we can build rehab and one thing in 2014 i said we needed a housing plan i know said that to john rahaim his staff was going nuts not getting all the permits out get them out faster at the knew and the public knew we announced thirty thousand rehab housing by 2020 well, today, because everyone is middle-class and working together 17 thousand one hundred of units have been completed >> (clapping.) >> 36 affordable inform middle-income and low income we have to keep it going working very hard and build and when we work together we can get stuff done today we are announcing something i really am excited about supervisor katie tang is reinching home sf home sf is a working with our developer community with the neighborhood with our labor leaders we can do more than that zoning if we provide more incentives this is what working with the board will be helpful in doing so with the home sf program over 6 to 8 hundred more restrictive units can be built in the city for middle-income and families throughout the city i'm excited with the supervisors come up with creative ideas i'm sorry 6 thousand

about the lack of smaller misrepresent units and director rahaim described the economics and suggested that strategy zoning can encourage the development supervisor fewer discussed allowing for senior housing and the problem of them in large unit and supervisor kim said she's eager inform move forward with a recommendation in response director rahaim said first to better understand the economic impacts of the community public comment were largely in support of recommendation and focused on housing costs several mothers spoke about the structural of being worked out a single mom andes capping depends on and the elderly talked about you how the housing costs push families into long commutes as well as teach family housing issues and so moving on the next step proposed for the department is producing a design resource guide and the work on the housing that will help to improve our understanding of housing and then lastly we'll work on the financial implications for the amenity and work on guides that was a big technicality items other items were passed an first reading the calle quarto an

rahaim can you talk about the missing housing. >> shoourl housing i mean it is really two ways to talkbout that middle-income housing which clearly the income level that is at least served by the type of housing for example, many of the types of building two or three story buildings in neighborhoods in the 210 east and 30's many of them mixed in with single-family and we think there are solutions we can look at that will allow this type of housing to go into somewhat lower density neighborhood in strategic locates for more family-friendly and affordable courtyard and housing more generous backyard and roof decks this sort of mill height and middle density, if you will, not been built in the city many a very long time. >> thank you and last question before i open up to my colleagues here did you do now work around the numbers in terms of missing income layer at planning. >> we certainly are the numbers in terms of the housing supply that we're building and . >> exactly. >> i don't have those with me today i believe the percentages are quite low and i'm sorry not the housing supply but i

rahaim can you talk about the missing housing. >> shoourl housing i mean it is really two ways to talkbout that middle-income housing which clearly the income level that is at least served by the type of housing for example, many of the types of building two or three story buildings in neighborhoods in the 210 east and 30's many of them mixed in with single-family and we think there are solutions we can look at that will allow this type of housing to go into somewhat lower density neighborhood in strategic locates for more family-friendly and affordable courtyard and housing more generous backyard and roof decks this sort of mill height and middle density, if you will, not been built in the city many a very long time. >> thank you and last question before i open up to my colleagues here did you do now work around the numbers in terms of missing income layer at planning. >> we certainly are the numbers in terms of the housing supply that we're building and . >> exactly. >> i don't have those with me today i believe the percentages are quite low and i'm sorry not the housing supply but i

staff it's been a long time and we have a way to go thank you director rahaim you rolled up our sleeves and got our hands dirty not in a derogatory way but we had over and over and finally the most comprehensive document outside of the mere zoning and planning and includes other things that would be great and a cough of points i support the old boundary for clarity sake so i was asking the motion maker to amend to the old boundary in the 2020 the question i have district 10 goes into the mission it goes everything east of bryant street. is that correct? >> where. >> it is potrero or bryant street. >> it includes the northeast mission okay. >> and in our request today is to - for the removal of district 10 in the discussion but up to the commissions consideration. >> not talking about the boundary the interim controls. >> and that boundary goes up to pier and it covers or projects for consistency sake that's fine. >> maintain the interim controls and not reduce that as recommend. >> i'll ask someone who worked on this including ms. flores who worked on that for the plan i don't want to t

we can build rehab and one thing in 2014 i said we needed a housing plan i know said that to john rahaim his staff was going nuts not getting all the permits out get them out faster at the knew and the public knew we announced thirty thousand rehab housing by 2020 well, today, because everyone is middle-class and working together 17 thousand one hundred of units have been completed >> (clapping.) >> 36 affordable inform middle-income and low income we have to keep it going working very hard and build and when we work together we can get stuff done today we are announcing something i really am excited about supervisor katie tang is reinching home sf home sf is a working with our developer community with the neighborhood with our labor leaders we can do more than that zoning if we provide more incentives this is what working with the board will be helpful in doing so with the home sf program over 6 to 8 hundred more restrictive units can be built in the city for middle-income and families throughout the city i'm excited with the supervisors come up with creative ideas i'm sorry 6 thousand

francisco but basically effecting the entire viability of rest of the country. >> thank you director rahaim. >> first thank you diane and byron this work is productive collaboration between the port and the planning department and with the other departments with the port and planning department co-chairing the effort a positive collaboration the thing that is important to note about the actual plan and the vulnerability analysis we're now entering into it looks like public facilities what is important to remember that large development like mission rock they've all be islands unless we deal with the public infrastructure around them we have to what we're trying to do with this effort is actually deal what the public infrastructure the streets obviously mta and b.c. and all the factors that serve the entire city that is this 1r50u7b9 analysis is really crucial part of city understanding what its own facilities will how they will be effected with the cost of inaction as diane a pointed out and how to have a multiple process to address this so i wanted to emphasize the distinction between the

. >> thank you supervisor yee thank you director rahaim and colleagues we'll open up for public comment if there are members of the public that want to speak specifically on this particular hearing please come forward this is not general public comment it is specific to our committee of the whole on this discussion. >> first speaker please. mbes of the board of supervisors ray hart for san francisco open government. i would like to first say this is a public hearing no copies of the report as requiredy the sunshine ordnance it is difficult to make effective public comment but i'll i'd like point out that exhibits the said set of planning department which is where we're talking about families with children we're talking about widow gets and chart and graphs and things that can be put into columns and put into statistics but little or no, if the talk about the human beings the people and children and families that are being affected by those problems i'm reminded of a meeting of the police commission they're talking about making funds available for crisis training for police officers in d

. >> thank you director rahaim. >> a couple of thoughts for the staff perspective staff can work either way generally a meeting for earlier so the only question i have for jonas do you need time to change the notices for notification purposes. >> no there is no important time it is up to the commission it is an agenda well in advance of what the minimum requirement is and for example, we regularly schedule joint hearings a week in advance not - yeah, the same room and same location additional notification is not required. >> commissioner fong a question for the director and putting on my responsible business hat if we go late is that over time. >> the way the rules yes, it is overtime in the form of half time. >> okay. >> so commissioner moore. >> i'm sensitive to staff because i asked many by statistical purposes where do you live they are not all living in the city so the commute time the latter it goes the harder it gets one thought here. >> it is good food for thought we often are here and see you know let's get here and see where we go and come up with a thoughtfully proposal thank

we can build rehab and one thing in 2014 i said we needed a housing plan i know said that to john rahaim his staff was going nuts not getting all the permits out get them out faster at the knew and the public knew we announced thirty thousand rehab housing by 2020 well, today, because everyone is middle-class and working together 17 thousand one hundred of units have been completed >> (clapping.) >> 36 affordable inform middle-income and low income we have to keep it going working very hard and build and when we work together we can get stuff done today we are announcing something i really am excited about supervisor katie tang is reinching home sf home sf is a working with our developer community with the neighborhood with our labor leaders we can do more than that zoning if we provide more incentives this is what working with the board will be helpful in doing so with the home sf program over 6 to 8 hundred more restrictive units can be built in the city for middle-income and families throughout the city i'm excited with the supervisors come up with creative ideas i'm sorry 6 thousand

. >> good afternoon commissioner president hillis and commissioners director rahaim thank you so muchor 53 me on the calendar i'm karen the wastewater enterprise program director for the sfpuc and today i'll give you an overview of the program bring up did slide this is agree selection of sewer improvements over the next two million years to upgrade our system. >> sfgov go to the - thanks. >> you may be familiar puc is responsible for 24/7 utilities water and power that i'll be focusing on the sewer side today first of all, we have a combined sincere system in san francisco serves san francisco 49 square miles we treat the wastewater and water - this is a red line that runs from north to south on the map and basically differences this into two grave bodily injury based i think and the bay side within the areas sewage and tunnels and box that convey such business by gravity to the storage boxes shown in the dark rectangle that - we have 30 treatment plant the baby is oceanside by the do zoo it started at 1993 - and then our largest plant and much of the work in the improvement program

. >> commissioners good afternoon for the record john rahaim director forbes great to see you and glado be here i've been coming annually for the last three or four years and pleased to be here i will say to start and finish this i'm really every year a collaboration between our staff and my staff has been growing and more constructive and as you'll see in any presentation we're overlapping in the work more and more everyday and great collaboration and director forbes history is part of a that but makes certainly the w40e8 staff is great to work with over the last couple of years i'm going to give you a brief presentation about the issues and he growth challenges and talk about briefing about the areas of overlap between the port and planting they're growing everyday and siege much more overlap to give us a sense of city's growth since 2010 it has been growing in the city we've seen 10 thousand resident a year and a couple of years more than that something on the order of one thousand per month we've seen in terms of population we've seen one and 25 thousand new jobs that is a little b

. >> good afternoon, commissioners director rahaim peter and here on behalf of the mission inconsistencies development agency you've gotten a lot of testimony i'll keep my comments to specification but want to i think will add a discussion i hope that all neighborhoods are not the same keep in mind as we're looking at this there are neighborhoods like the mission and others certainly that have different needs than other neighborhoods that is a sensitive idea makes sense in terms of the numbers and i think that as you heard earlier today there are already developers in the mission doing 25 percent so the discussion of feasibility should include what is happening on the ground and what is possible in certainly neighborhoods in terms of the overall picture, of course, we would like to see the higher numbers that are possible we're seeing them in the mission already and the market will adjust as supervisor peskin said that does that will evaluate upwards and changes possibly based on that require but once that is 235shgd them we'll move forward together and obviously don't want to see the very

whether or not you omit certain of questions from submitting any kind of response i know that director rahaim and myself will be filling out the requester in charge. >> this is a survey to look at the services and it is totally voluntarily. >> i'd like to restate i trust your judgment in terms of you forward to us. >> thanks commissioner vice president richards. >> on tuesdays new york state on the first page welcome to uber and lyft commuters inch through new york an interesting article of inputs of services on new york a couple of facts the actual speed of the vehicles on surface streets is one more like 15 million pricks jade in the apps in october alone and there were 50 thousand drivers in new york i understand we have $30,000 drivers i caregiver to the gentleman's memo he hbtd last week the director referred to for the un - data collection it underway with the routes of increased new trip generations for the land values hopes to quantify the effects of online vehicles and the amount of parking on delivery companies and hov on developments so manage we've been asking for it is interestin

we can build rehab and one thing in 2014 i said we needed a housing plan i know said that to john rahaim his staff was going nuts not getting all the permits out get them out faster at the knew and the public knew we announced thirty thousand rehab housing by 2020 well, today, because everyone is middle-class and working together 17 thousand one hundred of units have been completed >> (clapping.) >> 36 affordable inform middle-income and low income we have to keep it going working very hard and build and when we work together we can get stuff done today we are announcing something i really am excited about supervisor katie tang is reinching home sf home sf is a working with our developer community with the neighborhood with our labor leaders we can do more than that zoning if we provide more incentives this is what working with the board will be helpful in doing so with the home sf program over 6 to 8 hundred more restrictive units can be built in the city for middle-income and families throughout the city i'm excited with the supervisors come up with creative ideas i'm sorry 6 thousand

we can build rehab and one thing in 2014 i said we needed a housing plan i know said that to john rahaim staff was going nuts not getting all the permits out get them out faster at the knew and the public knew we announced thirty thousand rehab housing by 2020 well, today, because everyone is middle-class and working together 17 thousand one hundred of units have been completed >> (clapping.) >> 36 affordable inform middle-income and low income we have to keep it going working very hard and build and when we work together we can get stuff done today we are announcing something i really am excited about supervisor katie tang is reinching home sf home sf is a working with our developer community with the neighborhood with our labor leaders we can do more than that zoning if we provide more incentives this is what working with the board will be helpful in doing so with the home sf program over 6 to 8 hundred more restrictive units can be built in the city for middle-income and families throughout the city i'm excited with the supervisors come up with creative ideas i'm sorry 6 thousand did

table are sitting around the table and asking an important question you articulated to me and john rahaimhe head of planning department to make sure that the improvements we give in our neighborhood serve the people in this neighborhood so when we talked about greening and sustainable chinatown what we're talking about doing things that affect the resident for their purpose not for a grander vision but the people that live in the alleys and public housing for the people that live in sros can do they need to have a sustainable chinatown the other thing i've heard you say i've thought about a lot is the dilemma how we improve the quality of life without driving people out how do we gentrify without displace those are not the words you'll use but how to make their lives better and bring them all the benefits of the environmentism. >> i think that the dilemma you operate in the intersection of those forces and really hard and yet you bring warm accounting to our approach we'll figure this out and inspired by the work you to so thank you for all you do and your organization does as well. >> th

are concerns with the caress reservations we need help authorized unit on hyde and turk but john rahaimersections and people in the intersections and the crimes have not been mentioned tourists are evaluating we're evaluating them but people are robbed at gun point at the bottom of the hill in a busy day and tourists were robbed a block away most of those are one block away from did elementary school we are walking by cars and broken into everyday the biggest thing i want to say step back this is san francisco we believe in the environment and cliffs we say walk to school and bike to school and take the vehicles this is. >> tourist attraction we should be charging the pedestrians and regulating cars i understand that the car restrictions encourage more and more pedestrians so we - >> thank you very much thank you >> next speaker, please. >> chair peskin and commissioners i'm helen i live on hyde at the corner of hyde and lombard been there 15 years i'm here to speak on behalf of the tourists the tourists bring us $9 billion a year and the fact that they want to come and see this site we

are concerns with the caress reservations we need help authorized unit on hyde and turk but john rahaimersections and people in the intersections and the crimes have not been mentioned tourists are evaluating we're evaluating them but people are robbed at gun point at the bottom of the hill in a busy day and tourists were robbed a block away most of those are one block away from did elementary school we are walking by cars and broken into everyday the biggest thing i want to say step back this is san francisco we believe in the environment and cliffs we say walk to school and bike to school and take the vehicles this is. >> tourist attraction we should be charging the pedestrians and regulating cars i understand that the car restrictions encourage more and more pedestrians so we - >> thank you very much thank you >> next speaker, please. >> chair peskin and commissioners i'm helen i live on hyde at the corner of hyde and lombard been there 15 years i'm here to speak on behalf of the tourists the tourists bring us $9 billion a year and the fact that they want to come and see this site we

are concerns with the caress reservations we need help authorized unit on hyde and turk but john rahaimersections and people in the intersections and the crimes have not been mentioned tourists are evaluating we're evaluating them but people are robbed at gun point at the bottom of the hill in a busy day and tourists were robbed a block away most of those are one block away from did elementary school we are walking by cars and broken into everyday the biggest thing i want to say step back this is san francisco we believe in the environment and cliffs we say walk to school and bike to school and take the vehicles this is. >> tourist attraction we should be charging the pedestrians and regulating cars i understand that the car restrictions encourage more and more pedestrians so we - >> thank you very much thank you >> next speaker, please. >> chair peskin and commissioners i'm helen i live on hyde at the corner of hyde and lombard been there 15 years i'm here to speak on behalf of the tourists the tourists bring us $9 billion a year and the fact that they want to come and see this site we

are concerns with the caress reservations we need help authorized unit on hyde and turk but john rahaimersections and people in the intersections and the crimes have not been mentioned tourists are evaluating we're evaluating them but people are robbed at gun point at the bottom of the hill in a busy day and tourists were robbed a block away most of those are one block away from did elementary school we are walking by cars and broken into everyday the biggest thing i want to say step back this is san francisco we believe in the environment and cliffs we say walk to school and bike to school and take the vehicles this is. >> tourist attraction we should be charging the pedestrians and regulating cars i understand that the car restrictions encourage more and more pedestrians so we - >> thank you very much thank you >> next speaker, please. >> chair peskin and commissioners i'm helen i live on hyde at the corner of hyde and lombard been there 15 years i'm here to speak on behalf of the tourists the tourists bring us $9 billion a year and the fact that they want to come and see this site we

table are sitting around the table and asking an important question you articulated to me and john rahaimhe head of planning department to make sure that the improvements we give in our neighborhood serve the people in this neighborhood so when we talked about greening and sustainable chinatown what we're talking about doing things that affect the resident for their purpose not for a grander vision but the people that live in the alleys and public housing for the people that live in sros can do they need to have a sustainable chinatown the other thing i've heard you say i've thought about a lot is the dilemma how we improve the quality of life without driving people out how do we gentrify without displace those are not the words you'll use but how to make their lives better and bring them all the benefits of the environmentism. >> i think that the dilemma you operate in the intersection of those forces and really hard and yet you bring warm accounting to our approach we'll figure this out and inspired by the work you to so thank you for all you do and your organization does as well. >> th

table are sitting around the table and asking an important question you articulated to me and john rahaimhe head of planning department to make sure that the improvements we give in our neighborhood serve the people in this neighborhood so when we talked about greening and sustainable chinatown what we're talking about doing things that affect the resident for their purpose not for a grander vision but the people that live in the alleys and public housing for the people that live in sros can do they need to have a sustainable chinatown the other thing i've heard you say i've thought about a lot is the dilemma how we improve the quality of life without driving people out how do we gentrify without displace those are not the words you'll use but how to make their lives better and bring them all the benefits of the environmentism. >> i think that the dilemma you operate in the intersection of those forces and really hard and yet you bring warm accounting to our approach we'll figure this out and inspired by the work you to so thank you for all you do and your organization does as well. >> th