new ones. uh, regarding other things, how successfully was it possible to renew the supreme council of justice be possible to judge by their first decisions. anti-corruption policy this is a new member of the high council of justice, a judge of the civil court of cassation as part of the supreme court, serhiy burlakov. yes, i believe that it will be virtuous because i meet all the criteria for integrity. a member of the communist party of ukraine testifies to the opposite. he is closely associated with the kharkiv millionaire and mp of the ninth convocation oleksandr feldman, a former member of the already banned feldman, a member of the pro-russian party opzzh, is known for voting for the dictatorial laws on january 16, 2014, which actually led to the escalation of conflicts during the revolution of dignity in 17-18 years . burlakov actively cooperated with the flintven family and represented their interests and from this we can also draw conclusions about all of this candidate , in particular, burlakov received powers of attorney from feldman, even members of his family, burlakov does not de

unethical behavior, and actually on the one hand, since this judge is a candidate for the high council of justicehich conducts the examination of candidates , and they should ask him questions about this and be very interested to hear his answers, and on the other hand, this is a bright uh, well , this is a reason for a disciplinary complaint against a judge who should be considered by the supreme council of justice and prosecuted , but there is still no supreme council of justice. unfortunately, there is no one to review these complaints, and i do not rule out that some judges allow themselves such behavior, obviously realizing that they do not yet have a supreme council of justice, they are bezkarka yes, he will go there himself . he will enter there himself, and he can also consider this complaint on his own. well, frankly, i doubt that after such an incident, first of all, he will come to be checked by the ethics council. even if i liked it very much it seems doubtful that fellow judges would support such a person, although in our history he essentially makes very different decisions, so you

chairman of the supreme court is a member of the supreme court as a candidate for the supreme council of justice evaluated by the ethical council specially created based on the recommendations of international partners and in accordance with the requirements of the eu which consists of three ukrainian judges nominated by the council of judges, as well as a retired judge of the court of appeal of england and wales, a former judge of the supreme court of the state of massachusetts and a former general the prosecutor of the republic of estonia, the critical council checked all applicants for compliance with the criteria of professional ethics and integrity due to inadequacy for a high position, many candidates were screened out , but not all of them, some of them, despite their extremely dubious reputation , managed to break through and take the coveted seat in the vrp, positions for the next four years were taken by yuliya bokova, alla kotlevets, olga popikova , oleksandr sasevich, hryhoriy usyk, tetiana bondarenko, olena cowboy and serhiy burlakov , all the ethics council proposed for appointment

are necessary for the start of negotiations on joining the european union, what is the high council of justice and what is its role in the judicial reform ? the worst did not happen, the extraordinary congress of judges still elected eight members of the supreme council of justice, which means that a quorum has appeared in the body and it will be able to start work after almost a year of downtime. punishing offending judges, in particular from collaborating judges , gives permission for transfer from one court to another, as well as for the resignation of a judge, in addition, it is impossible to fill more than 2.5 thousand judicial vacancies that have arisen in recent years in the country , so the cases can be considered years she can start working and she has a lot of work, so this is to some extent a historic moment and i am very much counting together with my colleagues from the monomajority and with all my colleagues indeed, the year 2023 will be devoted to a total reboot of the judicial system, and this is a clear condition not only for our european integration aspirations, it is a key c

from the administration of justice today's event, or rather, it stretched over two days, yesterday and today, the congress of judges elected eight new members of the supreme counciljustice, and accordingly, we can state today that today the supreme council of justice already has a quorum and can work fully. this is very important because that this is, by and large, one of the essential steps towards unlocking and completing the judicial reform in general, which, due to the absence of the supreme council of justice, a full-fledged and highly qualified commission of judges, was incapacitated, well, it was practically general that this is your question about integrity, then i want to remind you that we passed such laws that provide for the appointment of mandatory conclusions of the relevant ethical council on integrity issues, and even today, and talk about the fact that they could participate in the competition only those candidates who had the opinion of the public council of the ethical council could participate, therefore, talk about any issues regarding the integrity of judges or representatives who were elected to the supreme council of justice for today well

the supreme council of justice must also appoint a new composition of another important body of the higherualification commission, so the integrity of the members of the supreme council of justice directly depends on whether corruption will be eradicated from the judicial system of ukraine, the chairman of the board of the de jure foundation, mykhailo zhirnakov, told us that it was necessary to hold a congress of judges to elect eight new members of the supreme council of justice. and you did not form the council of justice . in this way, further progress in judicial reform and european integration would also fail , because among the requirements under number one related to our european integration , the higher judiciary consists of twenty-one ten members are elected by the congress of judges of ukraine, two are appointed by the president, two are elected by the verkhovna rada , two more are elected by the congress of lawyers, two are delegated by the all-ukrainian conference of prosecutors, and two more are elected by the congress of scientists and representatives of legal highers. the co

us, because first of all, the judicial system is in the jury for a year without the supreme council of justicent new judges, dismiss or suspend those judges who commit crimes, in particular those who cooperate with the occupiers in osi. year, we couldn't do anything, besides, the opening of negotiations on ukraine's membership in the eu also depends on the start of the vrp's work, so at least the victory is that the judges have already taken five members of the vrp and now the second day of the congress is underway and three more members of the supreme council of justice should be elected at it. at the same time, we, as representatives of public organizations who analyzed information about all the candidates, are not very satisfied with the results of these elections, because we have doubts about the integrity of all candidates who were elected yesterday although they passed the ethics council check, however, the interviews were closed, they were not broadcast , and we do not understand at all how the candidates answered the questions regarding their declarations of conduct of relations with t

optimistic, on the other hand, if it will be a candidate or already a member of the supreme council of justiceho has shown public knowledge of problems in the judicial system by calls to reform the judicial system, this will be a signal that the supreme council of justice is ready to take a position that means recognizing the problems and seeking decisions after all, only the supreme council of justice can cleanse the judiciary from unscrupulous courts, the second stage is the formation of a higher qualification commission , a competition is currently taking place, the selection of candidates , they are selected, the involvement of international experts, but the supreme council of justice will form the final composition of the higher qualification commission. and actually, we will be able to see whether this composition is again dominated by representatives of the system who are quite conservative and do not recognize problems, or vice versa. agents of change are those who are ready to recognize problems, seek answers and well , temporary decisions may not be popular among judges, but those th

well, in fact, if we talk about the supreme council of justice, this is currently the position of threethe supreme council of justice, these are three members who left from the previous convocation of the supreme council of justice - this is the acting mr. veselikov, the chairman of the board, who signed these documents and sent his remarks to the state such a promotional program, i.e., now there are 7 members of the vrp, but even these remarks are an opinion, even we, and only three of them, and what the member publicly wrote about roman maselko of the supreme council of justice himself on facebook. he said that he didn't vote for such a decision, and this is actually the opinion of the members of the gdp. that's why it's so paradoxical that our plans and our demands put before us are blocked for it's actually three people and it can't be. well, it's actually bad, but on the other hand, it's a good test because the mice will never fight, but if, as they say, the anti-corruption program really poses a threat to those people who are not clean. with reputation let's say with professionali

appointments of these characters, what can be expected from them in positions in the supreme council of justice, really, i agree with the fact that actually to everyone the judges who were elected to the supreme council of justice have a question for them, of course the biggest question is the question for mr. bulgakov, who after the armed aggression after the beginning of the war repeatedly traveled to the russian federation, whose father is a citizen of the russian federation and that's why, of course , he has the most questions because it 's very strange and it's very, it's very unclear and when those judges are elected, the judges elect such colleagues to the supreme council of justice when we already have a full-scale full-scale war already it is not the first, not the first months therefore, there are questions for them, but in fact the biggest problem is also that, unfortunately , even after the e filter of the ethical council, we er and because of the closed interviews of the ethical council we do not know whether some of these er candidate judges have removed these questions or no. how

i believe that all of them will be acted upon as the previous supreme council of justice acted, therefore, and indeed you are right, and we are reloading almost completely both bodies of the supreme court commission of judges at 100%. the supreme council of justice, only three members are left from 21 after all the checks and all the dismissals. that's why it's a really big chance - it doesn't have a guarantee that we knew it was very bad and now it's just going to be perfect . unfortunately, it won't happen yet, but what we're counting on and hoping for. it's really a step. going forward, these bodies must be at least independent, unmanaged from some one center, from the bank there or from some other street, and they must be able to carry out independent selection, and this is actually what we are waiting for, what are we expecting, but mykhailo, what appointed these members of the supreme council of justice. this is an extremely important story. and there were absolutely unambiguous signals from the ambassadors of gsava. we don’t even know who else they came from, but the question remai

, they cannot be transferred to anyone, now the work of the supreme council of justice is unblocked and the constitutional body will begin to work actively mr. dmytro and how do you generally assess the final composition of the supreme council of judges based on the results of the election thank you, selection of candidates for the position of members of the supreme council of justice departure judges were conducted by the ethics council, it was formed from three international experts and three ukrainian courts , international experts had the right to a decisive vote on each candidate. i do not know this for sure. that is why some of the statements that are now being heard are critical of the already formed supreme council of justice. this is an opinion from the side of the ethics council, as a legal body, it had enough unlimited resources to check any of the candidates, it conducted thorough checks of each of the candidates, including me, therefore i have no reason to question the decision of the ethics council, which selected 16 candidates from those 16 military personnel, and ult

the commission of judges recommended the release of this action e kruhlelina, but the supreme council of justicesed to do so stanislav yurchenko head of the luhansk swativ district court oblast and he considers himself worthy of the post of a member of the supreme council of justice, although he himself was repeatedly held accountable by it for violating judicial ethics and even the law in 2012 it was yurchenko who saved from criminal liability the scandalous roman landik, a member of the luhansk city council from the party of regions and the son of former people's deputy volodymyr landik was accused of beating a woman who suffered a concussion. the video from the surveillance cameras clearly shows how roman landik uses defenseless force in a luhansk restaurant. judge yurchenko called it a necessary defense and acquitted the deputy of the region stanislav yurchenko was repeatedly brought to the disciplinary high council of justice, of which he now wants to become a member. for the first time in 2018, when a judge violated the presumption of innocence in his articles in a newspaper, he repeatedly

the judges are for themselves well , a little bit yes, and there is a so-called the ethical council of justicek the candidates, are they sufficiently honest or not? and this is a check. well, no, i wouldn't say that it is super detailed, but at least there is some kind of a. and during this check, the activists try very hard speaks publicly about the most scandalous candidates so that they do not pass this sieve, you can say so, and a-a as a candidate that will be passed by the ethical council of justice and will not be considered a-a and these are the congress of judges and from them they will choose those candidates who will enter by quota a-a with riding judges in the vrp vrp is the supreme council of justice i think that it is necessary to explain to people what is the supreme council of justice - this is a-a such a body that... - but let's allow the famous a-a judge pavel vovk from uazka when the case was opened against him and his colleagues. and we wanted him to be arrested, but unfortunately, since he is a judge, he cannot be arrested, he has no immunity so that it is still possible to

issues that we, as representatives of civil society, discovered and sent to the ethical council, this is the body that selected candidates for the supreme council of justicehopes that the ethical council the council will ask these questions to the candidate for the members of the supreme council of justice and to us too. be it any citizen of ukraine, it may be possible to read the answers and determine whether they were convincing or not , because very often you can find some information that may indicate dishonesty, but everyone well, i should have the right to explain such and such facts. unfortunately, in connection with the introduction of the military station, in fact, the council decided to close the interviews, and therefore it was impossible for us to find out whether the candidates gave answers to these questions, which in if so, what were these answers ? did they refute with their answers the suspicions that we had? well, i see that some questions were put to these judges by journalists . yes, he visited russia after the age of 14. well, he said he went to see his father, a pensioner of russian citizens, so he visited his father, he refers to th

of the scientific council is ? one or another university, for example, but no, what is the importance , oleksandr, the supreme council of justiceather important body, because thanks to this body , the selection and appointment of judges takes place, that is, the president appoints judges, but for submitted by the supreme council of justice. in addition, this body has many disciplinary and other administrative powers, for example, the transfer of a judge from one court to another, and the granting of consent to the arrest , detention of a judge, and so on, that is, according to the law on the supreme council of justice, there are more than 20 powers of the supreme council of justice and an understaffed vrp

election of members of the academic council of this or that or that university, for example, but no, what is the importance of oleksand oleksandr the supreme council of justice is an important body that thanks to this body, the selection and appointment of judges takes place, that is, the president appoints judges, but on the proposal of the supreme council of justice. in addition, this body has many disciplinary powers and other administrative, for example, there is the transfer of a judge from one court to another, and the granting of consent to the detention of a judge, and so on, that is, according to the law on the supreme council of justice, there are more than 20 powers of the supreme council of justice and an understaffed vrp, of course, this is a problem for the judges themselves, because without there is no such thing as a normal life in the judicial system, ok, oleksandr, we understand that, unfortunately, not everything is solved simply by the selection of candidates by their integrity and professionalism and the work of the ethics council, in particular, everything is really it is decided by an opinion and really an effort to clean up and a norm

council of justice, and based on the results of this congress, we will see whether the supreme council renewed, whether it will become high-quality, or whether it will be independent , fair, and decisive enough to dismiss such judges as vasylenko with russian citizenship, real estate or trips to the crimea, in january and february there will be interviews with candidates for the higher kovaliv commission of judges by the body responsible for evaluating judges on integrity, so in fact now the question of whether we should expect that in the future the judicial system will be cleansed of such people as vasylenko bohdan lviv and others is only being resolved at the very end of our conversation and with you i want to share with our viewers that there was a survey conducted to order center of the new europe and there it is reported that 73% of ukrainians said that it is correct that the european union requires reforms from ukraine and they must be what ukraine needs them first of all i need them why am i talking about this because the judicial reform is also one of the requirements of the e

, the war and what is happening around must be directed at the same time to how the supreme council of justiceill work, who it appoints as its head, who it appoints as its deputies and yes further because, despite the fact that these 8 elected judges, candidate members of the supreme council of justice, there is a question, we still hope that they are aware of all responsibility, aware of the huge demand of ukrainian society and the international community to that the judicial reform must be implemented, the judges' corps must be virtuous, because this is a huge, huge step that our state must take to preserve independence, to build democracy, and to preserve ukraine as a whole, we have very little time, but there is a little and tell me, please, alla kotlevets hryhoriy usyk oleksandr ssasevych yuriy bokla olga popikova tetyana bondarenko olena kovbiy and serhiy burlakov these were the judges of the kherson district court of cassation civil court of the northern operational court of the economic economic court of donetsk region lviv district administrator from different regions from different j

transparently as possible with the involvement of renewed as part of the reform of the high council of justiceation commission of judges and the new public council of integrity, however, the issue of the dismissal of former judges of the oases has not yet been decided, justice can only be the complete liquidation of one court, this must not end because in all dimensions it must be full stop both the activities of these judges and their status because they are still in the status of judges although they are no longer judges of the district court at the end of 2022 gave judicial reform another victory, the parliament passed a law that changes the system of appointing judges of the constitutional court of ukraine, although it put the reform of the constitutional court in jeopardy, this is not european integration, it is under the guise of reform of the dependents of the constitutional court and a direct path to authoritarianism, the law creates a group of experts it consists of six members, one each from the verkhovna rada of the president and the congress of judges of ukraine, one person from th

lists he condemned for voting will not want to block the election of members of the supreme council of justice, and 16 candidates for eight positions are already known, so the ethical council of the previous ones selected and these are all the names of these people, so according to the judges, all that remains is to gather and vote for eight of those 16 so and then we will get the authority that the council of justice and the first such stage of judicial reform will take place like this. that is, we are still fully reforming, but the first such serious step will be taken , that is, everything will depend on whether he wants to this old planning structure of the court will block this process if they block it and they won't. then we will get the authority already in january. if they finish blocking it, then accordingly they will simply not elect these members. well, we will have to make the names of all those people who can block as well known will this block vadim's process? why do you think they went in different ways when they created the ethics council , respectively, and when they considere

journalist, has already launched it, and they should elect eight candidates to the supreme council of justicemeeting, for each time we try to explain why this is important, because in fact the supreme council of justice will decide what to do with such different unworthy judges because otherwise they have immunity and in principle we see how the same pavlo the wolf continues to laugh at this country and says that nothing will happen to him, so i want to say that vsevolod knyazov has already spoken in court. he is very good. he was elected in a good competition. he is a worthy judge of the supreme court of ukraine. of ukraine to the european union, in which country of russia, that is, he called on them to vote for worthy candidates, there is a fear that the judicial mafia, so to speak, will support unscrupulous candidates. i knew ukraine on a visit. good day. i congratulate you. by the way, it is very, very correct. what you said. good day. one ukrainian who grew up and was born and grew up outside our country once told me that if you say good morning after nine in the morning, then you will y

that is, in my opinion, this is absolutely true, moreover, during the reform of the supreme council of justicewhich was developed, among other things , by mr. international experts also have a voice in the ethics council , and at that time there were also arguments that this could encroach on the sovereignty of ukraine, but in the end only the subjects of appointment determined by the constitution are determined to appoint someone to the constitutional court or the supreme council of justice or not, that is, i do not see such a threat here. and what other organizations besides the venice commission should delegate their experts ? the ministry of foreign affairs actually has a list. and the strengthening of constitutional institutions, and constitutional justice, in particular, the european union, the osce and other similar organizations, there are actually not many of them. i just want to understand from whom in the near future we should expect comments and, well, the absence of delegates. and is there any reaction to the e-e statement in the venice commission on the part of the ukrainian e-e

coming days it must appoint three more members of the council according to its quota currently there are only seven members of the supreme council of justice the 21st and has been inactive for almost a year due to the absence of a sick person after the appointment of 8 new members of the council by the congress of judges, they will become 15. and this will finally allow the body to resume its work. the task of restoring the functioning of the highest body of judicial governance, we must fulfill this task. the supreme court of ukraine has started considering the cassation appeal and the sentence against the former judges of the holosiiv district court of kyiv, andrii novak and oleksandr bilyk, who were sentenced to seven and a half and seven years of imprisonment, respectively, according to the version of the investigation ex-judge novak, through the mediation of a former judge of the same court, bilyk, received $8,000 in illegal benefits for making a decision in a civil case, during a search of novak, it was discovered firearms and military supplies for which he did not have a permit, the son of the judge of the court of appeal of the kyiv

the 19th extraordinary congress of judges of ukraine elected all eight members of the supreme council of justice, this is good the news, the worst news is who exactly elected the judges, anti-corruption experts note, what is known about the updated composition of the supreme council of justice and who is inhibiting the judicial reform , which depends on the country's entry into the eu about today, after the force, they probably captured the city of soledar in donetsk region, this is stated in the current review of the american institute for the study of war. the ministry of defense of russia claims that full control over the city allows russia to cut off the supply routes of ukrainian forces in baku and to take into account the ukrainian military that remain in the city, the russian side also claims that in the last three days , more than 700 ukrainian soldiers were allegedly killed in soledar and another 300 pieces of weapons were allegedly destroyed. at the same time, the analysts of the institute for the study of war in the donetsk direction point out that the probable capture of soledar is u

countries of the group of seven, i would like to remind you that the formation of the supreme council of justice is one of the reforms on which ukraine's further movement towards the european union depends in general. well, now let's talk about the consequences of missile attacks of russians for the ukrainian economy, we are visiting oleksiy blinov, head of the analytical department of sensbank . i congratulate oleksiy, mr. andriy. i'm not mistaken, it's in english and on the forbes ukraine website in ukrainian in a slightly shortened version, and i was really interested in this research, we know that there were rocket attacks on our energy infrastructure and at the beginning economists once said that it will not have a very big impact, we will manage , but later on, the more shelling there was, the sadder the comments were, and economist oleksandr baklii says that it can be considered that this is one of those macro events of last year that affected the growth rates even there gdp how did you assess this impact? i understand that it is not easy to assess what the methodology was, see now this y

the congress of judges of ukraine elected five members of the supreme council of justice, a key body judicial system that is responsible for the professionalism , impartiality and integrity of the entire judicial corps, to the following positions yuliya bokova, judge of the economic court of donetsk oblast, alla kotelevets, judge of the kharkiv court of appeal, olga popikova, judge of the northern economic court of appeal, oleksandr sasevich, judge of the lviv district administrative court and judge of the supreme court, hryhoriy usyk , have been appointed for four years. according to its quota, the supreme council of justice currently has only seven members out of 21 and has been inactive for almost a year due to the absence of eight judges after being appointed by the congress there will be 15 new members of the council. and this will finally allow us to resume the work of the body. this task is to restore the functioning of the highest body of judicial governance. we have to fulfill this task . half and seven years of imprisonment, respectively, according to the version of the inv

of the council according to his quota. currently, the supreme council of justice has only seven members since the 21st and has been inactive almost a year due to the absence of a sick person after the appointment of 8 new council members by the congress of judges will make 15 of them. and this will finally allow us to resume the work of the body. this task is to restore the functioning of the highest body of judicial governance. we must complete this task. complaints against former judges of the holosiiv district court of kyiv, andrii novak and oleksandr bilyk, in which they were sentenced to seven and a half and seven years of imprisonment, respectively, according to the version of the investigation, ex-judge novak, with the mediation of the former judge of the same court, bilyk, received eight thousand dollars in illegal profit for the decision decision in a civil case during a search of a novice , firearms and military supplies were found for which he did not have the permission of the son and the court of appeal of the kyiv region valery finegaev evgeny finegaev was caught drunk driving again, this is not the first tim

00;00] we would stand in the way of the appointment of bondarenko as a member of the supreme council of justice, however, the congress of judges did not see any problems in this , we will carefully monitor all the decisions of the new composition of the supreme council of justice in the next program , we will introduce you to other members and tell you what they are hiding in their declarations. and if do you know the facts of corruption in the judicial system or have you yourself become a victim of illegal proceedings, let us know, write to me on facebook or to the e-mail you see on the screen it was judicial control and i , tatyana shustrova, will meet at espresso exactly in a week, news for your attention, my congratulations to everyone from espresso, the figure of the day 11 people died, 11 more were injured, these are the consequences of today's russian strikes by drones and missiles, the data will be made public by the spokesman of the state emergency service, oleksandr khorunchii, enemy hits were recorded in 11 regions, two people were killed as a result of enemy shelling of the kharkiv

through which we are now going through a component of which part is the formation of the supreme council of justice, well, this is the first and i would say the most responsible step on the way to restoring the trust of pre- judicial authorities for example, as this judge and if this supreme council of justice will bring such judges to justice and dismiss judges from their positions for violating the law, then society and every citizen will feel that the judiciary is changing, unfortunately, very often we have examples of honest judges are persecuted, dishonest judges are covered , and therefore there is no public trust in the pre- judicial authorities. we talked and showed about the trust in the judicial authorities. dzerzhynsky judges i don't know the law on decommunization since the 14th year, her name is daria kry, she was a fire adjuster herself from luhansk oblast in kharkiv, she is under investigation by the sbu and suspects that she was a adjuster, there is an indictment and a court about bail on bail and released on the eve of the new year there. almost uah 500,000 without much, but later

this was olena kononenko from the 19th congress of judges at which members of the supreme council of justice are elected, and we are moving on. president of ukraine volodymyr zelensky today in lviv oblast, the head of state began his visit of the most important commemoration of ukrainian soldiers killed in battles with the russian invaders, the ceremony took place on the field of mars of the lychakiv cemetery, in addition, zelensky held a coordination meeting, the main topic of which was the security situation in northwestern regions of ukraine, in particular, discussed the state of state border protection, the operational situation on the border with the republic of belarus, as well as controversial counter-sabotage measures. for the second time today, ombudsman dmytro lubinets held meetings with his russian colleague tetyana moskalkova in ankara, and the chief ombudsman of the republic of turkey, sherif , joined them. little about what exactly they talked about, so far they have not divulged, they limited themselves to general phrases , saying that on the agenda are humanitarian problems a

yuriy good morning so, last week there was important news regarding the formation of the high council of justice this is a self-governing body of judges, and here at the meeting the judges finally elected representatives to this council, it seems eight people e-e voted, but here you know the situation better than i do, you even wrote about it, at least you wrote about it on your facebook, eh, are you satisfied with what happened, eh? well , unfortunately, it turned out that the solution is good. but in essence, it's treason this is how the paradoxical story came out. the supreme council of justice is the judicial body which, let's say, punishes bad judges. you know this is the existing structure within the system. without this body, the fact is that it is very difficult to even bring judges to criminal liability within the framework of the system. corruption proceedings of law enforcement agencies, and this body did not work in our country for a very long time because there were not enough people elected to it, and they were waiting for the congress of judges to be preserved and elect their own

find a common language in particular, with judicial authorities such as the updated supreme council of justice, which a-a put forward simply e-e maximum cynical and incomprehensible remarks, which in essence e-e if they are accepted and if you agree with them, then this part of justice, which is in the state anti-corruption law it can be crossed out and forgotten about it, and that is why these demands remain, they will be presented to the government committee, and the committee and the government will decide whether to agree with the absolutely absurd remarks of the supreme council of justice or whatever let it pass as it is, and this ordinary committee, according to my information, will be held the day after tomorrow, but in fact, most of the bodies that put forward comments, they removed them, these remarks were agreed with them , and they supported the text, they supported the state anti-corruption program. therefore in fact, we now see sabotage only from the judicial authorities and from the anti-monopoly committee, which says about the anti-corruption program, of course, it is great, but

the big seven were expecting, i would like to remind you that the formation of the supreme council of justice is one of the reforms on which the further movement of ukraine towards the european union depends in general. well, now let's talk about the consequences of russian missile attacks on the ukrainian economy we are visiting oleksiy blinov, the head of the analytical department of sensbank. i congratulate oleksiiv. greetings, mr. andriy, the owner, why did we turn to this topic , because i saw your large study, uh, with your colleague, i understand so where are the other economists on the vox sens website, if i’m not mistaken, in english and on the forbes ukraine website in ukrainian in a slightly shortened version, and i was really interested in this research, we know that there were rocket attacks on our energy infrastructure, and at the beginning the economists somehow said that it was not will have a very big impact, we will manage, but later on, the more shelling there was, the sadder the comments were, and economist oleksandr batliy says that it can be considered that this is one o

first, to the news, the 19th congress of judges of ukraine elected five members of the supreme council of justicea key body of the judicial system that is responsible for professionalism, impartiality and integrity yuliya bokova, judge of the economic court of donetsk region, alla kotelevets, judge of the kharkiv court of appeal, olga popikova, judge of the northern commercial court of appeal, oleksandr sasevich, judge of the lviv district administrative court and judge of the supreme court, hryhoriy usyk . for almost a year, she has been out of authority due to the absence of a sick person. after the congress of military judges appointed new members of the council, they will become 15 . governing, we have to fulfill this task , the supreme court of ukraine has begun considering the cassation appeal against the sentence of former judges of the holosiiv district court of kyiv, andrii novak and oleksandr bilyk, who were sentenced to seven and a half and seven years of imprisonment, respectively, according to the version of the investigation of ex-judge novak, with the mediation of the former the ju

the brother of the judge and the new member of the supreme council of justice , tetyana bondarenko, citizens of the russian federation, however, the judge rejects the accusation of ties with a relative, a citizen of the terrorist country, regarding the emergency operation in the soviet union with my brother. er, over time, she did not communicate with pivdenny once on the phone and at 32, when the aggression began, she really beat her. it is also known that tetyana bondarenko has a sister who often visits russia, of course she is new a member of the people's party of ukraine is not responsible for the actions of her relatives, however, the presence of family ties with citizens of russia, which has unleashed a full-scale war against our country and kills our citizens every day, together with other ambiguous facts, the judge's biography should stand in the way of appointing bondarenko as a member of the supreme for the sake of justice, however, the congress of judges did not see a problem in this, we will carefully monitor all the decisions of the new members of the vrp in the next program, we

, in particular, and for example, from the people who elect judges there now to the supreme council of justicee president, which keeps such people as the user is in some official positions and so on and so forth from those investigations, for example, by the national police, which closes the case against the tailor, and then even this is not reported anywhere, and there are still no official comments, well, in a word, this is all part of our future victory, because it forges it not only at the front, although first of all there, thanks to this victory, we have a chance to become a successful country, but this chance can, i apologize for fucats, even defeat the russian federation at the same time and still lose as the country is something that must be remembered, and the war continues. actually, the journalist esprellya berezenko is several

march, in fact, there is still a month left until september. to restore the work of the high council of justicend the supreme qualification commission of judges of the supreme court of justice. that is , these are self-governing bodies of judicial power. igor, what items perhaps interested you the most and what did you pay attention to? i would usually talk about structural reforms and effective management. assigned to the ukrainian customs, we talk about the fact that this is such a problematic area of ​​the ukrainian state administration, i would draw attention to it, besides, we are talking about improving the management of large state companies know that such a reform began, then it stopped a little in connection with covid, then the war. but nevertheless, the issue was and remains important, as is the adoption of a plan with deregulation and improvement of the business climate. i think that this is an element not only of aid to ukraine, but actually preparation for the future reconstruction , because the european union and ukraine are interested in receiving not only state funds of interna

the candidates you saw fortunately no longer participate in the competition for the supreme council of justice, however, they still have high powers as judges, despite a very dubious reputation, large fortunes of unknown origin and a large number of disciplinary proceedings regarding judicial decisions for them as well as for judicial reform in general. we will continue to monitor and in the new year, may 2023 bring us victory and many happiness, we will meet in exactly a week , will there be additional mobilization in the russian federation and rammstein 8 greetings dear tv viewers, it is time to learn about the most important news at this moment, i will start with the damn dozen of the moscow patriarchate. the president of ukraine suspended the citizenship of thirteen priests by his decree. all of them are representatives of the ukrainian orthodox church of moscow of the patriarchate this is also reported with reference to the publication's own sources, the left bank among these priests and vinnytsia metropolitan polit ioan-fan, who was searched by the security service of ukraine last year,

example, judges were finally elected in our country, you probably followed that up to the supreme council of justicefor ukraine in fact, it is a victory. this includes becoming a member of the european union faster and everything and away from moscow, but well, they voted from fertilizer, well, they voted from bad, they elected eight candidates, the worst ones that ever existed. among them, they elected this judge burlakov, who worked all his life with the party of regions with all his patrons. well, it is clear that the person has worked so well that he no longer fits into the cadre. in principle to react and everyone said that you can't do that well, let's somehow elect some normal people anyway, but some kind of judicial mafia remains, or should we be philosophical about it ? a beautiful man, handsome yes, what do you say about this? i think it is from trying to control all branches of government, we understand that the office of the president now controls both the government and the parliament. it is clear that there is no majority in the parliament, but they get there with these different group

fortunately, the candidates you saw are no longer participating in the competition for the supreme council of justice, however still have high powers as judges despite a very dubious reputation, large fortunes of unknown origin and a large number of disciplinary proceedings regarding judicial decisions against them as well as judicial reform in general. we will continue to monitor in the new year. may 2023 bring us victory and a lot of happiness. we will meet in exactly one week in ukraine. 5:00 p.m. news release on the espresso tv channel in the studio of iryna koval. greetings to all viewers of the tragedy in the kherson region in the city of boryslav the whole family died, and a 12-year-old boy and his parents were killed, a russian shell hit their house, the head of the regional military administration, yaroslav yanushevich, also reported that in the morning kherson was also hit, according to detailed information there an 18-year-old boy was killed, the attackers attacked the central part of the city, they targeted a house, also at the beginning of the day, the attackers with artillery hit cherno

what is the ethical council of justice ? to do a-and it takes six months to conditionally explain in order to ok we now understand how important it is we now understand how important it is to look after each candidate and put pressure on vlad to choose good people thank you polymerist mark savchuk advisor on anti-corruption policy dance axes and public control holo was with us well, the marathon continues, we will return with andrii seychuk very soon now it's time for news ulyana panasiuk their story to us ulyana to you a word congratulations again colleagues in this issue about the situation with light to ukraine and also where did the russian board find shelter and at the end we will have a connection from the capital, however, how to save people who fell under the ice do not miss 11 o'clock in ukraine news veteri espresso in the studio ulyana panasyuk works, congratulations, emergency power outages have already begun in a number of regions of ukraine, because electricity consumption has increased. the reason for the decre

most important bodies in the judicial system are currently being formed - this is the supreme council of justicearted , to which, unfortunately , the most virtuous members were chosen representatives of the congress of judges. we'll see. it's still a little early to talk about the quality of her work, but a very important litmus test will be who they choose for the 16th match as members of the higher qualification commission of judges, because the competition is currently underway, and they actually have to appoint the finalists of the 32 16 members this is going to be a very important piece of paper and a whole lot of money, and these two bodies should appoint us in the near future somewhere around 2.5 or at least a thousand judges for those vacant positions that have been in the ukrainian judicial system for 10 years and this will be this a very high rate and it will change the ukrainian judicial system forever or preserve it in this form for 30 years. well, one more topic regarding the draft law. well, this is already a law on increasing responsibility for the military with e-e. what was sign

beneath the diplomatic surface. mcfadden, he stumbled on al jazeera ah fierce department of justice names a special council to investigate the discovery of classified documents in president jo biden's, home and former office. ah phillips, the whole robin you're watching over like my headquarters here in dall also coming up standing up against al shabba protest is in somalia. and so the government's call to demonstrate against the armed group. you're going says its troops are holding off against a fierce russian offensive in the town of salida. but warns the situation is difficult. 2 ah, not blinking down the boulders of perused al stood president bedra castillo a back on the streets, demanding new elections. ah, welcome to the program. a special council has been appointed to investigate us present. joe biden's handling of sensitive government documents. a 2nd set of papers has been found this time at his private home in delaware, the 1st batch of files was uncovered at one of the biden's former offices 2 months ago. both only made public on monday, a white house correspondent, kimberly how kit reports. the

s. department of justice names a special council to investigate the discovery of classified documents and precedent. jo biden's, home and former office. ah, hello moneys, are you the sound? is there a lie from java also coming up, standing up against al shabani purchases in somalia on so the government's call to demonstrate against the armed group. ukraine says its troops a holding off against a fierce russian offensive in the town with sonata along the situation is difficult . i. 2 not backing down supposes of peruse, austan president peddler castillo a back on the streets, demanding new elections. ah, for hello, and welcome to the program. a special council has been appointed to investigate us president joe biden's handling of sensitive government documents. a 2nd set of papers has been found this time at his private home in delaware. the 1st batch of files was on covet at one of biden's former offices 2 months ago, but was only made public on monday on whitehouse correspond, can be hook, it has the story. the discovery of a 2nd batch of classified documents. this time inside the ga

s. department of justice names a special council to investigate the discovery of classified documents and president jo biden's ho, i'm full, my office. ah, i money inside this is out there, alive from day hall was that coming up? ukraine says its troops are holding off against a fierce russian offensive in the town of sala dog. a wound. the situation is difficult. standing up against alger, bob protesters in somalia on so the government's cool to demonstrate against iams group shlang because former president is fined for failing to prevent the east to sunday bomb attacks 3 years ago. the killed will take on 2 people. ah, hello, welcome to the program, a special council house been appointed to investigate the discovery of classify government documents at u. s. president jo biden's home. now the 1st batch was uncovered 2 months ago. their existence was only made public on monday. the documents i believe, to be linked to biden's time as vice president. and i reported to include us intelligence linked to ukraine. iran and the united kingdom. the white house press secretary says bought and