us department of justice new hunter biden. the department is studying the connections of the bankrupt head of ftx with the ukrainian mintsif, which, covering up its tracks, cleans its website and social networks valentin bogdanov about what they did not have time to delete. the collapse of the ftx exchange in the us already compared with the fall of such titans as enron and lemon brothers but it seems that the young billionaire managed to surpass all the schemers who tried before him . even stadiums have operated on a global scale firm shutdowns put at risk billions of dollars of investments from investors' clients in january the investment was valued at $32 billion and now investors are at risk of losing it all hard to believe, but inside, bangman freed's way of doing business looked like a parody of business. it seems that this only happens in a bad movie at a crypto exchange, in fact there was no internal financial control really, there was not even an accounting department for the transaction, the management claimed by send

small box, sometimes filled with insects, these methods were approved in july 2002 by the us department of justice under the administration of george w. bush mitchell admitted that he tried to stop several interrogations that came out of - under control. however, he could not stop in case of misconduct on the part of a high-ranking military man, quite in the spirit and democracy over the years of active work, up to a thousand prisoners passed through the prison, everyone knew that most sit for political reasons. well, this is america, so legal entities were formalized as enemy compactants. it allowed to put this democracy to keep the people there. indefinitely , the american punitive machine in the form of a guantana, it has simply become a kind of such a human meat grinder. i'm not afraid to say even such an animal farm, where the role of animals is played by judges and you have to look humiliated, tortured and sometimes killed for nothing. here is a typical story of one of the guntan prisoners. i was kept there for a year from 2002 to 2003 before my eyes, the american military beat two people to

the us department of justice said he was suspected of evasion of sanctions, in addition to the governor'sme charges were brought against four other citizens of the country. the founder of the forex club of one of the leading operators in the currency trading market, vyacheslav taran, died in a plane crash in monaco, according to local media, according to their data, the tragedy occurred on friday, the businessman was a passenger in a helicopter that crashed . , because this view is now interrupted by advertising, and then the news economy. we have different noses and we endure a runny nose in different ways for different requests different rhinostop rhinostop helps fight a runny nose at an affordable price, and rhinostop double help helps to gently restore the mucosa for everyone our rhinostop online and pay for purchases with one touch. enjoy, bewitching design, pay and win up to 5 million sberbank bonuses to pay by phone. 999 paid. make a payment using a qr code. scan qr-code with the camera of your phone from the terminal to get the opportunity to win up to 5 million bonuses from sberb

trump to be transferred to congress, we recall last year, under pressure from democrats, the us department of justiceconclusion according to which the ex-head of the white house was supposed to submit expense reports to the special committee of the house of representatives during his presidency, trump did not do this and went to court to achieve a ban on the provision of these documents to legislators. now there are two criminal cases against him. the ministry of defense showed the work of drones in moscow , this is the central military district drones are made on the basis of domestic eagles, they are equipped with radio modules that suppress control channels and transmission of adversary data. in addition, mosquitoes help artillery, aerial reconnaissance and fire adjustments. these types of barrens are designed to conduct aerial electronic and optics electronic reconnaissance, opening subscriber terminals for cellular communications of the enemy and blocking them. these types of drones. they have been in service for a long time and show themselves well very effectively there are no failures during

were not allowed to work at the polling stations observers of the federal office of the us department of justices clear that the commission employee, without even trying to hide, makes some notes on the ballots. that's all for now. be with us fer first channel will continue the program. good morning. a familiar star is foreseen again. i thought it was here . here we have cold lights here we are on our way, what kind of words are strangers hope is my earthly compass, and luck is a reward i dreamed of explaining quite. noah, so that they don’t sing about it, it’s time, and everything quickly remains impossible everything that we never hate so much again between us the city by chance, as before, my star in the light, like a monument to hope, my earthly compass, he is a doctor’s reward, the mercy to explain one thing, so that only the house is not a traitor. my compass is earthly, and luck is a reward for death, and one song is enough, so that only the ordome is not conducted, but repeated. look at the white panties they have wow, how clearly higher they are, so it was olga dianova thank you very mu

have killed her defense minister and against commented on twitter, sang the decision of the us department of justice to investigate the unfortunate death of sharina. aqua is a grave mistake. the idea conducted an independent and professional investigation which was presented to the americans who shed the details. i made it clear to the american representatives that we stand behind the i d. f. soldiers that we will not cooperate with any external investigation and we will not allow interference in israel internal affairs. moving on now and shirley's president, gabriel burridge is proposing a plan to reach a definitive solution to a land conflict in the iraq han uranium. al jazeera was given exclusive access to barge his meeting with indigenous mcgrew cheerleaders, and in santiago, our latin america, it is certainly say a newman sat down with the president a rare sight in the rest of at oconee, a region some 30 indigenous my put to leaders agreeing to meet the countries president abdel bondage to hear his proposals, solving the conflict in south central chile, the region is under a state of emergency,

small box, sometimes filled with insects, these methods were approved in july 2002 by the us department of justicender the administration of george w. bush mitchell admitted that he tried to stop several interrogations, which came out out of control. however, he could not stop in case of misconduct on the part of a high-ranking military man, quite in the spirit and democracy over the years of active work, up to 1,000 prisoners passed through the prison, everyone knew that the majority were imprisoned for political reasons. but this is america, therefore, legal entities were formalized as enemy kabatants. it allowed to put this democracy to keep the people there. indefinitely , the american punitive machine in the form of a guantana, it has simply become a kind of such a human meat grinder. i'm not afraid to even say animal farm, where the role of animals is played by judges and you have to look at your cheeks, humiliated, tortured and sometimes killed for nothing. here is a typical story of one of the guantanamo prisoners i was kept there for a year from 2002 to 2003 before my eyes the us military

of congress . and as the mid term election followed, continues, joe biden has hinted other plan to stop. donald trump from running for the u. s. presidency in 2024. by allegedly using the department of justice. we just have to demonstrate that he will not take power by if we, if he does run on making sure he under legitimate efforts of our constitution does not become the next president. again, basically the sitting president, united states saying that he will use the power of his office to keep someone else out of office. and you know, this is the kind of thing that the american public is used to hearing our politicians say about latin america or about some other country don't abuse. the process don't be a threat to democracy. joe biden just expressed what i think is a threat to democracy. his, his idea that he is going to be the judge of who's allowed to run for office. these people are using power regularly to get after their political enemies. so i do think they have a plan. i do think that they intend to execute a plan that will be putting donald trump in some.

even the us department of justice, american justice has seriously taken on another younger and more cautiousapplies to for thirty-year-old sam bankman freed, this status is an open question, it is physically difficult to calculate his fortune, because the batman's fortune that he lost in 48 hours. this cryptocurrency trading in digital money encrypted with a special code in just 3 years brought the bentman, real capital of more than 22 billion dollars, a place on the forbes list and laudatory articles from bloomer mole. look, the rich man drives a used toyota, but following the example of soros, he invests 40 million real dollars to support the us game party on midterm elections, and in 2024 promises them more. the billion image of robin hood attracted investors to the bankman ftx crypto exchange money flowed, and the exchange itself burst into the top three market leaders investors began to swallow validol it turned out that ftx cheated for a long time and secretly traded low-liquidity, that is, in fact, crypto-garbage , the price, which is worthless in the exchange world such rumors like a

of the intelligence committee. adam schiff, who led the trump impeachment in 2019 , abused his power to carry out political revenge, for example, used the department of justiceo prosecute his enemies. now his former chief of staff has confirmed yet another abuse of ordering the irs to check the bad things that are written about him. it's not just dangerous or wrong. it is also potentially criminal. well, as a cherry on the cake, they decided to collide trump with fellow party members, the desantis, the governor of florida. in the republican times, they published a cartoon, and sow launched a series of memes. but the landing party did not even declare a desire to run, apparently, the purpose of this hype is simply to weaken the opponents of the democrats and divide supporters of the republicans into two camps, because the positions of the ruling party and their president cannot be called strong. i'm not at all surprised by the high gas prices in the us, especially as we become energy dependent. we were independent when trump was in office. everything was fine with us, but now we are dependent, what biden did wrong, he turned everything that we had in place. t

department of justice. they department is going to not lean use the resources f of the department of justice and the fbi, but also report directly to merrick garland. this is a way for merrick garland to solely control the fate of donald trump's legal cases and i think it is probably the most partisan move he's made to date. >> well, he when asked about the news today, a white house officialed to told fox that the doj payings decisions about its criminal investigations independently and we are not involved. us. mike, we remember that story that leaked to the media this past spring where biden was quoted by sources as having said inside the white house that he was frustrated with garland. that's garland was acting more like a judge than prosecutor. some how that made its way into the newspapers and suddenly we're not supposed to believe that that has any impack on garland? that biden is himself independent here. >> and biden just made another public comment about this several days ago. also, re, it was biden remember, it was the biden white house that waive president trump's privilege for the mar-a-lago raid.

and justice department stayed out of it and let we the people decide who we think should represent us, who we think should lead us. this is the focus on the judiciary committee. the political nature of the justice department and the linkage to what was happening with the hunter biden story. just 15 days before we have presidential election. >> we'll be happy to answer questions. anyone on the committee will be happy to answer questions. reporter: are you putting the f.b.i. on notice for not bringing -- and the department of justice on notice for not bringing charges. mr. comer: we are focused on the bank records moving forward the oversight committee. the judiciary committee -- mr. jordan: i've been in congress a few years. i have never seen anything like that. 14 agents come talk us to while we're in the minority about how political the place has become. the purging going on. terms they used, not us. purnling of agents. the pressure to categorize cases in a political fashion. the putting the threat tag label on moms and dads who show up at school board meetings. we know over two doze

joe biden has proven he is committed to indoctrinating our children and using the department of justiceinst parents who not. -- object. it's a sad thing. >> [booing]. >> when i am in the white house our schools will cease pushing critical race theory as they were. >> [cheers and applause]. >> and gender insanity. if they do that, they will lose all federal funding. i will be the president who fixes education in america. we were doing great. we were starting to really get it right. we won't let men as an example participate in women's sports. is that okay? >> [cheers and applause]. >> no men! >> [cheers and applause]. >> my people tell me that's politically incorrect to say. that's okay. i will stay it anyway. we had tremendous problems. it's unfair to women. we will defend the rights of parents and the family as the center of american life. >> [cheers and applause]. >> who would think 10 or 15 years ago that a politician and i don't like to think of myself as a politician but i guess that's what i am. i hate that thought. that a politician would say we will defending parental rights. of

justice system is to take over the role of prosecutor and refuse to lock of criminals. and that danger is profound, you and i, neither one of us' to see a republican department of justicea democrat department of the justice, we want to see a department of justice and fbi that follows the law fairly and impartially. engaged in a corrupt persecution with hillary clinton party, and let me say this, last time i went on your show was my last book, one vote away. it shot to number one on amazon bestseller list, we have leased when ruth bader ginsburg died. this book i am h hopeful we'll see the same thing, i have to say this doj on exercises every day the abuse of power that we're talking about, this book explains why. mark: he was great. one of it greatest leaders of our time, reelection as prime minister of israel, benjamin netanyahu. we'll be right back. ♪ ♪ luxury exemplified. innovation electrified. with apple music seamlessly integrated. the all-new, all-electric eqs suv from mercedes-benz. mark: welcome back to this special thanksgiving episode of "life, liberty and levin ." "bibi: my story" is a fantastic book about natalia bryant, he hand wrote the entire book himse

former head of the intelligence committee woke up. adam schiff, who led the trump impeachment in 2019 trump abused his power to carry out political revenge, such as using the justice department to prosecute his enemies. now his former chief of staff has confirmed yet another abuse of the irs order to check the bad things that are written about him. it's not just dangerous or wrong. it is also potentially criminal. well, as a cherry on the cake, they decided to push trump's foreheads against the same-party member desantis, the governor of florida. in the battle for the place of candidates republican president. we are trying to publish a caricature, and then we launched a series of memes. but the desantis did not even declare a desire to cheat, apparently, the goal of this hype is simply to weaken the enemy in the democrats and divide the supporters of the republicans into two camps, because the position of the ruling party of their president is impossible. call it strong. i'm not at all surprised by the high gas prices in the us, especially as we become energy dependent. we were independent when trump was in office. we were fine, but now we're addicted, what biden did not lik

joe biden has also proven that he is committed to indoctrinate our children, even using the department of justice against parents who object. it's a terrible thing that it's so sad what's happening when i'm in the white house, our schools will cease pushing critical race theory as they were rather radical civics and gender. insana. or if they do that, they will lose all federal funding, but we'll get them to start. and i will be the president who finally fixes education in america. we were doing great. we were doing we were starting to really get it right. >> we will not let men , as an example, participate in women's sports . >> is that okay? no. no men . no men . my people tell me, sir, that's politically incorrect. >> to say. >> i said that's okay. i'll say it anyway, if you don't mind. we've we've had tremendous, tremendous problems. and , you know, it's very unfair to women, just very, very unfair. we will defend the rights of parents and we will defend the family as the center of american life. >> but i would think standing up here ten years ago, fifteen years ago, that a politician and i d

joe biden has also proven that he is committed to indoctrinating our children, even using the department of justice who object, it's a terrible thing, it's so sad what's happening. when i'm in the white house our schools will cease pushing critical race theory as they were. radical -- and gender insanity, or if they do that they will lose all federal funding, but we will get them to stop. and i will be the president who finally fixes education in america, we were doing great, we were doing, we were starting to really get it right. we will not let men, as an example, participate in women's sports. is that ok? no men. no man. my people tell me, sure -- sir, that's politically incorrect. i said, that's ok, i'll say it anyway. we've had tremendous problems. and it's very unfair, the women. we will defend the rights of parents and we will defend the family as the center of american life. but who would think standing up here 10 years ago, 15 years ago, that a politician, and i don't like to think of myself as a politician, but i guess that's what i am, i hate that thought, but that a politician would be

joe biden has also proven he is committed to indoctrinating our children, even using the department of justicest parents who object. it's a terrible thing. it's so sad what is happening. when i am in the white house, our schools will cease pushing critical race theory as the were. [applause] radical gender insanity, if they do that they will lose all federal funding. but we will get that to stop. i will be the president who finally fixes education in america. we were doing great. we were starting to get it right. we will not let men participate in women's sports. [applause] no men. no men. [applause] my people tell me, sir that is politically incorrect to say. i said that's ok if you don't mind. we had tremendous, tremendous problems and it is very unfair to women. we will defend the rights of parents and we will defend the family as the center of american life. [applause] who would think, standing up here, 10 years ago, 15 years ago that a politician, i don't like to think of myself as a politician but i guess that is what i yam, i hate that thought. -- i am, i hate that thought we will defen

we are now asking for a second to ask the us department of justice about something andrey, we asked foriosif gevorg i want to listen to arkady arkady nikolaevich, so your opinion finally got through very well that we touched on the second part of the transaction. i also immediately wanted to say this about our our wheat fertilizer exports and so on, which were in the first part. here is the most. the main thing is that there is in this whole story, because to get out of the deal. we can easily. we have shown this issue. and actually stop her. we also showed this, because commercial cargo, no matter what they say. about what determination and so on no cargo. uh, carrier yes owner of the cargo will not dare to take such risks when there is actually military action. god knows what might happen. no it won't go too well dear price, so we can stop, but why do we need to stay in this deal. it's because of this second part that's it for today. the key thing is that turkey has clearly expressed that they are ready to become our full-fledged lobbyists in the second part of this deal. it wasn't sa

look, the biggest threat we face in this country is weaponization of our own government against us, and that includes department of justicet who are simply standing up and fighting for children to not be indoctrinated in this leftist, frankly communist ideology. in this particular case, you know, sean, child predation is such an evil, most decent americans assumed it was very rare. then you see ad campaigns like this. you see international child sex trafficking, including our border, in and out of the united states of america, see the jeffrey epstein case, it dawns on people that perhaps this sick evil is actually a lot more widespread than we believe. so not only are our children being exploited and sexualized in the most evil and dark kinds of ways, they're also being indoctrinated in this radical left ideology. that's going to require a giant push back of decent americans, parents and otherwise, to push back to prevent this kind of normalization path that we're on because not only is it evil, it is very, very dangerous. we've been talking about this culture, but this is the ultimate end game, about separating children

of justice are turning. i know that they do not turn fast of us for most of us but i feel confident the process and the justice department and that they will carry out those legal proceedings with professionalism and with transparency and that we will continue to see people held responsible for their actions. host: sarah, your reaction to president trump announcing that he will be running for president. how did you react to that? >> i thought you were asking beth. it was difficult. it is difficult to see him stand up there and get this other chance when so many of us feel that he should be and is being held responsible. it was low energy. it was low-energy. it felt like his heart was not in it. we talk about that on our show. he even sense that the political reality has changed and will continue to change for him. host: richard in boston, massachusetts. democrats mine. caller: good morning. i have a question for beth. i was wondering why she switched parties and became an independent. and also i wanted to also point out that i've been a democrat since the 1990's. i don't understand how people can switch parties. it is th

john kelly said trump's demands were part of a broader pattern of trying to use the justice department and his authority against people critical of him. kelly said they included former fbi director james comey. kelly said he told trump he could not do that. a trump spokeswoman denied trump ever tried using the irs. >>> the head of the u.s. customs and border protection is out of a job. president biden accepted the resignation of christopher magnus. he had been under pressure to step down. it comes as an all-time record number of migrants is entering the u.s. from mexico. the government 125is.4 million border encounters this year. >>> officials looking into what caused a horrific mid-air collision at a dallas air show say they wanted to know why the aircrafts had the same altitude just before they slammed into each other. this was the fiery aftermath that left six people dead. one historic military plane crashed into another before both flames went down in a burst of flames. j.d. miles has more on the crash. >> reporter: smoldering wreckage is all that remains after two vintage war plan

taking the investigation out of the justice department's normal chain of command us attorney general merit garland said, given trumps announcement this week, that he's entering the 2024 presidential race. a special counselor is the only way to lessen the appearance of a conflict of interest. allan, but based on recent developments, including the former president's announcement that he is a candidate for president in the next election. and the sitting president stated intention to be a candidate as well. i have concluded that it is in the public interest to appoint a special council. this horrendous abuse of power is the latest of a long series of witches started a long time ago. his belief in american strength and his commitment to american speaking from a moral law go gala hours after the special council announcement, trump accused the bite and is ration of political attack. the corrupt and highly political justice department just appointed a super radical left special council. better referred to as a special prosecutor. this is a rig deal just as the 2020 election was rigged and we

taking the investigation out of the justice department's normal chain of command us attorney general merrick garland said, given trump's announcement this week, that he's entering the 2024 presidential race as special counselor is the only way to lessen the appearance of a conflict of interest stolen but based on recent developments, including the former president's announcement that he is a candidate for president in the next election. and the sitting president stated intention to be a candidate as well. i have concluded that it is in the public in rest, to appoint a special counsel. this horrendous abuse of power is the latest of a long series of which us started a long time ago. his belief in american strength and his commitment to american speaking from a moral law gala hours after the special council announcement, trump accused the bite and administration of political attack. the corrupt and highly political justice department just appointed a super radical left special council. better referred to as a special prosecutor. this is a rig deal just as the 2020 election was rigged,

was, as he put it, a horrendous abuse of power by a horrendous abuse of power by a corrupt and highly political us justice departmentment. now, all of this comes just three days after mr trump announced he will be running for president again, and in response to that, the us attorney general garland clearly felt he had no option but to appoint a special prosecutor basically an independent lawyer to oversee the investigations that are ongoing into trump's handling of classified documents at his mar—a—lago home, and also allegations that he incited a mob of supporters to attempt to overturn the results of the 2020 presidential election. now, by removing the attorney general effectively from these investigations, handing it over to jack smith, his independent counsellor, it is hoped that there will be seen to be no conflict of interest as far as the us justice conflict of interest as far as the usjustice department and it's officials are concerned. and just very briefly, the timing of it, is the reason for this right now because of him announcing he is running for the presidency, is that it? absolutely, and the need, pe

previously, images of a girl in public space did not appear the us department of justice appointed a ses against donald trump, the possible involvement of the ex-president in the storming of the capitol by his supporters in january 21, as well as his possession of secret government documents. in private the ability of a maralago, special prosecutor jack smith promised to conduct a thorough investigation and be independent trump himself, who a couple of days ago announced that he would run for president in 24, called the ongoing events politicized and refused to help. an emergency in the capital of peru, the line of jorge chavez international airport during takeoff, a bus full of passengers crashed into a fire truck, the liner broke out, but the pilot was able to stop it to the end of the runway along the emergency slide of everyone who was on board urgently evacuated and rescuers promptly extinguished the flames, none of the passengers and crew members. not seriously injured, but died. two firefighters whose car was in a collision, the prosecutor's office began checking how the truck

from the department of justice over how it handled the hunter biden probe. >> it would be nice if the fbi, the justice department just stayed out of it let we the people decide who should represent usocus on judiciary committee. the political nature of the justice department and the linkage what was happening with the hunter biden story. >> reporter: while republicans set their agenda democrats seek new leaders. hakeem jeffries of new york is favored to become the top house democrat. chuck schumer is back as senate majority leader. mccarthy haggle with two democratic leaders from brooklyn. liz? elizabeth: we have congressman pat fallon. talk about this first. before the midterms polls showed people were really worried about inflation and the supply chain. what are you guys going to do about that? >> well, with inflation, liz, the number one thing we're going to do is not have trillion dollar spending billions outside of the budgetary process like joe biden has done and the democrats done on the hill. that stops immediately. so they will have to negotiate with us now, liz. they will have to acknowledge our existence. four million people, four million more people voted for republican

and justice department stayed out of it and let we the people decide who we think should represent us, who we think should lead us. this is the focus on the judiciary committee. the political nature of the justice department and the linkage to what was happening with the hunter biden story. just 15 days before we have presidential election. >> we'll be happy to answer questions. anyone on the committee will be happy to answer questions. reporter: are you putting the f.b.i. on notice for not bringing -- and the department of justice on notice for not bringing charges. mr. comer: we are focused on the bank records moving forward the oversight committee. the judiciary committee -- mr. jordan: i've been in congress a few years. i have never seen anything like that. 14 agents come talk us to while we're in the minority about how political the place has become. the purging going on. terms they used, not us. purnling of agents. the pressure to categorize cases in a political fashion. the putting the threat tag label on moms and dads who show up at school board meetings. we know over two doze

department of justice? what this judge decided use of discretion, there was not a -- use to this power. was she allowed to make the decision? >> in a civilontext, it says this is an available type of equitable authority. there is also cases of 68,000 hundred. if you loo these four factors, even they are not explicit. >> what do you think of chapman? >> chapman uses the word foremost. a pumped suckern ying that. we get this eved notion of callous disregard. i am not sure how they paraphrased foremost. chapman fe to the test as being indispensable. later tesaying it was foremost, graduates indispensable. this is a misread of richie and hon sucker to that point. >>? does it matter? >> i understand what the court is saying. we are talking about an extreme situation wh e exercise of limited equitable jurisdiction by judge cannon. the fact that chapman overstated the law, for whatever reason, eier an error or trying to make use of a more restrictive regime, i don't know. but it is clearly misstating the law wh describes the prion. ere no case. when you consider broader equitable concern. that

more than 60 years ago. donald trump has head out at the appointment of a special counsel to oversee the us justice department investigation. jack smith will lead protein to his handling of classified documents on the legend election interference. the north korean leader kim jong, who has revealed his daughter to the world's, her existence, had never been publicly confirmed before these images emerged the photos so that you hand in hand inspecting a ballistic missile. north korea test fired a was song, 17 intercontinental ballistic missile on friday. and earlier i spoke to robert kelly, who is an associate professor with the national university. he says the decision to release the images suggest kim daughter may become north korea as next leader. north cruise monarchy, right? it's ruled by the kim family and there have been 3 events with the 3rd one. we anticipate that if the current kim were to pass away, that the leadership would pass to a blood relative. now it's never been the case. it's rarely the case and i'll talk, i see that you have succession go from a male to a female. so the daughter is actually t

intimidation and some of the things that we've seen, one people are showing up to vote the department of justice actually us will lease that plan today. and they said that they plan to send people to states all around the country to these polling places to watch and ensure that there isn't anyone trying to harass or intimidate people as they show up to cast their ballots. alexandra le mon live for us in washington, d.c.. alexandra, thank you. 4 is your local election headquarters and on that topic. >> the department of justice is sending representatives to several counties around the country, including sonoma county. this is all in an effort to make sure that rules and regulations are being followed per the federal voter registration act in sonoma county following the last census, the number of spanish speaking residents at a certain threshold that mandates on voting centers have spanish speaking. poll workers and all literature is in spanish as well. cinemas chief deputy registrar of voters says they were contacted by the doj representative and that they would be coming to make sure that the county is in c

use issues outside the context -- sorry, do i need to repeat? it's going to be very important for the future of the fair use doctrine for copyright. the copyright office worked with the department of justice and signed on to the government's brief in the case, which makes a number of important points. taking the side of the photographer. the main points we are concerned about our what it does transformative use mean exactly? and how do you interpret it? in particular, if transformative use is interpreted to broadly, it could undermine the existence of the derivative work right and copyright law. because if anything that changes the original is called transformative, then there is no more separate derivative work right which is defined to me as something that changes aspects of the original work. it's a new version of the original. one issue is how do you define what is transformative and avoid making it so broad that it covers all derivative works? the other question is, what is the impact of a funding of transformative use and the fair use analysis? because the supreme court has cautioned in the past that no one factor should control the entire fair use determination. it's important that