. >> thank you, madam chair person so mr. egon i don't want to leave it there i appreciate supervisor campos comments and numbers but that is taking apples and oranges and municipal court them to get some other fruit he'd like to have (laughter) clapping) i don't mean that facetiouslyly i want to get to our comment i think the budget analyst report makes a lot of assumes and has conclusions and from my prospective are dangerous you took a different approach to say we don't have enough data to analyze it can you talk about that it is important to have it discussion to take something piece of information they're important trade in the media as facts as you supervisor tiejdz there's no day available to the city or public domain that says how many nights a year the units is on a short-term rental approach theres a there's a cleaver method how many the period duration over which the rates are taken that method we replicated is subject to error we know that subject are used over hundred and 50 percent of the time it is mathly bobble it

a quick question and then one quick comment i think that mr. egon has left but i'm going to ask staff are we - do we look at the same income levels we talked the daytime of $60,000 a year this is prorngsly lower income have we looked at churn within the income levels people are moving out is that part and parcel of this or a different question. >> is it so part of the same question we've not gotten the information but part of i think one of our basic points we want to spend time and energy with the demographics and the current block as general how it is used. >> thank you gil. >> just to put awning emphasis of the million trillion other things you guys are research i think that is important a key back to a woman sitting here the landlord is renting their apartment for $7,500 a month this is compatible to $300,000 a year income most people are not making that kind of money we get something truly it what manhattan used to be like in the 90s you come in and spend our money in rent and endure it and move somewhere else and that's what's happening i try