pataki: hard work. door-to-door. not being partisan. in that city, democrats were first, independents were second and republicans were third in and rolled. -- third in enrollment. i knew i had to forget about partisan politics and had to have ideas that appealed to them. it is ideas and a vision that appeal across party lines. that was a great lesson for me in my first race and has been a lesson that america could lose -- could use more of. people should not have this blind, partisan loyalty. once the elections are over, we are all americans. we will reach out across party lines and govern based on solutions and not partisanship. steve: let me ask you about the farm. the new york times writing about your appearance regularly in the west village. it is safe to say that you are the only candidate that operates the farmers market, or sells beef at the farmers market. gov. pataki: i think that is pretty likely. it is something that has been in my blood since i was a little kid. my dad with the horse and wag

pataki: hard work. door-to-door. not being partisan. in that city, democrats were first, independents were second and republicans were third in and rolled. -- third in enrollment. i knew i had to forget about partisan politics and had to have ideas that appealed to them. it is ideas and a vision that appeal across party lines. that was a great lesson for me in my first race and has been a lesson that america could lose -- could use more of. people should not have this blind, partisan loyalty. once the elections are over, we are all americans. we will reach out across party lines and govern based on solutions and not partisanship. steve: let me ask you about the farm. the new york times writing about your appearance regularly in the west village. it is safe to say that you are the only candidate that operates the farmers market, or sells beef at the farmers market. gov. pataki: i think that is pretty likely. it is something that has been in my blood since i was a little kid. my dad with the horse and wag

pataki: i was in the city. my daughter called me and said debt a plane hit the tower and turn on the tv. she was rattled -- said dad, a plane hit the tower and to turn on the tv. she was rattled. i said it was probably an accident, then the second plane hit the tower and i knew it was an attack. we had to get the emergency response system. i called president bush and asked him to shut down the airspace and he had already done it. then we went to work that day and you can never anticipate it, nobody knew what might happen next. it was a horrible time but a time when you had to put aside the other concerns and to do whatever you could lead to the crisis -- whatever you could to lead through the crisis. i spoke to mayor giuliani, he had been out of pocket for a few hours because he was trapped under a building when the command center was destroyed. he called back and said i am ok, we have a new command center. in about a minute i said i am bringing my entire team down to meet with yours. from that afternoon on, 24

pataki: everything is different. i am the only one -- there have been liberal republicans, but i am the only one running as a conservative on the conservative party line. i think that my record is different from earlier candidates. they were other governors of new york. every race is different. people too often try to fight the last war or rerun the last race, this is about the 21st century, reclaiming confidence in our future, believing that the best of america is not behind us but ahead, and of the problems we face are not insurmountable, but with the right leadership in washington we can grow the economy stronger and reclaim our role of respect in the globe and protect our security. i am running because i know and believe if i have a chance to lead the country and can do that. steve: you remain in single digits in the polls, do you still think you can win? gov. pataki: sure, i am not running for any other reason. it is early. he looked back at other races and the front runner never almost makes it to the end, or b

glove new york city pataki, they are debating the policy of granting u.s. citizen ship to every baby born in this country even if born to undocumented immigrants. senator graham wants to end it, governor pataki, you support keeping it. >> it's a small part of an important issue. let me comment on what my colleagues said. we have to secure the border. people have to come to america legally. that has to be step one. step two is we have to stop releasing criminals into the communities. if you are charged with a crime as an illegal alien, you should be in jail or deported, not released as the obama administration has done. of course, we should out law sanctuary cities and hold them responsible, but we can't ignore 11 million people here. what are we going to do? we're not going to send them back despite somebody saying we're going to drag kids off of classrooms and send them back, but we have to send a message we're a nation that depends on the rule of law, and when your first act so to break the law, there has to be a consequence. i would require those who wan

governor pataki, you're first. >> hi, i'm george pataki, and i'm honored to be here this afternoon withibrary. you know, when i think of ronald reagan, i think of his tremendous smile, a smile that reflected his optimism and unending belief in faith in america and in americans, and it was that belief in america that led to a great presidency a presidency that led to decades of safety, security and prosperity for america. that's exactly the type of leadership we need in washington today, and that's why i'm running for president of the united states. thank you. [ applause ] >> hi, i'm rick santorum. some of you may know me because i led the the fight to end partial birth abortion. some of you may know me because the i led the fight to end welfare as you know it, put people back to work, reduce poverty and reduce the federal budget. some of you may know me because i successfully put sanctions on the iranian nuclear program in congress over opposition of both parties initially. hopefully, most of you know me most because i'm the proud father of seven children with particularly a special lit

pataki. >> i'd say pataki.

we need to recapture that spirit. >> governor pataki is joining us now.r, thanks for joining us. what was it like to return to the world trade center site and speak to the victims' families. >> wolf, i still have that same emotion that i did on the first anniversary, that sense of loss and sorrow, of the real human tragedy that happened that day. but then you talk to family member, give them a hug, see their strength and courage and it reminds you of the strength and courage new yorkers and americans showed in those horrible hours. we have to recapture that sense that we're all americans, we're all in this together. it's very sad that what had been a unifying experience, we were the most united of my lifetime, now we look at washington and see it's the exact opposite. >> you talk about how much the country has changed since those 9/11 attacks 14 years ago. you saw the pain, it did unite america. what else did you see today? >> i also saw the resurgence of lower manhattan about which i'm very proud. we had this horrible human loss but we also had an econom

tom: pataki. clarence: i say pataki. john: lindsey graham. bye-bye. ♪ >>> good evening and welcome to kqed "newsroom." i'm trivoo. fire crews are battling a wildfire that has destroyed more than 600 homes in lake county. they're worried that warm weather could add fuel to the blaze. three people have died in the fire andt least one person remains missing. four firefighters have suffered burns. the blaze known as the valley fire ignited last saturday and is burning in parts of lake, sonoma and napa counties. it's one of more than 5,000 wildfires scorching the state this year according to cal fire. >>> marco

it was during your program, state of the union, trump tweeted out why is george pataki allowed on the debate stage? i know you didn't make up the rules, didn't make up the criteria. what do you make of trump going after other candidates like this, challenging their legitimacy. our argument would be the more candidates the better, because then you hear more voices. >> first of all, george pataki is not on the main debate stage. he is on the undercard debate stage with the three other candidates that did not make the cutoff for the main debate. so that's -- he will be on the debate stage, that's true, but he won't be with donald trump. he is not at 0% in the polls. he is at i believe 1% in the polls or whatever the minimum is to make the debate stage. so that's not accurate in terms of qualifying to get on the stage. in all fairness to donald trump, george pataki is attacking donald trump and attacking his legitimacy. george pataki said that he is not going to vote for donald trump and donald trump won't be the nominee. so, in this instance, it appears more like donald trump is firing b

george pataki is touring the stage. they're getting their turns.ust talked to my colleague asena jones. here's what the governor just said. >> what id you do to prepare

here's a republican who doesn't like pataki. he's going to be an extremist, he's too conservative for the state. so it hurt. but on the other hand, i was talking earlier, when you grow up on the farm, you think you have the best crop and a hurricane comes along and you pick yourself up and go along anyway. and that's what we did. we picked ourselves up and said look, that's what he thinks, but here's why i can lead the state and change things. ultimately, made the case, fought the fight and won. that's exactly what i hope to do here. i was way behind in the polls. i understand i'm way behind in the polls on the republican side now. but there are a lot of serious issues facing the country. i know i have the ability to resolve those issues working as a conservative republican but with democrats as well. and i hope the people, as the election gets cloeter say yeah, pataki is the right guy to bring us together and solve these problems. >> just two questions about governor cuomo. in the last two weeks it began to turn in your favor.

to me it is not george pataki.ou can't. nobody knows what he looks like. >> i was going to say i can prove it because there was a crowd at the event. >> i think that is the hardest any media entity has gone after him. it is too good for too long. >> you know he is 10 feet tall and he can crush you. >> when is the last time you ran into pataki? >> in the green room. you are so in trouble. >> i will stay in the shadows. julie, is rubio a formidable candidate now that he put out this video? >> i was worried until i saw this, and then i found out his wife is a cheerleader for the miami dolphins and i am a little worried. >> it is fantastic. i thought he was great. >> that is absolutely the most scripted and impromptu video. that was more authentic video than any hillary clinton video. >> even if it was scripted he has a natural feel and a smile and made fun of drinking of the water bottle. >> he is 42 years old and he has a comb over my father would be ashamed of and he loves comb officers. >> i think it will give him

you cite bobby jindal and george pataki. they need to be relevant. to be relevant is to attack donald trump. jeb bush has a different mission on the primetime stage, which is to show fortitude, toughness, willingness to take it to donald trump as he's been trying to do on the trail. >> i read a fascinating "new york times" article just out this morning indicating bush has been preparing for just that time of thing. ana, you're close to jeb bush. you have been speaking to jeb bush. this is a guy who wants to get up there and talk policy, right? but he needs to do more than just policy here. how much life does he need to show, how much energy does he need to show? and does he need to be concerned about being dignied? >> i think he needs to figure out how to do both. how to be memorable and also how to be knowledgeable. donald trump, as we have discussed already, can get away with not knowing the names of the top terrorists wanting to harm america. jeb bush can't, because he is the policy guy. he is the wonk. he needs to be solid in all his answers. but

pataki did not give an answer. >> i think that shows you how much -- >> don't these guys think ahead?on't you know if you swear you will back whoever wins except that guy. >> i'm not sure anybody will throw the hand raising back at them. >> i just did. >> you are the only one. >> don't they think ahead? >> you would think they would. that is how they get caught in the moment and the words come back to trap them. if you will stake out the position hold the ground and stay true to it. you can't hold the question. >> you thought the guy made the strongest impression on you was lindsey graham of south carolina. >> senator graham brought a little happy to the happy hour debate. the lindsey graham we saw on fox news was sower. lindsey graham was one cracking jokes, loose. he has been in the mix on almost every exchange that we have seen. even the other candidates on the stage have turned to him and looked to him and he stood up on immigration. he said hispanics are americans. >> he has the guts in this crowd to do that. >> he stood his ground that he staked out and in that venue he looked a

george pataki is also running for president. he looked back at the past to governorship. smaller government and more bipartisanship taking a stand. another look is florida republican senator marco rubio in american dreams. he outlines plan for economic opportunity. bernie sanders, another candidate for democratic against tax cuts. in blue collar conservatives rick sanitorium argues the republican must focus on working class to retake the white house. donald trump has written several best sellers. he criticizes obama administration. mr. trump recently announced intention to release another public policy book this year. former virginia senator james webb writes about his time serving in the military in "i heard my country calling". joe biden may announce candidacy . finally governor chris christy, haven't released books. you can watch them online on our web scythe -- website on booktv.org. >> next up on book tv firefighter jason ramos talks about changes. >> t -- it's my pleasure to introduce jason ramos, threatens our beautiful forest and our lives. this topic is poynant f

. >> reporter: he even attacked the former governor george pataki who didn't make it to the big kids debate. >> donald trump is unfit to be president of the united states. look what he did in atlantic city. he invested four casinos, and every one of them went bankrupt. >> governor pataki who by the way was a failed governor in new york. very seriously failed governor. he would not be elected dogcatcher. >> if i was watching this back and forth, i would be inclined to turn it off. >> reporter: that didn't stop the comments. >> you got hillary clinton to go to your wedding because you gave her money. >> more energy. i like that. >> reporter: bush got into a heated exchange where trump refused to apologize for saying bush has a soft spot in his heart for mexicans because his wife is one. >> to subject my wife into a political conversation was completely inappropriate, and i hope you apologize for that. she's the love of my life, and she's right here. why don't you apologize? >> i won't do that because i hear she's a lovely woman. >> reporter: bill carson said he would offer illegal immi

people said he was a republican who doesn't like george pataki.he's too conservative for the state. soldier but on the other hand, i was talking early winter coat on a farm you can get the best crop and hurricane comes along and you pick yourself up and go forward anyway. that's what we did. we picked ourselves up and said look, that's what he thinks, but here's what i complete the state and change things. ultimately, i made the case, thought the fight and win. that's what i hope to do. i was way behind in the polls against mario cuomo in a democratidemocratic state. i understand i am way behind in the polls in the republican side now but there are a lot of serious issues facing this country. i know i have the ability to resolve those issues, working as a conservative republican but with the democrats as well. i hope that people as the election gets closer takes a look inside pataki is the right guy aspect in that race the last week and have come last two weeks they began to turn in your favor. what happened transfer in just hard work ? >> guest:

. >>> gore manager governor george pataki takes on sweater. what he wants the social media site to stop now. >> what happened when tim tebow walked into a hospital room to surprise a young fan. >> taking a live look outside, shall we? keep the umbrellas handy. meteorologist bill evans is tracking rain for us. woman: my mom and i have the same hands. same eyes. same laugh. and since she's had moderate alzheimer's disease, i've discovered we have the same fighting spirit, too. that's why i asked her doctor about new once-a-day namzaric . vo: new namzaric is approved for moderate to severe alzheimer's disease and can continue to take certain doses of both namenda and donepezil. new namzaric is the first and only treatment to combine 2 proven alzheimer's medicines into a single once-a-day capsule that works 2 ways to fight the symptoms of moderate to severe alzheimer's disease. once-a-day namzaric may improve cognition and overall function and may slow the worsening of symptoms for a while. namzaric does not change how the disease progresses. it s

governor george pataki refusing to support trump if he's the candidate. and others are knocking donald trump as a celebrity. >> i think donald trump is an entertainer. and i think i am a leader. and so what i do is talk to the american people about the issues they care about. and i think they hear what i'm talking about. >> with every jab at his fame, trump's poll numbers seem to only rise. for one candidate seemingly impervious lead in iowa this year has vanished faster than a fried snickers bar at the state fair. governor walker, thanks so much for joining me. appreciate it. >> glad to be with you. >> you were once poll-wise, the king of iowa, the prohibitive favorite to win there. this week a new poll has you in tenth place with just 3% in the polls out there. down from double digits in july. the conservative national review wrote a big piece about you saying there are questions about your cam pain. quote, the walker team has had a way of creating more fiascos. unanswered or treated with hostility. how do you respond to that? is your campaign faltering

first, george pataki. then, rick santorum talks about his time in congress, is 2012 presidential run, and why he is running again. on c-span2, on booktv, tonight ashill. p.m., jack c sunday at 9:00 p.m. on "afterwards" amy klobuchar talks about her life and political career. on american history tv on c-span 3, tonight at 8:00 in "lectures " paul christopher anderson teaches a class on how south carolina confederates viewed reconstruction in the wake of the civil war. he discusses how some white southerners justified and romanticized their defeat. and, sunday at 2:00 p.m., loving versus virginia pulled it was unconstitutional to prohibit interracial marriage. peter wallenstein examines the of lovingd legacy versus virginia. get our complete schedule at c-span.org. this year, c-span is touring cities across the country, slowing american history. up next, a look at our recent visit to grand junction, colorado. you are watching american history tv. all weekend, every weekend on c-span 3. area, the only source

new this morning, george pataki refusing to support trump if he is the nominee. others are knocking donald trump as a celebrity. >> i think donald trump is an entertainer. i think i am a leader. what i do is talk to the american people about the issues they care about. i think they hear what i'm talking about. >> with every jab at his people to, trump's poll numbers seem to rise. with one candidate's lead vanished faster than a fried snickers bar at the state fair. governor walker, thanks for joining us. appreciate it. >> feels like a college game day event. >> you were once, poll-wise, the king of iowa. the favorite to win there at the top of the polls for months. this week a new poll has you in tenth place with just 3% in the polls down from double-digits. the conservative national review wrote a piece saying there were questions about your campaign and the walker team as a way of following pattern and they're often allowed to hang with our without clarifications that are unanswered or treated with hostility. is your tam pain faltering? >> we get around the sta

you were pointing to governor pataki and bobby jindal's tweets this morning. every candidate has to figure out what is their approach about donald trump. do they want to link arms with him and they also have to prepare for the counter punch. donald trump has said that is what he does best. so i think everyone on that stage has to figure out how to have a moment connected to the conversation and as you know, the entire conversation of this campaign right now is about donald trump. >> it's so true. jeb bush wished it weren't. we saw him with the superman move and the t-shirt on underneath. i don't know if that will be happening here wednesday night. item number two? >> jeb's fortitude. this is a big jeb bush debate. he's going to be tested for his own strength. does he have the ability to stand up next to donald trump and take him on? as you know donald trump has been relentless in his attacks against jeb bush. jeb bush shied away during this first debate and that caused a lot of concern inside his land of supporters. in the last couple weeks, jeb bush has been

first, george pataki. then, rick santorum talks about his time in congress, is 2012 presidential run, and why he is running a.

>> well, let's remember that neither bobby jindal nor george pataki were on the main stage last timen the question was asked if they would raise their hands. >> why should that matter? >> well, i'm just saying they didn't do it in public. it matters in that it was a different standard. they didn't commit to doing that in public. the issue, though, is that if you want to get any attention right now, it almost has to be trump v. you. so what we have seen, i think, with pataki, with gendal, who are way down in the polls, is an attempt to get into the game. they want to be part of the trump versus somebody tell anovelo which we the media have been talking about for the last two months. frankly, i think donald trump, who knows tv very well, is very media savvy, was even, you know, more lethal towards these guys by not even dignifying their attacks with a response. he kind of waved them off and said i don't respond to anybody who doesn't have at least 1% in the polls. >> so jeffrey, you mentioned earlier in your discussion, you know donald trump. do you feel like he thought by signing that

rick santorum, george pataki, bobby jindal and lindsey graham trying to stand out and get traction with gop voters. wolf blitzer is in the debate hall and we'll check in with him very shortly and very shortly we'll see all of the 11 candidates, presidential candidates from the next debate coming out on the stage so that all 15 candidates will be together on that stage for the first time posing for pictures, front-runners donald trump and dr. ben carson, of course, n newcomer carly fiorina on the stage as well. let's go ahead to john king, host of "inside politics" and gloria borger, nia-malika henderson and michael smerconish. what do we expect in the big debate just minutes away? john king, what did you think of what you heard tonight? did anyone break out of this lower tier? >> it's a fascinating question. everyone did what they wanted to do. the question is, can they change their poll numbers? lindsey graham, every question you asked about the sunrise or sunset, he said we're in a war against radical islam. we cannot afford to lose. he turned every question to that. that is his beat

well if he has more twitter followers than you. >> i retweeted pataki.d not let anyone know the names and addresses of anyone else. >> i just think he is a communist. >> have i a snowden voodoo doll. >> here is where i don't agree with you. it violates the sank tau tee of a reality television program. >> if you are a pure us -- i would not -- in fact i would not bake a wedding cake for anyone who did what they did. >> i have agree with you about it being a set up. the judges were in on it. maybe the woman wasn't -- maybe -- >> i think they were all in on it. they did it for ratings and attention. >> two of the judges on "the voice" went through divorces. gwen stefoni with miranda lambert. >> it is a more interesting pairing you just made. >> it is a good point. >> jessica, you said this is the trump effect. i disagree. i think trump is a symptom and not the disease. >> as long as it is negative to trump. >> if i am saying it, it is negative about trump. >> awesome. >> and lastly, you mentioned blake shelton seemed ready to marry the couple. my friend bra

and bobby jindal, former new york governor george pataki and senator lindsey graham. i will be watching. ben: i may watch some of it but not all three hours and 11:00. juliet: we would get the clips tomorrow morning. ben: flying high but not your usual plane. she saw this inaction yesterday. juliet: we will tell you about it coming -- michael watching the forecast. >> meteorologist: looks gorgeous, sunny, beautiful, nice and warm, start up temperatures 67 degrees, a high in the upper 80s. we will do it. average high 75 but we have the myfoxny.com weather apps with headlines and alerts. if there's any severe weather in the area we will have it, download it for free at the we will be oh my gosh, it's the guy from last night. what?! can i jump on your wi-fi? yeah, you can try it. hey! i had a really good time last night. yeah, me too. the only thing is that... the only thing is what? what's the only thing? oh my gosh he's married. he's a kleptomaniac. he's a pyromaniac. he's a total maniac. hey! hey! go back to your wife you sociopath! leave slow internet behind. get the

is a deliberate shot across the bow to donald trump, and asterisk, and lindsey graham, and george pataki, and for example, get out of the way, and let the real fight begin, and in telling donald trump and ben carson, i would argue, these sort of outsider candidates, that you are not leading the r party in the direction that we need to be led to donna's point, and we need to have a serious conversation that we need to have if we want to win this election, because talking about whether you would vote for a muslim for president is or whether carly fiorina is robotic is not the discussion that the republicans want to be having. >> and who do you think is going to be next as far as the dropout is concerned? >> well, if i were scott walker i would have said to bobby jindal and others, you first. and if you want to influence the direction of the party, i would have said is, i am dropping out of the race, and this is who i am behind so that the republicans could win, and if you want to influence where we are going, be bold, and get out there, and say and have influence in direction of the party.

governor pataki i can is on the right.lify to make the debate next week but "washington post" reports it may not be a severe blow for gilmore since he is not campaigning at all. he is not holding events in the early states. he explained to the "washington post" he is trying to get on cable news now where people will describe him as running for president, even as he does nothing to prove it. i think even that will stop soon for governor gilmore. there's one last amazing, truly unexpected story in gutter ball today on the democrat side where one candidate has picked up an unlikely patron saint in the form of late night comedian conan o'brien. he launched a campaign to help get lincoln chafee to 1% in the polls so he didn't have to be at zero. >> right now no one is less popular than democratic hopeful and rhode island governor lincoln chaffe, who's currently at 0% in voting polls. i'm not making it up. that's an actual headline. that's why i'm taking a short amount of time here and making it my mission tonight to help lincol

graham and louisiana governor jindal and former senator rick santorum and former new york governor pataki, could tonight give one of them a shot at making it to the big stage? >> reporter: yeah, you know, it did during the last debate when carly fiorina did. she got her chance and she moved up to the upper card if we continue with that line of thinking. it's got to do something to one of these four contenders, because time and money is starting to squeeze as far as the republican party is concerned and there are a lot of heavy donors that want to make sure that their money will last throughout this thing and those candidates are struggling and if we'll have people attacking trump tonight it may be the first group of four that sends the strongest message here and some will tell you it's a message borne of desperation. >> jay gray reporting live from the scene of today's debate. >> new at 4:00, some of the victims' families are multimillion dollar lawsuits two years to the day of the navy yard shooting. the lawsuits allege the companies that were overseen aaron alexis's work should have kno

he's tied in the cnn poll below 1%, at the very bottom of measurable support, he's tied with george pataki and lindsey graham and bobby jindal and jim gilmore. how long are those guys going to stay in the race? in the latest iowa poll, the ppp iowa poll that is just out today, scott walker was polling at 5%. which is a disaster for somebody who's whole presidential cane depends on them winning iowa. but scott walker at 5% in iowa means in that state he's ahead of jim gilmore, lindsey graham, bobby jindal, also rand paul, rick santorum, chris christie. i mean, scott walker had more support in iowa than any of those other guys, and he has just quit the race for his lack of support. how long can the rest of those guys stay alive? if scott walker's out, who's next? joining us now is wisconsin state senator john erpenbach, who has a long history of battling with scott walker in his home state of wisconsin. senator, great to see you. >> thank you, rachel. >> when scott walker said today he was suspending his campaign, i don't know who it was. but somebody in the room applauded like a seal being

former new york governor george pataki talks about his political career and issues shaping his candidacymer senator rick santorum talks about his time in congress, his 2012 presidential run, and why he is running again. book tv tonight at 8:45 p.m., jack cashill discusses his book "scarlet letters" that argues progressives have become intolerant to opposing political views. sunday and i :00 p.m. on "after words, minnesota senator" amy susan pagealks with on american history tv on c-span3 tonight at 8:00 p.m., on "lectures in history," paul christopher anderson take teachs a class on how confederates viewed reconstruction in the wake of the civil war. he discussed how some white southerners romanticize the defeat and motives for fighting. sunday afternoon at 2:00 p.m., the landmark u.s. supreme court decision in loving v. virginia ruled it was unconstitutional to prohibit interracial marriage. at the virginia historical --iety, author and historian discusses loving get our complete schedule at c-span.org. >> in the fall of 1781, american soldiers under george washington and french forces

the other debate, perry, santorum and pataki and graham. these debates are getting much more personal. cnn's sara murray has more on that. >> reporter: good morning, john and christine. the gloves are coming off on the republican side. candidates are trading insults all as trump to dominates the republican field. the cnn/orc poll shows trump ahead of republican voters. a wide lead over ben carson at 19%. both candidates far ahead of jeb bush. the tenor of the campaign has changed over the last couple days. trump insulting carly fiorina about her looks. >> many of the comments are made as an entertainer because i did "the apprentice." it was one of the top shows on television. i decided i did not want to do it again because i wanted to run for president. everybody said as an entertainer, it is a different ball game. >> reporter: bobby jindal laid into trump calling him a carnival act and egomaniac. >> there is no intellectual curiosity or ideology. he is only for himself. he said his favorite book is the bible. i don't think he read it becau

faces, and the top 11 candidates begins 8:00 eastern time, and after that, we have the undercard, pataki and jindal and graham, and they will be before that. and so meanwhile, we have breaking news out of mississippi. >>> we have news that there is an active shooter on the university of mississippi delta center, and we will get you as much information as we can after this break. and strength. i'll take that. yeeeeeah! new ensure active high protein. 16 grams of protein and 23 vitamins and minerals. ensure. take life in. it's the brand more doctorsose recommend for minor arthritis pain. plus, just two aleve can last all day. you'd need 6 tylenol arthritis to do that. aleve. all day strong. j@j@j@j@ i'god blessed and teeming with citpeople of all kinds...e. living in harmony and peace. trump: they're bringing crime. they're rapists. if i am elected they're... going to be out of there day one. reporter: do you think birth right citizenship should be ended? walker: yeah, absolutely. cruz: i think we should end birth right citizenship trump: i will build a great, great wall... in my mind it w

george pataki is there on the tall side, or the left side of the stage. he ended up speaking a lot so that was probably good for him, more people heard george pataki's voice tonight than heard in the other parts of his not very impressive campaign. in terms of the guys in the middle, bobby jindal and rick santorum seemed frantic and urgent but they basically stuck to all the same stuff they always say on their campaign speeches, just more of a panicky tone of voice from those two tonight. south carolina lindsey graham, he had been criticized at the last debate for being morose, one republican observer told the "washington post" that in the last debate lindsey graham seemed like someone had "just killed his dog." tonight lindsey graham tried to turn that one around by being the jokester of the kids' table. >> i wasn't the best law student. by the end of this debate it will be the most time i've ever spent in any library. [ laughter ] we're not going to deport 11 million people here illegally but we'll start with felons and off they go. as to the rest, you

governor pataki, your response? >> my response is, wow. you know, we're going to have a president who defies the supreme court? >> i hope so, if they're wrong. >> then you don't have the rule of law. >> you have judicial supremacy. you don't have the rule of law when the court has the final say. >> they are elected representatives of the people have the opportunity to change that law. >> we lived our lives with landmark decisions by the supreme court, whether it's brown versus the board of education, which said no more separate but equal in public schools. they reviewed the civil rights bill of '64. you had roe-v-wade in '73. they've all been supreme court. many of them 5-4 decisions. >> we had brown versus board of education. >> i mentioned that. >> no, you didn't. >> yes, i did. >> you also have the dred scott decision. >> that was before the civil war. >> the point is courts get it wrong. >> who is to say that? >> you're saying if i don't like the ruling on same-sex marriage what do you do about it? >> you have a president who stands up

. >>> rick santorum, bobby jindal, george pataki and lindsey graham start their debate earlier. >>> breaking news in washington the white house is on lockdown! the reason for the lockdown is unclear at this point. we do know that president obama is not in the white house at this time. this is live look and we are gathering information on why the lockdown was ordered. we'll keep you posted and we get more details. >>> california is dealing with all kinds of weather right now. the wild river rescue caught on camera after rain caused massive flooding. >> and a major delay in releasing the latest apple software, what devices won't be getting the updates anytime soon. >> from the kpix 5 weather center, good afternoon, everybody. rain, it is now entering the north bay. i'll tell you just how much you can expect as the news >>> as we deal with fires in northern california floodwaters are sweeping through the southern part of the state. take a look at this dramatic rescue in los angeles. this flood caught people off guard. three men and a dog were saved from rushing water in the l.a. river. all were

governor pataki, your response? >> my response is, wow. you know, we're going to have a president who defies the supreme court? >> i hope so, if they're wrong. >> then you don't have the rule of law. >> you have judicial supremacy. you don't have the rule of law when the court has the final say. >> they are elected representatives of the people have the opportunity to change that law. >> we lived our lives with landmark decisions by the supreme court, whether it's brown versus the board of education, which said no more separate but equal in public schools. they reviewed the civil rights bill of '64. you had roe-v-wade in '73. they've all been supreme court. many of them 5-4 decisions. >> we had brown versus board of education. >> i mentioned that. >> that was before the civil war. >> the point is courts get it wrong. >> who is to say that? >> you're saying if i don't like the ruling on same-sex marriage what do you do about it? >> you have a president who stands up and fights the court. president obama has done that on occasion. >> you mea

. >>> four candidates did not make the cut, rick santorum, bobby jind jindal, george pataki and rick perry was set to debate as well but dropped out of the week. >> martin o'malley appeared on late night with seth myers. the two discussed how not having as many debates will negatively affect the democratic candidates. >> it's party malpractice, to really bad way to go about winning a general election. people expect us to be exchanging ideas. i've called for more debates not fewer. given the problems we face, i've called for more. >> o'malley discussed the migrant crisis. o'malley encouraged him to take 65,000 refugees into the u.s. right now the obama administration is only willing to take 10,000. >>> two firefighters are hurt and trying to get better this morning. a ceiling collapsed on them as they battled a fire montgomery county. chopper 4 showing you the burned gaping hole where the roof crumbled. this is at the leisure world retirement community yesterday afternoon. more than a dozen residents will have to find a new home. they all escaped safely but the fire damaged eight home

also skimmed george pataki and doesn't deserved to be skipped. not many people take hit seriously himself stood up when america was on its back. led in a time of crisis, let democrats as well as runs. his appeal to bipartisanship is the same as a number of people who say they can walk across the isle. he actually did it. rand spall's great strength is in an era of worry about surveillance, the opm hack, the worst national security nightmare with more than 20 million files, including my own. i had three full field background investigations done on me. they were all in the files of the fbi. as is the background on all of our nuclear scientists who work at lawrence livermore, as is anyone in the witness protection program, as is every fbi and cia agent, all in the opm files which have been hacked the surveillance state is a constant. as mike mooreal confirm, mrs. clinton's server was almost certainly monitor nil chinese, the russian and the iranians. probably have everything with ought to ask them to find out about the 30,000 e-mails. but that creep

former governor pataki. so much for coming in. >>> former cia director hayden is with us ahead. stay with us. we'll be right back. (clicking noise) (ding) read text. (siri voice) adam, i'm sorry. i shouldn't have said that about your hair. it's not stupid. (ding) find hair salon. wow. yeah, that's right. (siri voice) ok, jack's boutique is nearby. alright, i've got another friend and his name is bryan adams. ok. this isn't going to work again. ♪"please forgive me, i know not what i do..."♪ introducing app-connect. the things you love on your phone, available on 11 volkswagen models. if an electric toothbrush was going to clean better than a manual. he said sure... but don't get just any one. get one inspired by dentists. with a round brush head. go pro with oral-b. oral-b's rounded brush head cups your teeth to break up plaque, and rotates to sweep it away. and oral-b delivers a clinically proven superior clean vs. sonicare diamond clean. my mouth feels super clean. oral-b. know you're getting a superior cle

that's where new york's former governor george pataki spoke out against the kentucky county clerk who refuses to issue same-sex marriage licenses. >> an i elected official can't say, i'm not going to follow that law if it conflicts with my beliefs. i think she should be fired. if she worked for me, i would have fired her. we have to uphold the rule of law. >> that clerk, kim davis, spent several days in jail. pataki says there's a place where religion supersedes the rule of law, and that's iran. >>> much more is coming up on the "today" show. reaction from the debates coming up at 7:00. >>> it is 5:37 now. the aide to governor cuomo who was shot in the head in brooklyn has died. carey gabay was taken off life support last night just hours after his family announced he was brain dead. the 43-year-old lawyer was caught in the cross fire between two gangs during the festivities leading up to the west indian day parade. >> this was an extraordinary man, and he has an extraordinary family. i think this is another painful reminder of the problem this nation has with gun violence. >> this is

this is george pataki talking about his tax plan. mr.i: the normal american is being higher taxes because of lou polls. of loopholes. i would tax not income the same as others. i would lower the rate to 24% to all americans without a special break to the wall street fat cats. , you have done work on taxes. what did you take about the substance from the debate? you are showing the kiddie table debate. talk aboutot much taxes on the grown-up state. we talked about other issues and sensitive issues, but there was a missing tax, economy, wage issue. when you look at the republican debate, donald trump carried interest and stability to tax, both real estate and hedge fund managers at a lower tax rate equal to capital gains on the table. that has always been a democratic talking point that is now incorporated into the republican debate. republicans say they will close that loophole. there is a caveat, that it must be part of comprehensive tax reforms, lowering capital gains and income taxes overall. that has been hard to come by in previous ye