for example, a five-star fund, take any five-star fund, only 12% five years later had performed well enough to earn that same top mark. and a lot of investors rely heavily on those stars, some entirely, to make their decisions. >> morningstar i think would argue that they're constantly looking at their data and their star system, and they've said they view it as somewhat predictive. is that correct? what response did you get from them? >> i would say that they've said a lot of things but the predictive powers of the stars. they've said they're not predictive. they've said higher rated funds are more likely to outperform longer term, that they have moderate predictive powers. they've said a number of things on that present. >> i want to play a sound bite from the head of research at morningstar. it challenges some of the premises of your article. listen, and i'll get your reaction. >> sure. >> we strongly disagree with her conclusions. if you take a look at some of the findings that they themselves reported in exhibit to the study, what you find is that highly rated funds, five-star f

stars?ng stars, we think that this one could explode any day, literally. or it could be a thousand years from now. but near, near term in astronomers'-- >> whitaker: in cosmic time, any day. >> straughn: right. so big stars, when they die, they explode and send their contents into the surrounding universe. and these contents are what seed future stars and future planets and help to seed life, ultimately. the iron in your blood and the calcium in your bones was literally forged inside of a star that ended its life like this. >> whitaker: so we are all stardust. >> straughn: we literally are stardust. we are viscerally made of the stars. one of the things i think is remarkable about this image is it shows you how colorful the universe is. >> whitaker: this looks like contemporary art. >> straughn: this is a very tightly bound group of stars. and what you see here is about 100,000 stars. installed in 2009, this was one of the first images it took. >> whitaker: blue stars are the youngest and ho

stars are born here.finite black canvas overhead, hubble paints an ever-expanding picture of our universe, an awe- inspiring light show for us to admire, and for scientists to study. >> amber straughn: i believe hubble has been the single most transformative scientific instrument that we've ever built. >> whitaker: "most tranformative," says nasa astrophysicist amber straughn, because hubble keeps improving our understanding of the universe. she showed us what hubble discovered after staring for days into what seemed to be an empty black patch-- a deep, dark void in outer space. >> straughn: the original hubble deep field is located just above the big dipper. it's a part of the sky that most people are familiar with. it's a blank piece of sky. >> whitaker: so just nothing in here, just darkness. >> straughn: nothing at all. complete darkness. and then, when we look at it with hubble, what we see is thousands of galaxies. >> whitaker: not just stars. >> straughn: right. >> whitaker: galaxies. >> straughn:

tourism in the twenty first century looks to the stars. people are looking for experiences and astronomy is a new experience not available to them previously and this will be me and. i've never seen that the title. on the moon or. on some of the stars and spain is one of the best destinations in the world to enjoy astronomy it's a trend on the rise. that's more mastro tourism is giving value to the attraction of the night sky there are. scientific institutions businesses and tourist establishment are backing this new trend. that the fifteen years ago astro tours and sounded like times fiction didn't it would come from abroad just to look at styles from it i mean i laughed at. him as a bit more than thirty thousand german astronomers have to go abroad to practice their hobby with us here in. this intelligent tourism offers unique experiences to travelers from all over the world to discover in the southwest of europe. i don't know who that is spending the night looking through a telescope or even with the naked eye or to see things they've n

i have to tell my kids that i'm a rock star now. >> liz: she's a rock star. what do you think? >> general: the way she is doing this is just further testimony how far off she totally is in dealing with this sad situation that we have with the loss of one of our great soldiers and the public display of it like this, when a family is trying to grieve and take care of themselves and people are trying to wrap their arms around them. i can tell you this, that the words that general kelly provided to the president to use because the president was asking him to help him find the right words, i can say for a fact that i serve for 38 years in the united states army and i've had my arms around loved ones through those years and crying right with them over the loss of their loved ones and there is a consistent theme that would always come back to me that was very consoling to the loved ones that they offered to me and that was simply this, that i know he was doing exactly what he wanted to do and he was where he wanted to be and he was with his teammates, or in a number of cases it was al

all our grandparents knew and identified the stars speak of the brightest star in the constellation virgo that means with spike and when it appeared in the east they knew it was time to sew or harvest astronomy was essential for daily life but today environmentalists pollution and all our technology have completely disconnected us and. the stars have gone out in the eyes of many people who live in the developed world . this is what the planet looks like at night artificial light illuminates large surfaces of the northern hemisphere. is the largest dam in western europe the waters of the river serve as the boundary between spain and portugal. the portuguese were the pioneers in promoting astro tourism. the idea arose in two thousand and eight as part of creating a sustainable program for the ok region to offer something unique in terms of nature and resources for tourism we thought of something no one had considered before the sky. kjetil sail. it's now a starlight tourist destination certified by the starlight foundation in two thousand and eleven we were the first destination in the worl

two neutron stars collide ripples in the universe. most stars crashed 130 million years ago waves have just been seen and heard by scientists. ur correspondent had exclusive site to a wave detection in louisiana. >> it's the longest straight line in the world. a 2 1/2 mile pipe containing a laser that can detect powerful explosions in space. inside, a technician fine tunes the instrument. it's made a discovery that's shaken the scientific world. >> two stars colliding in a galaxy far, far away. around 800 billion, billion miles from earth. >> the two stars got closer and closer until they merged, resulting in a huge shock wave that rippled across the universe. the massive explosion led to the production of rare elements such as gold and platinum. neutron stars are what's left over when giant suns die and collapse in on themselves. they are so densely packed that a teaspoon would weigh a billion tons. and here is the actual sound of the collision. >> they then become part of planets when they form, including here on earth. >> the explo

one questioned i'd ask of any sitting four-star general overseas in afghanistan. we're 16 years into a war and the united states military under the direction of the president is expanding the troop presence in afghanistan when we've failed to subdue the taliban and they're on the rise. why do we think another troop surge is going to win? that's not a fair question to ask. i don't get this, wolf. there is it no way you can square this circle. >> she should come out and say she made a mistake and correct it as quick as possible. >>> coming up, a defiant new claim from north korea. we're getting new information. stand by. are you on medicare? do you have the coverage you need? open enrollment ends december 7th. don't put it off 'til later. now's the time to get on a path that could be right for you... with unitedhealthcare medicare solutions. call today to learn about the kinds of coverage we offer, including aarp medicarecomplete plans insured through unitedhealthcare. these medicare advantage plans can combine parts a and b, your hospital and doctor coverage... wit

at the end of the day what we have to look at is the idea of politicizing gold star families.ve had several people over the last 24 hours ask me if i was called by the president when travis was killed, and asked me if i know people that were called by president obama when their loved ones were killed because through my work i deal with a lot of gold star families, and the fact of the matter is gold star families are not talking to each other about whether or not the president called. what is important to gold star families is to make sure their loved one's service and legacy is remembered. i think that's the bigger story here. we need to make sure that we stop talking about who is calling our gold star families and we start talking about these gold star families and what they represent to this country and we start sharing their loved ones' stories. >> what do you want people to know? in some ways the silver lining of the sometimes uncomfortable conversations is it brings attention to the cause you want highlighted, so what do you want us to take away and what should we know ab

the only star who -- >> i know.e got hurt during a stunt for the new "mission impossible" movie. thankfully, he's okay. did his co-star, rebecca ferguson, have something to do with the accident. >> reporter: you there on set when he injured his ankle? how is he doing? what are the updates? they've started to shoot again. >> you put the marbles on the roof, didn't you? >> yes, i did. so sorry. >> reporter: 55-year-old tom took a hard hit when his rooftop leap proved to be an impossible mission. and left him with a broken ankle. >> i think he's fine. as you said, they're shooting. >> do you have more scenes to shoot? >> oh, yeah. oh, yeah. when we're done with this, i'm heading back with my bag of markles. >> he calls himself the snowman killer. doesn't hit theaters until july. but this friday, rebecca and michael fassbender team up in pursuit of a serial killer with a frigid calling card. so thank you for ruining frosty the snowman for me. >> you're welcome. >> pretty happy about that. >> reporter: are you, why? >> b

, former yankees star alex rodriguez joins the "shark tank." >> j.s buddy, you're late. >> reporter: a-rod arrived solo to craig's west hollywood 30 minutes late. after a two-hour dinner, the couple of eight months left together through the back door. >> hey, jennifer. how are you? >> reporter: on sunday, the entrepreneur will make his debut as a guest shark on "shark tank." and only "e.t." was behind the scenes. >> i've been a fan of the show since day one. i use these opportunities to teach my daughters lessons. >> reporter: worth an estimated $480 million, the 42-year-old is raising 12-year-old natasha and 9-year-old ella to be minimoguls. >> my daughters, we pretend. they go up on the the rug. they make a presentation. and we either, you know, get in or get out. i'm interested, mark, if you're interested. when i drive my daughters to school, i try to teach them one business lesson. i can't say they're enjoying it. they're learning. >> reporter: a-rod says his girls are also learning a lot from j. lo. >> jennifer is one of the most brilliant busin

for the first time the collision of the two dead stars which are called neutron stars caused a ripple in the fabric of space scientists say that collisions like this are responsible for much of the gold in the platinum that exists in the universe. the sensational discovery was made back in august by scientists in france and the us using gravitational wave detectors for the first time researchers were able to observe two ultra dense stuns so-called neutron stars as they caused ripples in the fabric of space some one hundred thirty million light years away from earth the massive neutron stars eventually collided with a massive flash of light. just two seconds later observatories across the earth and in all of it detected a burst of light in the form of gamma rays. scientists monitored the skies for weeks afterwards to see how radiation spread in various spectrums of light. telescopes on the earth and in space made this landmark observation possible. neutron stars affirmed when stars die with massive explosions what remains are extremely dense smaller more compact pieces of matter. these

is anyone here a gold star parent or sibling? does anyone here know a gold star parent or sibling? okay. you get the question. >> thank you general kelly. you have great deal respect for everything you have ever done. if we could take this a bit further, why were they in niger? we were told they weren't in armored vehicles and no air cover. so what are the specifics about this particular incident and why were we there and why are we there? >> i would start by saying there is an investigation. let me back up and say the fact of the matter is young men and women that wear our uniform are deployed around the world and there are tens of thousands. near the dmz and north korea. and okinawa and south korea. all over the united states training ready to go. they're all over latin america. they do mostly drug interdiction working with our great partners. you know, there's thousands. my own son back in if tthe fighr his fifth tour in the fight against isis. thousands in europe. acting as a deterrent and africa. and they're doing the nation's work there. not making a lot of money by the way d

the latest on the sexual assault investigations as more stars speak out. >> i don't want it to happen to anybody else. >> then -- >> we're very alike in many >> their first interview togetherle they're madly in love. what's keeping them up at night? >> him sleeping and me going, baby, baby. >> i'm the dolly mama. >> miley's godmother on what she has never done at 71ment then, the 9 to 5 reboot? >>> plus, mark rough low's romance with thor. >>> and -- >> no matter what, it is not good enough. >> this is "entertainment tonight." >> so tune in! >> take a look at all these faces. more than 30 women have come forward publicly to say harvey weinstein sexually harassed or assaulted them. >> now add to that list model turned act tres angie everheart. she explains what happened. >> i wake up, and harvey is standing above my bed. pants down and starts [ bleep ] and he's blocking the door. >> everhardt told an l.a. radio station weinstein told her not to tell anyone about the incident. the mogul is in arizona right now. he had planned to go to an inpatient treatment center for sex addiction ther

reporter is still tracking the world's biggest star thomas chasing c r seven. i'm still wiling at the real madrid training ground on my hunt for christiane when i. where will he leave from. a local cameramen if i'm on. ok i need to get past these roundabouts to the gate which the players usually past when they don't take the secret and. fortunately i meet some kids on the way they're going experts in getting players to stop for autographs they know all the tricks. they've even managed to get christiane or not oh i'm impressed. i am going to. the yeah now says i'm not. going to go. give them a good number. how can you keep track i recall a scene in the bio pic. why watching it i remember thinking christiane no really has a thing for cos. now . well it felt. very very very bright very bright. now. in the meantime. yes. they all start trickling in and i pick up some tricks from the time group. but it's done the bios won't even stop is there any chance that christiane what. might talk about the time for you. then i would have kept. the camera on the side when that.

of course, debra's "will & grace" co-stars were there.tten and sofia bush were also by her side. >> did you ever dream this? >> no, never, never. my big dream was to be a working actress. >> whoo! >> finally, we're coming out. it's very kiting. >> we were with messing on the set of her very first sitcom "ned & stacy" in 1996. >> do i have a man behind me? >> two years later, she was starring in "will & grace." she's still hopeful. >> harry connick jr. is coming back next week. can you tell me? >> it's so good. so good. >> can there be a happy ending? >> who knows? >> i giuess that's what it's lie to be a real star. >>> up next, sharon osbourne givers us a sneak peek at her new project. >> oh, my lord. what is it. >> you have never seen a home renovation show like this. >>> and then, macgyver gets down and dirty. >> you're disgusting. but still weirdly sexy. >> is he enjoying his action star dating status? ♪ >>> "e.t." certified country is hanging out with blake shelton in oklahoma. >> i don't think ♪ >>> how old was george when you lost h

not only stars, bus baby planet systems. >> most of the stars have planets. >> most stars actually do the planets inside our solar system now. we know the planets are everywhere. >> astronomer heidi hamil specializes with hubble's work ininside it the stole lar system. seesaw it slam into jupiter. creating giant if pacts. >> when i first heard that a comment was going to hit jum ter. my reaction was, so jupiter is huge. comets are small. when i saw the first impact site and it was huge, and, dark, i was flabbergasted. this its where the comet has smacked into the planet at such a high velocity. it's skautzed an explosion, the equivalent of many, many millions of bombs. i would have been shoem. earth its the size of if this happened on earth we're gone. a biosphere changing ee fent. which means we would be gone. >> you can see the full report on our website. cbs news,.com. theover will be right back. recommended dulcolax. use dulcolax tablets for gentle dependable relief. suppositories for relief in minutes. and dulcoease for comfortable relief of hard stools. dulcolax. designed for de

over all the space stars design is uncluttered. this indicator on the dashboard shows which driving mode is being used. our. unit says the seats in the front are quite comfortable and. there's enough room in the back to seat one adult comfortably but only for short hops. if she says that the four pedals are easy to reach what adults should test sit in this car first because you can move the driver's seat back further than this one of. you can also raise the driver's seat and that's unusual for an economy car but they're still not much headroom. on the other hand there's lots of room in the trunk. you can make more room by folding over the rear seat. them it's obscene is says that the mitsubishi space store has a lot to offer younger drivers it's a good first car and doesn't use a lot of fuel and it's fun to drive even more experienced drivers will discover that this is a solid vehicle that delivers the goods but it's not going to make your heart skip a beat when you take it out on the road ahead need to be can. kind of a couple of

to wear this gold star.ear this gold star. this is given to commemorate the sacrifice of your loved one. i wear it with pride because i am not wearing it just because of captain humayun khan but i'm hear wearing it to honor the sacrifice of all my sons and daughters that have sacrificed their life for this nation, for this country. >> trevor: you are someone spreading a story as you say of hope, of sacrifice. how do you preserve the mem ore of your son in such a way that it isn't just used as a political kujel? >> first captain humayun khan was made in here. we only brought him three years old to this country. all of the goodness that he learned, all of the caring for others, sacrifice, standing up for those who needed his support and all, that was made here. captain humayun khan rohatyn essay for his admission to the dormitory and the title of that essay was, and that applies so very much today and to the current situation, the title was, democracy requires vij lens and sacrifice. just think of this moment

you might even get to see your favorite star wars characters throughout the weekend. now lets talk to the man of the hour, literally, this is michael contract jew ski director of music and first, i want to say thanks so much for letting us sit in on your rehearsal it was exquisite. >> thank you, we are really looking forward to playing this fantastic music, music of star wars, music of the great john williams this weekend, hopefully folks come out and hear it. >> reporter: what other movies might we hear music. >>> from we will hear music in addition to star wars music written by john williams we will hear music by all of the songs for which he won an academy award, so that includes jaws, et, shindler's list, and another one that i cannot remember right now, star wars, the other one that he won the academy award for. >> reporter: will you be holding a light saber. >> i don't know if i want to give away all of our surprises , but very good chance that i might use a light saber to conduct the main theme of star wars report are the that is really cool. friday, saturday a

. >> inside the new show pitting stars against stars. >> it's all right. we're dropping mike on "entertainment tonight." >> kate beckinsale joins the list of ever growing women sharing her story of an inappropriate with harvey weinstein. >> he's under investigation by police in new york and london. meanwhile, weinstein had plenty to say when he faced the cameras before he headed out of town. >> guys, i'm not doing okay. i'm trying. i got to get help. we all make mistakes. second chance, i hope. >> weinstein spoke publicly for the first time since the sexual harassment scandal broke. >> i'm hanging in -- i'm trying my best. >> the 65-year-old was at his daughter's house yesterday afternoon before taking this private jet to arizona. >> get some help, man. >> that's where weinstein had planned to go to an inpatient treatment center for sex rehab, but a source tells us today that's not happening. instead, weinstein will receive treatment at a private arizona residence where therapists will come to him. meanwhile, kate beckinsale is the latest actress to speak

general kelly is a gold star parent. he doesn't want any special attention paid, and he doesn't want this to be politicized. and he's made that clear in his public remarks and in the speech that he gave a few years ago. and so for the president to invoke this as a defense in a political tit for tat with president obama, you know, kelly hasn't spoken for himself, but i can't imagine it sits very well with the general. >> kimberley, this isn't the first time the president has failed to let something like a military uniform or military standing or heroism in the military stand between him and a good bout with someone. >> this is true. this goes back to the campaign he openly feuded with -- gold star parents he openly feuded with during the campaign. and perhaps he feels a sense of invisibility from that. obviously that didn't keep him from being elected president. but i just -- i think this is one of the latest episodes where the point that charlie made about empathy, that was the main point about his trips for example to p

he put the full weight of his emotion as a gold star father, his moral authority, the stars that used to rest on his shoulders, and yet tonight here he is kind of the story. >> right. i imagine he wanted anything but to be the story. >> of course. >> at the beginning of this week when we set off on this week on monday. when you look at companies and how they handle crisis communications and situations like this and president trump, a businessman, he was going to run the white house. he's going to run the country like a business. i covered companies for a long time before this white house gig. i could not imagine a company handling crisis communication like this. you get your facts straight. if you're going to respond, if you're going to send someone out to respond, know it's going to fan the flames. it's going to drag the story on a day longer and you have to have that statement sealed air tight. you can't come out and make a -- even the tiniest error because it will fan the flames, exacerbate the story. sarah sanders has been doing communications, politics, campaigns, pretty much her

herformer her former co—stars herformer co—stars paid her former co—stars paid their respects.as gentle, kinding, so loving. she was gentle, kinding, so loving. she gave so many things to so many people. and that coming up, the final farewell. the funeral of liz dawn. some retailers stop selling baby sleep positioners after warnings from the united states they can cause deaths from suffocation. and cricketer ben stokes won't go to australia with the rest of the ashes squad. he was arrested on suspicion of actual bodily harm after an incident outside a nightclub last month. good afternoon. welcome to bbc news. theresa may has said she's providing "calm leadership"

george's good friend and co-star matt damon arrive with his life 11 years, lucy.babysitting tonight? >> we have nanny who is babysitting watching both knuckle heads. we can't leave her alone too long with them. >> reporter: twins alexander and ella are nearly 5 months old. george keeps it real when talking about the latest milestone. >> three days ago, my children started on what we would call solid food. it went in fine. i don't know how it carrot and comes out the way it come out. but it was shocking. and it was terrifying. >> reporter: do you have any baby hacks? things you can share with trance that you have learned that are 2k3w50d tips? >> don't feed 'em solid food. i mean, until they're like, 20. until they can change their own diaper, they just get milk. >> well, all joking aside, george clearly loves being a hands on dad. he told me the cutest thing about the twins is how much they love the laugh just like george and mail do. >> and knowing george, i bet he makes them laugh a lot. carly, thank you. >>> meanwhile, angelina jolie made it a girls night with

you will, however, see harvey's estranged wife, georgina chapman, on "project runway all-stars." the "marchesa" cofounder is a regular judge on the show. she announced on tuesday she's leaving him. >> just to be clear, the new season of "project one way all st stars" was already taped before the scandal. >> let's move on. jennifer aniston has written a lot of zeroes to help victims of the recent hurricanes. she just donated $1 million, split between the american red cross and the ricky martin foundation, which is for his native puerto rico. meanwhile, jennifer lopez and alex rodriguez have joined forces to aid those in need. we talked about that, and why they are just so good together, when they sat down for the very first time as a couple. ♪ i didn't see it, but i see it now, i think i love you ♪ >> it's got to be so good how people love you as a couple. >> i think we are very alike in many ways and i think that's what makes it work. i think that's what people respond to. >> we're alike, but i can't sing, dance, and i don't look like her. beside that, we are twins. >> an undenia

he's not a four-star general anymore. i honor his service. but he is the white house chief of staff. he was sent out there to speak for the president, to the country, and when he oversteps, he is fair game. >> i'm going to play that outrageous exchange that sarah sanders had at the white house briefing earlier today with chip reid. let's watch. >> i think he's addressed that pretty thoroughly yesterday. >> he was wrong yesterday in talking about getting the money. the money was -- >> if you want to go after general kelly, that's up to you. but i think that that -- if you want to get into a debate with a four-star marine general, i think that that's something highly inappropriate. >> let's bring in retired rear admiral john kirby. highly inappropriate to question a retired four-star general? >> it's absolutely an ignorant thing to say, and i'm not trying to be critical of her, but that shows ignorance. no active-duty general or admiral would ever believe that they are above scrutiny or above being questioned or actually above being debated wit

without names on them because the secretive nature of the cia, stars that recognize officers killed in the line of duty. how did the white house respond to that. >> not surprisingly, as sarah sanders said, it's not the same thing. you cannot draw a parallel between them and then she moved on to shift to other things. the but, look, i mean the reality here is this briefing was fairly extraordinary in the sent she was defending everything that the chief of staff said yesterday, but then, as we just played that clip there, see essentially suggesting that the white house chief of staff, who is a retired marine general should not be questioned here. so yes, he has incredible credibility, particularly in in white house. but that does not mean that his recollection of the events holding up to that video we've seen. in the video, she also goes on to appraise the bipartisan work of congress in getting this building passed. the she praises house republican speaker john boehner at the time. and president obama on this. the so in terms of congressional speeches, it was a pretty typical. yes, th

widow -- mother, but two gold star mothers, mrs. khan last year and then mrs. johnson this year. and not surprising from a president who said that his biggest sacrifice is building buildings, who said that his personal vietnam going to studio 54 in the 1980s, saying that john mccain wasn't a hero because he was captured. this is a president who's consistently disrespected military families and john kelly's great sacrifice can't cover for donald trump's great outrage. >> now, let's call keep in mind general kelly's being stunned, absolutely stunned, that a congresswoman would mention how the new fbi office in miami was funded and possibly trying to seek credit for that publicly as every congressman does in that situation. he considered that a dishonorable thing to do. let's look at something that president trump and that's the president's first visit to cia headquarters. >> we had a massive field of people. you saw that. packed. i get up this morning. i turn on one of the networks and they show an empty field. i said, wait a minute.

sticking to "dancing with the stars" and shania.m for movie night. >> the perfect reason. because the five-time grammy winner stars in higher first feature film, opposite john travolta. only "e.t." was on set. >> we need each other. >> we do. >> reporter: these two are close friends. and shania is making her movie debut at age 52. >> how about dinner tomorrow night? >> that's starting to become a habit. >> in trading paint, john is a race car legend. shania is his girlfriend. >> i would say that i have confidence in the fact that he would take care of me and i have never done this before. i've never done a film. >> hi son thinks you are smoking hot. i think shania is born to bonn film. her videos say that. the videos are knockout. ♪ i have to believe that things would get better ♪ >> reporter: john has always been fan of shania's music. as one of the producers of the film, he asked her to be a part of it. the singer met the avid pilot 12 years ago at his florida home. >> i flew into this cool area that had homes on a private airstri

star fund. to us that corresponds with success for the investor the stars are predicted. they are not astrology >> we have said they are a useful starting point for research they correspond with attributes we think correspond with the success. low fees, risk consciousness easier to own. if we can point investors to those funds they have a better chance of succeeding that's what we are trying to do with the star rating. >> jeffrey, what you said was interesting. i didn't understand what you meant by saying it's more likely to be successful for an investor as opposed to saying more likely in the three, five years et cetera to have this many stars what do you mean >> sure. when we look at the cross section of future results we are defining successful as achieving a four or five-star rating over a future event horizon in the numbers i quoted five-star funds were seven times more likely to achieve a four or five-star rating in the next ten years than a one-star fund would be >> are you planning to ma