it's like all of 5th avenue in new york, all the stores closed. people come from all over the world to shop there, and it's gone. the reason is because of the chaos out in the streets. all the homeless population that has exploded in california. i felt traumatized by what i saw. my favorite city, the most beautiful city in america. in a year, it's hard was torn out. i didn't know much about homelessness. i began studying it. my assumption was that homelessness is the result of drug addiction. and as the result of extreme poverty. that it's driven by mental illness. the weird thing is there is 520 5000 homeless people in this country, but half of them are in california. which only has 12% of the population. so, my assumption was that those homeless people had become homeless in other cities and migrated to california from new york, detroit because they didn't want to sleep on the grates and a snowstorm. it has better weather and a famously generous social services system. people also told me in san francisco when i was trying these cases and said,

on surface streets very close to 880 embarcadero both directions between 16th avenue and 5th avenue, letely shut down. again both directions. so that will affect your on and off ramps as you exit. so embarcadero off ramp from northbound 880, 16th avenue off ramp from southbound 880 we'll see closures there. it's not affecting the main lines of 880 as of yet. we'll let you knowny that changes and 880 is open itself at least the freeway is in both directions. >>> all right, we're switching live cameras crossing the bridge looking at san francisco. this is what it looks like from the mark hopkins looking south. you see the clouds there drifting in the sky. a prelude to a sunrise. jess has been tracking the storm. >> it has been impacting many of us all along our coast and we gear up for more rain in the forecast for us today which could cause other issues too. a coastal flood advisory in effect along the coastline into 2:00 this afternoon but to add to that also under a high surf advisory stretching from san francisco down into santa cruz and right back up until 6:00 tonight with breaker

it's like all of 5th avenue in new york, all the stores closed.eople come from all over the world to shop there, and it's gone. the reason is because of the chaos out in the streets. all the homeless population that has exploded in california. i felt traumatized by what i saw. my favorite city, the most beautiful city in america. in a year, it's hard was torn out. i didn't know much about homelessness. i began studying it. my assumption was that homelessness is the result of drug addiction. and as the result of extreme poverty. that it's driven by mental illness. the weird thing is there is 520 5000 homeless people in this country, but half of them are in california. which only has 12% of the population. so, my assumption was that those homeless people had become homeless in other cities and migrated to california from new york, detroit because they didn't want to sleep on the grates and a snowstorm. it has better weather and a famously generous social services system. people also told me in san francisco when i was trying these cases and said, wh

this was right near 5th avenue. this is video from the citizen app. you see officers on scene. police say the shooting happened yesterday afternoon. they found the victim suffering from gunshot wounds. that person died at the scene. it's not clear what led up to that shooting but anyone with information is asked to contact police. people in san francisco say they are frustrated with sideshows after one broke out over the weekend. stopping all traffic at a busy intersection. proper sarah stinson now with the story. >> the side show will people up in the middle of the night disturbing. not only them, but the people who are stuck in backed up traffic as the intersection shut down. >> another sideshow leaves a bay area intersection covered in skid marks this time in san francisco's south of market sideshow. >> mission in south bend. people who live near this intersection say they got woken up by people doing donuts around one in the morning sunday. kimberly chan spoke with me off camera saying it was extremely loud, boom. heard a lot of and then about 1 o'clock. a little bit later,

shooting at a gas station around 3:00 this afternoon, at the 711 on international boulevard and 5th avenue near lake merritt. officers say, when they got to the scene, they found a man with a gunshot wound. he was pronounced dead at the scene. no word on what led to the shooting or if any arrests have been made. >>> is the problem getting better or just changing locations? new san francisco crime numbers show car burglaries are noticeably down. this comes in the wake of a new crackdown on the city's most popular tourist hotspot. sounds like good news, but a series of break-ins this morning in the hayes valley neighborhood has some worried the bandits are just moving locations. here's nbc bay area's sergio quintana. >> reporter: a series of early- morning car burglaries that happened today, you can see one man breaks the window of a silver previous, then a white sedan with his by. from a different angle, you can see the white car, and eventually, a team of three breaking into several vehicles. a neighbor tells us she heard car alarms going off, called 911, then she yelled at them, and they

we all remember donald trump statement that he could shoot someone in the middle of 5th avenue in new york and walk away from it as no one would care. that's absolutely right. well, in your own country's recent election a far right candidate, one, the largest to share of the vote. what would you say prepared, go propelled, get builders to success? what is the central appeal that he holds for so many voters? i think he listens very carefully to the, to the needs of the people. the migration is a big topic and then other ones i come from from this country. and we've seen in the last decades, lots of people came to the netherlands. but let's say only of this year, 20000 people came with asylum and he thinks asylum was one of the biggest problems uh and uh, in the netherlands. so $20000.00 people is not that much, but we have a lot of on our migration, for example, people that come from other countries in the world to do the work a from eastern europe, for example, from poland from romania. and they do the work in the, in the factories in the supermarkets of a lot of basic uh, drops are,

it's like all of 5th avenue in new york, all the stores closed.me from all over the world to shop there, and it's gone. the reason is because of the chaos out in the streets. all the homeless population that has exploded in california. i felt traumatized by what i saw. my favorite city, the most beautiful city in america. in a year, it's hard was torn out. i didn't know much about homelessness. i began studying it. my assumption was that homelessness is the result of drug addiction. and as the result of extreme poverty. that it's driven by mental illness. the weird thing is there i0

. >> it was summer of 2021 on 5th avenue and 55th. i was robbed by two men. >> i lived an honest life. i have never been accused of any bad doing >> good morning. >> my company at the time we lost four employees that worked, that were at pulse nightclub. >> she was in the south tower. she made it out. got caught up in it. >> did i embellish my resume? yes, i did. i am sorry. >> what was the source of your funds, sir, what was the source of your money. >> you listed the wrong name of the treasure, why did you list the wrong name of treasurer on your campaign finance forms. >> i am asking you directly. >> sapphire. she is really probably pretty happy about this, too. this poor little girl she suffered the last three to four months of her life because he stole money from me and from her. he needs to be in jail and that is where he is headed. i just saw all of the things that he spent money on. all of those clothes, botox, sophora. i wonder what he spent her money on? >> i don't have one. you know, i will say i just discovered what it was

specious argument, that a president has absolute immunity, you could literally shoot someone on 5th avenue as president or call in a fighter strike on an american city as president, and it is likely that eventually the supreme court is going to reject this argument. i mean, most people who, you know, follow the court closely believe that. the question is when and how far they allow trump in his core strategy, really throughout his career, long before he was president, to use delay as a weapon in the legal system. jim, i can imagine a world -- i know we're not supposed to think of a court like this, but john roberts operates like a legislative leader who tries to put together packages that appeal to incompatible interests that include ideas either side would reject in a legislative bill. you can imagine an outcome, as we did with the aca back in 2012, where they allow trump to appear on the ballot, throw out the colorado ruling, but also reject his claims of immunity and allow voters to have the information before the election about whether a jury finds him guilty of these serious charges.

it's like all of 5th avenue in new york, all the stores closed.ople come from all over the world to shop there, and it's gone. the reason is because of the chaos out in the streets. all the homeless population that has exploded in california. i felt traumatized by what i saw. my favorite city, the most beautiful city in america. in a year, it's hard was torn out. i didn't know much about homelessness. i began studying it. my assumption was that homelessness is the result of drug addiction. and as the result of extreme poverty. that it's driven by mental illness. the weird thing is there is 520 5000 homeless people in this country, but half of them are in california. which only has 12% of the population. so, my assumption was that those homeless people had become homeless in other cities and migrated to california from new york, detroit because they didn't want to sleep on the grates and a snowstorm. it has better weather and a famously generous social services system. people also told me in san francisco when i was trying these cases and said, why

you have to put it maxime of come up with the 5th avenue at the end. those for the c c e. and that it forces you and that there is any left the of the wind of resistance is blowing in the mountains of america. when you get a settlement of this is this good fathers this the gym wasn't going to defend um was not the side was $7.00. most of the theatre some but because of the most, and those are one of the the most and know that the of them i, the one that the hiding of my, the bank allow the memphis you on that on this i'll just go, michael thought is coming from this in the nothing in the beside him who knows who the company is looking at the bottom, the bottom. most of the, of the look at the bottom. it was the record that if i don't know through nipples company, it was you, i bought them is the same place as people getting the, the, wherever the street. those either cause or by allow me know the other most are by you. so by i mean, any of the hallmarks of cb, velma supposed thank you live almost in boston. yes we all a 0. this is still the think about this company in the

vonnie: i was reading about product agreed to by the 5th avenue building that it is housed at, 420 $5lion come apart i wanted to go ahead with it. is that a good opportunity? might we see more brick-and-mortar retail because of the distress? >> i think the brick-and-mortar retail is interesting right now. that is one asset that is extremely strong from an fundamental standpoint because they have right sized over the last decade and there isn't a lot of construction that has come to bring a rising vacancy in that space. as was early in the program the consumer is relatively strong right now. there are a lot of tailwinds to the retail market. any value at purchases and opportunistic byes in the retail sector can do, they should absolutely execute now because that window is really shrinking as we enter 2024 and again interest rates start to fall. >> we have talked about office and retail and of course there is multifamily and industrial. two spaces that have held up pretty well. i understand that a lot of supply is coming due over the next year. do you expect it will be absorbed in a coh

police are investigating a deadly shooting at a 7.11 gas station on international boulevard near 5th avenueis is video from the citizen app. police say shots were fired this afternoon. it's not clear what led up to the shooting. anyone who might information about this is asked to contact oakland police. another former guard at the women's federal prison in dublin has been sentenced for sexually abusing inmates. john bel house is now set to serve 5 years in prison and pay a $25,000 fine. prosecutors say this was the 8th abuse case to be brought against a former guard at that prison last month. a former guard was sentenced to 8 years behind bars. >> santa rosa police say more teenagers are being arrested for carrying guns this year. they say that they've seen a 500% increase from last year arresting 21 teens for gun possession this year. the department in santa rosa blames it on an increase in gang violence. napa is offering free sandbags is saturday ahead of the rain that's expected this week. residents can pick them up at the city's corporation yard from 9 in the morning to one in the after

look, this is a man who said that he could shoot and kill someone on 5th avenue and get away with it when it comes to his base. and he can. this is just proof positive. but the base only amounts to, what, 28% of the electorate. you cannot win in the general election with just the base. and what these cases are doing is it's sending -- right now we -- these polls, you know i don't have much faith in any of these polls. when you start to see let's say the black community or the hispanic communities or the muslim community now rising as supporter of trump, i don't buy it. i don't buy any of it simply because his first actions are going to be against the same group that they -- the polls are showing he's rising in. it's nonsensical to me, and i don't know who's conducting these polls or what. but i believe that for his base, yes, continuing to play victim is always going to benefit him. but in the general election, it will not. people on the republican side will either not vote because they won't vote for a democrat, or -- or what they will do is they will just, you know, not vote at all

happened yesterday as the victim was pumping gas at the 7-eleven on international boulevard and 5th avenue near lake merritt. the owner of the store says shortly after the victim got out of his car, another car pulled up and several people got out and fired multiple rounds. other customers told us they're becoming all too familiar with the cycle of violence. >> every time i go, i have to be looking around. sometimes there are people parking there. >> you rarely see that kind of stuff happen here, but, you know, it's oakland, that kind of happens in every part of oakland for the most part. >> oakland police are not saying if they believe the victim was targeted, but they're asking anyone with information to give them a call. >>> happening today, leaders in san francisco's mission district will voice their opposition to a new bike lane merchants say is killing business. the lane is part of a one-year pilot program that now runs through the center of valencia street between 15th and 24th streets, and replaced about 70 parking spots. business owners say it's also cutting down on foot traffic.

. >> on international boulevard near 5th avenue. this is from the citizen app.ing happened yesterday afternoon and police found the person who had been shot and they died at the scene. it's not clear what led up to this shooting, but if you have any information, you're asked to contact the police. in the south bay. a woman was found around 5 o'clock sunday night. this hn the corner of lucretia avenue and thelma, way in the little saigon neighborhood. and police say thathe woman's body had obvious signs of physical trauma. no word on who did it is san jose's 31st. homicide this year. >> 6.33. the time of the man now facing attempted murder and assault with a deadly weapon charges for allegedly attempting to kill guests at a family holiday party last month. the alameda county district attorney's office says that leandre torres was asked to leave a family gathering on november. 25th again, this was in san lorenzo. but he later returned and allegedly attacked his brother's car. he's also suspected of driving his own car towards for women standing in the street. one

investigating a deadly shooting that happened at this 7.11, gas station on international boulevard by 5th avenued this is video from the citizen app. you can see the scene road here and police are investigating. this happened yesterday afternoon. they found the victim suffering from gunshot wounds and that person died at the scene. they don't have any leads at this point that we know of that. if you have any information, you're asked to contact the police. in the south bay. the police are looking for clues after a woman was found dead in a home in san jose. about 5 o'clock sunday night. the home is near the corner of lucretia avenue and thelma, way near the little saigon neighborhood. and police say that the victim's body had obvious signs of physical trauma. this is san jose's 31st. homicide of the year. 10. 33 and a man faces attempted murder and assault with a deadly weapon charges. he's accused of attempting to kill for guests at a family holiday party last month. the alameda county da says that lee and wrote torres was asked to leave a family gathering on november. 25th and sandler engine i

it happened yesterday as the victim was pumping gas at a 7-eleven on international boulevard and 5th avenue. this is near lake merritt. the owner of the store says shortly after that victim got out of the car, another car pulled up and several people got out and fired multiple rounds. other customers telling us that they're too familiar with this cycle of violence. >> every time i go, i have to be looking around, because people are parking there. >> you rarely see that kind of stuff happen up here, but it's oakland. that kind of happens in every part of oakland for the most part. >> oakland police are not saying if they believe the victim was targeted, but they are asking anyone with information to give them a call. >>> to decision 2024, the field will be down to four when gop presidential contenders meet tomorrow night in alabama for their latest debate. the field will include ron desantis, nikki haley, vivek ramaswamy and chris christie. christie barely qualified this time, needing at least 6% of support in the polls to take part in the news nation debate. republican polling front-runner

nonresponsive to say the least, but i mean, this is someone who said he could shoot someone on 5th avenue, you know, still win, and some people have suggested, yeah, maybe that's true. do you think he says this stuff because he believes that's what voters want to hear, because he thinks they don't care or simply because that's really what he thinks? >> well, he -- first of all, it's worth noting that that wasn't just a softball from hannity. it was sort of the softest of soft nerf balls lobbed up quite slowly, and it should not be that difficult to disavow the idea that you would like to be a dictator on day one if you took office again. what's happening here, frankly s a fascinating dynamic, which is that former president trump is saying this because it's how he feels. it's what he believes. it's what he thinks his voters want to hear, but the people around him, a number of people in his campaign advisers, they understand that maybe not for the maga base, but for some of those voters he will need to win over to beat joe biden, that they don't like to hear this. they don't like to hear a

investigating a deadly shooting that happened at this 7.11 gas station on international boulevard around 5th avenue'srom the citizen app of the scene roped off so police could investigate. this was yesterday afternoon police found a person who had been shot and they died at the scene. it's not clear what led up to it. we have no word on the shooter and they're asking anybody with information to contact the police. in the south bay, a woman was found dead in a home. >> in san jose was around 5 o'clock sunday night. police were called to a home on the corner of lucretia avenue and selma way in the little saigon neighborhood. and that's where they found the woman. her body had obvious signs of physical trauma. no word on who did it. this is san jose's 31st. homicide of the year. >> well, a man now facing attempted murder and assault with a deadly weapon charges for allegedly kidnapping or attempting to kill guests at a family holiday party last month. the alameda county district attorney's office says that leandre torres was asked to leave a family gathering on november. 25th in san lorenzo. but later r

investigating a deadly shooting that happened at this 7.11 gas station on international boulevard by 5th avenue. this is video from the citizen app. you can see it rolled off as police investigate. they say what happened was yesterday afternoon there was a shooting. they found the victim suffering from gunshot wounds and that victim died at the scene. they are now investigating what led up to this. so if anybody has information ask contact the police. in the south bay, a woman was found dead in a home in san jose. around 5 o'clock psunday night. this home near the corner of lucretia avenue and selma way near the little saigon neighborhood and police say that her body had obvious signs of physical trauma. no word on a suspect at this point. it is san jose's 31st. homicide this year. >> well, a man now facing attempted murder and assault with a deadly weapon charges for allegedly attempting to kill guests at a family holiday party last month. county district attorney's office says that leandre torres was asked to leave a family gathering back on november. 25th in san lorenzo. but then later retur

police are investigating a shooting death at a 7.11 gas station on international boulevard near 5th avenue happened yesterday. you're looking at video from the citizen app. police say they arrived to find someone who had been shot and later died. it is not clear yet what led to that shooting. anyone with information as always being asked to call police. a man is facing attempted murder and assault with a deadly weapon. he is accused of trying to kill guests at a family holiday party last month. the alameda county da's office says that leander torres was asked to leave a family gathering. this was november 25th san lorenzo. but later came back and is accused of attacking his brother's car and is suspected of driving his car toward for women standing on the street. and one of those women became pinned between his car and a parked car if convicted or torres could face up to 12 years in prison. in the south bay, a woman was found dead inside a san jose home sunday night near the corner of lucretia avenue in film away. that's near the little saigon neighborhood. police say the woman's body had

christina, how does and reports it's the time of year when new york 5th avenue is normally bustling with christmas shopping. but for many here the war and the ever increasing did total in gaza is front of mind. more than 2 months of his riley, it strikes underground operation have killed the 20200 people. most of them, women and children. do you when says people in garza also face salvation disease and, and uncertain future research shows those issues a strongly influencing how americans feel about the rules and the bod, an administration ongoing support for his room. it's not just america is questioning this relationship beyond conflict. location and the vin johnson project is found almost 90. percent of protest is globally stand in solidarity with palestinians. if we know if that demo bodies disease mass on gun by method demonstration, because i can no longer bear what is happening in palestine, this is the murder of a people. this is genocide. let's say the government, the stresses canada and use zealand, a bending to public pressure and yours is also starting to boss. so they say, wa

. >> check out all the windows along 5th avenue as you head to radio city.it's a new spin on the holiday tale. that is playing through the end of december. >> it's hard to think about the holidays without the nutcracker. >> that tchaikovsky score is so beautiful. it's been playing since 1954. more than 150 musicians and dancers are part of this production. it is truly fantastic. >> these are the shows that we see year in and year out. a jazz show and sandra bernhardt. >> sandra bernhardt plays the show from december 26th through new year's eve. she takes us on a fun spin, a throwback, and provides her amazing commentary about this crazy world we're living in today. birdland jazz club in midtown, they're doing a swinging christmas. i think this is their 13th year. it's so much fun. i believe they have a show on christmas night. >> tell us about new year's. >> let's go back to 54 below. lorna luft is doing an early new year's eve show providing tales of old hollywood and the broadway scene. then for the second show it's going to be a broadway favorite. he is d

so they went to ira's home, which was on 2nd avenue and 5th street which is sort of upper from yip's and c. and they had a victrola, which is like having, you know, huge instruments today, and played him h.m.s. pinafore. well, yip was just absolutely flabbergasted, knocked out. and that did it. i mean, for the both of them, because ira was intensely interested that thing, too. >> ♪ >> that began their lifelong friendship. then ira went on to be one of the pioneers, with 25 other guys, jewish russian immigrants, who developed the american musical theater. and it was only after -- in 1924, i think, that ira's first show with george gershwin, his brother, that they started writing together. >> ♪ amy: the gershwins' porgy and bess in 1940. >> ♪ >> yip's career took a kind of detour because when the war, world war i, came and yip was a socialist and did not believe in the war, he took a boat down to uruguay for three years. i mean, he refused to fight in the thing. that's shades of 1968 and the vietnam war, right? amy: and why didn't he believe in world war i? >> because he was a full, de

i will walk down to penn station on my way home, i will go down 5th avenue, madison avenue.uropean tourists are back. not so much asian visitors. i have not seen that, but i know for a light at the high-end retailers, they depend on china tourism. kailey: absolutely. you mentioned luxury goods. china drives so much of that demand. we learned in 2023 that the rebound on the part of the chinese consumer did not rebound in the way many thought. but i have seen a lot of people out and about. paul: absolutely. kailey: i did all my shopping online this year. paul: i was out a few times checking out the tree at rockefeller center. pre-pandemic packed. people on fifth avenue. you like to see that. hopefully, retailers are doing well. coming up, ian steeley, international cio for fixed income at morgan stanley. they had some positive results. hi, i'm kevin, and i've lost 152 pounds on golo. i had just left a checkup with my doctor, and i'd weighed in at 345 pounds. my doctor prescribed a weight loss drug, but as soon as i stopped taking the drug, i gained all the weight back and then

court gets this colorado decision somehow before january 5th, will that essentially settle the maine case and other cases like this? or are there avenuesf approach that could still get president trump off the general election ballot through similar secretaries of state or even supreme courts of state that maybe are politically partisan? >> that's the funny thing. the maine secretary of state says in her fake opinion that she knows that what she says might be nullified by the supreme court. so i think she is acknowledging that her decision will change based on what the united states supreme court says. but, at the same time, this is what is so dangerous about the arguments that the leftists are making here which is that the 14th amendment is self-executing, meaning anyone has authority to do anything about it. so, even if the supreme court were to rule, what's to stop some random poll worker from scratching off donald trump's name? there really is an endless amount of mischief that can happen when you have every person on to themselves. maine secretary of state, the colorado supreme court, et cetera. just saying i am the interpreter of

5th amendment right against self-incrimination. investigators have identified the man stabbed to death in pacifica as 30 year-old as rip you choose from oakland to the stabbing happened at a home on naomi avenue yesterday morning. a woman was also stabbed inside the home. she's expected to live. police have identified the suspect now as 46 year-old jason gill and water, he was later found dead yesterday after he apparently shot himself in ukiah. a source told kron 4 that he was a paramedic in coma and that he was arrested for domestic violence. at that same pacifica home just a week before the stabbing. police in oakley are asking for the public's help. they're trying to find a car that hit and killed a bicyclist. police say the collision was shortly after midnight sunday near bridgehead road and main street police responded to a report that a man was lying in the road next to a bicycle. the contra costa county coroner has identified the victim as 41 year-old haji to re officers arrested the vehicle's owner identified as 55 year-old timmy hudson. but they still haven't been able to find his car a 2015 toyota camry. alameda police are warning holiday shoppers about try to swipe their purchases

avenue in january. >> we had a combination of very high tides and very large waves that came at the same time. on the morning of january 5this year, along with strong onshore winds, griggs says most of california's coastal development came after world war two. >> from 1945 until 1978. during a calm climate period with less storms and rainfall. >> but the climate change in 1978 and from there on through the next 20 years, we had these big storms and big waves and more rainfall, and everybody went, whoa, what's happening? because we weren't used to that. and then we went into a calm period and now we're in a stormier period. so there is nothing we can do to hold back the pacific ocean. so trying to stop it is going to be temporary , but to try to slow down erosion. >> sean vitousek of the us, g.s, says there are some options for coastal armoring, such as concrete seawalls to prevent flooding, rebuilding beaches and sea dunes, or manage retreat. >> a managed retreat is basically infrastructure that is sort of critically threatened by eroding beaches, by cliff failures and by increased coastal flood areas, basically relocating

5th amendment right against self-incrimination. well, investigators have identified the man stabbed to death in pacifica is 30 year-old has from oakland, the stabbing happened on a home on naomi avenueas also stabbed inside the home but is expected to survive. police have identified the suspect as 46 year-old jason gill water. he was later found dead after shooting himself in. excuse me, you cup. a source told kron 4 news that he was uk. excuse me, everyone, ukiah. they say that he was a and he had actually been arrested for domestic violence at that same home in pacifica about a week before the stabbing happened. well, police in oakley are now asking for the public's help to find a 2015 toyota camry that was involved in a hit and run that killed a bicyclist earlier last excuse me last week. officials say the collision happened shortly after midnight on sunday bridgehead road and main street police responded to calls of a man lying on the road next to his bike. he was later identified by county officials as 41 year-old he to officers arrested the vehicle's owner identified as 55 year-old timmy hudson. however, they still have not been able to find that vehicle that you see there on

avenue. letter from edward g. requester asking that the board take jurisdiction over alteration permit number 2022 0804 9876, which was issued on october 5th, 2023. the appeal period ended on october 20th, 2023, and the jurisdiction request was filed at the board office on november 6th. the permit holder is lisa and patrice gauthier. the permit description install a new dumbwaiter elevator, including all structural supports as needed. add structurally reinforce concrete retaining wall and infill concrete slab, rip face stucco wall below stairs, waterproofing over mechanical room and tile replacement as needed area drains, plans, traveling with permit number 2022 08039878. thank you. and mr. can you please remind the board, please what the standard is and what we are expected to. okay, so how how we are expected to reach a decision or the standard for the decision please the requester has to show that the city intends finally or inadvertently caused tim to be late in filing an appeal. and so that that takes four votes in order to get that granted. thank you. thank you. welcome mr. yee, you have three minutes. i've been here so many times th