irvin painter the historian formerly known as nell painter. please welcome professors patricia bell-scott and nell irvin painter. [applause] >> would you like to say something about pauli murray before we start? >> i would like to say how pleased i am to be here at this event hosted by an institution as part of her alma mater. hunter was very important to her. she came here in 1928 after having graduated from a small high school in the south and all they went to the 11th grade which meant she had to come to new york and earn a second high school diploma so she could be admitted into hunter and if you have read her autobiography what you know is that hunter of all the institutions she approached during the weekend here was the one place where she found acceptance and encouragement, so she did come to hunter. pauli had all kinds of financial trouble so she did drop out after her sophomore year but she eventually returned and one of the things that she always remembered and would credit hunter for were her relationships with two professors here.

- [nell] mrs. findlay! mrs. findlay! - where could she be? it's seven o'clock in the morning. - [nell] i don't know. - bed hasn't been slept in. was when she came in at two o'clock this morning. - you were up at two o'clock this morning? - oh, i just happened to be here at the bar. - she had a date with senator myers last night. did he bring her home? - yes, but they were so late that your mother suggested he stayed over. i made up the sofa for him in the den. - must be so depressed. - ?(lyrics) [maude] i am woman, hear me roar. (laughter) (maude singing) - mother. mother. mother, ever since you decided to run for the state senate and walter walked out on you, you've been so upset. - carol, honey, it doesn't matter. and found walter in bed with... carol, walter and i are finished, over, through. so i've decided to paint the entire house. (singing) - [carol] mother, come on, let's have some coffee mother. - i love this color. i found it in the garage. it's the new me, carol. bold, independent, sort of a brash olive at five o'clock from the hos

[applause] thanks to patricia bell-scott and nell irvin painter for this discussion. [applause]lause] [inaudible conversations] >> that was patricia bell-scott talking about the book "the firebrand and the first lady" one of "washington post" notable books of 2016. i am the non-fiction editor of the washington post. in july 2012 the 82 year-old nun, a vietnam veteran and a house painter crack security at the highly fortified nuclear facility in tennessee as site known as fort knox of uranium with the massive concrete and steel building thousands of nuclear bombs the incident is that the centerpiece of the book almighty a frightening but dispassionate look at the current state of nuclear security and diplomacy. that follows the lives in the trials of the three nuclear protesters and makes a point to explore the impact of nuclear weapons testings at the marshall islands with the largest bombs were tested. and those who lived downwind of the testing flats' in nevada. where there really conveys the fear and danger of nuclear weapons as the discussion of proliferation is u

taking a look at our waukesha camera, first blast of the evening is i'm julia nell fellow. katie crowther has the night off. >> our winter weather advisory has been extended to 9:00 tonight. >> brian. >> definitely away from michigan, that's where we have higher snow amounts. you can see the back edge of the snow start to go clear through madison. we have a couple more hours to go of the snow in milwaukee. night fall settles in, the snow will stick to the pavement. let's zoom in on southern spots, kenosha, racine, these darker blues is where we're seeing the heaviest of snow right now, working across our southern spots. i think most of the area will see another couple hours of snow and maybe an additional inch on top of what you've already seen. most of us will fall in that two to three inch little less along the lakeshore. winter weather advisory extended until 9:00 p.m. because that snow arrived a little bit later, will continue a little later. couple more hours to go in milwaukee. snow at 6:00, maybe a still few flurries at 9:00 but i think things will be over with. 33 b

second quarter, andrew luck, under pressure is picked off by reggie nell sewn. oakland takes its 80 yards in less than a minute. carr to rashard for the score and will celebrate with the fans in the black ol'. it was 19-7 raider at the half. authority quarter, frank gore up the middle but coughs up the football. two plays later the give to washington and the rookie from texas tech take is it in for a touchdown, second of the day, 33-7. in the howth, raider by 19. carr has his leg twist it. he suffered a broken right fibula and will have surgery tomorrow. oakland beats the colds 33-25 but there wasn't much celebrating with the news about carr injury. >> derek had a break of his fibula and requires surgery. going to try to get it done tomorrow so he well be out indefinitely. once he is healed and ready to go, we-over go. >> mike shumann was the last san francisco to -- the two teams met at the coliseum, goff got the start. san francisco takes the early lead. kaepernick for toe hyde for the touchdown. 7-0 niners. the rams appeared to take control by scoring the nex

faosoputors office is now offering up to $2500 for infotlation that h" ips them track downheieror uilh ey nell. a 27-year-old woman is charged with murder in the death of her boyfrshnd. akartiin s westcott turned yourf in for the murder of her ip atiriend terrell brin ce. w is tcbut has >> s com is sed pulling the trigger from the passenger seat good we are learorng more aip pol the shockg death of hollywood legend, debbie reynolds, she passed away one dyou after her daughter, carrie fisher also died. she apparently suffered a stroke at her home in gros anp fhe was h" iping to plan fishers funeral at the time and funeral arrangor en of for bbuh are sti waing sode. >> the obama administration is expected to issue a pmoulic retaliation for russia after the cyber attacks. they were meant to embarrass hillary anpinrpn and h" ip dona hillcfi sou.nrpn and h" ip dona kenneth moton joins us live with the full details from waed bington, greev >> sara sourr is t" il abc fus that these u.s. actions are aimed at punishing russia and deterring fpolure acapacne bute response will be proportional. the last t

. >>> things are not so rosy for two penn state players, black nell and bowan are suspended from the rose bowl game for violating unspecified rules. and drexel plays depaul. and they started 12-0 and starts big east conference play tonight for villanova. can't wait for that. >>> adam joseph and the accuweather forecast coming up n. fios in the house! dave this fios party is da bomb! fo shizzle! it's tv totally ahead of its time. yo, let me check that. oh snap. that x1 voice remote is crunk! and it lets me search with the sound of my voice. what should i watch? things have come a long way since you got fios. [nervously laughs] what's fios? fios has fallen behind. don't fall with it. xfinity x1 will change the way you experience tv. >>> adam joseph is here your wet than white. >> most of it in the form of rain. a little snow on the onset in the lehigh valley. as we look at stormtracker 6 live double scan nothing happening at the present time here. temperatures today topped off in the middle 40s but falling back quickly with the clear sky for the most part. upper 30s for philadelphia an

so i know it's hard for you to keep what happened between me and nelle -- you know what? carly. it's done. let's just let it go, okay?

downloading happens, if app from a retailer go to the retailer's website and lock for the app because nellirect you to the direct one. >> how do you know i'm on the proper wednesday i'm the? >> now we're getting back into the how does the internet work and where are we every day? >> still good tips for people to hopefully protect themselves this time of year. ed and jeremy, thank you both. >>> moving on to memphis, the home of elvis presley and the birthplace of rock 'n' roll and global headquarters to one of the biggest shipping giants in the world, fedex. our morgan brennan gives us a look amounty behind the scenes of the high-tech handle and how it manages the surge. >> after dark this is the busiest airport in the world and during the hawke holiday season it gets even busier, 156 fedex planes land here each night care 2eg million packages destined for doorsteps. >> the planning process started literally as soon as we were done and then now into our super bowl. that's what this is. >> between thinking and christmas evening, 10% more than last year and many will pass through here in what

as nell has suggested it happened because of strategic self-interest, princeton and yale, dartmouth to admit women. by the late 1960s, these schools were beginning to see applications decline, the high school students, referred to as the best boys no longer wants to go to all mail institutions. to attract that, this is the time when harvard begins to pull away from yale and princeton in the competition. coeducation became the means for places like princeton and yale for first-rate applicant pool. it is not the result of any high-minded moral commitment to educational opportunities for women, not a matter of a mission to educate women or deep thinking or how to educate women, but about women could do for previously all mail institutions and how women would help renew their hold over the best boys. women in other words played the instrumental role of improving the educational experience and it is not surprising going coed does not always serve, for coed classes. for a later point which may be unexpected, the protagonist in the story are men. and the president of radcliffe, every strategi

when you look at the movement of amiri when he first showed up in italy nell was shot in milan, it'snding. it's a classic case study of a breakdown of a variety of issues related to counter terrorism. >> i'm glad you brought that up. it seems to me there are so much issues this particular case raises. every single time almost it seems when we have these cases, you have got i history of people like this involved in these acontrolsities having come to the attention of law enforcement they slip through the net. with your back ground you must have thoughts on why that is and what we can do to correct that. >> you look at amiri, the berlin attacker who has just been killed. he was labeled a terrorist threat by the italians before he moved to switzerland then germany. over a decade in terms of how we take this intel and couple with the operational actionable leads. you have data basses in italy and germany and france. here in the rules about privacd some are important. we have to have a balance. but you look at the e.u., and these countries are operating under extremely restrictive archaic

"it's just that i don't like a man being called unequal nell gets a chance to prove his inequality."ter say. this came at a time of personal crisis when he could no longer bear the compound disillusionments of his homecoming. he needed a crusade to just not only his cartoons but the whole catastrophe of the war to which he had borne such eloquent witness. during the war, willy and joe's camaraderie served as partial redemption for the brutalizing conditions of their existence. now the real willy and joe were in the shadows, misunderstood and overlooked, alienated survivors out of the tens of millions dead. their sacrifice -- bill always hated that word and refused to use it -- seemed for naught in a country that denied equal rights to citieses and deemed to be gearing up for world war iii against erstwhile ally the soviet union. while overseas, mauldin had avoided ideological outbursts and never allowed partisan politics into his cartoons. back home, however, he jumped into the political fray with both feet. he moved to new york city and began giving speeches, offering interviews and

. >>> are you selling your old nell phoe? >>> when you go outside and go oh my goodness. this feels amazing. how do you even play golf? >> when i got in my car and rolled the windows down, i felt like it was april or may. it was spectacular weather. only 4 degrees shy of a record. now the sun goes down and temperatures go down as well. with cooler air moving in it, it's a cooler day. really looking quite nice. 61 degrees still at the 6:00 can hour. by 7:00, temperatures so it's going to get. cooler, but still this time of year, not bad at all. out there right now, temperatures around the region a 54 in martinsburg. 52 over towards maryland. all in all, a very mild evening. on the radar, no rain or snow any time soon. that's the number one question i'm getting from folks on facebook and twitter. we did see shower activity this morpg. now not seeing a whole lot. we're clear from d.c. up towards philadelphia all the way down towards atlanta ask all the way up towards upstate new york u. we're clear and that's going to continue to the case. the cold air is moving into all tho

in april 1941, elizabeth nell joins the number 10 typing ten, taking dictation from the prime minister. sometimes his voice would become thick with emotion, she recalled. and occasionally a tear would run down his cheek. the next month he cried when visiting the destroyed chamber of the house of commons and didn't make any attempt to wipe away the tears. when in june 1941, the following month therefore colonel george broussard, the spy chief met churchill in london, his account of the sufrgs of occupied france reduced churchill to tears. the permanent undersecretary at the foreign office noticed the prime minister crying the following month also while watching that hamilton woman, the great laurence olivier-vivian leigh movie about admiral nelson. and while singing oh god our help in ages past with president roosevelt in newfoundland, a german president noticed how churchill was affected emotionally as i knew he would be, his handkerchief stole from his pocket. he wrote to his brother tom about the effect of the bombing of cities and the way it affected churchill personally. in particu

ja nelle will be up in a second to show you the cams here. the fog ahead a front that will bring us a few showers today. only about 20% coverage. we are going to go from these temperatures to much cooler weather up ahead. the upper 60s to low 70s right now. close to 80 degrees by noontime and then a few showers roll in. 20% coverage. drying out and cooling off tonight. the latest numbers coming up in just a few minutes. >>> good morning, everybody. we are watching a couple of crashes in pinellas county starting off here at 54th avenue north right at 49th street. reports there intersection there. another crash reported at mcmullan booth and enterprise. the back upstarts around 580. if you are heading that way leave yourself a few extra minutes to get around that crash. and we've been talking about the foggy conditions all morning. still seeing some fog out there along the i-4 corridor from lakeland all the way down through plant city. again, leave yourself some extra time. the good news, no crashes or break downs on the interstates. >>> we are

here to respond we have sheriff paul babeau from pin nell county. >> good to see you. lauren: and donald trump is the law and order president, he's showing that with response to germany? >> that's great news to be receiving a new president and president donald trump will be known in my lifetime as the greatest law and order president we've had and somebody who actually supports us in law enforcement at a time when you look at germany, the president-elect's response is we're going to go after and destroy isis. meanwhile barack obama is playing golf in hawaii. lauren: it's tough talk from donald trump. here at home we have 820,000 illegal immigrants according to a new report, most of them, 84% of them criminals. is trump with his tough talk going to be able to track them and deport them? >> absolutely. these aren't just criminals. 84% of this 820,000 are actually convicted felons. these are our most dangerous criminals in the whole country. and the fact that these people are not from the united states, they're from other countries, not just mexico, central america and ot

an idea that trump supporter scotty nell hughes articulated last week. >> i hear half of the media saying that these are lies. but on the other half, there are many people that go, no, it's not true. and so, one thing that's been interesting this entire campaign season to watch is people who really facts. everybody has a way of interpreting them to be the truth or not truth. there's no such thing unfortunately anymore, of fact. >> seth: no such thing as facts? [ light laughter ] that can't be right. let me take out my snapple and check. oh my god, you guys. it's blank. ?? now this brings us to foreign policy because in a little over a month trump will be in charge of our relationships with the rest of the world. and when you're dealing with major foreign powers in conflicts in unstable regions facts, really do matter, whether you believe in them or not. in china, trump has long promised to do things differently with china if elected. for example, there was the time the chinese government failed to provide president obama with the customary red carpet stairs to exit air force one. and trum

jim will hopefully dig that out of him. >> kelly evans is a w nell person. >> you knew that.it good for labor to see more of the type of deal mr. trump made? bill rogers, professor at rutgers, ron christie gop strategist and former special assistant to president george w. bush. welcome. let's start with your reaction to something that was -- that mr. trump did yesterday, that is he applied the bully pulpit, used a business man's kind of leverage, i would say, to get something that he wanted from a carrier corporation and united technologies. some, like the wall street journal, are critical of that. even calling it a shakedown. how do you see it? >> i don't think it is a shakedown. this is a smart move. he had the opportunity several months ago to speak to mr. hayes, the chair of united technologies, which, of course, owns carrier. had a conversation. said we shouldn't be moving these jobs abroad to mexico. we should find a way to keep the jobs in indiana. they did so. they found some tax incentives working with the government of mike pence in indiana and fouad a way to do so.

trump's surrogate, scottie nell hughes, went on cnn and pointed out that a jay-z video had images of molotov cocktails, but she called them something different, and so much better. >> when you look at jay-z. we talked about this that night. that he might be working on -- but one of his main videos starts off with a crowd throwing mozeltov cocktails at the police. [ laughter ] >> seth: now, for those of you who don't know, a mozeltov cocktail is what you throw at a jewish wedding if the groom is not a doctor. [ laughter ] congratulations on your union. now let's burn it down! and yet, at the same time trump with ted nugent who has repeatedly made racist and anti-semitic statements. said thing about hillary that we can't even repeat here. and he did this on stage at a trump rally just last night. >> i got your blue state right here, baby. [ cheers and applause ] black and blue! >> seth: wait. what? [ laughter ] why are your genitals black and blue? [ laughter ] it is it because you keep grabbing them like that? because -- you should go see a doctor, like, right away. [ laughter ] altho

do nell pump fri ran for 158 yards. brought a total of 6,405 over his four year career. surpassed the old record by eight yards. it happened at the las vegas bowl on saturday. leading to a 34-10 win over the university of houston. finally, when you enter one of those secret santa gift exchanges you never know what you're going to get or from whom. one hit the jackpot. erix got this huge box in her home. inside was her secret santa. that's right. billionaire, bill gates the -- true story. santa showered her with electronics, games, books, mittens, even stuff for the cat. >> the pets, those were hers not in the box? >> they didn't come in the box. she had been in this before previously. her secret santas turned out to be stooges and have given her nothing. it's worked out. >> it was definitely coming her way. how do we get in the secret santa pool with bill gates. how did that happen? >> i think that's the end of the year for bill gates. >> always next year. >> my gift is coming. >> really? >> a bag of coal. moving on to less cheery santa news. could amazon be experiencing

scotty nell hughes laid out the principle i've heard to date. >> one thing that's been interesting, ise that say facts are facts, they're not really facts. everybody has a way. it's like looking at ratings, everyone has a way to interpret them of being the truth or not true. there's no such thing unfortunately any more of facts. >> we got a different version of thesis from cory luan dow ski. he insisted the media's at fault for insisting trump knows what he's talking about. >> you guys took what trump said so literally. the american people didn't, they understood that sometimes when you have a conversation with people, whether it's around the dinner table or it's at the bar or it's wherever it is. you have to say something and maybe you don't have all the facts to back that up, that's how the american people live. >> trump appears to hold a similarly open ended view of the things he himself says. it wasn't until he saw a guy on the news who is taking seriously his pledge to keep carrier jobs in the u.s., that trump decided he meant it. >> they had a gentleman worker, great guy. handsom

. >> jeffrey lord, corey lewandowski, scottie nell hughes. >> not together. >> no, but people hired by to represent the trump side. by the way, cnn hired more trump surrogates than any other network. >> if cnn early on last year was a lot more open and fair and balanced. it seemed as the race went on, they started realizing that this is serious and we need to now start to hammer him harder. >> so you would have liked to have seen more complete numerical balance on the panels. >> yeah, because it's not news. >> and a lot of lies. >> it's making people think a particular way. >> hold on a second. what were the lies? >> a way of lying is to deceive, okay. when you deceive, it's the same as a lie. when you give people the impression that donald trump does not have the real support that he has. keep it just simple. a simple fact is just at his rallies. hillary clinton, a big rally for her would be 1200, 1500 people. the media would pan around the room and show how huge it was. he'd have 30,000 or 40,000 people. he'd fill up a football stadium. they would just narrow in the frame just on him

listen to what scotty nell hughes who is a paid person by cnn to be a trump supporter. listen to what she said about facts. >> listen to that construction there at the end. people believe they have facts to back it up. >> therefore, i will say it. whether or not i can materialize those facts. >> i was getting e-mails and calls long before donald trump made this accusation about illegal voting and i'm sure you did too. >> oh, yeah. >> the reason she was ahead in the popular vote millions of illegal undocumented had voted. >> when you get the toxic intersection of that stuff bubbling up in this fake news set of venues, and then the president-elect amplifying it, that is when you're in the danger zone. >> you asked if somebody around him who can stop it or will tell him no. at the harvard conference this week on the campaign, corey lewandowski was asked about one of the -- i can't remember whether it was judge curiel or another episode where trump went off the rails. he said he had advised trump not to do that and trump did it any way. >> it does seem as if the only effect

and if some of her critics would have the courage to come on this show i would talk to them nell anyt david has been watching all this closely. david, it's great to see you. so, i don't think liz spayd made a particularly controversial point when she said readers have to be able to trust reporters working for papers like the "new york times" aren't acting out of their personal convictions when they cover the news. that seems like a pretty basic point, no? >> absolutely. it's actually quite short-site sighted to be critical of that point. i think in the scheme of the next few decades, we will see this obsession with twitter as further undercutting the already troubled image of the mainstream establishment media after all, journalists are held in about as much respect as bankers. we have seen opinions of journalists have since the late 1990s. and it doesn't help when journalists news reporters at perhaps the country's most esteemed newspaper are tweeting is that correct and tweeting snark comments. this is a debate about perceptions. news reporters ought to be doing everything they can

setmeyer, cnn political commentator, simone sanders former press secretary for bernie hughes and scottie nell political editor at right alerts.com. welcome to all of you. going to be a tough conversation but we will get through it together. scottie, was this just politics or does it reflect the two americas everybody says we live in now? i ask you that first because you recently tweeted this. quote, i apologize if i ever said anything mean or caused hatred towards someone with courage to respectfully voice an opposite opinion. why did you tweet that and what do you think about the top of my question? >> well, this campaign season has taught me several things and honestly, shameless book plug, i and others write about those in the december 6 release of "unprecedented" which you can get in your local bookstore. one of the biggest lessons i was able to learn is it takes courage to continuously go into situations and environments where you know the audience, the panelists, the people you are going to be speaking to, do not agree with you, do not like you or what you stand for or the candidate you

he didn't have a whole lot to say nell was asked about air force one. welcome, everybody.unesse was okay, by the way. martha: live tv, you never know what's going to happen. 10 below. give the guy a break. bill: last hour in trump speaking with reporters in the lobby of trump tower. i'll saunter down and meet with the folks and i'll be back in a moment. here is what he said 30 minutes ago. >> we have some great people coming in today. you will see them. >> what are you going to talk about with the mayor from washington, d.c. today? >> we are going to talk about a lot of things with a lot of people. >> i heard you are canceling the contract for air force one? >> the plane is totally out of control. it will be over $4 billion for air force one. i think boeing is doing a little bit of a number. we want boeing to make money, but not that much money. martha: jonah goldberg and melissa francis. welcome to both of you. let's start with you on this. your quick reaction to donald trump's tweet which is how things usually get rolling. $4 billion for the pair force one package? cance

nell naloxone. it could save lives. >> you can't shake the dictiaddn completely. always going to be that monkey on your back. but you can't. >> -- >> not the stigma. your body is always going to crave it but there is a way to tamp this down. >> the way to defeat it is first of all get rhode island of this sha -- get rid of this stigmrid of. >> the addiction is there. you have to be careful of it and you need support. >> get help. absolutely. >> dr. david samati. always a pleasure to see you. >> arctic blast this weekend hitting many areas and bringing their first snows of the season. >>> and jurors hear the chilling confession from the accused charleston church shooter. our legal panel is here. the latest on the trial of dylann roof. with nature's bounty hair, skin and nails you'll enjoy lustrous hair, vibrant skin, and healthy nails... so no matter what happens,... you'll still feel beautiful. nature's bounty hair, skin and nails. better off healthy. >>> jurors viewing a chilling videotaped confession in the trial of the accused charleston shooter dylann roof. ro

. >> that was the death nell for health care because he was the 60th vote. >> a year of his presidency barack obama was likely staring at a defeat. >> there are people who think that if obama had been more of a schmoozer that maybe people like you were too partisan that somehow he needed to reach out. >> just one golf game away from singing kumbayah. give me a break. >> desperate, obama changed gears. first, he apologized to the country. >> i take my share of the blame for not explaining it more clearly to the american people. >> then he barnstormed for the bill across america and in congress. >> i may not be the first president to take up the cause of health care reform. i am determined to be the last. >> yes, we will. >> freedom. >> yes, we will. >> freedom. >> and he made more concessions, giving up the public option, which would have created a government insurance program that would have competed with private companies. >> we ended up having to wrestle this thing to the ground in a way that was less than ideal from my perspective. >> finally, march 21, 2010. >> on this vote, the ay

ok. nelle's ctors turned toude children's search hospital here we've helped incr the o childod ccer survil0% 8. we will not stop until we h. d jalle, you're gng up. dor showhe yosee.org thjude logo. ♪ >>> welcome back. let's get over to the cme group and join rick santelli for "the santelli exchange." rick. >> thank you. it's the final exchange of the year. kind of bittersweet, but nothing bittersweet about my guest tim cross. tim, thanks for taking the time. >> crickrick, good to see you. happy new year to you. thank you. >> happy new year to you and all our listeners. you wrote something i find fascinating and many are thinking it. when they look at the markets, there's not a lot of big trump fans out there other than all the people who voted for him, they say, ahh. and you wrote, honeymoon before the wedding. i get it. i have a retort to that. okay. maybe it's just the party before the divorce papers are final. so my contention is we're underestimating the fact that we've had a really cool president with really uncool policies towards business, his administration in my opinion thinks as

craig nell sewn. >> when the soviets invaded -- when the nazis invaded the soviet union the japanese war taken aback. that had a treaty with stalin and a treaty with germany and thought they were on top of the world, at this sort of closure point. they thought they would be their own united nations. and they were completely taken aback in and in the negotiations in fact over and over hear hall says hitler turn on -- he's going to turn on you. >> mike on c-span 2. >> caller: okay. here we go. my newed is this japan diplomatic code were bron by the time this war was started so the fdr administration knew what was going on and i understand at that time they american aircraft carriers had been sent away from pearl just before the attack occurred. so, the japanese war attacking military targets. so, it appears nat admiral kimmel and his men were being betrayed by the roost administration. the american response was to attack civilian darks and drop napalm on cities of tokyo. what is your group's response to that? >> host: steve twomey. >> he raised several points there. i can good through

franciscan i worked in district attorney's office and do criminal defense and on the bar association in nell question endorse john the southern california is concerned with what we are politically many of the people are targeted in the 9/11 world the fact by other people but by law enforcement so that's important to us but i want to share like a personal story why i personally am endorsing jonas a prefer and criminal defense attorney you speak to laermd in the trenches and people with contact with the police and influenced how justice if you have a victim mistreated it focuses their ability to come forward and testify and if you have a defend balanced treated by the police they don't come forward the whole notation we as citizens have ability to supervisor our probation officer police department for that reason we ask you to consider john for that position. >> thank you very much. >> next speaker, please. >> good afternoon. my name is michelle i'm a public defender from the public defender's office and a resident of san francisco for the past 4 years lived in supervisor mar's district and li