i took snowden as malicious. the worst part is i can imagine someone sitting at the special, you know the special communications information service going the heck? we cannot get this for several years. some guy civil liberties besides going to give us everything orders ever done smith obtain my journal's perspective. i'm a journalist perspective. this is blasphemy coming out of a journalist mount requires a nuance perspective on this. i always, because i'm a journalist air on the side of my transparency, right? that's the bias i bring being given access, i start my book with me in the little closet at the "new york times" that he used to dig through snowden documents. i had just come off three years of covering none stop chinese espionage. my immediate reaction, thank god you're doing this. then god or capabilities are better than sloppy e-mails doing. and then looking at the coverage and glenn greenwald and everybody else, shame. because what snowden says you can write up these documents, but don't publicize an

we see more and more the use of cyber hacking tools cyber some surveillance tools you know edward snowden made us all aware of this in the united states with what our government was doing in regards to the n.s.a. . and here we are you know years later and understanding that there is software being developed by private companies like like ana so out of israel that will sell these hacking tools to governments regardless of what their intents and purpose are and that these tools are even far more dangerous than what snowden unveiled under an a so because this is a direct targeted tool that can take control of your device and as we see in the dissident saudi arabia used this technology to hack the phone of omar abdel aziz the saudi dissident living in montreal and jamal khashoggi and arguably this hack was one of the reasons once they had access to their their devices that they decided to murder 2. mol and the hacker jeff bezos phone was pure you know retribution or revenge for the fact that he owns the washington post which is a newspaper operating you know in under the conscripts of freedom

six years ago we were debating government surveillance in the age of the snowden story and somebody said something unbelievably wrong, could have been me, i don't remember. but that person said if you're not doing anything wrong, why should you be worried about surveillance? and that is now the defense of cancel culture. it you shouldn't worry about being canceled if you're not doing anything offensive. but the problem is, who is deciding what is offensive and what needs to be canceled? the people deeming the standards for offense often lack the experience or wisdom of an adult who has led a real life. a lot of this is coming from young people who just got out of college you don't even understand what the person meant by it, don't understand free speech. it's up to the adults in the room, the people who have been on this planet a long time to tell you, you know what, offensive things will exist and some of this stuff might hurt your feelings, but you know what, it's in there so you can decide and you can talk about it and you can write about it. but banning things only makes it more inte

we'll speak to jay snowden after the break. for your meeting? uhh yes. and your lucky jersey? oh, yeah. lauren, a cooler? it's hot. it's march. and jay, what's with all your screens? just checking in with my team... of colleagues. so you're all streaming on every device in the house, what?!! that was a foul. it's march... ...and you're definitely not watching basketball. no, no. i'm definitely not watching basketball. right... ( horn blaring ) >>> 27 million americans expected to bet on ncaa games. one company reaping the benefits is penn national jay snowden joins us now with an update on the events of the past week i hope your fortunes at penn don't correlate with my fortunes in the tournament. i would say most people's, probably, jay? are people still having fun losing their collective butts? >> i think there's a difference between the office bracket where we have been destroyed versus betting on the games itself. you have people on both sides of the wagers, people betting underdogs. it's been craziness and madness this year

actually agree julian assange which absolutely snowden and they fight for freedom and i personally has moved a publicly demanding the release of international munch i could scream here. at what. about that kind of connection sure release the connections. well that these are nora people frank knew that song political parties were people hours. mailing spangle not on a spending try to put on the agenda in order to be security to attack our. repudiation our credibility so if they can't find you. in the field i did x. may try to use that dark tool called nero's how you are trying the russians on who are friend of that cream outre well if you look into the past there is nothing nothing some fantasy in order to attack our probation we were spared spain is famous for serial or starve and culture of course but i mean it affects this this channel you're on now my my effective boss margarita simonyan name by the judge i understand that you are working with her and thousands of troops were being prepared from russia to help you carry this debate. there is not one single fact losing your group the

his mate a little bit more complicated after snowden. for long time the government said most data that we see now is not at the nsa. as you go to web services these are the new frontline being the threats and malware and intrusions play out peripheral want in the government was threat sharing and then after snowden on the leaks the last thing you ever wondered was any kind of mechanism for real-time threat sharing with united states government because foreign governments were so appalled at the level of access to snowden dockets appeared to show in the level of collaboration it appeared to show between industry and the nsa. as a thorny issue for some time. but as it got worse and worse there been more and more calls and demand for better threat sharing for this is in your data threat sharing. this is the ip addresses the techniques and the malware strains that security firms and also google, apple, amazon or better picking up the nsa is picking up. so we have seen better information sharing. one of the things is getting discussed more an

edward snowden the defense contractor who leaked information about u.s. surveillance methods to charge him in the u.s. courts with espionage theft and conversion of government property edward snowden blew the whistle on a secret program of mass surveillance carried out by the united states government and its allies you ultimately have to make a choice about what do you have a greater commitment to the law or to justice al-jazeera as investigative unit and says this hidden world where companies make and sell equipment to intelligence and law enforcement agencies talk of russian hocking of democratic party e-mails released by wiki leaks tended to interfere with the u.s. election process in which it's a global multi-million dollar industry whose products can capture your life on your phone tablet and computer one the operates with few controls and little political oversight. even as a politician who is responsible for human rights foreign policy specifically export controls it is difficult for me to know how big this market is these companies operate and the

been working with julian assange who according to the un is being tortured here in london and would snowden who has asylum in moscow for availing secrets of the us secret state and the russian army i don't know about russian soldiers being brought him to create an independent catalonia what did you make of those allegations made by any you judge i had. something you said is a joke but in the span you're really you would say that yazid. for meat and lable and jascha leaves trust in that kind of fantasy obviously we. actually agree julian assange which absolutely know them and they fight for freedom and i personally has moved republican leader mending to release or international runge i could scream here. at what. about that kind of connections sure release the connections. well that these are narrow people knew that song political parties were people hours. mailing spangle not on a spending try to put on the agenda in order to be security to attack our. repudiation our credibility so if they can't fight you. in the field of idea x. may try to use that dark tool nearest how you are trying the

fast as possible to the most reliable source possible there are people like daniel ellsberg edward snowden and chelsea manning they don't drop clues and make you solve puzzles to look at the information q does though he does this because he is not a whistleblower q is a fictional character an x. exactly like a fictional character. this is because the purpose of q. is not to divulge actual information between create fiction let's take a look at how this works. to create apophenia 1st you need random data the more the better then you need to interpret that data in a way that leads you to a full solution that fits the narrative and several q. drops q. tells followers that there is a shadowy call to out there in which the members are required to reveal their status through symbolism owls or an animal. cue ask them to look out for these symbols and jewelry tattoos or hand gestures of public figures and celebrities of course q. knows what they'll find the clintons throwing the rock and roll hand horns jay z. flashing the illuminati. the rothschilds wearing foreign heads of fancy dress costume pa

going to change the drug dealing business is going to change a lot in the near future well of course snowden showed us full spectrum surveillance but your or your friend seems to evade. this panel think relatively easily by very simple kind of common sense ideas yeah always meet in person if you can you know if you can avoid making a phone call and never use the phone never say anything or write anything that you wouldn't be comfortable appearing on the front page of the new york times you know avoiding electronic communication is a key part of the way to avoid detection and the united states but the problem is it's increasingly difficult in the age of coronavirus to do that so. it's it's a paradox for sure. joe biden of course says his mass incarceration policies were a mistake do you think i don't know when you sent it to the new president. you know if he'd read it and begin to understand even more why mass incarceration was such a mistake i should say it's a western soldier and it's and denise of it should in the way you certainly alan on a missed talks about presidents in the united stat

greenwald an independent journalist on substract and the author of the book no place to hide edward snowden the n.s.a. and the u.s. surveillance state and from london i'm joined by yes me an alibi brown she's a columnist and professor of journalism at middlesex university thank you both for joining me on front yes i mean let me start with you what do you see as the biggest threat to free speech currently today in democracies around the world. well i have to answer your question but i tell it saying i have never believed in absolute free speech i absolutely believe that words can hurt words can incapacitate it i think if you use words carefully censorship is something done by the powerful usually governments but at the moment probably the the big tex. and i certainly feel that our government's response is deeply hypocritical and actually quite sinister. but i don't believe in absolute free speech i think words hurt. me understand what you mean when you say you don't believe in absolute absolute free speech because words heard what type of words that are heard for should be limited or constra

you could find snowden before you could find cnn fact checkers at this point. the press's questions were meek and vague. the president had to look at a list of reporters with their photos next to it, in order who to call on. the leader of the free world is afraid to call on fox news reporters who ask tough questions. president xi and putin and china and russia are paying attention. who are we dealing with? he is afraid of his own press corp. we can do whatever we want now. how could he stand up to us. and chuck said there are no negative questions on covid. they only ask questions when it's challenging. i have a question on covid. i am the parent of a 5 and 7-year-old. mr. president you said you would reopen schools and listen to the science and the data. your own cdc director says it's safe to reopen now. what do you say to parents? you assigned your vice-president kamala harris to pick the crisis at the border that you won't call a crisis. yet she compared i.c.e. to the kkk, and asked when a reporter asked when you are going to visit the border? those are que

to fully been snowden's i've been forgotten really do we want to see him because he knew that. we've been told he buys horn from fresh kills that makes him a level 3 trafficker. but you guys they all are going to be up. to 6 years of australia problem in their mild consumate way all of this pain that you do to them or does not hold with them or hace my uncle. i mean i would be glued in a mobile moving moment only one which enables me to get them out and hear what was i don't want to be. without you having all fall short with a collar. on john let me get back on this and a. little now i hope you can help but it was the end of my 2nd is i don't. think that while one of my computers ungentle going to. achieve good at clinton it didn't need to. cheat mediumship. case you know you may have missed each others. lives of about. one leaves a message for one of his contacts and says he'll get back to us with an answer. well the granite one has certainly become a commodity that's worth more than gold plant. you are dealing with networks that span the globe. julian wright in my is a luther

assessment for the pentagon papers, before edward snowden, a group of eight teamed up to steal fbi recordsylvania office. it goes on to say, ralph daniels squeezed themselves -- himself through the doors, looked across the room, taste the small office for months and now he was inside, roosevelt beckoned. this was the moment group of eight had planned. they were convinced these records would prove the malfeasance. daniel was 26 at the time. scooped up the files, his gloved hand shook. burglars had a hurry. they chose march 8, 1971 because muhammad ali's title fight against joe frazier would keep most of the country and world and most importantly fbi agents and police glued to closed-circuit screens and radios for a few hours. one of the intruders could he their broadcast and a nearby apartment so they thought the sound of the fight would cover your actions, is that right? were you surprised to hear that ralph daniel has come forward? >> them delighted that ralph has. he played a key role. he was reluctant to come forward earlier because he was afraid it would affect his professional life. b

history of having large spying programs, pointing to the nsa program that was disclosed by edward snowdeng ago. in fact, just a couple of months ago, the chinese government called the u.s. the empire of hacking, bugging and spying. so the paper says that if the biden administration wants to work through these issues with the chinese, they should be rational, as well as fair and that they should look to coordinate with beijing on cyber security issues, but brian, you and i have both been covering this relationship between the u.s. and china for quite some time, and i remember when president obama just five, six years ago in 2015 had called a truce with president xi jinping on cyber security issues, and it doesn't seem as though all of the attacks have necessarily ended. >> yeah, and you wonder, is there any sign of president biden is going to be having a quad lateral meeting about the regions, india, australia and others and the united states to try and make blunt the growing impact and economic force of china, but is there any sign or any knowledge of any official meetings, virtually or o