juanita tolliver and tim miller, thank you both very much.lks, a new york subway argument turned deadly. but no criminal charges have been filed. when the 11th hour continues. has no idea she's sitting on a goldmine. well she doesn't know that if she owns a life insurance policy of $100,000 or more she can sell all or part of it to coventry for cash. even a term policy. even a term policy? even a term policy! find out if you're sitting on a goldmine. call coventry direct today at the number on your screen, or visit coventrydirect.com. you don't have to mow the lawn this weekend. with the performance of craftsman battery power by your side, you get to. you also get to trim this, edge that, and blow everything away. isn't the outdoors great? it is great. because you made it that way. get the job done right with craftsman. we build pride. ♪ prices keep going up. but experian is here to help you save on personal loans, credit cards, or car insurance. experian helped me save over $1,400 a year on car insurance. start saving now. free. at experian.

jake sherman and tim miller are back with me.reporting in punch bowl on the disconnect between the biden administration and speaker mccarthy. walk us through the strengths and weaknesses on each side. >> let me say this to begin with. there is virtually no chance that congress is going to lift the debt ceiling for 30 or 60 days. i can say that with a ton of certainty based on my reporting. house republicans are not going to engage in that, and if that's the white house's strategy, that actually just adds more to the argument that we've made over the last couple of days in "punchbowl news" that they have zero idea what house republicans want. i get the sense from the white house they're trying to figure out whether kevin mccarthy is playing 3d chess or something. he's not. he's not very complicated on this topic or any topic for that matter. he wants spending cuts, and he's not going to lift a clean debt ceiling. i mean, it's unfortunate for the folks that want a clean debt ceiling, but they won the house, and that's kind of the p

tim miller is back with us.ie, what congress traditionally does and what happens these days are often two different things, so what happens now is the ethics committee now in the driver's seat? >> well, a top lawmaker on the ethics committee is arguing that their panel is actually still doing what it's always traditionally done. i spoke to dave joyce, he's a republican who is actually leading the investigation into george santos, and he told me that they are following precedent by not deferring this to the doj, the department of justice, as they've done in the past. i'll lay out why. he talks about this example of congressman matt gaetz, the dom was pursuing criminal charge against him. that is why the panel felt comfortable referring to the doj and letting them handle it. in santos' there is an ethics matter and criminal matters. that includes the 13 counts that santos was indicted on. that is what the doj joyce tells me will continue to look at while the ethics panel investigates everything they've been lookin

former congressman, max rose, and tim miller are here on that. then later, the ceo of chatgpt are going to testify before congress, as lawmakers raced to catch up with a i. good luck with that. jay korbel will break up what to expect. the 11th hour, just getting underway on a monday night. a monday night has no idea she's sitting on a goldmine. well she doesn't know that if she owns a life insurance policy of $100,000 or more she can sell all or part of it to coventry for cash. even a term policy. even a term policy? even a term policy! find out if you're sitting on a goldmine. call coventry direct today at the number on your screen, or visit coventrydirect.com. he snores like an angry rhino you've never heard an angry rhino baby, i hear one every night. every night. okay. i'll work on that. save 50% on the sleep number limited edition smart bed. plus, free home delivery when you add an adjustable base. only at sleep number. ♪ i have type 2 diabetes, ♪ ♪ but i manage it well. ♪ ♪ it's a little pill with a big story to tell. ♪ ♪ i take once-daily

>> tim miller, an important insight as well. thank you. erin, of course, thanks to you.at way to start us open. the first republican primary voting is only seven months from now. as ron desantis enters the field, donald trump is still dominating. >>> let's head to steve kornacki at the big board. he has a huge lead. there's a big distance between desantis and the rest of the pack running or thinking of running. >> yeah. i think that's why this is such an interesting moment. we talk about the last few months for ron desantis before he entered the race. he has taken some hits. he has had donald trump attacking him. i think that's brought his poll numbers down a little bit. you see the field that desantis is jumping into. seven republicans with desantis coming in later today saying they are running. then there's a question of how big is this field going to get? think of at least seven more who are either poised to enter or who are toying with entering the race. you are getting into the territory, that double digit candidate territory you saw in 2016 which raises questions a

tim miller, who won the week?for serial sexual sought under oath. and her amazing lawyer judge lewis a. kaplan that he had a lap a lash out of her and said you're not my type either, and i promise you the feeling is mutual. do not hurt robbie kaplan. >> listening to the deposition was mind-blowing. trump is a bit pathetic. mine of the wic week is one from the, nurse justin ricketts, he is a high school rising senior it's on coast community high school in florida, and he got a perfect score of 1600 on his sats. only a person of the class of 2021 scored above a 1400, making his 1600 perfect score an incredibly rare feat. go south florida. finance gun appreciate that. he's from our part of florida, from south florida. so go justin ricketts. he's going to be somebody huge

tim miller is writer at large for the bulwark and msnbc political analyst. hello, everybody. so, ron, let's go back to the hearing that is going on today and just what 90 minutes. what is that all about? >> well, it is about this order and the judge explaining to former president trump exactly what he expects and what he can and cannot talk about. specifically the evidence in the case. he's barred from disseminating it, he's barred from copying it and he's barred in some cases depending upon what type of evidence we're talking about and that's not laid out specifically in the order, he has to see it in the presence of his own defense attorneys. so the judge is concerned about influencing the jury potentially, yes, but also concerned about security here at the courthouse and the protection of the d.a. staff and himself. you remember there were many threats lobbed at the judge, at his family, at d.a. bragg, after this case was announced a couple of weeks ago. that's another concern of the judge. he's trying to make sure that this happens in the safe environment. and no doubt he

joining us now is jemele buoy, cohost of the unclear and present danger podcast, and tim miller, writer at large at the bulwark. thank you both for being here. tim, can you help me understand what was going on in that room last night, what almost sounded like a laugh track at points for some of the most disingenuous, hateful, malicious commentary i've heard in a while. >> well, there's two things that were happening. one is the room was stacked with republicans. it was obviously there were local new hampshire republicans, but i saw in the audience a guy i know as a professional republican fund-raiser. he doesn't live in new hampshire. woody johnson, the new york jets owner in the crowd who's there. so a lot of trump people were stacked in the audience, so that's part of it. i think that was a really poor production choice. i think at a broader level what we've learned here and the difference in the video you showed up at the top from the trump era is not that all humans don't have darker choices and impulses but donald trump says it's okay to let those out and let that free flag fly. wh

like they are under siege from one side. >> these are complicated times, we will keep covering, tim miller ben collins thank you for being here just an, i want to make you stick around because coming up we are talking about ron desantis and a new florida law that is already driving agricultural workers that we really need out of the state during a critical labor shortage. when the 11th hour continues. we planned well for retirement, but i wish we had more cash. you think those two have any idea? that they can sell their life insurance policy for cash? so they're basically sitting on a goldmine? i don't think they have a clue. that's crazy! well, not everyone knows coventry's helped thousands of people sell their policies for cash. even term policies. i can't believe they're just sitting up there! sitting on all this cash. if you own a life insurance policy of $100,000 or more, you can sell all or part of it to coventry. even a term policy. for cash, or a combination of cash and coverage, with no future premiums. someone needs to tell them, that they're sitting on a goldmine, and you have n

now, jamelle bouie, -- opinion columnist, and co-host of the unclear and present danger podcast, tim miller, writer at large at the bulwark. thank you guys both for being here. tim, can you help me understand what was going on in that room last night? the -- what almost sounded like a laugh track at points for some of the most disingenuous, hateful, malicious commentary i've ever heard in a while? >> there are two things that were happening, one is the room was stacked with republicans, it was obviously a little -- republicans, i saw in the audience the former a guy know that republican fund-raiser, professional fund-raiser, he lived in new hampshire. trump acknowledge what it seems woody johnson, the new york jets owner in the crowd. who was there. a lot of trump people were stacked in the audience. that's part of it. i'm not sure, i think those really poor production choice. but i think, at a broader level, what we've learned here, the difference between the mccain video you showed at the top, and the trump era, is not that humans that republican base voters, but all, humans don't have da

former democratic new york congressman racks rose, and tim miller, a contributor to the bulwark, a formertions director for jeb bush. max, when you've got maria bartiromo giving you a, say what, you've got a problem. what is going on here? >> that was one of the craziest things i have ever seen. when you can't even tracked your informant, when your -- >> what he's in the spy business. >> when your best possible route is to somehow insinuate that your informant has been disappeared or something else, you know you really aren't on a strong footing. but let's take a step back and look at the larger picture here. the republican party during the course of the previous election ran, for the most part, particularly when they were actually electorally successful. they were warning on bread and butter continual issues. >> crime, immigration, inflation. >> exactly. then suddenly they actually have an opportunity to at least in the house show real legislation and they are incapable of it. because because they actually have no real solutions, they are just capable of fearmongering. so they go back an

nope, nope. >> stephanie ruhle, tim miller, thank you both very much. 11th hour. that is tonight's reidout. out front with chris hayes stts

like they are under siege from one side. >> these are complicated times, we will keep covering, tim miller an, i want to make you stick around because coming up we are talking about ron desantis and a new florida law that is already driving agricultural workers that we really need out of the state during a critical labor shortage. when the 11th hour continues. 1he1th hour continues ut] for fast sore throat relief, try vicks vapocool drops with two times more menthol per drop*, and the powerful rush of vicks vapors for fast-acting relief you can feel. vicks vapocool drops. fast relief you can feel. oh booking.com, ♪ i'm going to somewhere, anywhere. ♪ ♪ a beach house, a treehouse, ♪ ♪ honestly i don't care ♪ find the perfect vacation rental for you booking.com, booking. yeah. ♪ ♪ ♪♪ voltaren. the joy of movement. ♪♪ how to grow more vibrant flowers: step one: feed them with miracle-gro shake 'n feed. that's it. miracle-gro. all you need to know to grow. so it's decided, we'll park even deeper into parking spaces so people think they're open. surprise. [ laughs ] [ horn honks, muffled talkin

juanita tolliver and tim miller, thank you both very much.minal charges have been filed. when the 11th hour continues. he 11th hour continues ♪♪ voltaren. the joy of movement. ♪♪ this is going to be great. taking the shawl off. voltaren. the ok i did it.ent. is he looking at my hairline? is plaque psoriasis making you rethink your everyday choices? otezla is a pill, not a cream or injection that can help people with plaque psoriasis achieve clearer skin. and no routine blood tests required. don't use otezla if you're allergic to it. serious allergic reactions can happen. otezla may cause severe diarrhea, nausea, or vomiting. some people taking otezla had depression, suicidal thoughts, or weight loss. upper respiratory tract infection and headache may occur. doctors have been prescribing otezla for over 8 years. don't hesitate. ask your doctor about otezla today. i bought the team! kevin...? i put it on my chase freedom unlimited card. and i'm gonna cashback on a few other things too. starting with the sound system... [autotune] that's caaaaaa

tim miller is joining our conversation. e from this story cnn just broke about federal prosecutors having their hot little hands on an audio recording of a summer 2021 meeting with trump allegedly possibly waving around a classified document, at least talking about it, but importantly making clear that he know that he is doesn't have the authority to share it because he doesn't have declassification powers over it. it is all unsurprisingly part of a grudge match maybe happening just in his imagination with chairman of the joint chiefs mark milley. i want to put more data points in the record to miller and then i'll open the floor about the time line. this allegedly takes place in the summer. this is from cnn. meeting took place well before trump's team shipped 15 boxes of classified documents back to the national archives in january 2022. after months of back and forth between trump's team and the records agency. the justice department later obtained additional documents with classified markings from trump seizing more than

. >>> joining us is kimberly atkins stohr, tim miller and sam stein. tim, i want to start with you.ritical as the first real test of desantis' retail politics, the name of the game in early voting states like iowa and new hampshire. it's those relationships, that connection that you as a candidate can make. is he up to that? how critical is this visit? >> iowa is extremely critical. i don't know how critical one visit it. it has extra import because of the weak campaign launch desantis had. he doesn't seem like that great of a retail politician. we have seen not great retail politicians do well in republican primaries if they can have a message that is resonating with the primary voters. that's his big issue. i look at that fox clip. the electability message, we tried that in 2016. that's not enough for republican primary voters. you have to make the case you are electable and you are somebody that can win on issues they care about. that's where desantis would seem to have an opportunity. hasn't done a great job of making that case. there's a poll out that showed that over 50% of re

tim miller's a former rnc spokesman -- current writer large for the bulwark. -- former democratic congresswomant with you. let me say something that you say in the peaks, the point they are making, is by no means substantive at all. it's purely at this level of, where you're trying to fit in the primary. one of the points you make, elizabeth warren was had this campaign that was electric to a certain portion of the democratic base. that proved not to be big enough to win the primary. you think desantis has the same problem, and before we get to that, oh my god, can you believe what happened? >> well, i'm just thrilled, i don't if you remember, i was part of the john huntsman presidential campaign announcement, we misspelled our candidates own name on the credentials, -- we sputtering, to me so shameful and embarrassing. we crushed it. so, thank you to the run desantis team for making our little small gaffe there look very manageable by comparison. that was just an epic disaster. i'm like you, chris, i'm a twitter addict. it took about to get to how to get in. the first two or three spaces this

fernando, tim miller, that's time to read out. turn out tonight tonight for stephanie ruhle's exclusive interview with president biden. all in with chris hayes starts now. >> tonight on all. in >> only supreme court justices refused to allow their conduct to be investigated or reviewed. it's a cover-up in plain view. >> more secret money from conservative donors. this time directed to the wife of a supreme court justice. tonight, senator sheldon whitehouse on the ongoing cover-up in plain view, and what democrats will do about it. then, the former presidents sworn testimony in his civil rape trial is released to the public. >> when you were a star they let you do. it >> historically that's true with stars. >> and breaking news from fulton county. >> this is not a game at all. >> eight fake electors have cut a deal with prosecutors. what it means for the criminal investigation of trump world in georgia. when all in starts, right now. good evening from new york. i'm chris hayes. we begin tonight with a question. just how much money

msnbc legal analyst joyce vance and writer at large for the bulwark and msnbc political analyst, tim millereat to have you here, all of you, vaughn, what were the key takeaways from trump last night? >> reporter: ana, there was a lot that was covered. number one, he suggested that republicans on capitol hill should be ready to take the country into default, if democrats do not negotiate massive cuts. he was pressed by kaitlan collins whether he believed russia or ukraine should win this war. he refused to answer. this is somebody who did not apologize when asked if he had any regrets about what happened to mike pence on january 6th. this is somebody who when he was asked what the details of a federal abortion ban that he would sign into law would be, he refused to give specifics but did not deny that he would sign a federal ban of some sort. i want to let you hear, though, part of when he was talking about the e. jean carroll liebt verdict here, and the reason we want to play part of this bite is also because of the audience's reaction. this is a room full of republicans that laughed as don

. >> stephanie ruhle, tim miller, thank you both very much. be sure to join stuff tonight on herschel, the 11th hour. that is tonight's reidout. out front with chris hayes starts right now. out front with chris hay>> toni. >> not one republican should vote for this deal do not vote. >> for this bill. >> the best deal is no deal. >> republicans floundering on the debt ceiling deal, as biden plays it cool. >> why doesn't biden say what a good deal it is? why would biden be saying what a good deal it is before -- think that's going to help me get it passed? no. >> tonight, how calling the bluff of the hostage takers was the key to saving the country from economic catastrophe. >> democrats are committed to making sure that we do our part and avoiding default. >> democratic leader, hakeem jeffries, will join me live tonight. then, >> have all members voted? >> the radical republican attorney general of texas, impeached by his own party. plus, as the special counsel closes in, new worries about a snitch in team trump. and he's out of jail, unrepenta

joining our coverage, former congresswoman donna edwards and tim miller, writer at large for "the bulwarkh msnbc contributors. tim, you did a fantastic interview with the congressman. let me play some of this. >> you come to the nfl locker room and you go at lunchtime, you'll see the countriest boy sitting next to the guy from the middle of the city who are like best friends and who are, you know, going to -- who are working hard together and feel like they're brothers. and so i -- i've seen these divides be bridged. and -- you have to be inclusive, and you have to give folks some buy-in. i have said in particular these are pro-democracy folks who -- i think the biggest divide in their politics right now isn't so much when democrats and republicans, it's between folks who believe in our democracy and those who don't. >> i mean, tim, this is like -- it is one of the most important messages, and he's one of the best messengers on this front. tell me your reaction to his announcement. >> yeah, i was hoping he was going to run. we interviewed him on the podcast about a month ago, and i though

i mean, i think this is, you know, i think if i have sort of a -- i think tim miller called me a dogis trauma, when there is a crime, the healing doesn't start until the accountability piece. so i feel like part of it isn't justice delayed. it's the healing from the trauma that has been delayed. >> that's it. it's not over yet. how do you move on and it hasn't been rectified? there is no closure. where is the closure? moving on? no, that's not -- no, you don't move on from something. you have closure. and then you -- you know, i don't like the term moving on. you learn how to live and exist with that trauma existing in your life and you learn how to work with -- live your life with that trauma still as an existence. so, no, you don't get over it. you learn how to live your life with it there. >> fred gatlinberg -- i know you were with fred last night. we talked about how some grief is so enormous there is no process you get over it. you learn to live with it. i don't want anything i do here to retraumatize you. can i play your comments from american university? >> that's fine. >> all

miller is here with that story. >> opening arguments are under way in the trial of tim bliefnick. his estranged wife in february and he was arrested in march and has pleaded not guilty. a family feud contestant who joked on national tv that getting married was a mistake now on trial accused of killing his estranged wife. >> what's the biggest mistake you made at your weding? >> honey, i love you, but said i do. [ laughter ] not my mistake! not my mistake. i love my wife. >> reporter: authorities say in february of this year, tim bliefnick killed his wife becky. >> searches. how to open a door with a crow bar. how to make a home made pistol silencer. >> reporter: tuesday, he was in court for opening arguments in his case. >> the last letter to becky was, in fear, in pain, in peril. >> reporter: becky's father taking the stand tuesday telling jurors how he discovered her body. >> i ran up the stairs and then she supposedly was sick. i wented to the bedroom to see if she was laying down. didn't see anything in her bedroom. went into the attached bathroom, and that's when i found her