a march 2015 email shows clinton aides trying to decide whether to turn over the president's emails with clinton which certainly implies that think had some sort of communications on her nongovernmental email account. >> did the president lie there? >> >> well, i don't know. i actually do not know. >> with wikileaks founder julian assange promising, he has got more emails that

that moons all the deleted emails, 33,000 emails looking for, if she was backing up her entire device to her laptop, then she has all of them and she knows she has all of them. kennedy: she admitted under questioning that she never delete ad thing. i don't know if she is guilty as that. anthony could be technical one, go ahead, let me handle this. i will make it easy for you, when you come home from work you open up your laptop, all of your contacts will be here. maybe he didn't tell her all emails were there. i don't give her that much benefit of the doubt. i think it was personally motivated by anthony weiner. maybe he knew this was bargaining chip that he could play in a sink -- >> bret baier reported from some incredible sources while anthony weiner is not cooperating with the fbi, that is, he is not sitting down and talking to them, he has been croptive because he handed over the laptop are -- cooperative. they didn't have to go to the grand jury get a subpoena, they didn't have to go to a federal judge to get a search warrant. harris: nasty divorce case. >> his problems are far

both sides at this point are saying release the emails, release the emails, both democrats and republicans. that is not likely though, right? this is evidence in a new case that the fbi has to go over. then again we're in uncharted territory. so what do you think? reporter: they didn't release emails before and in the first investigation so i doubt they will do it now. and it is politics, right? so, with a lot on the line. melissa: yeah. wow. all right. peter barnes, there you go. what next? we have no idea. we'll see. david? david: there is other breaking news by the way. this fire on the american airlines plane at o'hare in chicago. the flight 383 was headed to miami according to officials. it was going down the runaway when it encountered engine issues. passengers have been deplaned. so it appears all is well. bring in today's market panel to talk about what's happened today, which is really monumental. steve forbes, chairman and editor-in-chief of forbes media and one time presidential candidate himself jack hough from "barron's" and john petrides, point view welt management. steve wha

having reviewed tens of thousands of emails and found, had will new emails that are not primarily bylary clinton but are more from an aide change that and suddenly in a smoking gun way find intent? that's unlikely h. not impossible. but what would show intent? i guess you could have an aide say hillary told me she wants to release classified information or an e-mail from hillary saying that. is that likely? absolutely not. again, this letter is trying to do something that may be legally appropriate, which is carefully update congress on facts as they change but was written so poorly or criyptically that it is distorting the story. ten days from the election, that's not a good thing. that's why everyone from mike pence on "hardball" to hillary clinton are asking for more information. >> and same, members of congress saying director comey, give us information or make a statement. over the weekend is what they're calling. nbc's chief legal correspondent, thank you. >>> to the latest polling numbers. with ten days to go, donald trump's path to victory hinges on locking the battleground s

quote: this is a legitimate email.needs to change his password immediately and ensure the authentication is turned. he can go to this link to do both it is absolutely imperative that this is done a. sap. if you or he has any questions please reach out to me. it seems podesta rather than using the fresh link sent to him by the it team instead kicked on the one in the bogus email opening the door to his personal email account and he is not mincing words about who he thinks is responsible. >> the russians and the u.s. senior members of the u.s. government confirmed have been hacking in to democratic accounts and now they have hacked into my account. >> that bogus email to podesta is dated march 19th. and all the material we have seen in from the wikileaks releases seems to stop right around that time. begging the question whether podesta or the team realized he had actually been hacked relatively quickly after it happened and took further precautions. brit? >> shannon, thank you. if you are going trick-or-treating or even

that is how the fbi found out about these new emails.y had a separate investigation going on into his sexting and they found all of these emails that they believe tie back to the hillary clinton investigation. and what they're trying to get at is two things. number one, are these emails back and forth between huma abedin and hillary clinton, maybe? they could also be back and forth with other staffers within the campaign or any number of people. so we don't know an answer to that, number one, number two, we don't know whether or not there is classified information in those emails. that's what they are really trying to get at. remember, fbi director james comey in giuliani had extraordinary news conference as we wait for hillary clinton maybe to have one in a few moments. his news conference in july here in washington, he laid out all of these allegations and suggested that, in fact, hillary clinton had mishandled classified information. >> suggested? he said it. >> said that but there is not enough here for there to be criminal charges.

that is where these emails are.eve there are some emails on there that may relate back to the original hillary clinton email scandal. as soon as we get more i will get it to you. former republican senator from florida, george lemieux, and former democrat governor from new york, david paterson. the pile on continues, or is it? is it worse for huma abedin? can hillary's camp divert it away from her. >> i have some bad news here, liz. i think the cubs will win last two games of the world series. liz: you know what? get off the set. [laughter]. >> you know, this is situation where the one thing -- liz: by the way, that is called diverting, what you just did. >> yeah. the diversion in this campaign would be, that each time the two candidates debated, it appeared hillary got the edge in the polls afterward. it doesn't matter who won the debate, it is who became more popular. i think the advice for diversion might be right here, for a candidate to say, listen, there have been two candidates in very short period of time bef

again back on the of a private email server. the source of the emails is the other big surprise here. nbc news has learned they didn't come from clinton's server or even wikileaks, but rather were found on a computer belonging to anthony wiener. the estranged husband of clinton's long-time aide houma abedin. and a target of a sexting investigation. clinton came before the cameras to call on the fbi to immediately release all the information it has. nbc's justice correspondent pete >> reporter: nearly four months after saying its investigation of hillary clinton's e-mail server was over and recommending no charges, fbi director james comey today said new emails have come to light. in a letter to congress, he said the emails surfaced in an unrelated case and quote appear to be pertinent to the investigation. he said the fbi cannot yet assess whether or not this material may be significant. and that agents will now determine whether the emails contain classified information. and evaluate their importance. unrelated case is. but law

>> look at the wikileaks email. >> the number of leaked emails today crossed the 33,000 mark as the latest dump showed top advisors scampering to deal with the fallout from the email scandals that broke from the 2015. with one former clinton aid at the state department trying an everybody does it defense. writing everyone i knew at state used their private email when we were out of the office except for blackberries which were state issued because the system was so incredibly clunky. except that suggest the refusal to comply with federal record keeping laws were more widespread and you clinton's leadership at the state department. rather than use that defense the former secretary of state first told the public she only relied on personal email for official business because she wanted to carry one electronic device. >> when i got to work, as secretary of state, i opted for convenience to use my personal email account. >> although that tenure of the first news conference was do down play the controversy. three days earlier told ryan there is just no good answer on how to explain the server.

the emails appear to show in august of last year, months after the email scandal blew up clinton's aides were struggling how to convince her to apologize for it all. julie, i have to come to you first, our democrat on the couch. you have not liked since the beginning this was messy. hot miss what they're saying. >> it's a hot mess. i'm glad they were saying in private what i was saying in public. this is all revealed. this is hot mess. she never have done it. when it was revealed she had done it and she should have come out apologized and she made a mistake. i said this all along, she has allergy to saying she's sorry. that is their words not mine. i may be paraphrasing. they did ask her to do that and she ultimately did it. i get her frustration. same frustration she and other democrats think about this this was calculated decision to do this. once you did it you should have it and apologized for it and moved own hopefully. harris: guy, one of the other things we learned about the emails, that president obama knew about this, and chatter in the background among the same people how you c

for the release of the emails. director's comey's letter refers to emails in an unrelated case. the director himself knows they may not be significant. clinton arrived in iowa. she didn't mention the new probe. she focussed her message in getting out the vote. >> donald trump says he can still win and he's right. unusual election. >> reporter: nbc news reports there are likely thousands of emails to examine. there's no reason to believe anyone was with holding anything. clinton's campaign calling the timing of this extraordinary. >> it boggles the mind why the step was taken with 11 days to go. >> anchor: hillary clinton addressing this latest email scandal. >> sent or received. >> we have anyone. first we knew about it is i assume when you knew about it. when this letter sent to republican members of the house was released. so we don't know the facts which is why we are calling on the fbi to release all the information that it has. even director comey noted that this new information may not be significant. so let's get it out. >> secretary clinton. >> you have 11 days to go. wh

this i don't know where this email -- where these emails came from. >> apparently tony weiner. >> well the question is the clinton campaign imploding? more ahead ♪ tell me lies ♪ tell me lies ♪ tell me, tell me lies ♪ you can't despise ♪ you can't disguise ♪ no, you can't disguise ♪ tell me lies ♪ tell me sweet little lies ... built a life for my family... ... and liked to help others in need. but i couldn't bear my diabetic nerve pain any longer. so i talked to my doctor and he prescribed lyrica. nerve damage from diabetes causes diabetic nerve pain. lyrica is fda-approved to treat this pain, from moderate to even severe diabetic nerve pain. lyrica may cause serious allergic reactions or suicidal thoughts or actions. tell your doctor right away if you have these, new or worsening depression, or unusual changes in mood or behavior. or swelling, trouble breathing, rash, hives, blisters, muscle pain with fever, tired feeling or blurry vision. common side effects are dizziness, sleepiness, weight gain and swelling of hands, legs, and feet. don't drink alcohol while taking lyrica. don't dr

is carrying out a new investigation into her emails as part of its probe into a private email server. they want to see if emails contained classified information. donald trump was in new hampshire and he immediately pounced on the news. for weeks he had based much of his campaign on referring to her as crooked hillary. >> they are reopening the case into her criminal and illegal conduct. that threatens the security of the united states of america >> the republican candidate went on to say, this is bigger than watergate. the news came in a letter from the director of the f.b.i. to members of congress. i agree, he wrote, that the f.b.i. should take appropriate steps designed to allow investigators to review these emails to determine whether they contain classified information. the f.b.i. says it doesn't know whether the material is significant or how long its investigation will take. this inquiry goes back to the time that hillary clinton was secretary of state and used a private email server. in july after a long inquiry, the f.b.i. closed the case. >> although there is evidence of pot

this email was not on her server.ector has been little vague about that and he should come out and actually clarify this even more. but this whole issue has been exploited by the republican party as well as clinton campaign. >> what do you think comey's motives are. >> i don't think he has any nefarious motives. it is incumbent on him since people are very confused to come out. the letter was too vegas. it'sen exploited by the trump campaign and couple members of congress. >> he recommend nod further indictment and indictment from the doj and for now to go and take the massive step of saying let's start reexpecting some of these we found new information, there has got to be some there there, doesn't there. >> it's incumbent upon him not to just stay silent with you to actually explain himself. this is where the hillary campaign has been very clear they want him to explain more and release information back as soon as possible. they have nothing to hide. >> he said new evidence pertaining to hillary clinton's email. not

this email was not on her server. the director has been little vague about that and he should come out and actually clarify this even more. but this whole issue has been exploited by the republican party as well as clinton campaign. >> what do you think comey's motives are. >> i don't think he has any nefarious motives. it is incumbent on him since people are very confused to come out. the letter was too vegas. it'sen exploited by the trump campaign and couple members of congress. >> he recommend nod further indictment and indictment from the doj and for now to go and take the massive step of saying let's start reexpecting some of these we found new information, there has got to be some there there, doesn't there. >> it's incumbent upon him not to just stay silent with you to actually explain himself. this is where the hillary campaign has been very clear they want him to explain more and release information back as soon as possible. they have nothing to hide. >> he said new evidence pertaining to hillary clinton's em

clearly she didn't ever expect her emails to be in the light. i will tell you a lot of them, it is not adding up to a lot for me but the ones that do are crushing it. for example, yesterday the podesta stuff, podesta and, kim strassel wrote an op-ed in today's "wall street journal," lead op-ed, talking about this relationship between teneo a corporation set up as a pr/lobbying firm, to unite, access bill clinton with these big donors, coca-cola, ubs, dow chemical. $19 million goes through teneo and ends up in bill clinton's pocket. these are massives massive crony agreements. kim draws the line, the clintons don't have the line. blurred line between what is charitable activities and what goes right into the clinton covers and i think that is really damaging stuff. not necessarily who they like, who they don't like, four white guys running campaign. harris: i also see a tremendous collateral damage that we are keeping up with now. she didn't even care about her own people. they didn't know what was going on but would be tasked with defending her.

we saw the email between podesta and cheryl mills on potus and emails.his seems to contradict something president obama said he first heard about the clinton email server through press reports but, clearly he was using or sending to that server emails long before the press knew about it. >> you know, this is so true. these emails are so damning. i mean, give the attention to the trump sex scandal which is more titillating than you know, what is going on right now with the barrage of emails that wikileaks is producing, but if you really look into this, this is such a blatant, you know, ordeal of cover-up and delaying and protecting hillary rodham clinton. this is so on just and in plain sight we can all see. david: there is a pattern. when we see hundreds of one particular types of documents we look for pattens. there is a pattern. richard obviously the democrats are pointing a pattern of behavior now with trump and women. isn't there also, isn't it fair to say you see a the pattern of behavior of misinforming when it comes to emails, when it comes to the

[booing] let's see. 30,000, 33,000 emails deleted, right? i would bet she had three for yoga and maybe five for the wedding, right? what about the rest? she had no defense when i brought up her failures in iraq, syria, and libya. she had no defense when i brought up her failures as a senator from new york promising to create the 200,000 jobs for upstate new york but instead the jobs were shipped to mexico and other countries. she had no defense for calling on millions of americans and then saying that they were deplorable, that is you, deplorable, me, all of them. [booing] you know what is worse? irredeemable! which is worse? would you rather be deplorable? irredeemable means you have no chance, right? deplorable and irredeemable. i don't think so. i think we have the greatest people on earth. the smartest people. [cheers and applause] we have the most loyal people. that is one thing. every poll points out that, boy trump's people, it is like the most loyal ever. one thing i know, we'll get out and vote and we're going to be voting and, you

it's not as though they didn't know anything in the emails. they stumbled upon them, found they seem to be pertinent to the clinton email server investigation and that is why -- >> seemed to be pertinent, not significant, 11 days before the election. is that something you toss on the table or do you take the time to do what other prosecutors have done in the past and make sure that it is so significant that you had to go forward with it. i don't fault him for taking a look at whatever he's found, we don't really know what that is but at this stage having taken the steps he ought to explain if he thinks it's significant or not significant let us come forward and say why. >> do you accept the fundamental premise that the reason we're here is because hillary clinton and her inner circle not including you made a horrible decision to set up her private email server and everything that has happened since then is her fault? >> well look, i think she's apologized for setting up an email server, said it was a mistake, said she wouldn't do it over again

and looking at emails related to hillary clinton's use of private email server. justice department came out saying they will put all available resources looking to emails. back in july the agency cleared her of any wrong doing. here's what both candidates had to say about this -- >> i have to give fbi credit that was so bad what happened originally and it took guts for director comb dwroy make the direct director comey making the move in light of what he had to face in light of criminal prosecution. has spop about this as well. her camp is none too happy of what was wrong. is comey a scapegoat for the clinton controversy and is it overshadowing election day. >> let's bring in ronica cleary. what are people saying about this? >> it's interesting i know you played donald trump having a change of heart if you will about the fbi director james comey and that's definitely what we're hearing from the democrats as well in reverse. when the news first came out back in july that hillary clinton would not -- there would not be charges against her for use of private email s

email. slug, the head lion of the email was sometimes i get the questions in advance.s written by donna brazil. what kind of answer was this for the head of one of our two political parties to give? >> well, you have to consider the context in which all this happened. this was in march she was contributor at cnn scwels abc news and vice chair at the democratic national committee it's posh to note at the time there were complaints and worries amongst the people at the sanders camp and people supported sanders that clinton was being treated more favorablably and the system was rigged against them. of course we had the separate wikileaks exposure during the summer showed sort of collaborating to sort of help hillary clinton along. now we have. this we have donna brazil, an arm part of the dnc helping out hillary clinton ahead of a town hall. and who was this town hall with? bernie sanders. so it gave her an advantage over bernie sanders. you have to put all these pieces together and then you get a better picture of what was actually going on during the primary within the

emails to him. that doesn't mean that he necessarily knew that she had a home-brew server in her house running a whole separate email chain and didn't ever use state dot-gov emails. so he has plausible deniability on that count. bill: quickly, do you see why the fbi did not prosecute? into. >> yay? bill: or do you ask yourself why not. >> james comey basically said it in between the lines. his point was everybody knew, his first defense witness in the prosecution would be who? president of the united states. followed by secretary of defense. followed by head of nsa. a who's who of the obama administration and across the national security apparatus of the federal government because everybody knew. they let her get away with it. in the end you can't come back in well you let her get away with it for years but now we'll prosecute for it. the chief magistrate of the united states knew about it and. bill: we'll look for a little bit of redemption, sir. the reverend, chris stirewalt, see you soon. martha.

a day after that email exchange.his email, that reads in part, fy it, the idea of using private security experts to arm the opposition should be considered. >> i can assure you that these operations did take place and those weapons did go in different directions. >> who got these weapons? was it al qaeda? was it ansar al-sharia? was it isis in the end? >> all of them. all of them. all of them. reporter: he says he never got the contract or sold the weapons. instead it went through two gulf nations with the state department in the lead in that is why it spun out of the control because there wasn't proper vetting on the ground in libya you with some weapons going essentially to america's enemies and others heading to syria, martha. martha: incredible. was she asked about this, catherine? reporter: in fact clinton was pressed on weapons issue during her 2013 benghazi testimony. >> were any of these weapons being transferred to other countries, any countries, turkey included? >> senator, you will have to direct that ques

a fishing email? some news reports say yes. i want to report our fox news colleague is reporting on him and his former sister-in-law who happens to be a major campaign fundraiser for hillary clinton in 2012, to lobby for the company when hillary was secretary of state. on podesta was a senior advisor, states must approve sales of us military equipment to foreign countries. raytheon won 14 military sales contracts with $26 billion in the last few quarters of 2012, breakdown paid heather podesta $100,000 according to records. they don't see any laws, when asked about the circumstances state department spokesman said, quote, the only considerations factored into military sales programs, furtherance of foreign policy objectives of the us and not the lobby to influence that decision. sent james a short email saying i never lobbied the secretary or john podesta on this matter. neil: they knew who she was. thank you very much. chris bedford on what he makes. what do you have here? >> the only bombshell out o

the emails reveal it was clear. they said we have to find a sympathetic host, that would be george receive open louse. be -- george stephanopoulos. there was an email where they say we got him to do our bidding. and that's i think what's so trouble being these media emails. some of the names you kinds of expected. you know which reporters seem to be on the side. lou: nbc news, et cetera. >> but some are pretty surprising that you didn't anticipate to have this cozy relationship. we are not talking about just sort of being collegial. we are talking about sharing information. lou: what surprised you most? >> i think number one, we are going to dean interview but we'll let you decide what's going to happen. number two, the bureau chief of the "washington post" say we are running this story on lobbying but we won't caulk about this case involving you. there is only a single line where we are discussing you. come on, you are supposed to speak truth to power. that's bowing before the throne. lou: it is so many things. pet

you know myrrha emailed john podesta, do we know who told hillary clinton she can use a private emailt apology in that locker room talk. no apology to the khans. >> who told her? >> i don't know who told her. i know she's said a mistake. donald trump, i don't think anything was a mistake. as to whether she wrote the words or not, it's not funny steve and it's not a joke, 17 of our u.s. intelligence agencies -- >> which we have reported. >> -- have confirmed that these leaks came from the russians and that mr. putin has interfered in our election process. were it to the benefit of a democrat, can you imagine what republicans were saying? >> you want to come on and say your speak. >> thank you for being fair, steve. you always are. >> we try to do that here on the show. fair and balanced, our opinion, plus some details. we'll take a quick time-out. larry sabato is joining us eight days out. how could the email thing change the race? we'll talk about that next. and cherna is their dirty little piggy bank. we're going to insert into the country while nobody is looking. we're going to stea

content. >> there is much concern about the emails.hillary's word they're deplorable, they're insulting, more than that they're frightening they reveal a clinton administration would continue antipathy of, marginalization of christians really begun by barack obama. remember it was obama who called people of faith es, those who bitterly cling to their guns and bibles. i think these emails show clinton and her officials if she is elected will have the same attitude towards people of faith. melissa: to be fair, it wasn't written by her. it was written by jennifer palmieris a top lieutenant in her campaign. in her part, when she was cornered about it, she doesn't quote, recognize the email. it kind of plays to the whole theme that we've seen in all of these emails where there is the private hillary clinton, hang on, who thinks one thing and then there is public person who says something else like that she is tolerant of all religions? >> that's exactly right and that's the hypocrisy of all of this. look, this is a part of a bigger narrativ

they want all emails and less women. amy: right. this letter that james comey sent went to folks up on the hill. in charge of investigative committees. what are we hearing from capitol hill? and the bottom line, we don't know anything yet. and how long is it going to be before we find out what's in there? >> you'll be shocked to know that members of congress are using this for partisan gain. on the republican side, what we've heard is a can could havify of -- can could have if -- can could haveny of voices saying that the investigation has been reopened. the investigation has not been reopened because it was never technically closed. on the other hand, we don't know what these emails actually are. a lot of news media outlets raced to say that it had been reopened. they walked them back as more details came out. as they more closely read the letter. members of congress, especially on the republican side, did not. the letter was -- i first saw it come out from jason chaff etc.'s office. he's going to be the chairman of the house overs

and he authenticated the email. a feud in 2011 between doug bands at clinton foundation and chelsea clinton saying she is acting like a spoiled brat kid who has nothing else to do except to justify what she's doing because she hasn't found her way and a focus in her life. john podesta says i'm not happy about being hacked by the russians to throw the election to donald trump. liz: we have sarah huckabee and materials. what do you think of this new batch of emails? >> i think it's bad news for hillary clinton. it tells us what a lot of people have known about hillary clinton for a long time. she is a complete fraud. she lives one life in public and another life in private. one of the big takeaways is she is completely and totally controlled by special interests. i think wall street owns her and that's a big problem in an election where 70% of americans are looking for change. she represents everything wrong with washington and this was bad moment for her. >> for keystone, fracking, prove trade. later on the show we'l

director comb may said they found emails pertinent to the clinton email investigation. charlie gasparino, they have not looked at the emails to, just te met at that data, right? >> right. just the metadata i put a interesting timeline how we got hillary clinton being exonerated in july by james comey or retention and use of private email server, whether he broke the law or not based on evidence at hand, which essentially is reopening of the an investigation. and it began with anthony weiner. here is what is interesting about it. we know what came out with anthony weiner. follow the timeline. it basically started when i believe in august anthony weiner was supposed in a british tap lloyd for sexting a 15-year-old girl in north carolina. that is -- state, which becomes is a federal issue -- over state. they investigate it right up front. they find there is legitimate cause for concern there. by the way the child abuse aspect of the department of the new york city police department began the investigation. they find there is a legitimate complainant in the woman. that is w

i don't want to sort through 300 emails. i want to sort through three million emails.now those folks have some connection to target of intelligence, target of a criminal investigation. so, it's a philosophy but i think they're going about this wrong. they have to be more narrow what they do because i think legally it will be better. but just as an american citizen, do you want government going through your trash, email, your house, all at the same time? jenna: to finish up, they could be scanning for anything. for example, if they decided they were going to scan for the term fox news, for example, then all emails that had fox news in it would get caught up in this collection? >> yes. let's talk about that real quickly too. say they're scanning for term obviously related to terrorism. what if i'm a researcher, if i'm a student simply looking up information because i'm writing paper or reporter researching that topic, am i now flagged, put into a system, am i put into a bucket they will take extra level of scrutiny for simply engaging what is supposedly constitutionally-

let's talk about some of the hacked emails that were released. we saw some information regarding elizabeth warren in those emails and it showed that at one point the staffers were considering flip-flopping on bank regulation to earn warren's support. th really incredible. she is the game changer in the democratic party but it also shows that hillary needs to mend some serious fences with the liberal wing of the party even if she does win. she's basically given liberals very little in this campaign. liberals were expecting that at least maybe have elizabeth warren as a running mate or some other liberal in the party but she appointed a moderate in kaine. so liberals are pretty angry right now. but will they be angry enough and that i don't think is possible given trump. >> these emails also showed that the clinton campaign, they were worried that warren was going to endorse bernie sanders. >> right, and who knows. that might have made a huge difference in the primaries. she is the queen makener this case, in the party. >> if clinton wins, does she

mora -- mora -->> hillary emails. we have seen, talk radio says there standing by for press conference with hillary clinton the local iowa press was not invite -- invited to attend. we will keep you eye on that it we know that. campaign chair talked about the emails earlier today. when she was here, she was over the market talk about something incredibly important to cedar rapids residents, flood protection. the spoke at the market where just a month ago it was a town because it was the flood evacuation area. clinton said of she gets into the white house she will push the permanent flood protection that cedar rapids needs but that has been held up for years. >> the process that you have made in rebuilding cedar rapids especially right here in the newbo district proves what is possible when we work latest information about what the campaign is saying about the emails that were just released from her press conference in des moines. we also taking a look at how they are pulling out all of the stops with just 11 days unti

the fbi has obtained a new warrant to review the emails related to hillary clinton's ivate email server. those emails were found on a device shared between disgraced former congressman's wiener's sexting scandal. the couple are now separated. director comey is taking a look at emails that may be pertinent into the secretary of state's handling due to the emails, which he announced via a letter to congressional republicans on friday. and this morning, former attorney general erick holder with aew opedcalling him a mistake. writing quote he has made a serious error with implications and now a new poll shows hillary clinton just one point above donald trump. it comes as both clinton and trump made the renewed investigation the very center of the campaign. >> we never thought we were going to say thank you to anthony wiener. this is the biggest political scandal since water gate. >> the director he doesn't know whether the emails referenced in his letter are significant or not. >> in fact, it's not just strange, it's unprecedented and deeply troubling. >> hillary clinton is not the victim.

emails.eeing two different hillary clintons. you are seeing strong ally of israel, do whatever i can in her speeches. in private they are saying let's not be too trofng an ally publicly. that will hurt us with the left. we have seen that again and again when the wall street transcripts come out. why did she do that? when she was talking to goldman sachs for hundreds of thousands of dollars per speech. she wiewls saying you need a public and private position for things like trade. she also sort of down played her support for wall street saying we had to do dodd-frank for political reasons. finally telling the wall street bankers, that's the opposite of what she said. so can trump in his final debate prosecute the debate about the two different hillary clintons. martha: it goes back to bill clinton, too. you try to figure out how to say the right thing to this side and the right thing to that side and donald trump has an opportunity to remind people of this very long pattern. blow everything up

well, now we have the emails.t was fbi director comey testified as they decided not to recommend charges for hillary clinton. but anonymous fbi insider is saying many people involved in the case believed clinton should have been charged. fred tecce, former federal prosecutor joins me now. let me read you part of the quote. this is from the source on the case saying no trial level attorney agreed, no agent working the case agreed with the decision not to prosecute. what do you think? >> what i think, i think this is absolute travesty. melissa you may have heard me say this. the proudest day of my life i put my left hand on the bible and raised my right hand and blame a federal prosecutor and agreed to defend the laws of the constitution of the united states. it is unbelievable job. it is an honor to have it. to see what these people have done and basically turned the united states department of justice into a political circus, makes me sick. when you hear that no trial level attorney agreed with the decision not to

no one had complained about the fact he not only used personal email but disposed of all his email, we don't have any of them. none the emails about the decision to go to war with iraq, the aftermath of 9/11, all kinds of things we could learn had powell's emails been available we will never know. unlike secretary clinton whose decision to sort her emails between personal and public has been criticized but she did turn over tens of thousands of emails from her time as secretary of state when the state department asked her to do that. >> host: april 27th of this year, joe scarborough, cohost of the morning joe talking about 2010 donation in algeria, the terror list, misreporting on all of this. >> guest: that was broadcast at the time clinton cash came out and my friend show scarborough, excited about clinton cash, that day he took a donation funneled to the clinton foundation from algeria to haiti in the aftermath of the haitian earthquake and the devastation there and turned it into a nefarious scheme in which the nation of algeria would be removed from the state department terrorism

a lot on those emails. maria: big show this morning, ladies.ybody, i'm maria bartiromo, happy monday, october 31st, halloween, top stories right now 6:00 a.m. on the east coast. race to the white house neck and neck. new polls shows that donald trump has come within point of hillary clinton. it was taken before the fbi fire storm late friday. hillary clinton's campaign on edge this morning as fbi director james comey revealed the agency found emails tie today clinton's private server on a laptop used by huma and her husband. the agency has the warrant to search 650,000 emails newly found. >> hillary clinton is not the victim, by the way. she's not the victim.

these people may have used emails but they weren't careful about they were using emails.sh: here is my question, back when he first started getting investigated for this situation with the 15-year-old girl, shouldn't huma abedin been thinking at the time, wow, oh, gosh, that's our computer, our family computer, lord knows what's on it, i'm kind of thinking why she didn't get the computer and dump it in the middle of the ocean. >> destroy the evidence. trish: she didn't know -- >> they are stunned by this. here is the other problem. what is in those 650,000 emails. donations for the clinton foundation from the russian, for example. is there stuff there about quashing the fbi investigation. is there something there that says to the attorney general -- trish: do you think that james comey has some indication that it's sketchy enough that he needs to be doing this 11 days before the election. >> here is what i have been hearing from former fbi people, they were angry that comey did not recommend hillary clinton be indicted for the e-mail scandal in the first place and so they