murase mr. chin ? okay motion and second for formal introduction of the resolution moved and seconded thank you reading of the reds ms. fewer >> thank you very much in support of sb 172 to spint suspend the exit examine whereas it calls for the suspension of the california high school examine and the removal of it as a condition the graduation for the fiscal year 2016-2017 and whereas sb 172 requires the superintendant to create a report that includes a recommendations whether or not to continue the exit examine to assess the academic achievement and whereas the superintendant to give a panel of experts to weigh in on the conditions and whereas when the high school exit examine was approved it was criticized that is upper fair to english learners and students of disability and low income particularly african-american and latino students and whereas the high school exit examine unfairly punishes exiting students failed educational systems and the 0 chronic under funded and whereas it takes the research

murase commissioner president murase hopefully things don't get worse from that kind of an introduction thank you in the article i want to is it is reflecting of this districts commitment to the language for all students that i proudly represent the district? a recognition of the districts work thank you so much good evening to everyone and as we all know last week we gaining ban with the celebration of lunar new year's and the schools start their celebrations i wanted to point out lake shore kindergartener planned a parade and actually carried out and implemented a parade every year 4 kindergarten classes button on a line distance and our students dressed in costumes and as classmates cheered them on happy new year and those of you not familiar with the tradition this is the year of the sheep so happy new year to everyone we're in the month of february and at the last board meeting we learned about the history of san francisco unified school district and in particular the first african-american teacher ever hired in san francisco unified school district we also have another tradition t

superintendent. >> thank you commissioner president murase i'm sure you're aware of we have in the san francisco school district an incredible came back that puts in long hours that dedicates loot time and how we're spending the budget another layer of the accountability to the folks in san francisco to make sure we are spending those funds with the chapter and the legislation is so this evening we would like to recognize those individuals and thank them for their services i wish we could give them a trip to hawaii but instead a certificate from the board of education and know that means the world to us a board address staff that i've dedicated this time and your expertise to assure with the voters of san francisco have asked us to do we're true with that kathy to please come forward and recognize the members of the peace good evening, commissioners i'm kathy the supervisor for the public education enrichment fund and for the 6th year that's been my honor to serve the peace cock members i'd like to recognize each member by calling their name and say a little bit about them many of the

murase and commissioners, i had the wonderful opportunity to award tracey an outstanding teacher and wonderful can colleague tracey teaching is initiative and her outdoor out of the side lessons courage the students to surpass their portable or potential she leads other teachers with positive courage time and implements complex resurrection that tints to achieve equality and access for all students tracey is our advanced placement coordinator at washington her role enables students to enroll 2, 3, 4 washington's policy as well as the policy of the district w in other classes without further ado i'd like to give tracey. >> (clapping.) >> yeah. i want to say thank you very much for this honor i feel really surprised and grateful for the unanimous colleague that wrote all the nice things i'm so lucky to be at school like washington i feel supported and valued by our principle and the whole administrative team i feel very lucky to work with an amazing teachers and under the influence of alcohol our students in their by the evidence so go eagles (clapping.) >> congratulations once again s

murase that's 5 i's thank you very much clapping we have one more item for approval authorization torant on the or deny the petition for san francisco bayview charter schools it was moved and seconded we've heard from matt haney on the recommendation and commissioner mendoza-mcdonnell. >> yes. mr. davis commissioner president murase i want to note a correction on the kill switch bayview in the therefore, be it resolved i want to make that clear the recommendation is that the petition be approved thank you very much and actually, the superintendent if you could get mr. davis to read the presentation. >> mr. davis please read the recommendation. >> i will thank you superintendent recognize for the bayview charter school petition authorization to grant the alternative deny the san francisco bayview charter school whereas pursuant to the education code if bayview not limited to a application and whereas pursuant california education code the board of education district is in receipt of the renewable receipt effect 2014 and the district shall comply with the action on petition as required

murase. >> 6 i's. >> thank you, very much. to staff and to the peace k ak a rich decision we'll be back april 14th and our superintendent carranza >> just for clarity for all of the community and for staff then we will we will be submitting the budget without the board approval for the applying for the requirements and understanding we will come back on april 14th not august april 14th with version 3.0 but sorry folks i know everybody has been here a long time next week is spring break i want to be clear i've directed my staff to take spring break no one will be here that's one less week to work on version. >> can we add when we submittal that the board had been month to month on april 14th. >> i'm sorry director lee. >> thank you commissioner president murase that's fine commissioner mendoza-mcdonnell for us to say a little bit more than there's will be an amendment to say the timing exactly so i think that is not he'll done i want to say in terms of what happened the superintendent alludes to now and the 14th alike lecturer

murase. >> 6 i's. >> thank you very much and thank you to the mr. haney and ms. mendoza-mcdonnell the next is j request to speak general matters a lengthy list i'll be limiting public comments to one minute i'll be reading names in group as people if we could hold the applause to the end we'll hear from more speakers on the item of 8th's grade algebra (calling names) if i could please come up and press the button. >> yes. one minute per person. >> press the button. >> again commissioner president murase and commissioners and superintendent carranza i'm alison collin in the last week i've heard about parent reinstating the honors in our middle school as someone that taught forlism 20 years in and out of the district and a parent of two children i've heard something that has made me concerned bhoi experience when we have a two tier system kids get tracked into low-level classes a two-track system is boys no matter what is fair the schools have ended up 106r9 the students by in case and parent educational level a child's baurgsd shouldn't determine their future the

murase. >> 6 i's. >> before i call the next item i'd like to remind the members of the public if you want to address the board of education an individual can complete a speaker card prior to the item being called and given to ms. casco corresponding to board rules and speakers items will not be accepted before the board and superintendant report is next mr. superintendant good evening a couple of items to update our community is it a fair statement or starting off with the superintendent excellent venture i was honored to represent the san francisco unified school district and as a member of the council for a one-on-one meeting in the white house with president obama i know some folks say that didn't happen he's the proof i'm the supervisor from president obama what is so important about it opportunity was that we do have a president who is keenly aware of public education and actually met with superintendent from the larger urban skublths u school districts as well as board members with the intent of hearing from us directly with the effects of proposals currently being discussed on

murase i that's 5 ids your next there is a motion and a second for a structural calendar and mr. superintendant commissioner president murase i'd like to ask the deputy to please read this thank you, again superintendent requested action that the board of education adapts the corrected 2015, 2016 structural calendaring can you point out the corrections. >> yes. an error was bring your attention the month of september has 15 not 16 work days on the board minutes so we had to make a change to the calendar thus, the last day of school is may 27 not may 27 relationship. >> thank you very much no public speakers questions from the board. >> commissioner wynns. >> let's clarify the new year's not wants day will not be moved new year so the public knows that. >> question commissioners next year we're back to observing the wants day a national holiday yes. >> thank you very much no further comments roll call vote. >> ms. sonata. >> mr. chin ms. fewer mr. haney ms. mendoza-mcdonnell ms. mendoza-mcdonnell and ms. wynns and dr. murase it's a 6 i's. >> the committee may be seated on february

murase. >> where's dr. murase thank you that's 5 i's all right. so i'm stepping in here moving on 0 sshlgs board member's reports standing committee do we have a report from any of the board dlblts or board organizations? no other reports by board members a report by the committee as a whole february that's me one informational item our digital learning framework we heard really existing work in our district has been doing around extending a number of things one extending computer science standards k through 12 and developing those are standards and presenting a plan that will could. to the full board as to how we'll go about or about doing that and extending work around digital literacy and introduction technology into destruction and greater levels and the overall approach to keep that in mind how we make sure our students have access to the digital learning it's happening all over the school reports if the legislation committee ms. wynns >> we have already recorded and taken care of the items two were on the agenda related to each other one to

. >> thank you commissioner president murase that's fine commissioner mendoza-mcdonnell for us to say a little bit more than there's will be an amendment to say the timing exactly so i think that is not he'll done i want to say in terms of what happened the superintendent alludes to now and the 14th alike lecturer what i've heard we had a lot of boos to construct and modify the plan it is less clear at least to me what amendments would make sense based on the feedback that was provided tonight we heard questions we can follow-up open the additional questions but in terms of of version 3.0 and how it differs from 2.0 but speaking for myself didn't hear clear direction to you know that we should move in a certain direction on certain line items there were comments made and individual commissioners but it's less clear what modifications will be made than last week our main direction or follow-up to answer our questions and maybe that will illuminate things but as far as the boards feedback the spending plan could look similar in two or three weeks than what was presented. >> i'm urge my

murase. >> thank you ms. sonata. >> yes. >> thank you. >> okay item q superintendent first reading we have one approval of public education expenditure plan for school year 2015-2016 is p there a motion and second to refer to committee as a whole. >> don't need to vote there; right? that will be referred that will take place on august 17th and r the first reading creating aerobic and vietnamese public health in san francisco unified school district authorized by ms. fewer and commissioner shamann walton and have this a there is a motion and a second. >> i didn't call for public comment open the first item was there public comment on the public education combrsht fund no one signed up all right. 0 that will be referred to the curriculum and budget committee and we'll have a hearing on both board members report item s standing committee reports i have the first one that is the curriculum and program committee that meet on march second a busy one we have two chapter petitions from kip renewal petitions both were

murase that's

murase smooth and mr.hinning. >> thank you please join me in the pledges and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> can i have a motion and second possible the board minutes of february 24th, 2015. >> so moved second. >> any corrections? roll call vote >> thank you ms. sonata mr. chinning ms. fewer ms. mendoza-mcdonnell ms. norton ms. wynns and dr. murase. >> thank you before i call the next item i'd like to remind the members of the public if they wish to address the board of education an individual can complete a speaker card prior to the item being called and pretty bad to the clerk according to the speaker cards will not be submitted for the item on the agenda. >> thank you commissioner vice president haney and good evening to everyone listening or watching on tv just a few comments they're more extended commissioners by i do want to thank all our parents and students and staff for an absolutely wonderful school planning summit that

>> commissioner president murase tuesday march third we were welcomed audio the caesar chavez community the superintendent senior staff and ms. fewer and i participated in an experience on the smarter balanced assessment where we sat down added computer terminals to skewer canyon core and math and arts questions it was tree informative i hope there will be a way for families to do a test one of this kind testing we were joined by 3 caesar chavez fifth graders i want to thank the caesar chavez community for that opportunity oh i wanted to say if commissioner mendoza-mcdonnell wanted to talk about the the mayors breakfast and announcement. >> certainly last week, we all the board members attended the annual chamber of commerce city breakfast with the mayor and is superintendent and the chamber announced united sf to bring together the community to invest in the public schools we're excited about the initiative that will hope to convene the members of the chamber of commerce to be a lot for supportive of our schools and two inches we have on the table in light of the initiative one is with

murase when is the president of the san francisco school board. >> how's everybody doing today were we can do better than that how is everybody doing today a few thank you's want to thank my staff that were here earlier in the morning and dj and susan has been working tireless for the last few months. (clapping.) >> and mayor ed lee, of course, and marily and others from the mayor's office who made today happy. (clapping.) and we have saving lives in san francisco we've heard the mayor the city has joined i'm joined by our city agencies let's hear if for our city agencies. >> i'm happy happy to reporting we have housing authority and at domestic violence brochure out to the city employees we've trained people in our housing authority and have a new officers involved domestic violence policy at the police department. (clapping.) in human trafficking supervisor tang has lead the way to go after our logically massage mroorldz we have eric mar and trained 88 did that want public health inspections how to look for signs of human trafficking (clapping) so, now it's my great pleasure to intro

. >> commissioner president murase superintendent and commissioners my name is neil goss man i was a product of the 70 san francisco unified school district it's been over 40 years since law versus nickels i don't think this district has gotten it right yet we're talking about 40 years where filipinos the beginning of the filipino betsey carmichael education center has tried to teach the bilingual programs we've lacked the services and tools and the resources to really fully teach the program the way it should be i'll give you an example i commend you for adding this round the budget that we're seeing lecture it wasn't there but when we look at the christine wong she spoke but with the law versus nickels one point we're talking about a world language where children are taught a foreign language english language learners at betsy from k through 5 and k through 8 english language learns kids that speak the first language and english as something they're trying to understand so let's try to get it right let's see how we can make that change to have a bio literacy so open the program and

the reason i'll not support the amendment. >> superintendent. >> thank you commissioner president murase and thank you, commissioners just a couple of points of clarification i think that regardless of what is voted upon or not voted upon there should be additional conversation with board members in a little bit more detail as we make

the reason i'll not support the amendment. >> superintendent. >> thank you commissioner president murase and thank you, commissioners just a couple of points of clarification i think that regardless of what is voted upon or not voted upon there should be additional conversation with board members in a little bit more detail as we make amendments whether voted on positive or not we are going to need positive direction from the board i'll make a cautionary note there what was extensive notes taken from the asterisks of board the other evening this is a thoughtfully krauftd proposal for your consideration that enexcuses the feedback that will not be perfect opportunity to make amendments and we will be here until tomorrow morning we we make additions and subtractions i want to call to the commissions attendance we have professional educatorors macro those recommendations we'll not make a recommendation we'll not purport i wanted to speak to that in support of our staff working with the community as well and just remind us all that is the first year we're in growing modes we've been suppleme

. >> thank you commissioner president murase i'd like to ask the executive order steven koffman to take this item and good evening all i'd like to welcome julie chang the analysts for lending support as well as mccain from post secondary head council i'm sorry supervisor and jane fong and the issues it takes a village to address our most needy kids that is a continuous or tuition continuation of work under the sprifshgs of mr. sanderson so okay. so sorry go ahead. >> i'd like studio take a moment to join when this award was going on i hope to see all the students graduate from a there g it's been a true honor to see them and like to see the fund they stay pursue and the primary recovery and the commitment of this board for the recovery funds thank you very much for that with the idea of credit recovery i've communicated and to the school sites noting non-negotiable for us so, so last december the conversation was held around the word plan i'd like to know before we modify the graugs graduation requirement i thank you to billing sanderson for his leadership in this plan since last year i

back for school board 2014 home share bottle for district 2 supervisor 2014 committee to elect emily murase for school board 2014 committee for jobs government reform fund san francisco labor council labor and neighbor independent expenditure political pack national union of health care workers for quality patient care and union democracy. >> we need to select two committees from this level. >> okay. so - >> would you like to read it. >> okay. >> hydra mendosa for school board 2014. >> one more. >> ca bottle supervisor 2014. >> thank you. >> and we have one more audit policy of campaign committees would you be kind to read those? >> this is the third and last policy okay no one else san franciscans against gridlock yes on j and g chinese progressive association committee to pass laura's law 2014 miracle murphy for school board 2014 lee sue four board of education committee to elect the committee college board 2014 reelect public defender jeff 2014 ed donald son supervisor 2014 john railways do for community college board 2014 golden state restaurant association pack san francisco for a wort