidad que tengamos, como unidad que se escuche la voz latina, que se oiga aquÍ en este salÓn, en estos corredores para que los senadores y los representantes se den cuenta que tienen a favor a la comunidad latina. >> o sea, tienen miedo entonces, ustedes creen que muchos republicanos estÁn votando por esto, porque tienen miedo de que lo vayan a sacar de sus puestos. >> estÁ bien, esta bien que tenga miedo. >> es la razÓn, lo que me importa es el voto. >> claro. >> y entonces, y la verdad ahora tienen miedo, antes ellos tenÍan miedo sÓlo de la extrema derecha, en este momento tienen miedo del voto, del votante latino, estÁ bien conmigo. >> bueno, le podemos llamar miedo, le podemos llamar interÉs. >> motivaciÓn. >> motivaciÓn, exactamente. porque es que cuando los senadores o los polÍticos hacen algo porque un grupo los estÁ presionando es bueno, excepto cuando nuestra comunidad lo esÁa haciendo, yo creo que aquÍ. >> porque los es

. >> me siento mucho mejor y la meta es estar cerca del 100 por ciento, prácticamente vivo en el hieloera consecutiva frente a un equo similar al tuyo dijo el entrenador de los heats de miami. >> susto enorme se vivi'ño en la quinta entrada entree bay tampa city luego de ser alcanzado por un batazo en la cabeza, el jugador se mantuvo siempre consciente pero sigue hospitalizado. >> los giantsa de san francisco frente (información en pantalla) (información en pantalla) (información en pantalla) piratas dodgers frente a raptors. >> (información en pantalla) (información en pantalla) los dodgers terminaron loa victoria 5 carreras contra 3., >> y cómo viste brevem,ente el partido?. >> unteresante, valió la penaióncontinuamos con noticias, general motors anuncia el de modelos por riesgo de incendio, más información a la vuelta. ♪ [ locutor ] universal studio's verano del valor. ♪ [ locutor ] universal studio's verano del valor. >> la compañia general motos retirará muchos modelos del mercado 2006 y 2007 debido a que el circuito de la puerta es muy corto y ocasiona incendios. >> (información

aggregated meta data can be more revealing than content.an entity collects information about you, that includes locations, transactions, credit card transactions, travel, plans, easy path, on and off toll ways all of that can be time luind to track you day to day to the point where people can get insight into your intentions and what you are going to do next. it is difficult to get that from content unless you exploit every piece and even then a lot of content is worthless. >> megyn: they seem to be saying don't worry because we're collecting on so many hundreds of millions of people, we're not going to track you, megyn kelly or you, kirk and bill, we are trying to look at general patterns. only when things get suspicious, if we need to go to a court and what you shall actually saying. >> well, let me -- the content acquisition by nsa started at least by my time line as early as 2003. that goes back to mark china's court documentation of the nsa facility in san francisco where they had the merits hooked up to cyber optic lines inside the un

transporta mercancías pero también a decenas de inmigrantes que buscan una mejor vida para los suyos, la metanas. >> de acuerdo a cifras del instituto de desarrollo social los inmigrantes son muy vulnerablesi.ón >> hay mucha corrupción, autopridades del estado que no trabajan apropiadamente que son tratados como delicncuentes y luego son víctimas de trata. >> las grandes redes se aprovechan de las condiciones de vulnerabilidad de los inmigrantes. >> en oaxaca y otros lugares es más probabvle que se encuentren vñictimas. >> se asegura que méxico es un lugar de origen, tránsito y t'rafico de trta, principalmente menores. >> hay lugares de méxico como cancún que less dicen el bangkok mexicano por los abusos con niños y personas vulnerables. >> el mito del chupacabras se vuelve a popularizar con el vídeo de una familia que asegura haberlo visto. >> buenas noches, les saluda stefanie severino, temperaturas en los 70 grados cerca de los niveles promedio, en san nosé con máxima de 83 grados, en concord con 90 grados, con brisa fuerte desde el oeste con 33 millas por hora, embarcaciones en la bahía c

. >> recalcaron la importancia de lograr una meta. >> los padres de familia queremos paz y buscamos unaces para crear la paz. >> (hablan en inglés) >> (aplausos) >> (gritos) >> manifestaron que además de la violencia, les preocupa la seguridad vial. también les gustaría ver más presencia policíal en los vecindarios. >> hoy comenzó el jucio sobre una violación que se llevó a cabo. >> se espera que por primera vez la víctima testifique. >> presentan cargos formales a un sujeto que baleo a un hombre mientras robaba la casa. >> el primero de abril del 2012. >> se busca al sospechoso de balear a dos hombres hispanos el sábado por la noche . >> de acuerdo a testigos el hombre se bajo de un vehículo y comenzó a disparar. >> los agentes decomisaron desde joyerí hasta ropa. >> las autoridades del condado de san mateo buscan superar los daños. >> vemos como esta pareja mantenia encerrada a sus hijas mientras ellos jugaban video juegos. >> sus hijas vivieron encerradas. >> entre cubiertos llenos de moho y sus propias necesidades fisicas. >> en una de las cámaras de la legislacion se aprobaron vari