>> well, i think we have recorded back to the board at the request of the board whether our votes werehe majority of the votes and a lot of those issues are new issues their i think gaining transactional and increasing most of them i would say were not successfully couped that is the pattern and it takes a long time the first time you get 15 percent of the vote and the next time 26 percent we recorded back how many of the votes were on the side of a prevailing vote and i mean bob can speak to it but generally speaking those types of resolutions are gaining in strength and i think that there is very few of them have been successfully adopted by the companies how to measure process to answer our other question it is slow proxy seasons lasts 7 or 8 or 9 months every year the deadlines for your simulation is very, very slow we've not seen our action of level one changed the proxy vote we believe that our proxy policy was already in line

the board welcomes your comments. there are customer satisfaction forms available. ou have a question about the schedule, speak to the staff after the meeting or call the board office tomorrow we are located at 1650 mission street, suite 304. this meeting is broadcast live on sfgovtv cable channel 78. dvds are available to purchase directly from sfgovtv. thank you for you attention. we'll conduct our swearing in process. if you intend to testify and wish to have the board give your testimony evidentiary weight, please stand and say i do. please note: any of the members may speak without taking the oath pursuant to the sunshine ordinance, and thank you. do you solemnly swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the whole truth and nothing but the truth? >> i do. >> thank you. >> thank you so the first item is public comment for people who wish to speak on an item in the board's jurisdiction but not on the calendar together any general public comment seeing none the next is commissioners questions or comments commissioners? okay. no commissioner comment

approvals as the strategy and if we present a hybrid approach it will be the board deciding whether they agree with the hybrid approach or go completely fund to fund that's the tipping point in which the board makes the decision. >> we've not given a definite on that. >> that result is to go figure out we can go down the line so staff has the best feel of this i mean, we should be in a condition 80 today, we he prefer fund to fund or want to do it direct and that's great direction for the staff we'll be doing a service there's a slight standoff on the question and the rfp in my view a properly written we have not will given the definite answer at the end of the day you know i'll leave it at that. >> perhaps reading to the material we'll be educating to which model we're prefer. >> no i'm not sure i agree. >> that's the whole point of the whole model are we're going to go fund to fund or - >> we know that staff has not direction they're still a standoff on whether it is fund to fund or a direct program. >> or both. >> this is more education for us >> yeah. or both because people are t

and not staff to guide the board in a policy in direct approach i'll urge the board to include questions and the consultants rfp that will help the board to understand which consultants have the best qualifications to insure the lowest fees and transcript to mitigate the risks we provided a list of questions attached for your consideration in the selection process including the refrance from hiring manager that support the benefit retention and hiring the consultants that have the experience working with clients when factor environmental, social and governance issues into their decision-making process sincerely margaret and some of the questions are is your firm of pure consultantcy if you offer investment product are the real conflict of interests mitigated will you require all hedge fund managers considered to be fiduciaries describe our experience and track record working with public pension clients please provide a list of the managers. >> 30 seconds. >> you recommend and describe our experience and success in negotiating lower fees how do you factor in the government to do their due

. >> welcome to the march 25, 2015, meeting of san francisco board of appeals the presiding officer is our president commissioner president lazarus joined by commissioner vice president honda and commissioner fung and commissioner wilson is absent we have a vacant seat when a seat is vacant a vote of 3 members is required robert brown the deputy city attorney and provides the board with legal advice and mr. pacheco is the board legal assistant i'm cynthia goldstein the boards director we'll to be joined by representatives that have matter before the board scott sanchez is the zoning administrator and he represents planning department and planning commission and joe duffy for the department of building inspection mr. pacheco go over others meetings guidelines and conduct the swearing in >> phones and other electronic devices are prohibited. out in the hallway. people affiliated with these parties must conclude their comments within 7 minutes, participants not affiliated have up to 3 minutes - no rebuttal. to assist the board in the accurate preparation of the minutes, members of the pub

i think they should do that concurrently with going with the board process. that will be the only time in the timeline from step by step perspective that it would change so when it's gone through the mayor's office process that they are able to issue it out to the general public an getting the proposals shortly there after. that would be the one thing and if you take that and that's 30 days, you can move everything else up along that change 30 days sooner and if the board were to complete the process quicker than 90 days you would take that same amount and move those items up more. you have the potential to move the time on the rfo process and get the rfo issued and sign 2 months earlier if it went according to the regular schedule. the rest of the agenda, third time i'm actually fine with and believe they have put together a very solid timeline. i agree i don't want to put something there and say we can shave 3 days off here. let's give them the time they need and i think they have done a great job. this is one item that i would like to see changed. >> in ter

the agenda. >> yes. absolutely. >> thank you. >> no reports from board members? >> commissioner president murase tuesday march third we were welcomed audio the caesar chavez community the superintendent senior staff and ms. fewer and i participated in an experience on the smarter balanced assessment where we sat down added computer terminals to skewer canyon core and math and arts questions it was tree informative i hope there will be a way for families to do a test one of this kind testing we were joined by 3 caesar chavez fifth graders i want to thank the caesar chavez community for that opportunity oh i wanted to say if commissioner mendoza-mcdonnell wanted to talk about the the mayors breakfast and announcement. >> certainly last week, we all the board members attended the annual chamber of commerce city breakfast with the mayor and is superintendent and the chamber announced united sf to bring together the community to invest in the public schools we're excited about the initiative that will hope to convene the members of the chamber of commerce to be a lot f

89 percent building the city should a restrictions for vvl in hedge fund and 96 percent building the board should ask about the deinvestment of hedge funds to go off to cal teachers union to investigate infrastructure you should visit cal ferries and talk about the hedge funds 94 percent are not prepared to see their member contributions 25rdz future retirement increase in hedge funds fail and 93 percent would not charge - >> the staff to perform adequate due diligence on hedge funds and 98 percent building that all union members should be surveyed for their preferences in investing in hedge funds and 95 plus building that this board should not make a decisions to invest in hedge funds without approval of the 54 thousand plan beneficiaries i urge you to vote no on any asset obligations thank you time (clapping.) >> if people could listen up to speak on public comment i'll work off the speaker cards first. >> good afternoon board members i'm worked at laguna honda for 20 years i'm not an expert in vvl but warren buffett is and george sorry is and mr. cal per if they don't recommended the pe

we will have two internal staff we'll have a consultant that will be other than the boards consultant and try to have one, if not 2 other public employees or entities that have experience or expertise in the selection and evaluation of hedge funds so it's a 5 person panel and we'll be eliminating our consultant from the process. >> that's the recommended amendment. >> may i ask a question. >> have we in the past exclude our consultants from evaluating rhd. >> i don't believe so. >> have your clients ever included you from the rfp process in evaluating applicants. >> no it is part of our contract we would include the hedge fund to fund and candidate review process but not the hedge fund process that is a different amen we considered it i guess we graded i guess only the last contract 8 years ago it was included point scope of services. >> but not direct. >> not direct. >> can you say that 8 years ago the hedge fund was in your contract. >> we had two extensions and i think our last contract. >> 2008 but again the listing of activities that we're expecting were basically at the discreti

the grant proposal has been conditionally approved we're here from the school board in april so the grant itself is to support transitional aged youth parents both young would women with are housed here in san francisco and the giving up of a new program for young men. >> great thanks for being here so supervisor tang. >> just a quick questions are there any matching fund. >> no. >> we have no budget analyst report so we'll open up for public comment seen none, public comment is closed. on item 13. >> through the chair i'd like to make a motion to forward this to the full board open up for public comment and madam clerk any other business before this committee? >> mr. chair there's another amendment. >> we have an amendment for the open spaces in rec and park department for a fiscal year 2014-2015. >> okay. so we don't have our department supervisor tang. >> i mean, i look at the item i'm sure we can go to harvey rose report i don't have questions i know that rec and park tend to bring this report out of an abundance of caution and need for transparent especially by the board when t

appoints the board members. surely the director, especially with the additional disclosure requirements in the bill will show the kind of judgment and prudentens that is necessary. surely, surely, that said, my friends, this is a work in progress. but it's an effort to turn around a problem that's greater than just one science board, aun agency. it's an effort to address a problem that faces the entire federal government. let us continue to work and try and do something for the benefit of everyone. i yield back, mr. speaker. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman yields back the balance of his time. without objection, the previous question is ordered. the question is on the motion to recommit. those in favor say aye. those opposed, no. the noes have it. mr. peters: i ask for a record vote. the speaker pro tempore: a recorded vote is requested. those favoring a recorded vote will rise. a sufficient number having arisen, a recorded vote is ordered. members will record their votes by electronic device. . the chair w

when we presented to the rate fairness board last time. it was important to be able to describe to them for their consideration both the program design and the rates. sort of like what are we getting for that price. and so what you see in the schedule is meeting with stakeholders to discuss program design and policy guidelines, taking those program design guidelines and procurement reform issues to our commission and then taking it to the rate fairness board. so we will know as a staff that we've done some outreach within the community, we've informed, we have taken that into consideration, we've informed our commission as to what we recommend, we've taken that into consideration and then we bring it to the rate fairness board for them to consider as a package, the program design as well as the not to exceed rate. then we go out, we do a lot of things, but one of the thing we do then is go out to the market and see if we can get resources to match that program design at that not to exceed price and we come back to the rate fairness board wi

welcome to the rules committee of the san francisco board of supervisors. y name is john avalos, chair of the committee. joined to my right by vice chair katy tang and will be joined shortly by supervisor malia cohen. >> please make sure to silence all cell phones and electronic devices. speaker cards and all documents to be included in the file should be given to the clerk. >> okay very good. thank you. we have several appointments up for us today and let's go on to our first one. item no. 1. >> item no. 1 is a hearing to consider appointing two members terms ending november 16, 20016, to the bicycle advisory committee. there are two seats and two applicants. >> very good, we can go straight ahead to presentations. i know the district 11 seat applicant, casey allen, will not be here, but i believe mr. mark brand is here. please come forward. >> good morning, supervisors. by the way, i have worked with casey allen and i think he's really great committee member. i've been on the bicycle advisory committee for a few years now and i consider it a great honor. i

make a short presentation and the council of the mime to follow in the presentation and andy who is the board chair and mr. going ms. will speak. >> john updyke director of real estate this is a resolution authorizing even though city to enter into a long term lease with the mistake museum a nonprofit corporation we know as 706 mission street at third and mission and that depicts essentially the premises around the building so while the museum has a history of over 4 decades and this particular project has roots over 20 years ago when the former development agency supported a home for the mexican museum that day has finally arrived protectively we have a b little bit of work to do this is too the city and ocii and the developer millennium and consistent with their entitlements construct and knee a condo interest in approximately 48 thoughts square feet across 4 floors of development and lower levels storage including the historic building all below the historic building above. >> just to give you a sense of the massing of the project that depicts this development within the existing new const

>> it is just an item for action or not action by the board, it's not -- because that was kind of -- you know, as much as -- >> we all discussed not wanting to have the same hearing all over again and i just remember that we had really talked about all that kind of other -- looking at now and into the future and the grand scheme of how we were achieving our goals and other things so i felt like the spirit of the motion didn't capture quite the dialogue. >> yeah, that's good, i'm glad you brought that up you know we have that feedback now and we know when that does come back, we have an idea of what we're all expecting and i think we have a member op of the public as well. >> and madam chair, just for the record, in the original staff in the resolution, there was a discussion about staff bringing back the study about the economic impact of construction and all of that, so that is -- that was separate -- that was in the main resolution, this was something very specific, so that study will come back at a future time. >> director borden, are you okay with that, or do you want to -- >> yea

to be sent to the california city hall legislators there are no public speakers and comments from the board? commissioner walton >> i do want to comment also related to a lot of the public comments we're heard tonight i hadn't to look at the high school questions from the examine they're really focused on traditional in the math portion traditional way of teaching math which the focused on computation i think we're moving in a significant way away from that fngd on problem solving and critical open and teamwork so it is very not what we're will trying to accomplish in the district i want to add that the math common core was developed by a team 6 over one hundred teachers and field tested by field teachers this very rich and deep curriculum that will not be served by the questions on the exit examines so i want to thank ms. fewer. >> commissioner wynns i've never been a supporter and don't know what it is accomplishing it seems to be penalize students being a not reliable so thanks for bringing it forward. >> ms. fewer. >> i'd like to note that the san francisco unified school district offer

next item think on the agenda is consent calendar resolution for the board discussions and immediate action there are non-and item 2 superintendent proposal for first reading is there a motion and second to the wellness thoughts policy? thank you very much this will be referred to the rules and budget committee is there a month to month on the authorization to grant on the petition or deny it for the charter >> is there a second. >> move to move. >> second. >> this will be referred to the curriculum and budget committee commissioner, i wanted to mention that sarah was in the audience but i think was gone the only speaker that would have spoken just to acknowledge she was here thank you. >> the next item on the agenda r board members proposal for the first reading in support to support and as a graduation requirement authorized that i ms. fewer motion and second for the suspension of the rules. >> second. >> thank you very much roll call vote on the suspension of the rules. >> thank you ms. sonata mr. chin ms. fewer mclaren mr. haney ms. mendoza-mcdonnell ms. norton mr. walton ms. wynn

are the requested action the board of education of the san francisco unified school district be public hearing and adopt the agreement and the related disclosures documents thank you there are no public speakers ohoh - i'm sorry you have had to submit a card in order to speak pubically on the item comments from the board commissioner wynns. >> i want to inform everyone that i'll be abstaining with the conflict of interest my husband is a member of the local 377 and want the members of the board to know that. >> thank you commissioner wynns if there are no further comments roll call vote please. ms. sonata mr. chin ms. fewer mr. haney ms. mendoza-mcdonnell ms. norton mr. walton ms. wynns abstain. >> abstain on the whole item? the whole item >> okay. thank you same agreement so i have to abstain. >> dr. murase i that's 5 ids your next there is a motion and a second for a structural calendar and mr. superintendant commissioner president murase i'd like to ask the deputy to please read this thank you, again superintendent requested action that the board of education adap

this afternoon. >> you're very first speech to the commission. >> my ask today is that the board eir prove the plan always curl submitted or the intention to alter the plan for what alternatives are to be included this is a legacy project over 2 years of planning and decision that have occurred i've had a short less than two months to dive into this and bring might have up to speed i've spoke up with the recognizecy groups i've met with the mta and the office of economic workforce development i've done my best to become a good std state of this situations my analysis is that project is primarily 3 things for the most part an infrastructure project trying to repair aging sewers and streets and district 3 is the oldest district with the oldest neighborhood our infrastructures need upgrading i've not spoken with anyone that is obviously the most expenditure of what is being proposed the second parrot of the project has been overlooked this is a public safety project and perhaps the most significant changes r those that will make the intersections safer intersections that have inside

be it further resolved the board of supervisors urges the sfmta board to report on compliance with transportation code sckz 1914 f 5 which requires the service provider to provide real time locationdality data for each bus and the board of supervisors requests to analyze the shuttle bus location area to determine how the routes and stop locations can be modified [inaudible] the board of supervisors urges the san francisco mta board to conduct a analssis to demonstrate the nexus between the [inaudible] and traffic and increase cost of affordable houses. the board of supervisors urges to adopt a fee to receiver the cost of the impablth demonstrated in the next analysis. those are my amendments i would like to make to the this resolution and just to say i know i expect that there will be a statement saying this will delay this resolution from being passed, but i think colleagues all of us can give indication that we'll support the snd lying resolution and whether we support it or not it doesn't give the green light to the board to implement a harmony program sfr labor. that is my motion to add the l

. >> correct. >> and by then the legislation will be introduced at the board okay. so that should get us on the elements of the timeline and one other pious on the telling meeting what the stakeholder to discuss the precipitates. >> that's the week of april 6th we'll be presenting before we present program design and not to exceed rates here and at rate fairness we're proposing to talk with the stakeholders so that will be a step ahead of presenting to you. >> great. >> thanks. >> and but to our point that's not the only time we'll be talking about this. >> thank you. >> thank you very much. >> does that conclude our - >> yes. >> report now i'm going to ask for. mr. brooks hello >> good afternoon, commissioners i was going to tall one water a little bit i need to forego that and talk about community choices i'll say by the way the stakeholder process that was mentioned didn't include the community advocates only the stakeholders that the mayor come up we need to get the stakeholder meeting to run the program to initiate to work with staff and contractors to make sure

body to the successor agency aka, the board of supervisors follow the board of supervisors' rules order. this will allow us to treat successor agencies like board business so we don't have to schedule time-consuming committee of the whole board meeting every single time a successor agency item comes up for a vote. today i'm introducing an ordinance to streamline a couple of the group commendations. we currently have restaurant commendations and small business commendations. local restaurants are small businesss and i propose that we consolidate these into one. group commendations are great opportunities for the board of supervisors to acknowledge leaders in our community, but they take about an hour and a half of the time during the board meetings. that is not always fair to those who have other business before the board. and the restaurant and small business owners themselves are very busy people and often have to close up shop when they come here for those commendations. so as a compliment or alternative to that, my legislation officially recognizes that january is restaurant month in

you commissioner president murase i want to thank commissioner fewer for introducing f this and the board for strong support we're in a intriel new era of learning the cognitive learning for our students and continuing to administer this is like filling your gas tank with a horsewhip it is miss aligned it is the common core is a deeper set of standards that asks our students to do much more complex thinking and as the board has taken a strong stance an decreasing the amount of testing unnecessary testing in our city hall's that is an excellent example an archaic testing not in modern time i want to thank the staff for supporting that as well. >> commissioner haney i want to say thank you to ms. fewer for bringing this forward i remember this of the first brought about but i think without a doubt at the canyon core changes what we should be testing for 12 graders it makes that more irrelevant i want to make sure we a lot internally it seem like there is agreement we will like this is not an ascertainment sunshine we should be doing if we're stoougz it has in the past superintendent evaluat

of a different system and want to brought to your attention because this is the discussions with the board of supervisors as it relates to clean power and the concept of a program what this definition requires us should we step into the business line down the road we will have a separate set of books speaks for itself so it is related to a future integration separate from the rest of the enterprises we're going to set up the program make sure under is some sort of loan agreement or more than a gentleman handshake and that's our plan all along when we were talking about this anyway so no change again, i mentioned the master venture you have several maps i want to list or review them this is the rolls of the road for the promise to the bond holder the supplemental around this transaction to having in the next couple of months did preliminary is the large disclosure document we create at the out sit down this is the bond verifies that are interested in bond buying this is who we are as an agency and our expenses and that sort of thing the continuing disclosure is what we report out to the the

i'm here to ask the board to exempt motorcycles and scooters from the rpp program. i recently am in a neighborhood that area q has added the rpp which will hopefully allow for a bit more park ining our neighborhood and everything else but then was to find out that the motorcycles were charged the same $110 that a car is charged and the rational for that is the cost of enforcement is the same. now, we all know that common sense says you can stick 8 motorcycles in one car space so i'm hoping you guys can help invent advise mow cycle and scooter parking but taking the need for the rpp for motorcycles and scooters which clearly will allow for more parking, less congestion, less wear and tear in the city. the revenues that the rpp bring in from motorcycles, i haven't been able to find this 10 million that it puts out for the car, if motorcycles are included in that, it's a small number. motorcycles will help, gone are the days of the harley david sons, we have thousands of small scooters that just add to the transportation system, unfortunately, the mta doesn't really ad

is what are the next steps in the sense how can we as a full board give input to you on it and broader process whether the school community or different community organizations can move forward and give feedback or is that done in the phase of it both what can he do and what's next. >> well, it's really in the hands of district staff but it will building advanced together through the subcommittees you'll assign it to and the computing input from ourselves and the boarding public will happen through the. >> ms. fewer. >> i request it be reviewed it will be great to get student feedback. >> i have a question last year this was an dense active project sponsor with the food bang p in rethinking our lunch rooms how is that influencing some of the work. >> i'm looking for over and over la you know we stayed to the degree we tried to be focused on the school food environment to the degree that staff has they're really leading all this work on the future dinging experience so again, this is really being led by the staff and to the degree it is in the wellness policy it will be that's an item t

education code if bayview not limited to a application and whereas pursuant california education code the board of education district is in receipt of the renewable receipt effect 2014 and the district shall comply with the action on petition as required by law and whereas the board of education shall require the petition and all information received with respect to the petition complugd the supporting documentation and incite by the california lufrgs and should be a part of educational system and whereas the district superintendent and staff shall complete a report and recommendation to the board of education therefore, be it resolved that the board of education shall grant the petition subject to the requirements worthwhile. >> thank you, mr. davis i have 5 speakers signed up for comment (calling names) two minutes and again, if the audience could use a silent applause we will have a larger applause at the end of the. good evening and community i'm mike i'm the principle of kip san francisco bay academy our goal tonight to have the approval our charter to continue to have a choice for parents

dave is here from h s a and supervisor kim acknowledged the contract board the 24/7 and the e pitiful of community services working on other things with the city departments now mohammed and the mayor are going to start off a tour with the press and anyone is welcome to come here we're going to have food assessable twoursz for people that are living that under tunneled thank you all we look forward the best is yet to come thank you very within our population there are people who simply do not have access to the internet who do not have the means to access information the way that others have, and i think that it's really imperative for government to make sure that we play a role in closing that technological divide. so you have to strike that balance between maintaining that character, but also welcoming in the new people who bring their own -- >> absolutely. >> so i love that. i love that mix, that balance that comes with it. it's hard to strike the right balance, but -- >> it really is. >> but it's there. >> i was born in guatemala and came to this country

steel we wish you the best and on behalf of the board congratulations to you (clapping) >> thank you thank you very much i really appreciate that. >> two announcements on thursday i don't have the right date lincoln lois lane high school will be celebrating it's 21st brotherhood assembly eye i hope high colleagues will be able to participate the brother and sisterhood assembly is to show the diversity around the school it is performed or performed by students from over 15 clubs eaten on saturday march 14 the rosa parks is having their annual fund raising that concludes the announcements next report of closed session but before we go into closed session i'd like to yes - i'd like to read the in memoriam prosecute we adjourn into closed session i'd like to ask mile colleagues in helping me adjourn tonight meeting in memory of dr. aaron earned son a great sadness the family shares the news of this unexpected death in basil switzerland he transcribed to the board in the state and advisors for the president of the mckennaly elementary school pta i want to acknowledge kimberly pta president

policies on vaccinations come to the board to the board at the next meeting on on april 13th so that will be coming to you that will only be a first reading and theoretically won't have to come back to the rules committee. thank you. >> president? >> just the position that the committee took on the ending of the personal belief exemption there's a resolution tomorrow night which i'm going to go and speak in favor and communicate the board's position on that and i just wanted you to be aware of that and invite anybody else to give public comment if you happen to be around the state building tomorrow night around 7. >> can i say something that the committee will follow up on i've received a request from the senator's office that we take a support position and send a letter on the community school's act that she has proposed and the hearing in the education committee is on april 8th, so we will not have another rules committee before that meeting so i have asked i sent it to -- i forwarded it to mr. davis an

of supervisors that like the president of the board of supervisors that said i had no idea so when mr. raven put together the section for the grand jury he repeated the quotes under the nicole and the board of supervisors and there's no mention in any of this about repel the public benefits prohibition there was an earlier effort by members of the commission to repeal the section having go to do with the board of supervisors but couldn't find a section you'll not find a sponsor for that 0 that's not the way it is at city hall of this is not election year people understand the dynamics but certainly when your talking about things like tomcast or ecology or other types people with special permits there are questions raised all the time about the fact that in terms of being able to do research and work we did it at city report i just hired somebody to go through the top 15 you can go through the star and match it up on the converting computer system additional match it up virtually everyone of the nancy pelosi nonprofits had made contributions we're talking about people getting contracts

.) >> thank you good afternoon trustees i'm cynthia landry sits on the 1021 executive board for the local trustee it's been said before it's been said today and it will be continued to be said by our members active and retired that we have saying no to my hedge fund allocation simply stated zero hedge funds allocation local 1021 exclusive board has passed a resolution along with the committee opposing zero hedge funds allocation. >> support. >> what did i say and supporting. >> okay. thank you for the correction supporting zero hedge fund allocation our members have done their due diligence and my question to you trustees have you done our due diligence regarding hedge funds we've had a town hall meetings regarding hedge funds and the board has been educated on hedge funds do you know the specific instruments that comprise our hedge fund allocations what does the hedge fund comprise of what are the fees? and where was the corp headquarters? is the and does this corp headquarters pay taxed do they invest in the u.s. and economy are they good corp citizens those are questions you should loo

vehicle before i call the next item i want to remind the members of the public if you wish to address the board of education you must complete a speaker card prior to the item being called and presented to the clerk the board rules speaker cards will not be accepted for an item before the board before i move on to the superintendent ins and outs for the presentation i want to point out that superintendent carranza is on the cover of the education week (clapping) and you're amazing familiar with the education week for the analysis on k through 12 education the third year of leaders to learn from superintendent carranza was selected will i the educators if a pool of quarters debater and other education writers and experts in the k through 12 field so it's really wonderful to see the superintendant acknowledge we knew how good he was in san francisco but to have him acknowledged subtitling we'll move the presentation to the board of education board of education the superintendent report. >> wow. thank you, dr. murase commissioner president murase hopefully things don't get worse from that kind of

rfp and bringing forward a recommendation for hire to the board on all the investment dmoilts so to answer your question the question for parole could state they could perpetrate potentially all 3 models the hybrid and direct only and fund to fund and the signal from the staff the recommendation and i think we have basically although it's not clearly state not having the restriction we could decide to go fund to fund completely or defying direct the recommendations to the board their skill set that made us decide to recommend them and the direction they will go and commissioner president before we get to the recommendation there will be a set of final recommendations to present to the board whether fund to fund or direct and so my vision you'll see some mix of them in the semi if not lift we'll conduct due diligence on site to 9 place you have places that have offices all over the world but we'll do onsite and bargaining the change in the board policy we'll bring back the recommendations. >> great. >> and so we get to vote that up and down. >> that's the cotter policy yeah. >> great

of education and know that means the world to us a board address staff that i've dedicated this time and your expertise to assure with the voters of san francisco have asked us to do we're true with that kathy to please come forward and recognize the members of the peace good evening, commissioners i'm kathy the supervisor for the public education enrichment fund and for the 6th year that's been my honor to serve the peace cock members i'd like to recognize each member by calling their name and say a little bit about them many of the members were here on march 17 we're not able to make it tonight we have two members that have served 4 years both of the members were appointed by commissioner president murase and both of the two members have consistently participated and attended and served in very important ways to help the group move forward and come to meaningful recommendations year after year i'd like to recognize jeff who also served as co-chair. >> (clapping.) and the certificate recks four years of service and the second person for four years are you here (clapping.) folks you

the city a better place for everyone to live thank you. >> thank you. next speaker. >> board of supervisors my name is nick jenkins. >> please pull the microphone closer to our mouth mr. jenkins. >> i'm an employee of the tenderloin housing clinic to keep people housed what we have their situation some of the residents have mental illness those are people are not well we provide a place for home as a desk collect i keep resident safe and make people comfortable i have to enforce the rules some accept and so resent i'm a residential manager with the clinic which is an unpaid position that allows me to stay in the city free i'm also on the clock if i didn't have this position i couldn't afford to live in the city over the years i've seen how funding shortages have hurt our resident we can't maintain the facility and often storages are supplies staffing shortages will make that harder for me to do my job and make sure the residents feel safe in july the board passed a resolution that loud the nonprofit if there's a surcharge the city has the money it's hard to ask for something

ies there is a quote done deal quote/unquote with the retirement board some of the board members they think there's a commitment to purchase the down payment loans without having brought it to the retirement board for approval sf dr s is preceding are due diligence but we certainly have not begun to discuss this recommendations with the retirement board any way you can so often the announcement will help me get the full retirement board to support it when it comes before them later this year unquote and some of that with my apologies i took out a few phrases i kept it to a 50 word limit for inclusion but the rest is pretty much a direct quote of e-mail to mr. elliott. >> i've had spotty results are transparency with the mayor's office of housing a year ago inkwooig about the down payment loan we gave me information and now will not tell me how many of the fiscal year 2013-2014 loans that were not issued under deploying were revolted over to the next year and not tell me how many of the applications were received this year you have to be very, very careful with the mayor's office of ho

. >> thank you very much any questions or comments from my colleagues on the board. >> thank you, dr.urase i had a wonderful tour of your school and thank you to the principles i picked our brain and saw things that i think under particular that impressed me 89 percent of kip students are san francisco resident i think you're making great academic progress what i saw there i wish i could see in some of our schools that didn't mean we hope to put you out of business willie brown but i just want to say that before a member i saw what i say i was impressed and want to congratulate you and recognize the pay off of our hard work i saw students more engaged than in a while thank you for your tour yes i'll support it. >> any other comments seeing none we will go to roll call vote on that motion. >> thank you and this is on bayview academy; is that correct ms. sonata mr. chin commissioner fewer mr. haney ms. mendoza-mcdonnell rachel norton ms. wynns and dr. murase that's 5 i's thank you very much clapping we have one more item for approval authorization to grant on the or deny the petition fo