so working with sf puc on the commission it should be possible for the sf puc to fulfill that role that was initially envisioned to be supplied by shell energy. the next question was the timing and economic benefits of local build-out and some of these tasks really were related to each other. so this also relates to one of the later tasks. you have the potential to realize the benefits, the economic benefit of the local build-out and this translates to how much, how many dollars per cost of mega watt. on the chart here is down to dollars per watt so what will reflect what customers will see. you also have the build-out construction pay jobs. i understand the jobs were one of the questions raised for what kind of economic development and using the nrel. the development impact tool that we use to refine and estimate the construction phase jobs in terms of dollars or jobs per million dollars spent per construction as well as the assumed operational jobs after the generation station is up and running. and we'll go into more depth into some of these on a later task. so this is a high level s

because this report is based on a list of proposed projects that were scoped and suggested by the sf puc. we gave that list -- the city and county gave that list to enernex as a way of saying without going all crazy into the behind the meter stuff these are projects that the puc looked at. why don't you look at these potential projects and this list is from those projects. as was said we might not do all of the projects. >> >> by the end of january we want to see the updated rate setting and plan creation under -- >> thank you. next speaker please. >> good afternoon commissioners. thanks so much for giving me the opportunity to speak. i am jess ackerman and the conservation manager for the sierra club and excited to see the enernex report and resolves the issues that we had and excited to move forward. we would like to see director malcolm come back to the puc and actually start looking at what the rates would be for a program that wouldn't include the shell contract and that's pretty much it so thanks so much for all of your work on this and we look forward to having you continue to pus

>> barbara hale, assistant general manager at the sf puc. i used that as an example of the sort of thing i know already we're looking for better clarity on now that we received what is referred to as the final report. >> okay. is there a list of questions or a way to coordinate a meeting with you and enernex and mr. fried in order to address some of the issues in order to be all on the same page especially when we have our joint meeting about this particular report? >> yes, as i mentioned it's my intention to collaborate with mr. fried to go through the report and understand the various issues, have an opportunity to document -- write something up in a summary way. my commission asked for that prior to the joint meeting. we received this report on the afternoon of monday of this week. >> okay. >> okay. >> got it. >> prior to that we provided a multi-page comments on the prior version. i'm looking for a little time here to work with mr. fried to identify any outstanding issues that we may still have and to summarize that for my commission. >>

>> barbara hale, sf puc. we have not had discussions with puc about projects. we have been shaping the proposal that they put before the california puc as an interested party in that proceeding, but no discussions about projects, no. >> okay. i think my question is leading me to the thought that if there were discussions about site, for example, solar sites that we would want to be sure cleanpowersf has priority over pg & e site. that's something that the green tariff made me think of. thank you. >>supervisor london breed: thank you. so seeing no other names on the roster. i will like to move on to item no. 6 at this time. city clerk: status update on the san francisco boerndz ordinance electing to study the feesibility implementing a community choice aggregation program by joining marin clean energy. >> jason fried. i have the information provided. since the memo was written on tuesday, supervisors avalos and members of the board of supervisors introduced an ordinance and looked through our own going through the process and given the recent developments happen

the if sf puc rate could have set the rate not to exceed today. what i'm going to call on the commission is to set the not to exceed rate at

go with the shelf program we can see this program will create jobs and actually help the long term sf puc financially and we would a lot of loving to have the cac director kim come back and talk about the new rates and set them to go forward i want to give you a status report around the bay area napa has joint joined the clean energy and the city testify el cerrito and alameda county that as 1.5 million residents and the san mateo county of board of supervisors is voting to move forward into their community choice program and the city and county of santa clara r seriously looking at this san francisco was the first ever in california to have an ordinance 0 moving forward with community choice we'd like the city to be a leader in climate action and move forward before the rest of the bay area catches up with us and takes us over we want to w work with. >> he see kim come back in a year thank you. >> thank you, jason freed. >> hi jason freed executive officer for california last could i want to comment about the report one thing you'll find in the report we took all the comments especially

legislation and then for on future agenda items when you do have your next joint meeting with the sf puc this is just kind of a point of information -- especially i think the supervisors might be clued in on this but the public members i want to make sure you know about it. in the scott wiener london breed legislation that cleared authorizes the puc to sell express hetch hetchy power in the city to make money and bring clean energy to the city. >> >> originally when that legislation was drafted in july it did not include making cleanpowersf a priority customer of that power, and thankfully advocates approached supervisor wiener's aid and they graciously included an amendment that makes it clear that yes cleanpowersf is in the queue by that power and that is very important. even if cleanpowersf buys that power at full retail rate there are benefits from that because it helps -- we were discussing the wind power, solar power doesn't happen to be working and you have hydro power there as well in the mix and balances the resources out and help lower load curves on peak load and save money on

to begin with the local policy work primarily our work at the local area is around insuring that sf puc items but that the board of supervisors whether their be incarcerating contract or commission appointments a make it to the progress we have 40 sfpuc items that passed to the board last year had he some of basic items for the design contracts and others are the smaller items that are recorded to the ongoing operations of the 3 enterprises ass also at the local level i would say that 2013 was a huge year for supervisor initiated policy for the operations of the puc i think one example i think the commissioner was engaged in the bolted water band and the supervisor chiu catered one of the things we tried to do with the supervisors is really put forward policy directives working closely with the enterprise staff to make sure it implemented in a way that really works for our enterprise and is effective trying to take the mission of the policy so in the instance of working closely with david bird and his team he helped to an through what are the departments that are tied to implement this

2013-2014 was also issued earlier in comparison to the earlier years as compared to those tables sf puc was the first of the enterprise department in the city and county to issue it's financial statements and we expect to continue to receive the award from financial offices from excellence in financial reporting at this time, i'd like toenter introduce nancy to present the audit information and afterwards we'll answer any questions. >> thank you. >> good afternoon as francis said i'm the audit partner from k n e g i'm here to present the audit results but first, i wanted to spend about an hour since we did the presentation to todd and i wanted to throw out to say when the report i'm about to present to you would not be possible without the leadership from todd as well as the leadership and dedication to quality financial reporting that the management present has you know they show a clear leadership and clear sorry dedication to the quality and financial reporting. the court: objection sustained. the report i'm about to present would not be possible without them so our responsibility is

another area that we are very active in now is we've been working with the puc on marketing, go solar sf and we've had a number of grants from the federal government. we recently received one to start doing a planning of solar plus energy storage for the purpose of the disaster preparedness. we are working with the department of emergency management, puc and the power enterprise and with pg & e will be launching that next month. it's how we can get more solar into the marketplace, really back up our critical loads with energy storage technologies and then use that on a daily basis to provide grid support, demand response, peak load management and during times of disasters have those electrical loads for on going support. we've also been very active in the finance area. we have several finances areas in multifamily buildings and commercial pace program out of our office and as residential pace is just launching now and we are working with water enterprise on the pay as you save program. we are hoping some time this year and next year that will be up and running. finally the regulatory are

sf puc. i want to thank you for the information. i want to say the collaboration and dialogue that we had with taf was constructive. the report reinforces the number of program design elements that the puc was already considering in the cleanpowersf program. there is five key points from the enernex report that i think from a business perspective are worth emphasis. first is the report recommends that we set the energy price and then figure out the mix of supply that we can afford. second, we need to recognize that local requirements and preferences are going to be more expensive. that a phased implementation of the program is smart with the 2-tiered offering with the light green and clean start is what sonoma calls it. that basic light green offering be at pg & e rates and include build-out with the expansion of the program. once we have established that financial stability that jeremy just referred to. to remember that investment in generation may impact rates and affect customer retention. i mean that both in effect customer rete

i think we started this process to answer some questions that had been raised when we went to the sf puc before for approval of the project so it's a really good thing to me that a lot of the answers that we provided are not being questioned, at least by staff, so we're just talking about providing more clarification in terms of tables so that's a good thing to me in terms of a joint meeting maybe we answered a lot of the larger questions that the commission had with respect to moving our program forward so i take this kind of -- these questions more of clarification and certainly it's important to know. multiplier effects on jobs are -- like you said they're very sensitive to whatever model you're using, economic model you're using, but indirect jobs are just as important as indirect jobs. they're all jobs so i think it's fine to provide a table with more data but still a job. >> that's great. and just for our purposes in the past the city has really tried to emphasize in any way by any means necessary the number of jobs created for a new project, new program, some initiative. it's the

passionate folks about the past 3 resolutions one on global technology sport and one for clean power sf and the puc's ground water program the resolutions are here i want to express we want action on those 3 items from the commission we working hard and cared about those issues we want to know that the commission hears us we strengthened our relationship with the commission and cac and staff the cac represents the report to the commission we have commissioner courtney at our meeting and want to see more p of that in january general manager kelly will be giving his update for the cac pr we'll have impactful meeting we've met ten times this year required to meet 9 and our subcommittees are required to meet 4 times each has met 4 to 6 times we've p had a busy year one of the other things on behalf of the entire cac todd has been one of our biggest allies and champions todd will be at our december meeting thank you for everything you've done and wish you well in your new job. >> good. >> yes. vice president. >> thank you for your work i've valued our work cac and want to respond in some way to the senior

grateful for people making that that includes the puc and the fire department and i don't think want to miss anyone else the preservation commission and sf planning and others beyond that the people at hoff people that designs high speed rail to make sure we have a starting point in a public space and it will extend ultimately people that are spider by the incredible work of you people and the private community to bring the money in place to surprise the world in a project wouldn't be possible without the community that made the bay lights a reality and today is is a great day we're getting xiefltd about that project i want to take the moment to highlight the difference the bay lights there's a different artist with a different set of instruction and the artist are making a beautiful eloquent statement and expression of civic automation it celebrates the mass transportation it used the light and energy and movement to create a sense of community up and down the length of market street but the emotional divides that keep it open for half a century i'm feeling grateful to everyone that made this project possible if you have any questions,

the sf foundation received the first two of six payments to create the fund, which will grant the five community based healthcare organizations the parks and rec department and puc and sfmta. and the park, and around the cpmc, cathedral hill and the california campuses. and the mayor's office of housing and community development, received the payments into the city wide affordable housing fund for placement housing and rental assistance. sfmta received payments for transportation improvements including bicycle safety and the brt and so our and we had two parts to our role in this dba the first one was hiring around construction. and you can see the goals and at least, 50 percent of the new entry level positions. and we have met that, and the goal, with cpmc and we have actually done quite well there. a couple came through the office as internships and were placed there and very strong candidate and we have done quite well there. and then the next is for the apprentice program, which is how we with the city bill worked to get a lot of new folks in the pipeline there. and at least, 50 percent of the new entry level, apprentice ships which was our goal and we have

excited i can say this i want to have this on our future agenda a joint meeting with the puc about clean power sf. >> the meeting i feel i was promised. >> yes. yes. you were. our colleagues over there at the puc all promised that we'd do this again and it's coming up on the year anniversary so it probably is timely. what do folks think? okay that was a fun one and also on that note i talked to two of the planning commissioners who would be very much in favor of having a joint meeting and the catalyst was our great work together around mandatory solar at the staff level and filtered up to the to the commission and i think it it can be another joint meeting. >> i think that's an outstanding idea i'm very excited about the joint puc opportunity to talk about this. with planning they are doing a very interesting thing. they have hired a consultant to do a scan for the city they interviewed me and department heads across the city and it would be very interesting. i haven't heard the findings yet because they haven't presented them but they are very cognizant about the fact we exist and are trying to