(softl: ye ah ♪ sol: tnk you vy much.bobbiethank yo won: yore very lc ome.e. bbie: goodby (sniffs) sol:t's okaybobo ve me a hug. obbie yi ng) (raifalling) ♪ ♪ sol: t day fre died, i was ab to let m go d i let father go. and m not hoing the dness ornger at i t nk i ow i hel with mfather'sea th. the su muslim et rumisays it ke this:"goodbs are ly "for tho who lovwith the ey "bause forhose whoove th theireart and oul, there iso such tng aseparatio n. i s 44 whei starte maki thifor you. anfor me i'46 n ow i'll be when yowatch it maybe yoll see iagain when i'mong go . maybe y're sharing withour chilen right ow. my prayer, my pe for y is ts, my so my daug er. may you ve a lifof pur se and in service to othe rs. y you fit for po peopleand lile peo e. mayou breathe cycl thatold you ba ck. may u be bra enough know and holdour familyyour wle fam il ♪ ♪ ani love y all, de ly. so i loveou all, ep ly. lliam: vy deep . so very de ly. del toro: follow the conversation r tonighs amera reframed using #mytwoth ers. i justant to just wanto thankou gu for thiweek en- i had a bl

call by phone or order on our website leomax. .ru studios of the tnk program, siblings who grew up iner met with a resident of the moscow region who may also be their mother's daughter, the foster mother of yulia doronina was always afraid that in the village of yagunino her daughter would learn the truth about her birth from strangers. and when is it happened to a woman, she had to tell how she took the girl from the baby house in zvenigorod and then hid her from her biological mother with her neighbors. i learned from my mother that the family was large and not particularly prosperous, that there were many children. how much money do not know? and the fact that then i was allegedly looking for, my dear, ideological mother, and with her there was still a small child, a boy since then , yulia has been haunted by thoughts about her biological family, yakovenko who are her parents, where are her brothers and sisters and for what reason was she seized from the family, what do you want? find out what happened, something happened , the opportunity to find blood relatives tatyana kulishenko

[crowd murmu] now, i tnk i canpeak r the whe town wn i say that o thought and r prayer are th you bh.e're alremindedf thimportan of fami anthe valuof commuty, t... it never bn morelear tme than it isight now and i st want thank each andvery onef you for l your wds ofompassioand suppt. now, iany of y have any infoation that might assist us in finding laura, please, just come forward. hattering] i'm not hungry. here you g i am. [wom] your b doing all righ eh? stuffing hisace li a pig! your boall righ 'causeine isn' mi's dead. my boy'sead! [gasps] porcelaishatters -[exaims] ma [motr speaksoreign lguage] [jefey's motr sobs] no, nono more,lease. [m speaks reign lauage] [jefey's motr weeps] your mother'staying here to help ck up thhall. nobody hped mrs.u. th just wahed. [woman] anks, sun. i' see youomorrow. -y. i know -[ma she's gonna ball righ les get ho. ev the pole saw what hapned and ss findl can st walk ay? yes, inow. st keep down. mrs.u didn hurt anne. know. les talk aut this when wget home go night, ter. sley. come on,harlie what do u think ppened truthfully-- [clears throat] fore to

no wder he tnks can cavt aroundown enever hfeels li it!gdancing th the gis at h age. that is mpletelyrrelevan he cld havdied, sley! weon't know who'out ther agree. b screang at him n't gonnreinforcthe poin what's your solution? do nothing? just disappear in there anwrite a oody story about it? s buckti the sappeari man! yoknow, some of can't jt shut the doornd avoidiving re! oh, sus christ! e you twever nna list to me? i am fedp! fed u now, iove you, chles buckn, and i amlad you' alive but tomoow, u're gon wish yoweren't! w, get o of my sht! [svel scrang] no dig. what? wh becausi said s w deep? i'll tl you en to st. ch-chop! i di't say y could sp. at is this en fo i dot undersnd whi'm dointhis. well, don't unrstand y at a, charlibucktin. one minuteou're avoidinge ke i'mongious, the nextou're teing peop we'rsneakingut atight togher becae we're romantally atthed. you ow, it'solite to ask airl firs can expln. um, no. excuse m this not on. [eliza] just cam to g somethi back. well, itan wait. charlis workg very hd athe momen let m finishp, than

[crowd murmu] now, i tnk i canpeak r the whe town wn i say that ourhoughts and ouprayers are wi you bote're alremindedf thimportan of fami anthe valuof commuty, t... it never bn morelear tme than it isight now and i st want thank each andvery onef you for l your wds ofompassioand suppt. now, iany of y have any infoation that might assist us in finding laura, please, just come forward. hattering] i'm not hungry. here you g i am. [wan] youroy doing all rit, eh? stuffing hisace li a pig your boall righ 'causeine isn' mi's dead. my boy'sead! [gasps] porcelaishatters -[exaims] ma [motr speaksoreign lguage] [jefey's motr sobs] no, nono more,lease. [m speaks reign lauage] [jefey's motr weeps] your mother'staying here to help ck up thhall. nobody hped mrs.u. th just wahed. [woman] anks, sun. i' see youomorrow. -y. i know -[ma she's gonna ball righ les get ho. ev the pole saw what hapned and ss findl can st walk ay? yes, inow. st keep down. mrs.u didn hurt anne. know. les talk aut this when wget home go night, ter. sley. come on,harlie what do u think ppened truthfully-- [clears throat] before t

evan uh, no, i tnk my frnd isonna helme. t she's lming sothin won: ah, ay, okay.ughs): but mae y. t she's lming sothin isdo you b a ticke for e trai won: yes. evans: he? woman: yes, ithe . n: doou have your evans: yeah, do. achine cnks) man: thas it. evan oh, oka great, thank. woman:o alexanrplatz is that y. - ay, than. ootsteps echng) d singlen your0s, th blind ce, and automatically think that that is, um, a potential burd, or that ey're going to have to be, um, a cataker. it not sexy. to ne. thosere thing i thk abou from ts t to coueract the kind o attides and ejudic. evans: hi-- rody. arosa: nice to et you federov:kay- -huh. like federo i need scratah? slightlyour skinyeah? - oh, ok. ferov: notoo much, not to. - don'mess witthe, e beauty. ferov:(laus):much, not to. st kiddi. ferov: ay. - ybe you' taking the yes. u felt i okay. anaros so wre goingo measure thtiny little eltr currents youeyes genate. fedoro lighon, off-good.20 minut . won (on fi): hetesexualit ishe opiatof the mses! ♪ ♪ (groing) evs: that s an intse lastreatment woma really? - i'm ki of excid foi

now 's no appening tnk you f today's sunse. den, you want andian me? yes. yr names littleox. theisplacemt reallyreally made change iour culte. now weind of le-- ha ha !--like ere are indns, ok? dup: the on way these cotal counities ll suvive io the ter 21st centu is to ptect ourlves fm the gu of meco. i realize 300 yea, this wl probablbe all on water. i mea the seaill takes all overwhat i'm tryg to do th th levee stem, wt i' tryg to do, is buourselve two o3 generaons. it's just about impossible t clude em into a levee sysm. it wod cost pbably $300 million, and it would be nearly imposble because the salt nditionsre so ba u know, build a fod-proteion prect, you ve to he more befits an cost. onehing th's no facted in thcost, th only look at t cost ofhe homes the co of the sinessesthe inastructu, but, y know, i don't know howou put price ont, but ty do notonsider the co of a whe cultur filmdvance ccks] om-tom aying] cordelle: displacent kepsappeningnd we just fuher sepate our communy, it'llust get st. [men chting] man: turto the lt. coardelle:e learneabout a natnal disaer resiln

billioofns dlaolrs in da ma tgeo his reactitoon t he unans imouveicrdt came swift ly on twitter, n.s.a.e.ha tnk negoodsshe t wisdom of the ople has prleevaid. >>> the reconggaonti of a shjewi nasygogue in san anfrcisco still dgon ee teafr a waman lk iedn and began ngfiri a gun. the fbi put t outhe es images of spa suecant d they ar e ilstl secharing for him toghnit. >> reporteher: t cgronegation here at s theynogague off baoatr seet isll sti skehan afr tethey say a caman ment io theinar sygoe guon wednesday ght and fireved serarol unds ofwh tathey believe beto blank cadgrtries. no one was injured but powe skewi th orjuni bbrai who said he believes this s waa rgtaeted ckatta. >> the on rlyeason to send ts that arenk blas into a ssian synagoclgue asans d shitoot aupnd then say sothmeing about we sastw ju by coincide nce. >>porert: erthe man hsayse is still ngtryi twro ap his head around why a man walknted io a sygoe guand fired bl anks around zedonsf oelderly corentgas. maybe itot's n a crime if nobody irts hu but maybe hife ge t cuhe didn't alactuly kill anneyo? i'm sunot re r>>eporter: the atta

music] - 's harto expla whatttaché ibecause wh i tell eryone iame om the sw choir rld, they immiately tnk anthat is thing what ixpernc ed.what ient throh was ve specl becaus you k w, we we one ofhe numbe one ow choirin the w ld. ♪ ahh hh [davidwe've be to 79 coetitionssince ve been re wi attachénd we ha been ned grandhamp io 70 of hem. - we'rexpected to behe be and to lookhe b est. - in any given wee we're putting hours a eek. i mean, 's serio stu . - exceence is e only o ion. - [all] wherever ile ads- [did] i'm nna enjoy thri de. - [a] i'm goa enjothe ri . - every year, we, you know do some competitions in the south but we pick one venue somewhere in the nat ion for the big competition of the year. thisear, is at loslamitoshigh schl in calor ni our sort of rival, i guess you could say, fothe last decade has beenhis sc ol namejohn burughs, whs fr burbankcalifornia and of crse, thell be there asill twinurg, o o, and thenountion, ill ois. will geon b us becae they d't fly uthwest to jacks anymore. that hts so the's t a planbig en gh to g us on swe haveto bus to w orle s ov threeours ay and

>> ihi tnk there does.hen t therump admtrinisatnio shut this ial tke pdi pompeo about it.ca rrdie out in the state of tes xaby the csehine govenernmt was horrifying. right now there is a ,text a litical isproner. a hgeosta in incha. be trehe ten years. isth past we iek irontduced a relusotion on the floor othf e tesena anglo with john cornyn te leeas him. gfwronul ilyn prison, ten years. tespenns hedim to death on chargestl liteo tno kw evidence and asked aynton bnklien to raise he be beleased. ch iina,fhe ty want to demonstratey' there notad b actors and can aspire to being a great natn iotheyel rease him be cae usgreatow person d't hold litical prisons.er >>ai rsed to si n sxi jinping. >> yeou'r onhe t repubcalin co mmteite and a dad. you know how hard toee kp kids off kttiok. dolownaded 200 mliilon ngtimis. uyo think it's onespiage. are weas pt theoi pnt of a ban? so eedmbdedou y can't get rid of ?it >> look, tkikto is incredibly erconcni.ng you're rhtig with our kids, if yo huave teerenags, if youav he

could not refuse and he was forced to give his seven days, eh, now it's all the same and this is the tnk company, which was private, it also came under the control of state-owned state-owned companies, we are a state-owned gas company even those headed by putin's friends and his former associates, pure economists, also talk about such a thing as the dutch disease, that is, when some e sector of mineral extraction develops. and all the others sectors of the economy are not developing, because why develop something else? i don’t know processing in the agricultural sector or some industry when there is enough money from oil and gas, something similar. it did not develop on them , it now occupies a very small small share in the structure of gdp, while the main one , after all, is the extractive industry, it is not only naftogaz, it is also coal, diamonds vs. which will also happen stations that they are not fully introduced, in fact , all these high-tech areas in russia did not develop queues, there was an attempt to create there the very word, it was there again, everything was thanks to co

tnk i know what he meant now. - how can it be nothing but trouble? - we risked everything to get it from the girls. how long before the girls attack us to get it back? - yeah, forget about the girls. what about when the c.i.a. or the russians know we have this? they'll come after it for sure. - maybe we should take it to some place safer. - and then what? hide forever from the government, from the terrorists who want to use it for evil? maybe nobody is meant to have this kind of power. - you mean destroy it? - are you guys nuts? after everything we've gone through? - we got it away from the girls. that's what matters. but now the right thing to do isn't using it ourselves. then we're no better than they are. - think of the power. - it's too much power for anybody. stan's right. it has to be destroyed. - are we sure about this? we'll never know the future. - nobody will. that's the way its supposed to be. hit it, kenny. [explosion] - damn, ken. - here, here you see? it's going to be all right. hello, s-s-son. - hi, dad. - he was supposed to stay dead.

hii tnk kop-p really hsitd kin of a vacuum that was some pop urcultal trend left behind.l k cneoncticuten vti.on soow h is the con?cert everreywhe you look you see fans faithfully re-crngeati their id's are the ads ty hewould be ab leo t receit every >> 1%.00 th know it better than i .do ♪ >>epteorr: kevin wooa is k-pop star, a capolit idol, who spent ynineea irsn uks.is >>om setimes it gets dangerous at k-popce conrts because there e so pasonsiate. i have seen aot l of casesre whe th heyave toet g escorted o ut either to the ergmeency or, you kn, keta a eabrth. er >> repr:orte a slluccessful basnd have fans. but in k-pop the fans/idol retilaonship is more recipr.ocal >> fans are extremely datediced and theyxp eect aot l inet rurn from idols. >> reporr:te according to the members of n-i-i, a kop-p idol ner declines a fan inteioractn. tishereve er a tyoime u d'ton want a sele?fi liouke y're tinryg to shop or see a movie? >> no. selfies are a gopood pounrtity usfor tcoo mmunicate wi othur fans. ♪ >>ep rorter: some attendees are iatheru cidesion for kouts and competitn iosho

kagan: y tnk that there are circumstce thiss important to me. somef ur arguments seem extremely widely, most of them. there are circumstances in which the population that is turning 7% of the states population could -- 27% of the states population cldssentially be foreclosed anywhere. mr. lacour: there is always going toeha local appraisal toee what was going on there. if we had these guidelines and we passed a map that took us from one down to zero, where we taed a course of districts one through six and not district seven, that would be ey case. justice.: it all depends. it a depends? mr. lacour: it all depends on icection we are trying to get at. justice. kagan: it is trying to ensure equal political opportunities. let me use that as a segue to my last question. this is an important statute. it is one of the great achievenof the american democracy to aie equal political opportunities regardless o race, ensure that african-americans could have as cholitical power as white americans could. that is a pretty big deal. it would strengthen the stat

let me tell you why tnk that matters. much like what justice kagan was suggesting,e ve to figure whether you are claiming that we edo change jingles in some fundamental way, or whether you are saying that these points ar't satisfying jingles in the way that we normally understand. i thought you were saying, jingles that one needs to be retooled to require some showing of a comparison wh a race neutral lined algorithm. my question was, he wouldea the burden of showi tt there is a problem that we are doing it n, at the way that jingles is working. at a race lined algorithm actually produces a better result. but are implementing what congress intending -- better implementing what congress intending or are required by the constitution. l of these are heavyurns in the constitution. are you asking us to recoid what is happening with jingles ruire that challengers compare their original map at step one with a race lined algorithm? >> the algorithms e t essential. they are eliminating this case. >> what do they eliminate? >> they

throughout the year sounded different maxims, but they always mutually excluded each other also en tnk noted the regularity of the success of the sobolenko arena at the australian open due to which, for sure, there will be an even greater influx of children in the tennis section of minsk and the whole country year. however, the national team can not take part in the davis cup and the billie jean king cup. in mid-february, a meeting of the sports arbitration court will take place, which will consider the appeal of the belarusian tennis association. i would go to him related to the statements. uh, well, carelessly, i would have waited for some action, because since a has now been announced, we will allow athletes who will express their opinion, in my opinion. this provocation is not so affected by the international ban the level of the rising generation, which deliberately compete with our leaders will not fall. and more about the events of the day in our nightly broadcast. so see you. the editors' club is the main brand of belarus for all these 30 years - this is the world economy. safe

>> i do and ihi tnk having that sivion isa, a bigar pt of why thile chi pppeers have managed tont maiairselves,st we ilfel el rentleva andvi brt.an >> s btillased in gerreat los anleges, it's the cyit theyiv le inhe, t city of angels. ey're not just from the area, but of it. kieds is iaoc lalix fture on his morctoycle. fl,ea atak ler games and in his oretr deri. >>hi ts isou yr town. >> yeah. look, i'm an. l.a boy all my life and i know this town iensid out, every little cckra in every desiwalk. t>>heir story bsegin on the pament of hoywllood. no tlmpa-linedie movta sr hollywoo bduthe t seedy one from e th'70s.fl ea spentar ely yrsea in new york befor heeangdi wt eswith mohis m.an thyondi kies a trspanlant from chigan living with this ther. neither cricatilly had brot.hers longef bore they were bandtemas edkiis and flea weer best mates fairfax ghhi. >>t whawas the fenridship born of? >> bot chame fmro broken homes, atypical mehos, non-convention's mehos andea rlly wteand to get in trouble. how much trouble cane w get in wiou gtoing to jail. >> us jtit ltle street urchin peytt tevhiing r

neuriva: tnk bigger. man: i responded to the call. woman: i didn't know if he was guilty or not.: i couldn't ignore public opinion. woman 2: i got caught up in the emotion of the trial. man 3: i could have testified, but i got scared. man 4: i'm expected to be tough on crime. woman 3: i know my son was innocent. woman 4: i will never forget his final words: "forgive them." ( ♪ ) ♪ we all have a purpose in life - a “why.” maybe it's perfecting that special place that you want to keep in the family... ...or passing down the family business... ...or giving back to the places that inspire you. no matter your purpose, at pnc private bank, we will work with you every step of the way to help you achieve it. so let us focus on the how. just tell us - what's your why? ♪ this week is your chance to try any - subway footlong for free. like the subway series menu. just buy any footlong in the app, and get one free. free monsters, free bosses, any footlong for free! this guy loves a great offer. so let's see some hustle! bye, bye cough. later chest congestion. hello 12 hours of relief. 12 hou

justice kavanaugh, tnk this is a statutory interpretation case.this court has emphasized the stare decisis considerio, they have the greatest force here. it is a voting rights actno an area that the courts decisions have flown under the radar or escape notice. congress has not hesitated to step in and alter the statute when it has been dissatised with this courts interpretation. that was the whole point of the 1982 amendment. i think that is the principal today and far from disrupting or disturbing the jingles framework in anyaycongress has repeatedly left secon two untouched while itasemanded other aspects of the statute. in the 2006 amendments, police report specifically noted that congress did not intend any departure fromingles or its progeny. i think the stare decisis considerations weigh heavily in tance here. >> thank you. >> justice barrett? justice jackson? >> thank you counsel. robo? >> you have five points, a try to get through alofhem. justice kavanaugh to your point, it is not a departure from jingles to clarify, this court didn't dep

>> trevor: i truhily tnk it is. i inthk in lifoue, y're on the rir. ingog to be moments erwhe there are dsrapi ttha shakeou y up. yon'u dot owkn what your life ll be like. atwh you can control is the ople you're in the boat with d anso i'm gladho i cseho tse peoporle f mliy fe, fort tha boat r fide,orha tt journey. it wason wdeulrf. >> senteph: owkning that one tofhem would tr dy toro mwne to get out heof t reriv. >> trevor: hdne di'try t to drmeown . he triedo tsave himself. anind the process, he pulled me do. >>ph steenwa: sn't trying owdrn you. merely dt idn'ca wrehether you lived. >> trvor: ifmy le heflasd before mesy ey. you know wnohat one t yellsou when your le ifflashes befo uryo eyes is yosou al remember ra tndomhis.ng everyone thiitnks 'soi gng to be like oh, wyohen uer we born. i s keli oh, that's e wheri left that controller. it's like, ranthdom in lgsike thomat ce toin your head. s>>teenph: the erit is. 'sthat ectxaly right. u'yore back on toahe rd with the comeoudy tr. >> trevor: iin am de.ed te>> sph: enhow is that? yogetot go and live

obstetrician premier women don't understand that's what medicine is. today at 20:00 on ntv this is a tnke trans-baikal territory met to find out if they are children of the same mother cuckoo, she does not deny that she herself asked her daughter to abandon the child in the studio galina stepanov whom did they meet today sister? anastasia succeeds. she will show, perhaps, and resemble something, but, in my opinion, she does not resemble svetka. she is a little bit on the floor to dump. here your daughter svetlana refused her daughter katya, i don’t know, i didn’t hear her name, and firstly, i found out that she refused, and then her friend told me that svetka gave birth to a girl in the hospital and refused. just a second. isn't it by your advice. didn't you yourself ask, because and where did i find them? here they are, they grew before my eyes and one more. we have three on my neck and she gave birth again in speed. i have them where one of my one worked, that is, i left three children with you, of course, so that she is pregnant, and my friend said nothing to me, the answer went to gi

wait for me on friday at 17:50 again ntv this is a tnk program, a resident of tatarstan suspects thateone else's sick daughter on her, and they gave her healthy one, another family. valentina asanova has four children and only one daughter, marina's twin sister , was born with a serious congenital disease. the woman's family lives in the village of the state farm named after vorovsky of the republic of tatarstan in this house. this is our large living room. we spend more time here. well, as we have a small tv wall , the old bridge, well, this year the ceiling was pulled so quietly, we live in cities , people live a daughter, irina, whom valentina considers a substitute, helps her parents to do all. what i thought, she is happy to bustle with her mother in the kitchen. she can boil the kettle, she can peel the potatoes. here, if we are valued, ours, but let me cook . it's on potatoes. there she will peel the potatoes, she is already peeling. yep, they're cooking. i also wash rice in the winter with my father , armed with a shovel. irina clears the yard in front of the house from meter

and she cheated on this tnk program to her roommate with her ex, and he took revenge on her with here rejected him, please, the second envelope in the second envelope answer to the question from konstantin li kononova 9 months ago anzhela panfilova gave birth to a daughter konstantin elena but she was not at home. but konstantin was not alone at home, he retired behind a closed door with angela , elena's niece, where allegedly. they just kissed what? neighbor they categorically do not believe konstantin i can announce your dna test result with my daughter angela yes angela you will allow me to do this, yes. in this case, i open the second envelope. on the one hand, the alleged father konstantin kononov, on the other hand, his alleged daughter eva panfilova, the likelihood that your elena lover did not just kiss your niece, but also became the father of her daughter , make up 99.9% yes, everything is acute that i 'm here, but let's sleep, they said that dnkty, you won't be able to open it. and what now, but mind you will not pay. i'll plant you. that's all nothing but what were you hi

is operating to actually advantage minorities in a way that is harmful to anyone else in the syst >> tnk that attributes to the careful queue that unc has taken to this court's decision. themselves in a problem about considering too much or too little. >> there are other consideratiothe point. everyone can get a boost for all sorts of reasons, minorities don'tomatically get a boost under this system so it's hard to know whether anyone is being antaged from the mere fact that a minority could get a boost in this environment, ght? >> that's evidence also bears out, the eviden sws that hundreds of white students with lower combined gpas and sat or were admitted ahead of higher performing black students. latin studtsho went to unc, i think that there is a hallmark t type of individualized consideration that this court wanted. >> thank you, counsel. >> mr. chi jtice and may it please the court, for decades this court has rightly recognized that student body dirsity is a compelling interest that can justify limited consideration of race in the university admissions. that holding recognizes tha

this is a tnk program right now we will find out if an exemplary family man has an illegitimate daughter seven-year-old daughter, adelina, from her former mistress, ekaterina balashoveva, ekaterina recalls that she was in love with the alexandrovnas without memory. he didn't even look at other men. and when i found out what to expect father alexander immediately understood the child. but he did not believe the devotion of his chosen one, since even his friend admitted that he had an affair with her, despite this, alexander suggested that catherine take a dna test when the girl was just born. but the beloved did not come at a definite time and place, and later married another alexander you are ready to find out the result of your dna test with ekaterina's daughter ekaterina i can announce the result of a genetic examination between adeline and alexander attention, i am hiding the envelope. supposed father alexander rozin, the alleged daughter of a man seven -year-old adelina smirnova, the probability that it is you alexander who is the father of adeline, which means that all these years y

s they just think it's a bunch of they conservatives complaining and they think they ca tnk theyk and chew gum ae t the same timen look, president trump going weere wednesday is a smart move . he's going to draw a lot of s attention to the issues and hemh should the issue that i keep bag balancing, though, is a lot ofst the tests that are being dons t there locally by locale officials are coming back ansayg saying that the soil is fine, the air is fine, and people prot don't want to leave it.e that's the problem. stration has created by waiting s the bush administration's created by waiting so late. and i don't wantla to overstattt the fears or overstate the scare because we don't knows and i don't want people to rushn out and think, oh, my god, i everything is terrible. especially if local tests arenga coming back saying that. so people do neet. d to approacpeople nh. this with an open mind. but but the administration blew itat acting like thund to it so late and by acting like they didn't care, larry. >>eyt >> if they do arrive, caney they make up for this gap? mak >>e well, you tel

. >> i tnk weould do more than assume it. stay with mand assume that we have. if we have, do we lose? mr. lacour: i think therere going to be some cases where section two violation lines up th the equal protection law violatn. if theres ce in a line, you have tha aemedy to take the race out of the lines. i do not think there is a compelngnterest here. based on the showing they made, they shod broad-based discrimination. th do not show anything wrong with our maps. it cannot mean that that is identifying discrimination that can jti using race to change ou map. u can go through the entire 300 plus pages and really -- our map altogether thaits not produced the second district. >> thank you. >> i am solad for justice barrett's clifford tatian. i had the same thought -- arication. i had the same thought about what you were . i am glad you are clarifying that your core point that the baselinetest haso ve a the first step has to beace neutral. when i'm confused about in light of that argument is why, given our normal assessment of the gin our normal assessments of the

three injury on that basis, it would iumbent on them to explain their ho unexplained position of why th tnk the secretary could do this, under thhier education act. my friend has adjusted that that's what ts ogram was actually designetoo. but this is a pdec related program. it's specifal focuses on the national emergency circumstances that have had profound financial effects on student loan boows. and the secretary acted to try to mitigate those financial harms from covid. that's what the hero a was made for. it's a perfect fit for this kind of cirmsnce and explains why the secretary chose to providth relief to those who were harmed by covid. just as th forbearance policy was put into place, at the start of the pandemic, similarly on its covid coer. and then finally, i know that we've had hourtoy on the legal issues in this case, but i do want to step back for a moment and focus on the stakes of this case for the nsf millions of student loan borrowers in this country who have had devastating financial impacts, based onhi unprecedented pandic. over the past three yes, they've benefited fr t

>> of course, we tnk congress didaddress this expressly here and directed that. in the context of a national emergency, that is the limitation of the heroes act. seetary candid folk that whenever he wants, there has to be thapredicate war or liry operation or national emergency in that context, in line with congress's limitations on who can count as unaffected information by that inine with the purposes that relief has to serve. congress has said that you can waver modify any provision order to get relief to borrowers. justice alito, i would pnto the forbearance policythat's been in place for the prior the years, put it into place at the beginning of the pandemic by then secreta devos. it has been an econicly significantprogram, currently costing the federal government more per year than this loan rgeness plan would cost the government annually. but i would argue that that is a right in the heartland of the heroes act aimed to do. it's critical relief that was puedt the beginning of this devastating pandemic to ensure that we didn't see spikes in delinquency and

i am trying tnk about whether it was a set-aside program, that there was actually 16 seats in the cls 100 that were being set aside for underrepresented minorities and therefore the concerns about peus in this and bng problematic. but when you have a situatio like this in which you are talking about a holistic review, other peop a getting classes no one is automatically getting a plus in the system. i wonder if the urge to end it d is to include race alongside 40 other characteristics. i wonder if it implicates the same kind of concern about the use of race. >> yes, justice chaska. -- jackson. i think the unc record illustrates this point. not usinra when it's not necessary to achieverue student body diversity. maybe that means given t limited way that race functions in our society is taking longer for our society to get to the int where everyone agrees, i don't think that the basis to condemn the case now. >> thank you. points here.g to make four first with respect to the military, the united states brief on that is long on assertions. but not actually long on any evidence in that fa

course erare not quotas for a ecic numerical thresholds that need to be rehe that is not the right way tnkabout the diversity interest in this contex n, i do not want to suggest the moaphics are whol ielevant here, the court has also said in grutter and reiterated in fish or the numbers can main relevant for purposes of trying to measure whethethe is truly meaningfulpptunity, for example, to have crossedacl interactions. >> y don't have a number, i undeta why it's difficult, i understand the problems, i get all that, if you don't have something asable, it is gonna be very hard for ts court to for called upon ten years fromowr 20 years from now, it's gonna be, this is a bit of a replay of the greater argument, if we come back to it, okay, are we there yet? what do we look at? you're seeing meaningful opportunity i don't know exact wt thatmeans, i don't know how the schools will know when they have to, when they, when the raceeual trinity of could get them close enough, or it has to meet some threshold. i don't know what meaningful means. i noted means in terms ofhat you're describing. i don