i'm trying to figure out how much the observer or the informed observer knows.t seems to me that when you think about the three factors from our case law controlled almost all of the work, because really it's the informed observer knowing about the degree of control that the government exercises, that if we're creating this fiction, makes the informed observer think or not think that the speech is actually uttered on behalf of the government. would you agree that control is the most important factor? >> i think that's right. control is the most important factor. and that's because all of the factors are just that, they're factors to determine who is speaking. and when you're asking the question who is speaking, generally the person speaking has exercised some degree of control over the message being conveyed. >> what if the city exercised complete control in this sense, it was a policy that says anybody can put up whatever message they like on a big billboard that we have in front of city hall, except that we will review all of these messages and we will exercis

ab observance, a remembrance. there's not ever a suggestion that the city hall flag pole was open to all comers. >> thank you, counsel. >> just briefly, you mentioned diversity several times. and what i don't understand is your definition of diversity because it would seem to me that christians in boston would be a part of that diversity calculous. >> the specific form of diversity that the city was trying to celebrate was national origin day --ty. the reference is to coup tries throughout the world. of course, there are other aspects of day --ty. the city can choose to celebrate those aspects of diversity in many ways. they celebrate religious events in other ways. there's been events that happened on city property the city chose not to start down the road of speaking on the subject is of religion from the flag pole. had they started down that road, the argument would have been they had to carry all religious communications because theyen couldn't prefer one religious communication from the flag pole or at least

when you read this article in the _ you read this article in the observer, it feels like in the lastcome quite senior people, including sir charles walker, as rob said, maybe not a household name to many, but he's held a senior position at that influential backbench committee. i influential backbench committee. i think a lot of tory mps are yet to make up their minds and i think for many of them, the question will be, as the prime minister got the moral authority he needs at this time when we have more than 100,000 russian troops ranged on the ukrainian border, at the time when there has been a sino—soviet pact between president xijinping and president putin? and the prime minister will need to look like a towering figure on the world stage punter and that is the question i suspect they will be asking themselves and i suspect that many of them do not really know the answer yet. also, i would say that, as intimated in some of the papers, many will not wish to act too quickly because if the attempt too quickly because if the attempt to get him out of hisjob fails, he is in it for anoth

observing smells across the internet. i tasted with my father-in-law, a wine instructor and miller fan. when tasting is clicking observing wine smells with other people can feel erlike an improv troupe finding their flow. it's all yes and. you can smell and taste different things once a someone with a more expert, as pointed them out. it's taking a line withfocus, the fun of taking something more seriously. back to me and the glass in the smells . previously i had a sliver of anticipation, time to drink something yummy. but now i can see how the smells point in many directions at once. the smells i observe right now back to the past. they connect me with other people, all of us smiling together and the closeness of true friends and perhaps the most important factor isn't an arrow pointing anywhere. if the dock of now. wine smells a does because of innumerable factors. is made, age and change over time and what i bring to you and even changing a glass between six. it's almost as alive as i am. all right. i think wine is in

they're same for the observers. as you've just admitted to me and not always reliable, you don't really know what's going on, i'll say, and i always level dot challenges because a human institution, you just don't want to take one of the classes as part of the message. the best way to go is attach certain video companies that will be able to get more of their views as high. she's already speaking of technology, let me company manual because what more can be done in terms of technology to improve not just regulation, but implementation of these laws. we have not been able to coin quick successful culture. so these pieces that can i to, i didn't really talk, what did you look at? i got a cockroach or something i would gun. well regulate, right? well, investing to, that's one of the options to resolve this problem, right? nana we, we, we support a quarter, but we, however, disagree with the use of fish to fit. uh huh. in order to rely on fish mean for o'clock watcher. it's all sustainable. is against you and convention

the fishies commission has a glazed observance in these vessels. it is the machine that pays them, and so if they are not lucky to observe, oh no, even go, you've had about one person who got miss him and the person is yet to be found. yet an observer, if you go and you decide to do the right thing, you are frown upon by the authorities who have placed them. okay, let's hear from the person from the commission. now, number one, you're the ones who license these vessels and to be fair, the bulk of the funding that comes from that industry from industrial vessels is from licensing. on top of that, the observers allegedly come back and report things which are not taken up because of all these companies, we decided to pick observers as fish, fishes, the, our kids giving what i will, they will know what, what is all $1.00 come to the porch, we expect them, then we will not be able to look at any illegal. net at is enough for some of them that are the same people that are complaining, they just keep the net for them for free, and then to meet them at hou

the observers take is that _ vote at that point.ake is that it's inevitable, - vote at that point. the observers take is that it's inevitable, quite | take is that it's inevitable, quite the opposite on sunday times. you need to take division to get me out of dino street the prime minister tells his allies. it doesn't sound like he's fazed by these growing calls from his own side. == like he's fazed by these growing calls from his own side. -- downing street. it calls from his own side. -- downing street- it is — calls from his own side. -- downing street. it is extraordinary, - calls from his own side. -- downing street. it is extraordinary, the - street. it is extraordinary, the language _ street. it is extraordinary, the language that the prime minister has employed _ language that the prime minister has employed this way. he's referred to the lion— employed this way. he's referred to the lion king, he is compared himself— the lion king, he is compared himself to othello and now he is seeing _ himself to othello and now he is see

yes, an observer. if you go and you decide to do the right thing, you are from upon by the authorities who have blaze in them. okay, let's here from the person from the commission. now, number one, you're the ones who license these vessels and to be fair, the bulk of the funding that comes from that industry from industrial vessel is from licensing. on top of that, the observers allegedly come back and report things which are not taken up causal. all this completion we decided to pick observation as fish fish, as the kids giving what i was able, know what, what, you know, when the toilers come to the porch, we'll inspect them. then we will not be able to look at any illegal, a net as an officer, some of them that are the same. people that are complaining, they just keep the net for them for free, and then been re done what houses and then there's under met them. but the issues that the memory will not be able to be with each of the officials. you're thank to me that you don't have eyes and ears. they'r

the observer front .ae. hard to know. the observer front -ae~ has hard to know. _ hard to know. the observer front page has got sadiq khan - hard to know. the observer front page has got sadiq khan the - hard to know. the observer front i page has got sadiq khan the mayor hard to know. the observer front - page has got sadiq khan the mayor of london warning about his views on the next head of the metropolitan police service having been so instrumental in the ousting of cressida dick and that he would not support any successor to her who does not understand the deep cultural programmes within the beleaguered force. this is an exclusive for the observer. it is really interesting area to look at in terms of how much power he wields on this. we have seen the power he wielded in her resignation but it is the home secretary who ultimately makes the call on who the next commander should be and how are they working together on this? this commander should be and how are they working together on this?— working together on this? this whole kind of argument _ working togethe

some very robust observations about the culture in - observations about the culture in downing — observationstions about the culture in downing street, she was- observations about the culture in downing street, she was clear. observations about the culture in downing street, she was clear that rules had been _ downing street, she was clear that rules had been broken. _ downing street, she was clear that rules had been broken. the - rules had been broken. the investigation sits at the police, and they will decide in the coming weeks, possibly months, but that the law was broken or whether penalty notices, fines should be handed out to people in number ten potentially including the prime minister. i think that gives or is something of a rep read for now, and i think tory mps are waiting to see but that police does, to see what happens in the big set of local elections coming up in may before deciding whether or not to pull the trigger, because it is a huge thing for a tory mp to do, certainly to say publicly that they do not feel that there prime minister is up to the job and should resign, but

i think it's a key observation. _ observation i think it's a key observation.pe us with the legal issue here. no formal admission of liability here, and one of the things which was interesting in the run—up to this in the weeks before hand, i recall virginia giuffre's layer getting an interview shortly after they whine or rather prince andrew's attempt to dismiss the case was thrown out. i recall him saying at the time that she would potentially be in the market for some kind of settlement. she doesn't want to go to trial for trial�*s sake. anyone who brings a case is told by their lawyers, if you can avoid going to trial, please avoid it, because it is so incredibly expensive and damaging. the potential for, incredibly expensive and damaging. the potentialfor, you know, blowback for years to come can be awful. so he was indicating that she was prepared to settle but he made clear in that interview that she wanted some recognition of what her words amounted to and what she'd suffered and gone through, and in hindsight, that was clearly a coded signal to prince

and as we turn to the observer, picking up i turn to the observer, picking up another strand of this,t out and trying to verify what has been posted, because social media as you have both said is playing a vital role in this conflict? it is have both said is playing a vital role in this conflict?— role in this conflict? it is and propaganda _ role in this conflict? it is and propaganda has _ role in this conflict? it is and propaganda has always - role in this conflict? it is and propaganda has always beenj role in this conflict? it is and - propaganda has always been putin's most powerful tool against his own people _ most powerful tool against his own people. steve rosenberg from the bbc has been _ people. steve rosenberg from the bbc has been reporting all week and it looks— has been reporting all week and it looks like — has been reporting all week and it looks like regular russians in russia — looks like regular russians in russia are not buying into the propaganda to the same extent putin anticipated band that may be one of his key— anticipated band that may be one of his key un

let's go to the front page of the observer. being a pariah i of the observer.mir putin. that's right, that mi . ht vladimir putin. that's right, that miaht be vladimir putin. that's right, that might be his _ vladimir putin. that's right, that might be his default _ vladimir putin. that's right, that might be his default by - vladimir putin. that's right, that might be his default by this - vladimir putin. that's right, that. might be his default by this point, but i think the russian people who could be on the end of some free a serious damage may feel differently. the world has been overwhelmingly against russia's actions. this includes china, which abstained on the un security council motion to condemn russia. russia would have hoped china was on their side. even country like turkey, hungary, people have been sympathetic, they have come out. viktor orban said he completely endorses all the eu sanctions. he says a lunatic should be isolated. this is someone that many in europe might continue a bit of a little —— consider a bit of a lunatic. i think this poses

and when we observe, we observe all kind of as well, but we really felt was because we were on the goals in india and the good when we have a cy thing, we have to record out what we actually see them doing, say whether that swimming or diving their somewhere in that general vicinity. papa dolphins die. they sure smiled. come on dolphin. they belong to a large boy that name on it are for the last 11 years. and now that he was able to undo the big picture of adorable things with them identify which individual they are. and when we last saw them. since i was very young, i always loved the science of biology in nature. i must be 7 near the volt and they don't allow that 5. i believe that we saw a farther away bmw built in a very special landing mice. they have a very complex social structure and they are very intelligent. artic hedges, great jumping on as well. and you can see the themes and this thing that a big so that then define them. oh, we have a very over a i that is rare guys, my giant berwin fin. ways these animals and children know more about the dinosaurs and those realize next to

one of the observations i saw six months ago.up in any compound in any molecule that suffered a quality. it still has that rotten egg he smell. it sounds like, okay, it kind of is. that is how early they are in the process. yes. i love the way that you described that. the smells are opening up in a certain time. you notice the different time of day. they are attracting during the morning or whatever. >> flowering plants have been around for 340 million years. basically, they evolved in companionship with insects, for the most part. and, now i feel very bad because 20 years in the virgin islands, bringing in all of these honeybees. these honeybees are out competing. the pollinator species are just back. you are losing a lot of that diversity because, sooner or later, the honeybees are just going to die. >> yeah. and then you would be left without the pollinators. it is something that really needs to be captured before it is all gone. >> yes. all my gosh. a question. >> this will be good. >> can you get it? [laughter] >> enjoying t

and when we observe, we observe kind of as well. but we really felt was because we were on the goals in area and the good. yeah. when we have a side thing, we have to record down what we actually see them doing say whether that swimming or diving their somewhere in that general vicinity dolphins die. ah, the shores now come on dolphin. they belong to a large for that name on it for the last 11 years. and now that he was able to undo the big picture of adorable pain within identify which individual they are. and when we last saw them. since i was very young, i always love the science of biology in nature. there must be 7 near the volt and they don't allow that 5. i believe that we saw a farther away than that of a special landing rice. and they have a very complex social structure, and they are very intelligent a. and you can see the themes and then this thing that a big so we can define it yet. mm hm. we have a very diverse, a that is a rare, guys might a giant, the sperm weighing fan ways these back, you know, animals. and yet chil

the officers observed a person on the ground who was holding their leg and someone saying the personby witnesses that the suspect dropped something on the ground. officer lee looked at the object and saw that it was a firearm. officer lee approached the suspect and as he did, the individual reached into his pocket. officer lee displaying admirable restraint and discipline gave immediate commands to the subject demanding to see his hands. officer lee directed officer torcheon to handcuff the suspect who dropped the firearm while he secured the firearm by stepped on it in a chaotic and uncontrolled scene. as officer torcheon attempted to handcuff the individual who was now on the ground, the suspect began to resist and pull his arm away from officer torcheon. the danger opposed by the suspect at a scene where a victim was shot is now resisting attempts to restrain him. the suspect was reaching in the direction of where the gun lay on the ground inches from him. officer lee called for backup and advised that the suspect was resisting arrest which updated multiple units already respondin

what i observe what — yes, it is also pretty true. _ yes, it is also pretty true. what i observe what i hear _ yes, it is also pretty true. what i observe what i hear from - yes, it is also pretty true. what i observe what i hear from my - yes, it is also pretty true. what i . observe what i hear from my friends and family is that on the other hand people really are getting on with their everyday lifestyles and it is also part of, you know, resilience, and the ability to keep mental well—being under uncertainty and pressure. i read today from my colleagues and friends about holidays abroad they have the planned celebrations of the next week, etc, etc, they don't cancel their everyday professional activities at all. but one of my friends, she's a professional dentist, she told she put on hold strategic planning, she put on hold her big projects because she understands that within the next week or weeks it might happen that she lives in the capital kyiv, the capital is attacked or might be attacked from air. and this worst possible scen

withdraw israel's observer status. if i vision for a block that values consensus, this internal clash is expected to hamper proceedings as it heads into the 2nd and last day. of the summit on sunday, ah, now to the olympics and the luge is under way at beijing's national sliding center . germany typically does well in the event. in fact, since louis became an olympic sport in 1964, it germany has won the most gold metals, detail he's jonathan crane went to find out why this is lose a sports where competitors hurtled down a hill that speeds up to a 150 kilometers per hour. early to find out at the bottom is a german has probably one in germany, we have her big loose traditional kits. they do this board and everyone is on fire for this for. i think this isn't very big advantage. germany dominates news like no other country at the last winter olympics in 2018 german athletes, 13 of the 4 gold medals on offer. so why is that? germany invests heavily in sled technology and infrastructure to support its lose teams. that incl

it's broad in the sense what are the observations the study i saw six months ago one of the observationst was amazing it is so for shows up in any compound in any molecule tends to retain its quality. bounds of carbon bonds or something else it sells a rotten egg smell which sounds like this does not fill or revelatory but kind of is to people that is how early they are in the process. yes. i love the way you describe that though. it's like seasonally the smells are opening up at a certain time and you notice the different times of day, different flowers are attracting different pollinators that are active are not active during the morning or whatever. >> flowering plants of the number 120 -- 140 million years they basically evolved in companionship with insects for the most part they were the pollinators. and so now i feel very bad because 20 years it's st. john and the virgin as an intact forward they brought in all these honeybees. honeybees are out competing all the pollinators for the pollinators species are dying back. and so you are losing a lot of that diversity because sooner or

highest with vigilance is required and that a significant withdrawal of russian troops has not been observed so far. so the opposite of what president put in the saying, they agree on that. the situation in the border area is still extremely serious. yeah, there is kenny, confusing messaging with russia, saying it's pulling back its troops, nato, and the usa. that's not really the case. here's the latest press conference from the state department spokesperson. net price. to be very, very clear. we have not seen that. in fact, we have seen the opposite in recent weeks. and even in recent days, more russian forces not fewer are at the border. and they are moving concerning li into fighting positions. this is cause for profound concern. so in as, what are we to wait in to this? well rayleigh, we all know that the 1st victim in a war is always the truth. so what we are experiencing right now is kind of an in for war being at full force in that regard. the statement of president biden is also a kind of a strategic reply to the information put in one's to spread by saying he is pulling troops back

one thing that does make _ pleasant one to observe. observe. one thing l that does make a lot of people laugh every day is the met cartoon. i think we can show it here. can we zoom in? well done. that's our director. just talk us through this one, kate. it’s director. just talk us through this one. kate-— director. just talk us through this one, kate. �*, ., , ., ,, one, kate. it's two people wrapped u i one, kate. it's two people wrapped u- in their one, kate. it's two people wrapped up in their living _ one, kate. it's two people wrapped up in their living room, _ one, kate. it's two people wrapped up in their living room, and - one, kate. it's two people wrapped up in their living room, and then i up in their living room, and then the husband is a saying to his wife, if you wear your coat and here, you won't feel the benefit when you go to bed. which isjust ludicrous! this is what people are having to do. people are having to make these awful choices about heating, about how they live their lives, whether they have enough money to k

with no international observers on the ground to check these claims and tens of thousands of russian troops still in place and bowers, the black sea ukraine leaders say it'll take more than just a few statements as a photo, opportunities for them to believe that the danger has really policy hearing heard, give people tell you that they've been living with war in their country for the past 8 years. that the tensions of recent weeks and nothing new. the russia can't scare them yesterday, but i don't think there's any danger. that's my opinion. i don't think there's any war ever coming up because you know, train and russia. 8 is always on wire since 2014, i guess. and this is just a political thing. you know yet, so deal it. i think there's no chance. so my futon will take that risk a to good, but ask a few more questions and many will admit the news of ukrainian oligarchs and politicians leaving the country in recent days. and private jets came as shock that the wealthy and the well connected no things over people didn't. ukraine's president, ludmilla zalinski is now struggling to take

physical evidence and available video evidence, including an unmanned aerial vehicle which began observing the scene about three minutes after the attack. at this point i want to acknowledge that the investigation differs from what we initially believed on the day of the attack. at the time the best information we had in the immediate aftermath of the attack indicated that it was a complex attack by both a suicide bomber and isis-k gunmen. we now know that these explosively fired ball bearings calls for wounds that looked like gunshots when combined with a small number of warning shots that led many to assume a complex attack had occurred. the fact this investigation has contra ticted our -- contradicted our first investigation, demonstrates to team the team went into the investigation with an open mind. it confirms the age old fact that the battlefield is a confusion and contradictory place and it gets more confusing the closer you are to the actual action. that is why i ordered the investigation to find the truth. our commitment to transparency has now led us to provide you our best info

according to some experts, there is an understanding by the population, but also independent observers that this is not the objective is not security on me, or that this idea it does. conceptualization of security is also married with conceptualization around migration management on top of the european missions. there's also a un mission running concurrently in molly. the country hasn't really known peace or stable self governance in over a decade. well, that report from jack para, who joins us now from brussels. welcome jack. so as well as france went over to canada and a couple of other european countries are withdrawing their troops. so where does this leave marley's fight against you? hardison? well, in a pretty difficult situation, to be honest with you, phil, what the french president and i was showing a press conference in paris is that the around 2400 troops that is stationed in marley, specifically with the a goal of trying to fight extremist to had his a in the country, they will now be moved into other places. he suggested that they might go to natasha and also into the gulf

legal observers say andrew reall had useful. legal observers say andrew really had little _ useful. andrew really had little choice _ useful. legal observers say andrew really had little choice but - useful. legal observers say andrew really had little choice but to - really had little choice but to settle. ., . ., really had little choice but to settle. ., _, , , .,, settle. out-of-court settlements as we know are — settle. out-of-court settlements as we know are most _ settle. out-of-court settlements as we know are most often _ settle. out-of-court settlements as we know are most often used - settle. out-of-court settlements as we know are most often used to - settle. out-of-court settlements as we know are most often used to try| we know are most often used to try and keep things private. he has given her something in this wording, he said he acknowledges that ms giuffre is an established victim of sexual abuse.— giuffre is an established victim of sexual abuse. buckingham palace offered no comment _ sexual abuse. buckingham palace offered no comment but - sexual abuse. buckingh

consideration of sworn testimony of more than 100 witnesses and especially those witnesses and observation towers american and british who were in locations unaffected by the blast and that had commanding views of the scene before, during, and after the explosive attack. this conclusion was also confirmed the findings and analysis of medical examiners and explosive experts. a review of all evidence and all available video evidence including an unmanned aerial vehicle which again observing the scene about three minutes after the attack. i want to acknowledge that the investigation differs from what we initially believed on the day of the attack. at the time, the best information we had indicated that it was a complex attack by both the suicide bomber and isis-k gunman. we now know that the explosively fired ball bearings caused wounds that looked like gunshots and when combined with warning shots, that led many to assume that a complex attack had occurred. the fact that this investigation has contradicted our first impression demonstrates to me that the team went into this investigation wit

we've got to figure out how to tap those lessons learned into those observed. it may not be practiced on a day-to-day basis, but when there's a crisis we need to have the coordination between the appropriate federal and state and local authorities and the private sector partners. >> yeah, no, i mean, we're systems federalism and we need to apply that when we're talking about data sharing as well. >> to mr. currie, the strategic national stock piles should be a critical tool. by quickly providing medical supplies to aid in the response. what are the most significant challenges when it comes to managing the strategic national stockpile? >> ma'am, since covid and really, well before covid, we've had a number of concerns about the strategic national stockpile. before covid we were concerned about the way it was funded sporadically and what it meet mean in terms of readiness to handle an event like this, in the past it was to use h1n1, or what is the target in the specific areas of the country or specific population, of course, in covid we needed it nationwide and i

well, that thing, there are no observers on the ground. the russians have basically claimed that these are lots of smaller exercises rather than one big exercise, which if there were more than $13000.00 participants on the internal rules, the russians would have to allow international observers in, as there aren't any. this is all based basically on either what the russians say they're doing or on western intelligence using satellite imagery, or to try and work up what is actually happening. the interesting thing is that some of these people, these russian troops leaving crimea actually based institute on ukraine's border. so they basically be moved back to their home based in locations where they could still potentially strike ukraine. so not much of a difference. the major takeaway is that the troops that have been brought in from siberia, from the russian forest, they are not going home for now. so no real sense here in ukraine that this is a major shift. and more really, the, the of is the idea. at least from ukrainian decision makers.

this week, sold a launch of the energy observer to concept. this prototype is powered solely by renewable energy on his capable of producing its own hydrogen using salt water. oh, and as of silva in of yellow energy observer, 2 is a 120 meter long and 22 meter wide ship which can carry fights has and tons of freight. her own as no one is a 0 direct emissions if the hydrogen fuel that powers the electric engines is produced in a carbon free way. it was anna of 20. milton methodical. the plan is to have the 1st operational 0 emissions cargo ship take to the seas by 2025 carrying up to 240 freight containers. if boats are built on this model, it could de carbonized a 3rd of the world's existing fleet. the revolution in energy technology could c, c o 2 emission cargo vessels make way for a truly sustainable way of transporting goods on the high seas. and a reminder of the top business story we're following for you this. our key u. s. inflation gage rose a steeper than expected 7.5 percent in the year through january high energy prices . supply con

so i want to read this headline about how they observe the world and then interpret it for you. okay, here's the headline, and it's a real headline from the u. k. the daily star. it's a tabloid, it's like an onion. portion of, you know, not really true perhaps, but latimer putins war threads or why aliens haven't made 1st contact, expert claim rushes. vladimir putin. constant threats, risk in world war 3 or up doing is hindering chances of aliens making. first contact with humans on earth. a u. f. o expert has fed nick pope who investigated flying saucers for the m o. d believes e t z who keep a close eye on earth will view russia escalation of tensions with its neighbor as primitive behavior. this is the sort of analysis you see from the washington post in new york times that they can observe something and refused to see the truth. so they have to make up some elaborate schemes of aliens coming from outer space and then deep galaxy far away to explain things. but of course, max, you and i have been already visited by you up. i was so the fact that they visited our show in 2013

as some kind of international observation. so it becomes clear what exactly rusher is doing. what those intentions are, not much in the way of chances that that will succeed. but certainly ukraine pulling out all the stops and showing that ellis, in terms of talking it is open to dialogue, but not really as such, willing to make the concessions and offer any of the kind of miti m concessions. and a, the kind of the still, the kind of demands that russia has been putting on the table in recent weeks. talk about it russian demands. one key demand is that there is a guarantee that ukraine will not become a member of nato. is ukraine increasingly ready to maybe give such guarantees what we heard from ukraine's ambassador to the u. k. he was austin in to you today . whether that might be one of the possible concessions. and he said yes, but then within a couple of hours he rode back on that and said that hadn't been his intention. that the main thing now was to de escalate the situation and to maybe make progress on the piece proce

but most independent observers say that the language in minsk agreements is very vague. in terms of what kind of governance there could be in those territories and the ukrainians have argued that it has russia and the separatist, those are consistently of violated those terms. what do you say to them? well, we can, we can argue about the governance and the other language. but the terms of the men's agreements are actually very concrete. and they involved pulling back heavy artillery from the separation line. that's number one. the number one point that was never observed from the ukrainian side, but the ukrainians again, have said that they are simply responding to russian provocations. so on this. but yes they are, but they're also, they're also never provide any proof of set publications. and again, you know, we're talking about to pull back of heavy artillery what is that an answer to if you're not pulling back your heavy artillery, what are you answering to what kind of provocations you mentioned to you, you refer to our president putin speech a couple of days ago, i

this work is based in philadelphia based on observation interviews history. what have you? and i lived in various parts of philadelphia and i've done few work in these areas of the city. and follow people through these spaces. i've been i've worked in corporations. i've worked on the street. i've worked in communities. i've befriended all kinds of people blacks and whites to get this understanding this body of work that i've created over the years beginning in chicago with a place on the corner that's spent three years on one street corner with the black street quantum men. that was my phd thesis. but then i came to philadelphia and i wrote this book called streetwise, which was an analysis and ethnography of a changing the inner city community. basically, the gentrifiers were moving in and black people were moving out oftentimes, but it was all about how people live in that community called streetwise. and then i was very became very concerned about why so many young people in inner city communities were killing each other and so began to investigate that issue and that re

the second observation that was mentioned earlier, her ability to inspire people through talking to them, the rhetorical capacity from the beginning had been limited and i think that in our society like many other societies as we are flooded by the internet and social media, we need more not less explaining and if i can put it this way, leadership. i think that's been increasingly difficult because i guess she thinks any normally gifted person has the understanding of what i'm saying and doing and what i've been deciding because that is the only rationally sensible thing. and i think she found it difficult when people tried to explain to her you've got to go to the marketplace and you've got to go on television not only a little bit of blogging once a week or so, but in a more hands-on matter and i think that has been especially the last several years with the migration crisis and all that came with it that has been one of the downsides. the last point i want to make is and i think this is also about the characteristics, normally one would think that if somebody leaves a job after 16 yea