and the memorandum based on the results of the ukraine-nato council meeting states that the alliance s developing a road map for ukraine's transition to full interoperability with nato. so i want to ask you, what is this compatibility and what exactly is it about? good question. in fact, you need to look at the document, unfortunately, i did not hold it in my hands, but first of all it was about the year the national program, which in fact we have every year since 2015, and they say that now there is a reduction of this article of the national program from 300 pages to about 10, that is, there is a compact document that goes on the main reforms, in fact, which coincide on 70-80 %, with the road to the european union, but... and i was actually not so very optimistic after this ukraine council, nothing too special happened there, except that we heard the assurance that we will be with you as long as there is necessary. er about some common history of its destruction within the framework of the military-industrial complex and finally some such unification of interaction, well, of course

so the historic meeting is the first meeting of the ukraine nato council, at the level of foreign ministers it essentially demonstrated that ukraine is moving closer to nato, and our foreign minister was on a par with all alliance members. so about podsu. meeting, we will talk with people's deputy, deputy head of the permanent delegation to the nato parliamentary assembly, solomia bobrovska. ms. solomia, i congratulate you, congratulations, glory to ukraine. glory to heroes. and the memorandum based on the results of the meeting of the ukraine-nato council states that the alliance is developing a road map for ukraine's transition to full interoperability with nato. ot i want to ask you, what is this compatibility and what exactly is it about? it's a good question, in fact, you need to look at the document, unfortunately, i didn't hold it in my hands, but first of all, it was about the annual national one. the program, which we actually have every year since 2015, and they say that now there is a reduction of this thing in the national program from 300 pages to about 10, that is, there is a

the ukraine-nato council was just formed at the last vilnius summit to establish cooperation between ine and nato structures. after all, what is happening on the border directly harms the national security of both ukraine and poland, as well as nato itself, because the eastern borders of nato some unknown people control all military cargo, if earlier, when i was driving, for example, from warsaw to kyiv, i saw a huge number of cars, and convoys with military equipment were lost among these cars , now, when the cars are blocked, to determine what exactly is moving military equipment is not a problem at all, but our... the president never addressed either nato or andrzej duda. previously, zelensky was very proud of his special relationship with the president of poland. even the servant of the people faction in the verkhovna rada staged a political provocation against they demanded that the newly elected seimas deal with the border problem. although at that time the government of law and justice was still finalizing its mandate. think about what we do. we appeal to the newly elected sena

in this part of our conversation about the ukraine nato council, this meeting was held at the level of foreign ministers, literally on november 29, some call it an absolutely historic event, well, i don't know, let's talk with you now , it must be said that this is the first such meeting, well, today is the first time we will sit with the ministers on an equal basis, said the head of the ministry of foreign affairs of ukraine dmytro kuleba, noting the difference between the former ukraine nato commission and the new council. in the council, ukraine has the same rights as members of the north atlantic alliance and the same opportunities for consultations. short the summary that i made in particular from this event, well, first of all, the support of ukraine on the way to nato, that is, the program of reforms described for us, for our full operational interoperability with nato, is being finalized, being prepared, and it seems that the talk is currently even going without about the absence of any political requirements for us. when we talk about the north atlantic alliance, it is importa

results of the first meeting of the ukraine-nato council at the level of ministers of foreign affairs

ministry of foreign affairs, dmytro kuleba, approved the structure of the recently created ukraine nato counciloved its work plan, as well as the national program for 2024, which prepares our country for joining nato. among the reform priorities, the fight against corruption, strengthening the rule of law, support for the protection of human rights and national minorities. the secretary general of the alliance said that ukraine has already made significant progress in modernization. i... in fact, i am impressed by the dedication with which ukraine approaches the implementation of reforms, the modernization of society during a full-scale war. we see that the ukrainians have introduced legislative changes, taken specific steps not only in the fight against terrorism, and now ukraine is in the process of reforming defense procurement in close coordination with nato and modernizing intelligence services, and at the meeting we talked about how to use the council of ukraine nato to ensure full implementation of reforms. nato is transforming its comprehensive... aid package ukraine for a multi-year su

the moscow start treaty or with potentials, relations with nato developed and was signed. the minsk declaration, the rome declaration , the councilrussia and nato was formed, moreover , as the president himself said, he even admitted the idea that we could become members of nato, although i must honestly say that time has already passed, i was in the ministry of defense and being responsible for this direction, we did not receive any specific... instructions to study this issue, that is , it was such a political statement, a trial balloon, to which, in general, a fairly clear answer was received that they were not waiting for us there , well, in general, when i communicated with my nato colleagues, i always said that we cannot be members of nato, because the american philosophy is that americans do not, do not join. our period, as i say, rosy in relations with nato, when we had 26 working groups holding exercises, conferences, dealing with issues of interoperability, did not last very long, well , literally 5-6 years in the seventh year in munich , the president already outlined russia’s attitude towards happening in the world, t

when the president or i or the minister of defense, we meet with our colleagues in the ukraine-nato councileneral, as a guest, in the alphabet. by the way, he was a smart guy, kuleba, young, smart, smart, a politician, he just turned into some kind of stuffed animal, absolute and pretty quickly, please, little man, little soul, how little he needs , just to sit between the big guys, so he told the ukrainians that they should live as if ukraine were already in nato, and not listen to those there who say something there he says, today the minister of finance of ukraine said, yes, that without money europe, if not yes, the west will not give money, then 10 million pensioners, 1.5 million teachers, 500,000 employees. they won’t receive a salary, well , you can develop the idea, cool tips, you have to live in ukraine as if you already have money, that’s all they received pensions as if they had defeated russia, as if zelensky already had beer.

so-called counter-offensive in the summer and autumn months by the armed forces of ukraine, the nato council ended in complete failure , the previous policy was nevertheless confirmed that support will continue and the goal is confirmed in principle sometime in the future ukraine will join nato , and those statements that you mentioned, there are many of them in the western press, they can probably be called a certain sobering, understanding that, i will say again, to some serious political change, this did not lead, if we talk about a change in nato’s position, i mean this, because there was some discussion about the fact that - members of the alliance can take a country that still has one, but yes, according to the rules , you cannot accept countries who have a territorial a conflict with neighbors there or with someone else, and now they began to say that it’s okay, you can take countries like georgia, and so on, there are also questions there, yes, or moldova is transnistria. well, georgia is clear, this is abkhazia and south ossetia and so on, that is, ukraine, accordingly, you can take

and vitaly portnikov, in fact, in this part of our conversation we will talk about the ukraine nato councilas held at the level of foreign ministers literally 29 november, some people call it an absolutely historic event, well, i don't know, now we will talk with mr., we must say, well, today we will sit together with the ministers for the first time on equal terms - said the head of the ministry of foreign affairs of ukraine dmytro kuleba, noting the difference between the former ukraine nato commission and the new council . in the council , ukraine has the same rights as members of the north atlantic alliance and the same opportunities for consultations. a short summary that i made of this event in particular. well, first of all, the support of ukraine on the way to nato, that is, the program. forms described for us, for of our full operational interoperability with nato , is being shaped, being prepared, and it seems that right now we are even talking about the absence of any political demands for us, although when we talk about the north atlantic alliance, it is important not to forget

they established the ukraine nato council, it's better than nothing, but it has no real impact on securityr membership we need more security guarantees, we need more commitments. we need to make sure that in the event that there is political will of russia to start negotiations, there should be a plan, a concept that will be accepted by nato countries, how to provide and ensure security for ukraine at this moment, there are already some things on paper, but i don't think , that there are any commitments from various nato members. and here i think we need greater political pressure from various political players, of course, from ukraine, but also from civil society in our countries. the problem is that people still do not understand that if there is no peace and stability in ukraine, it will threaten ours as well. if ukraine does not succeed, it will affect us as well. next could be moldova, georgia, armenia, the baltic states, we don't know, but russia will get an incentive if ukraine doesn't beat russia. with the beginning full-scale russian invasion, ukraine's allies provided our country

actually , in this part of our conversation, we will talk about the ukraine-nato council, this meetinge at the level of foreign ministers, literally on november 29, some call it an absolutely historic event, well, i don’t know , let’s talk with you now, it must be said that this is the first such meeting, yes, today we will meet with the ministers for the first time in rivne, said the head of the ministry of foreign affairs of ukraine dmytro kuleba, noting the difference between the former ukraine-nato commission and the new council. in the council, ukraine has the same rights as members of the north atlantic alliance and the same opportunities for consultations. a short summary that i made of this event in particular, well, first of all, the support of ukraine on the way to nato, i.e. the reform program described for us, for our full operational compatibility with nato, is being finalized, being prepared, and supposedly it is even being discussed now without the absence of any political demands for us, although...

pavle, here is the creation of the ukraine nato council, and a meeting at the level of foreign ministers. i am sure that you have analyzed this important event that took place on november 29, can we say that we have any practical gains as a result these stairs? well, the council is a good story, it does not mean that we now have the same status, the fact that we are at the same table, we can speak in a different way, yes, it gives us opportunities, after all, all decisions in nato are key , they are political, and if they are political, then this is a decision at the level of heads of state and government, and this is exactly the kind of meeting... the council has already been, the ministers of foreign affairs, when they meet, they are engaged in, i would use such a word, refining those political decisions, which are accepted by management of states and governments, and this is actually a meeting, it first of all gave an understanding of where we are moving in terms of interoperability, where we are moving in order to advance, well , actually in the area where we are already advancing, t

pavle, but still the creation of the ukraine-nato council and a meeting at the level of foreign ministers. i'm sure you 've analyzed this important event that happened on november 29, can we say that we have any practical gains as a result of these steps? well, the council is a good story, it doesn't mean that we now have the same status, the fact that we are at the same table, we can talk in a different way, yes, it gives us opportunities, after all, all decisions are made in nato. key, they are political, and if they political, then this is a decision at the level of the heads of state and government, and there was already such a meeting of the council, ministers of foreign affairs... when they gather, they deal with matters, i would use this word to refine those political decisions that are taken by the leadership, states and governments, and this is actually a meeting, it first of all gave us an understanding of where we are moving in terms of interoperability, where we are moving in order to advance, well actually... in the area where we are already advancing, that is, there with sys

brussels announced the date of the first meeting of the ukraine-nato council. ill take place on january 17-18 within the framework of the meeting of the military committee of the alliance. it is known that the commanders of the armed forces of nato countries will take part in the meeting. the press service of the alliance reports. they will discuss russia's war of aggression against ukraine and the next steps to support the armed forces of ukraine. another 1,080 russian invaders destroyed the defense forces in a day. thus, the number of eliminated occupiers has already exceeded 350,000 since the beginning of the full-scale invasion. also, our defenders burned another 14 enemy tanks, 31 armored fighting vehicles, 20 art systems, 53 units of cars and special equipment, and four szvs. in addition, they landed 26 enemy drones and shot down one enemy cruise missile. in... the general staff reminds that all data are approximate. the espresso tv channel together with the public organization baza ua is collecting funds for atvs to transport the wounded and other needs o

calm, then russia... signed these fundamental acts with nato, uh, eh, which created the russia-nato councild again , i repeat, in poland itself, in the czech republic, in hungary there was... no reason to think about such security, from our point of view, there were more reasons, let's say, in slovenia, which wanted to join nato in the first place, which was not accepted then, because they were worried about the general situation in the former yugoslavia, but the peoples of these countries simply remembered what russia was, knew, and so this is an extension. happened, those who made it, they got to the nat, got their security system, let's look at another, another, but, sorry, but we also knew what russia is, why the same experience is even more short-lived for them, than we have in some places, but the effects are so different, we did not know anything , what russia is like, ukrainians in 1994, three years before this fundamental act of russia-nato, before the ukraine-nato charter signed by leonid kuchma in madrid, voted for kuchma , it was... the first term: kuchva came to power with slog

in addition, at the meeting of the ukraine-nato council, which took place in brussels, the alliance highlyated the reforms that are already being implemented in ukraine, and at the same time outlined new plans for reforms. kurt walker, who was on the air before you, says that during the war there are none questions, there are no problems for ukraine to be accepted into the north atlantic alliance , because this will be a marker and an indicator for putin that no one will let him go... and even if putin threatens nuclear war or nuclear missiles there, no one will be on to consider, i will quote kurt volker, convinced that nato policy today is inadvertently sending a signal to putin to continue hostilities, because we say that ukraine will become a member in the long term, but we cannot bring it into nato while the war is going on. this is an incentive for putin continue the war. i really think it's time for us to do. the opposite message is that ukraine will become a member of nato as soon as possible, this will mean that there will be no way for ukraine to lose, then it will be pointless f

ukraine nato council.o zelsky instead of an invitation to the alliance in vilnius. and then in the summer, against the background of the revival of the armed forces of ukraine, stolteng probably did not think that he would have to say such things. we must understand that there is no silver bullet, no weapon that by itself will change the situation on the battlefield. it's a matter of system capabilities working simultaneously, which will be discarded. with readiness , the problem is clearly not only that it depends on nato itself, but also on kiev too. kuleba, who heads zelsky’s ministry of foreign affairs, came to brussels to boast about the successes of military development, away with soviet approaches. we are increasing our interoperability with nato. we are practically becoming a nato army in terms of our technical capabilities, approaches and management principles. if nato standards involve managing a poorly trained mass of yesterday's civilians at the age of 40 plus, then there is nothing to argue wi

and brussels named the date of the first meeting of the ukraine-nato council. ill take place on january 17-18 within the framework of the meeting of the military committee of the alliance. it is known that the commanders of the armed forces of nato countries will take part in the meeting. according to the press service of the alliance, they will discuss russia's war of aggression against ukraine and next steps with support of the armed forces of ukraine. ukrainian men living abroad are planned to be mobilized into the ranks of the armed forces. forces this may happen as early as next year - the minister of defense of ukraine said in an interview with walt tv. rustem umyerov emphasized that men of conscription age will be invited to the conscription points of the armed forces of ukraine. but as the german publication notes, the official made it clear that there may be sanctions if the request is not fulfilled. we are still discussing what will happen if they do not come voluntarily - omierova is quoted by welt. the head of the ministry of defense emphasized that

consultation and discussion of this situation. to initiate an emergency meeting of the ukraine-nato council , such discussions should have been done a long time ago, discuss how we act in such situations. so what's going on? russian attacks are taking place on the border, not only on the territory of ukraine, but also on the border with nato countries. so, some action must be taken. i think it is necessary to discuss the joint work of air defense systems, or joint work, well, actually there are, for example, border, joint. points, there is such a thing, that is, it is not about the sovereignty of the country, why can’t there be joint air defense points, wherever they are located, that is, the idea is that the poles can shoot down these objects, as they say, nlu, an unidentified lethal object, yes, that is , for them to be these objects until they fly to their citizens, to shoot them down, if they fall into the territory of ukraine, then we have such... agreements with them to have and accordingly, ours on the territory of poland, because it is over the border , so that we have to react to i

last week, well, a regular autumn meeting of the nato council at the level of foreign ministers tookcracy is huge, of course, there are a lot of statements, but frankly speaking, there is no point, just like the role of the general secretary, who we are completely unjustifiably exalted, so the general secretary said who the general secretary is, well, a bureaucrat who should, the main task is to hold a meeting council at the level of ministers there, at the level of heads of state, to knock with a gavel, well , develop some proposals, generalize something, send out, so to speak, requests in the capital, but he himself makes no decisions, and even speaks to the press conferences, to voice, so to speak, this is what happened and what will happen, so this is a fortune teller, or what? well , like, like, like, like, goroskov, so , what happened, what will happen, what will calm the heart, yes, but the salary is very good, more than that of the general secretary, he, although that’s all, that’s why and the estonian girl really wants to get there, an international organization, but this is

very calm, then russia signed these fundamental acts with nato, ugh, which created the russia-nato counciland again, i repeat, in poland itself, in the czech republic, hungary had no reason to think about their such... security from our point of view, there were more reasons, say, in slovenia, which wanted to join nato in the first place, which was not accepted then, because were concerned about the general situation in the former yugoslavia, but the peoples of these countries simply remembered what russia was, knew, and that's why this expansion happened, those who made it, they got into nato, they got their security system, let's look at... another , to a different situation, but i’m sorry, but we also knew what russia is like, why the same experience is even more short-lived with them than with us, in some places, but the effects are so different, we didn’t know anything, what russia is like, ukrainians 1994 , three years before this fundamental of the russia-nato act to the ukraine-nato charter signed by leonid kuchma in madrid, they voted for kuchma, it was his first term, kuchva came

well, the bureaucrat who should, the main task is to hold a meeting of the nato council at the levelgeneral secretary, although that’s all, that’s why he wants, an estonian girl, wants to get there, yes, although all international organizations, but this is not an open rule, they all calculate their salaries from the salary of the un secretary general, for with the exception of the nato bloc, well, that’s it. the swing was big, everyone expected that some fateful decisions would be made there. and what? there are two wars going on in the middle east, they expressed the hope that the humanitarian pause will last, that’s all, nothing more. as for china, they expressed it, well, taking into account the fact that, naturally, the united states has already created there, in asian technology. region and kvat and akus, this triple alliance is there, the usa, japan, south korea, so far without a name, i would like, no, some powerful statement was planned on the fact that nato it goes, so to speak, to asia, it goes to asia , it contradicts the basic, it contradicts everything, but nevertheless

on tuesday in brussels , the military-political new formation of the ukraine nato council finally made of an invitation to the alliance in vilnius. and then in the summer, against the backdrop of the revival of the armed forces of ukraine, stoltenberg probably did not think that he would have to say such things. we must understand that there is no silver bullet, no weapon that by itself will change the situation on the battlefield. it is a matter of systemic capabilities working simultaneously that will push the russians back, we must be prepared for a long and difficult fight. willingly, while there are clearly problems. not only in what actually depends on nato, but also from kyiv. kuleba, who heads zelsky’s ministry of foreign affairs, came to brussels to boast about the successes of military development, away with soviet approaches. we are increasing our interoperability with nato. we are practically becoming nato's de facto army in terms of our technical capabilities, approaches and army management principles. if nato standards involve managing a poorly trained mass of yesterday's

but the nato russia council back in the day to work on the joint security issues. so looking ahead, how do you say russia's relations with the west and say 10 years as well? i don't have a crystal ball that fail, but frankly, let me put it like that. as long as putting is in power. as long as he's under crumbling, there's going to be no change because for him and he made it very clear. there's not just about to cry. it's about russia standing up for what you called it sovereignty against the west. it's another question whether this, but it's good consensus of this piece on quite in rush or the put in the manuals exist, will continue because of all in this video clip that you showed. all the background, we've seen the text messages coming up in the russian. all screens, these are on selzer and one of them read, mr. punch. and when do your russia russia of your television become a reality? this is not the rush or we'll see. so maybe the route tensions which ones will explode and we will not be ready for that. but so far he's in control and he's ready for she is quote

there were five resolutions... of the security council of the permanent members of the security council, only natoes carried out three operations, carried out attacks on bases, pirates, missile attacks, among others, very actively... the russian navy participated, especially escorting, guarding civilian ships, merchant ships, well, from the twelfth year , companies began to hire private security companies that guarded each ship, so from the twelfth year to the seventeenth, there was not a single case of piracy being captured, in addition, puntland is such a quasi-state on the territory of somalia, where the main piracy bases were located, with it and this state. now the actions of the houthis have given a new impetus to the aggravation, this is not pure piracy, these are generally stated political goals, at least in our country legal piracy from the point of view of legal norms and responsibility for a pirate is classified in two documents: this is the geneva convention of the year fifty-eight on the open sea and eighty-second maritime convention. right, we have article 227 of the criminal code, b

then, was furious because of this, he was rude to his partner all the time, the creation of the nato council of ukraine was supposed to console him for a while, the historic, as the ukrainian media called it, meeting took place, and what was the result, but there you go... and we don’t know exactly how it will be, because this is life, and this is russia, and no one will tell you for sure, and whether we will be in nato or we will not be in nato, we want, but now the truth is that people are more interested not in this, but in who will be sent to the front line next against his will, zelsky is slow to sign a law that would lower the age limit for men to be sent to the front, bloomberg writes, zelsky is faced with a personnel dilemma. president's office. fears that the adoption of this law may lead to an escalation of tensions, it may also increase the mood of the world at any cost, this is a trend, although not very popular, it already exists and may become stronger. the law has been on the presidential desk for a long time, patriots who have not yet realized this continue to be caught on th

attempt, so to speak, to ask, are you waiting for us in nato, well, naturally, no one is there for us waited, and uh, all our attempts, uh, permanent councilrability, it was all there. but we will say more there, right now there is a lot of discussion there about this agreement, which is signed by the united states in finland, i think we are talking about the famous sofa, this is an agreement on the status of forces, this is not about bases, this is not so to speak, these are legal issues, although not a sofa for nato countries, in 1995 there was a little bit of relief... agreements between nato countries and countries participating in the partnership program for the sake of peace, we had disagreements there on weapons, on criminal civil liability, but all this happened, but after georgia, despite all these attempts to re-establish ourselves as independent, no one wants to see us in any, so to speak, no one wants to join us talk as equals, or you are in the general ranks. we haven't seen you since friday last week, what's the news on the fronts of the special military operation? well, in general, positive news, the enemy obviously has no c

well, of course, that's it. we see how the meeting of the council of nato and ukraine takes place inssels, where dmytro kuleba, the minister of foreign affairs of ukraine, receives good feedback about ukraine's movement towards nato, and representatives of the north atlantic alliance say that ukraine has done a lot to become a member they also approve of the north atlantic alliance and the reforms carried out in ukraine during the war. however, there is a procedure that has the north must be fulfilled by ukraine in order to join the north atlantic alliance, and this reform plan must be developed and implemented by ukraine, because next year the nato washington summit is to be held, and in this, during this, there will be a summit, well , as we expect, some decision regarding the adoption of a decision on ukraine's accession to nato, and we already have a punker on the line. mr. volker, i congratulate you and i am glad to see you on our air. mr. volcker, you stated that delaying ukraine's accession to nato is only encouraging putin's regime to an endless continuation of the war. but,

belarusians bring to personal receptions with citizens are brought to the council of the republic to a logical resolution. another step towards natorkish parliament 's foreign affairs committee supported sweden's bid to join the alliance. protocol on the entry must now be accepted by the grand national assembly of turkey, and then the document will go to erdogan for signature. earlier , the turkish president said that approval of stockholm's application could be facilitated by us permission to sell f-16 fighter jets to turkey, as well as canada's lifting of the arms embargo on ankara. it is known that the white house supported the request. with defense spending on the rise, germany this year approved arms supplies worth a record 11 billion 700 million euros, thereby breaking the 2021 record by 25%, and about a third of this amount came from ukraine, and the german news agency dpa announced such gigantic defense spending. member of the bundestag sevim dagdalin. in germany. the west planned to organize a revolution in serbia, french politician florian philippot said on social networks. the leader of the french patriots party drew a

fleets of all countries , members of the security council, permanent members of the council participated security, natoarried out three operations, striking pirate bases, including missile attacks. this is the malakh strait, this is the gulf of aden, the gulf of guinea, the southern part of the red sea, in addition, the approaches to the ports of brazil, venezuela and bangladesh, well, the main zone of operation, this continues to be the eastern part of africa, because the plane does not continue , the civil war is possibly continuing, which means that, well, now... the actions of the houthis gave a new impetus to the aggravation, this is not pure piracy, this is in general political goals are stated, at least legally, in our country, piracy of the eighth year on the high seas and the eighty-second year convention on the law of the sea, we have article 227 of the criminal code, but this includes pirates, i’m just a little bit. i want to add, including warships and vessels during air combat operations that strike civilian ships of neutral countries, well, in this case. the sieve struck neutral ships ope

nato parliamentary assembly for a long, long time, but then the same failures, the same breakdowns occurred in others, our own majority imposes its agenda, this has already happened with the parliamentary assembly of the councilturned out to be dependent, which worked in the interests of nato countries and the european union, and this is now happening before our eyes in the osce parliamentary assembly. we participate , where we try to declare our positions, but where we are convinced over and over again that dialogue becomes impossible there too, because the majority in the osce parliamentary assembly is now, as we know, created in order to ensure privileged security for member states, in this sense, nato is the antipode of the osce, but nato has captured the osce, a big meaning in the osce, as russian foreign minister sergei vidikarov said at a recent government hour hearing in the council. federation , the meaning of further dialogue with the osce is now increasingly under question, but this is not the only platform for the inter-parliamentary parliamentary dimension of brix. russia will chair brix next year, and we are planning to hold a number of parliamentary events of the highest level, we are preparing

nato. the criminal has denied that the council of europe has asked finland to ensure it keeps and stores open for migrant seeking protection. the closures meant many russians speakers living in finland or cut off from family members inside russia. i knew about that. hello. hello. how are you? he's on cheerful. it's all the same. instead of hugs and kisses, now only telephone calls, just 200 kilometers, separate to mckinney from his father, east gainey and his family lived in the finish city of elaborate on his bed across the border in saint petersburg. when seen and shut down, it's border with russia. you're guinea didn't know when he would see his father again. his death was recently diagnosed with cancer and suffered as to the ocean because of us though of doing your says that i'm, i'm very worried about his health. as i said, what if he gets worse now and i come to you with him. yeah, but i'm glad you think he misunderstood. i'm even thinking i would have to leave my family here 5 years a while you send you a decides and drive through more months. going to know a fly by a simple i don't kn

talked about the fact that nato calculations based on nato textbooks are no longer ... so relevant, the secretary of the national security and defense councilised to send all these nato textbooks to archives, in your opinion, what went wrong, that the counteroffensive did not give the results that everyone expected, about which everyone talked so loudly, at the beginning of the counteroffensive, they also talked a lot, during the offensive , they also talked about everything and continue to talk, well this is the work of those officials who must... must, must say, our work as soldiers is to perform the relevant tasks. we understand that the main task, one of the main, one of the main reasons is a well- prepared defense. i will say that the enemy was preparing, and i repeat that this is one of the strongest armies in the world, its defense consisted and consists not of one, but of several lines of defense. the enemy built these defensive lines directly in more than one month, during which he was preparing, during the period during which we were preparing for offensive actions, therefore you understand that intelligence works around the clock

all, what role he should take, then they will be pumped into the brussels offices, nato, the european union, the councilmissioner on some problem, somewhere, without solving any problems, absolutely, but receiving a solid salary, this is the emergence of this kind of, i would say, transnational bureaucracy, it is also a very stable mechanism, which is curious, some ukrainian politicians fit in by the way, they are trying to fit into this system, yes, i agree, they are trying to fit in, that’s the strength, not only that. not only leopards, not only the economy, but this political bureaucratic system, which, as i said, is attractive, not we need to conquer, who studies this among us, mgu, and mgemo, but if we speak seriously, then of course, we also fight against this, and in order to know this, it is necessary to create analytical groups that would study the enemy and develop, but this is a deep state, otherwise we talk a lot about deep stuff , this is diipsteate, i’m talking about something else , it’s just very important, but it needs to be studied in the most serious way, vladimir, we don’t even have

to the council, ministerial ukraine of nato, when high-ranking officials of nato come out and on briefingey say, but no, we know that ukraine has a military plan, refuting the nonsense of some people's deputies, of course it is very shameful, and it seems that today we all need to, you know, stop, and do everything to if not a facade, there was real unity both in power and among the military. military and political leadership , you know, i am not in vain asking about what is happening now in the ukrainian government, because literally today, colleagues from tokyo called me twice from brussels, and a japanese journalist, was taking a comment from me, and my colleague called from brussels, asking what is happening in your ukraine, and there were questions here and there, which just amazed me. what is happening now between zaluzhny and zelsky? to be honest, i was very surprised by the set of questions from one journalist and another, but it honestly struck me, what is happening now between the supreme commander and the commander-in-chief of the armed forces of ukraine? i'm not a gossip, you

nato countries have their own the majority impose their agenda. this has already happened with the parliamentary assembly of the council of europe, which turned out pendent, which worked in the interests of nato countries and the european union, and this is now happening before our eyes in the osce parliamentary assembly , where we participate, where we try to declare our positions, but where are we time after time we are convinced that it is there too. dialogue becomes impossible because the majority in the osce parliamentary assembly is now, as is known, occupied by nato countries and the european union, although in fact, the osce was created in order to ensure the indivisibility of security, and nato was created in order to provide privileged security for member states, in this sense, nato is the antipode of the osce, but nato captured the osce, the meaning of the big thing in the osce, as the minister of foreign affairs said russia sergey vichlarov. at recent government hour hearings in the federation council , the meaning of further dialogue with the osce is now increasingly questionable, but these are not the only platforms for inter-parliam

has something to do with danilov’s statement; the head of the national security and defense council said that natosh, given that we hoped, we wanted, we tried, but their nato science led us... lithuania would be very sad if the soviet union did not win the great patriotic war. if you open any archival materials, there are a lot of documents, most of them, by the way , are signed by rosenberg, this is hitler’s comrade-in-arms, a baltic german, what fate should the baltic population have in general. this is the settlement of these territories by germans, which means colonists, yes, the germanization of part population, but only 30%, because the same rosenberg, despite the fact that he has baltic roots, considered the baltic peoples inferior and 70%, according to their plans , should have been destroyed, but unfortunately, again, propaganda, western propaganda about this doesn’t tell the residents of the baltic states, well, look at the baltic states. now nato troops are already leading there, german troops, yes, and before that the economy was completely captured by german scandinavian business, yes

nato nations. the president of the un security council has said yesterday's vote on gaza is a crucial step towards averting a humanitarian catastrophe. the resolution aims to increase the supplies of aid to the territory, but does not call for a ceasefire. for the first time in centuries ukraine will celebrate christmas not on 7th january, but on 25th december. earlier this year, president zelensky signed into law a parliamentary bill that aimed to "abandon the russian heritage of imposing christmas celebrations". now on bbc news, take me to the opera: the power of glyndebourne. i've been an opera fan for decades, and i want to share my passion with you. so i'm on a mission to find out how opera is reinventing itself for the 21st century. this time i go to glyndebourne in the english countryside to find out why it's a unique place that offers more than opera. we've got beautiful grounds and gardens and lakes, a wonderful visual art gallery and then a wonderful opera. glyndebourne may be a historic venue, but it is also trying to make opera fit for the future by being a pioneer in sustainability. w

nato nations. the president of the un security council has said yesterday's vote on gaza is a crucial step towards averting a humanitarian catastrophe. the resolution aims to increase the supplies of aid to the territory, but does not call for a ceasefire. for the first time in centuries, ukraine will celebrate christmas not on 7th january, but on 25th december. earlier this year, president zelensky signed into law a parliamentary bill that aimed to "abandon the russian heritage of imposing christmas celebrations". the grandmother of alex batty has spoken of how she felt "utterly betrayed" by her daughter and ex—husband when they took the schoolboy abroad. in an interview with the sun, susan caruana said she feared she would never see her grandson again. our reporter nickjohnson has more. susan caruana waited six long years for this message from her grandson, alex batty. their first direct contact since he failed to return from a holiday in spain with his mother and grandfather. now back in the uk, alex and his grandma have been speaking to the sun newspaper, describing the last time they spoke ov