we asked facebook to respond to that but facebook declined. laura was one of those researchers, who had her facebook access disabled. thanks for joining us, laura. so, start by telling us what you were researching, and why. >> hi. um, so really, the thrust of our work is trying to understand misinformation online. we try to understand how it -- how it spreads and how it can be stopped. >> so, why do you think facebook disabled your accounts? >> it's a little strange. facebook claims that they disabled our accounts because of our browser extension ad observer. they say that it violates their terms of service. obviously, the ftc somewhat disagrees, as do we, to be clear. but what's strange about all this is that the effect of facebook's banning of our accounts is that our other research, that isn't connected to ad observer, at all, that's what's been stopped. >> so, not just this research. other research, too? go ahead. >> right. so a lot of our research right now is into disinformation around vaccines. so, these are some of the -- you know, the

we will hear from facebook. this hearing was made possible through a cross partisan group of organizations including freedom house, the national center for civil and human rights, the george w. bush institute. for we begin, a word from our cohost, the president of freedom house. >> i'm the president of freedom house. on behalf of freedom house and our event cohost, the national center for civil and human rights, issue one in the george w. bush institute, i would like to welcome you to our event series, reimagining american democracy. we launched a series a few months ago in order to help address a critical challenge facing the u.s. today. the health of its democracy. this is our third episode. today, we are looking for solutions to an issue central to the work we do at freedom house. how do you prevent disinformation from destroying democracy while protecting free speech online? in the digital age, during a global pandemic, at a time when political polarization is at an all-time high, this is no easy task. our s

their response was a brief e mail that didn't once reference facebook. it did however, contain this phrase. the well being of our employees is our priority. to finish our tour of the internet, trash cleaners the invisible workforce behind your facebook or instagram feed. we had one last meeting, sarah roberts is the leading researcher specializing, and those who work as moderators. she is a key figure in this field. we met her at the university where she teaches in california. she presented us with an analysis of the rise and development of content moderation. over the past year, we are talking about a scope and a scale of magnitude that has not been seen before. billions of things shared per day on facebook. hundreds of hours of video uploaded to youtube per minute per day and so on. the response has continued to be, we'll put more content moderators on it, which means that, that it continues to exponentially grow. it has gone from next to nothing kind of line item in the budget to being a massive, massive cost center. meaning it doesn't actually return

the social media cleaners who work on sites like facebook or instagram. these workers are never mentioned in the slick presentations of the silicon valley c e o . i started building a service to do that to put people 1st and at the center of our experience with technology. because our relationships are what matters most to us. and that's how we find meaning and how we make sense of our place in the world. today with 2000000000 users, facebook no longer has anything to do with mark soccer bags, initial vision of the site. with violent videos, he speech and pointed graphic images. more and more content has to be deleted and it isn't always robots doing this job. there are once again, humans hidden behind the screen. determining if something is hate, speech is very linguistically nuanced. i am optimistic that over 5 to 10 year period, we will have a i tools that can i get into some of the you answers the linguistic nuances of, of, of different types of content to be more accurate and flagging things for our systems . but today we're just not there on that. s

but according to facebook's rules, he was wrong to do so. in the feedback session, the trainer offers this explanation. can go into here and that is taking place on ticket with the nipple. that's exactly why i'm having so much trouble understanding you now to take picture of a photograph of a woman and you show. ready a tiny nipple. and so on one hand, because we have a 100 percent coverage label. on the other hand, you're almost full picture. and you don't do this because people look exactly right. yes, but you have a problem because you're going from when you're in learn the rules, applying facebook rules without questioning them is the number one rule, a principle that will be drilled into you all day every day has to be life and they live alone. receptive and we just seem to like to do our job. sometimes we'll find them job because not my training program with the end goal of turning you into a machine, pedro worked for 6 months as a content reviewer for facebook and accenture. he agreed to respond to word questions, but only if he remai

facebook is free for all of us. you can't accuse facebook of under cutting rivals on prices.competitors and it does not innovate the same way it used. >> i think you made a subtle antitrust point which is the old law and jurisprudence. as you said and everyone's kids know, tiktok is free but if they leak your personal contacts or gobble up your data, there is a price being monitored. the question of facebook is how we are paying for that price. it is a long week. i see the candles behind you. i don't know how you are go ing to use them. i nick, we wish everyone a rest full weekend whatever way you are getting to it. >>> when we come back, we have an update on matt gaetz, he has a new sex probe and new ethics problem. we'll explain next. get x pros problem. we'll explain next hybrid model. experience amazing at your lexus dealer. i became a sofi member because i needed to consolidate my credit card debt. i needed just one simple way to pay it all off. it was an easy decision to apply with sofi loans, just based on the interest rate and how much i would be saving. there was onl

free basics is just one of facebook's many initiatives across africa. facebook, the latest sharing can. yeah, it's called extra. why fine. the company is teamed up with local internet service providers to install why fi hotspots like here in the town of gala on the outskirts of nairobi, jerry nimble thea is a headdress, who signed up as a vendor for facebook? express? why funny. he gets the commission on every data bundle. he sells his customers, say they love lead to facebook because even myself, i use it and they find their bundle cheaper. that cheaper than you compared to the network. you get the 5 bundles, 1100 for free. yeah, did you find people? yes they do. they find it cheaper, you find it available and they made up from experts. why fi has been an undeniable success. yeah. it is made web access cheap of the people living in undeserved locations. then there are so many people living our own water connected to their ways. however, for those studying the activities of facebook and other big tech companies in kenya, it's impossible to ignore the huge potential for data mining. las

i cannot scale that, i work for facebook. okay, this is not allowed. it's completely like confidential. the work is that he's looking at the case code names, confidentiality clauses, and a complete ban on cell phones. facebook gives you the life of a secret agent for 800 years a month. and if you're the chevy type, the following argument should shut you up pretty quickly. like an agreement and you cannot that agreement because by law we can do what we can punish you by law with, you know, it's confidential or cleaning up social media is a bit like doing your family's dirty laundry. it has to be done, but nobody talks about why so careful? what does the job involve the we continue discreetly with great. why? the before becoming a moderator. greg, why has to follow a 3 week training program? moderating facebook's content does normally involve deleting violent videos or racist jokes. it's a lot more complicated. at the moment. the algorithms can't handle everything. every decision must be justified using very strict rules. this is what we learned during t

facebook knew that.ing down misinformation when literally the top viral item out of everything, i don't mean just out of alleged news, i mean out of everything during vaccine rollout was the evidence free headline that would make many people think twice about a vaccine, if doctors were allegedly dying of it already. now, there are even secret internal emails busting facebook for the cynical plan to bury the report. if this were in court, that kind of coverup makes you look way worse because it covers up evidence of your bad intent, shows people knew internally at the time they were already wrong. and this is a long ways from what can be tougher debates on sensorship. the main issue is that facebook profits off super viral content, stock exchange engagement, keeps the site relevant as they worry about new other social media platforms like tiktok. in 2021, disinformation and conspiracies about the vaccine are a big deal that millions of people engage in, which to facebook makes them big business. now, the

so my job was to study facebook's policy and apply it to to post comments pages on facebook and instagram. and so what i saw was clear bias. a slanted plan towards the left where, you know, facebook was actively censoring post about trump actively having us delete your viral videos. it would, which creates empathy for trump. so these were all examples of things that i saw. and so after a year there i started, i decided enough was enough and i reached out to a few journalists and they referred me to project curtis. i found with a camera at work for about 9 months straight. and so i covered all these exceptions in bias and you know, went public with project fer task where there are so much more in the, in what i had uncovered. so i decided to write a book about it behind the mass, your facebook, and yeah that, so that's my story. i was a content moderator, content sensor, working for facebook and instagram. well the 2nd ryan, i mean, i don't know, maybe i've been gone a long time or i'm just getting too old. but i mean, i think we all kind of brought up that censorship is a dirty word. and,

he is a free speech advocate, facebook whistleblower, and co author of the book behind the mask of facebook. current settlement cross talk rules and effects. that means it can jump in anytime you want. and i appreciate your both whistleblowers from some of the most tyrannical organizations that have ever existed on this planet. i feel very strongly about that. so i can ryan, i'd like you to give it a thumbnail sketch of your whistleblower experience that these tech corporations. you 1st back in san francisco. well, google was a really great company all the way up until 2016 when donald trump, when the election. and then they decided that they were going to go to a hard authoritarian company. and they changed all their policies and they started to classify things like big news with a program called machine learning fairness. they had all their evil plans on designed documents inside the company and as a full time employee, i had access to these documents. i copied them ah, and realised that this was something that the public needed to know about because it really is going to be the end of de

facebook saying the rchers designed a browser program to escape links and they collected data about facebooksers who did not install this extension or consent to the collection of the data the ftc said had you honored your commitment we would have pointed out that it does not bar facebook from creating exceptions from good faith research in the public interest. nyu researchers deny wrongdoing and they were quote gratified for the ftc's communication that facebook is not required to shut down our work. we are eager to return to our work facebook clarified in a the order didn't require them to disable researchers' accounts but rather required them to create and enforce a privacy program. the issue, facebook says, is not about making an exception for good faith researchers but that the researchers were violating the privacy rules. this is of course complicated, and it comes ahead of the deadline for the ftc to re-file its anti-trust lawsuit against facebook. >> a further degradation between the relationship between the commission and the company the real surprise would have been if the ftc was

why would facebook do this?hirds of a vast majority of the worlds interconnected countries is on facebook. the continent of africa has 1.2 billion people. smartphone is still increasing. if you think about it, is one area of growth they target. one of the top stories on the bloomberg today. emily: thank you for the update. $1 billion is how much facebook and instagram plan to pay their creators over the next year and a massive bid to bring more enforcers -- and floors to the platform. tiktok, snap and youtube. just about anyone can cultivate their fan bases and it is changing social media as we know it. so much so that adam mosseri said instagram is no longer a photo sharing app. he joins us now to explain. it was kind of a moment. explain to us what you mean. i know you have more video coming, expand on this vision. adam: in general, we are always trying to see how the world is changing and how to adapt as the world changes. one of the biggest risks is that big -- we become relevant. one of the changes is the e

ready the facebook free basics model, which is basically about expanding for facebook, the demain of day to extract across the world at a time when demand for facebook is beginning to fall among younger people in particular, in the so called west is very interesting justice, in historic colonialism, the apparent weakness of the colonized population, the lack of weapons, their lack of sudden resources. the lack of an economic structure suggested to the colonizers that they needed to be colonized. they needed to have whatever the colonial system would offer them to bind them in. free basics is just one of facebook, many initiatives across africa. facebook, the latest push here in kenya, it's called express why fi? the company is teamed up with local internet service providers to install why fi hotspots? like here in the mesquite town of gala on the outskirts of nairobi, jerry nimble thea is a headdress. he signed up as a vendor for facebook express, why funny. he gets a commission on every data bundle he sells his customers, say they love lead to facebook because even myself, i use it

emily: now, a facebook spokesperson saying there was no valid claim that facebook was a monopoly andhat has not changed, our acquisitions of instagram and whatsapp were cleared years ago, and our platform policies are lawful. i thought what was interesting about this suit was the way they differentiated facebook from twitter, youtube and tiktok, which are more public-facing content. while facebook is more targeted, more personal, and, therefore, facebook has a monopoly in that kind of market. what do you think it says about lina khan, that she came back with this, and so quickly? naomi: obviously, lina khan has been a leading advocate for more progressive vision of antitrust enforcement. she is the one arguing that, the traditional measures of competitive harm, which is, do consumer prices go up, is insufficient to really capture these tech giants, which are often offering free services. so she came back with a suit this quickly -- i think it is not surprising. it is what her supporters in congress and beyond were likely expecting. whether she succeeds will be an interesting test cas

facebook. these type of practices are under scrutiny. they came up in the lawsuit today. emily: facebook said there was no valid claim that facebook was a monopolist. that has not changed. it was reviewed and cleared years ago, and the platform policies were lawful. what i thought was interesting about this suit is the way they differentiated facebook from twitter using tiktok. the content generated is meant for a more public audience, where facebook is more targeted and personal. and therefore, facebook has a monopoly in that kind of a market. what does that say about lena conn that she came back with this so quickly? >> we know conn has been a leading advocate for a more progressive vision of antitrust enforcement. she is the one that argued the traditional measures of competitive market, consumer prices going up, is insufficient to capture these tech giants which are often operating free services. that you came back with the suit quickly is not surprising. it is what supporters in congress a

it's removed from facebook because facebook was a set that this word was in there title on their facebookpage. isn't there some power here with intention? have we lost our minds is one of asking? >> yes, we have lost our minds. facebook facing massive fines, gargantuan fines with hate speech, billions and billions every hour. human contact moderators they hire from i just filed a class-action suit because the working conditions are terrible so what facebook uses human contact moderators our programs. so no human thought and going to off that town in france, they just saw the term and there was gone. the town renamed itself. [laughter] so there is lack of intention on social media platforms trying to keep up with regulation and they over removed, it's a real problem for they are talking cancel culture talking about the n-word, i mean yes, that word like a swastika and a number of other things are simply radioactive. last year in germany, it will get cleaned out. it won't happen.n. they have words beyond what they signify. the case you were talking about, the n-word case, caps off law schoo

because facebook was upset that that word was in there, on the title of their facebook page. doesn't intention have some power here? have we lost our minds is what i'm asking, eric? >> yeah, yes, we have lost our minds. facebook is facing in europe massive fines, i mean huge fines for letting hate speech through, billions and billions of pieces of content roll through facebook every hour. the human content moderators that they hire just filed a class action suit because they are made insane because the working conditions are so terrible. what facebook uses in addition to a human content moderator are programs. the programs do clean sweeps. so no human thought i'm going to off that town in france, where term was seen and it was gone. the town actually renamed itself. so there's a lack of intention on the social media platforms trying to keep up with regulations, and they overremove, that's a real problem, but also talking about cancel culture, and you were talking about the n word, i mean, yes, that word like the swastika, like a number of other things are simply radioactive.

of their facebook page.n't it have some power? have we lost our minds is what i'm asking. >> yes we have lost our minds. facebooknd is facing massive fines, gargantuan fines for letting the hate speech through. billions and billions of content rolls through every hour. the human content moderators that they hire just filed a class-action suit because the working conditions are so terrible so what facebook uses in addition to the human content moderator our programs. the programs are clean sweep. no human thought i'm going to off the town. they saw the term and it was gone. there is the lack of intention on the platforms trying to keep up with regulation and they over remove the problem but they also talked about cancel culture. that word like the swastika and other things are simply radioactive. it's allowed here in germany, no. it will get cleaned up.et it won't happen. it's beyond what they signify. now the case you talked about, that was a law school case. there was a student quoting from a judge's opinio

because facebook was set the workers and their, a title on their facebook page.ere some power here? >> yes, we have lost our minds. facing massive fines, gargantuan fines, billions and billions every hour. their human contact moderators they hire bob class action suit because they are made because the working conditions are terrible. the human contactac moderators e programs. so no human thought i'm going to off the town they saw a term and it was gone so the town renamed itself but there is lack of intention trying to keep up with regulation and over removed, that's a real problem and also cancel culture talking about the n-word, yes, that word like swastika like a number of other things are simply radioactive. it will be cleaned out, it won't happen. they have forced beyond what they have signified. arthat was a law school, they we quoting from a judge's opinion including that word so her intention was simply to discuss the case but we have a touchiness where that can't be allowed. talking about cancer culture, i want to get more subtle than that because i was

the facebook had monopoly power over the social network market. federal regulator, ledgers, the company violated anti trust laws when he bought social media platforms, whatsapp an instagram and wants to force it to sell them on. which stultz is the senior staff attorney at the electronic frontier foundation, a non profit group, defending digital rights. he joins us via skype now from san francisco. thanks very much for being with us. now this is a 2nd attempt, as we said to, to go off to facebook, which alleged anti trust violations off to the judge dismissed the, the 1st case, what's different this time around? what's, what's the basis of their argument now? so their basis is the same, but they are showing more of their cards. they have to say is put more quotations and what appeared to be internal emails but weren't made public. but worse given to the court that show in different ways how facebook has acquired and has and maintains monopoly power. so what if facebook is saying that their accusations, a key, acu, sorry, acquisitions, rather of wh

be able to communicate with their friends who are still on facebook . in other words, some interoperability requirement that by lowering the barriers to switching social networks, that could really have a strong influence on breaking facebook monopoly. and that's something that they're still asking for. give us governments introduce title controls and the use of social media binding pointed calls, false news, and anything it says could damage the country's prestige to these abode reports. these were the largest protest in q vine decades. thousands took to the streets last month to demand food medicines and freedom. young people using the internet, managed to organize protests nationwide. but now the government is doing everything possible to prevent them from happening again. a new decree announced this week to control social media will put people like junior darcy at risk of getting out of these new laws come to reinforce the prohibitions that already exist and legalize things that were been doing outside the legal framework, such as the cops of the in

facebook exodus becoming an epidemic facebook management, continues exodus, surprise departure of twoxecutives, heralding a terp be turbulent last years. >> be careful about narratives that move around the stock from 180 to 150 when headlines out. now, of course, above 300. not everybody's gone. >> i would say some of more important than other she was seen as a big loss as potentially the successor to mark zuckerberg. ran and built the facebook app had a huge part in it. jon, talked about it with amazon as well. seems every once in a while the stories come around, carl, about an exodus from a big tech company. when you look at them hitting record highs they run so much, start-ups could be more appealing in terms of what they can do in terms of control and what they can make especially. >> yeah, jon, you said it. not everybody's gone. >> indeed. >>> meanwhile, two former disney execs, did leave disney. kevin mayer and tom staggs pap new immediate gentlemen venture with reese witherspoon pap new partner and both joining us other side of this break don't go anywhere. sofi is a one-stop s

there's a town in france which had to remove its name from facebook because facebook was upset that theword was in there. we lost her mind is what i'm asking. >> yes we have lost our minds. facebook is facing in europe massive fines and i mean gargantuan fines worth billions and billions and billions of pieces of content. their human content moderators that they hired just filed a class-action suit because the working conditions are so terrible so what facebook uses as a human content monitor programs. so no human thought they just love the term and it was gone. so the town renamed itself. there is a lack of intention on the social media platform trendy keep up with regulation but they are talking about cancel culture talking about the n word. i mean yes that was like swastika and a number of other things. swastikas allowed here in germany. it will get cleaned out or it won't happen. they have words beyond what they signify in that case we are talking about that was a law school the n word case that was at a law school quoting from a judges opinion that included that word. her intention

facebook under fire for trying to silence law enforcement.ed officer as officer of the year for shooting and killing a staffer on —- a stabber who attacked him but facebook denied the request. this add content has been disapproved for violation of facebook advertising policies and guidelines. your matt add may have been rejected because it mentions politician or about sensitive social issues. in response the executive director of the chief of police said "the way i see it , facebook things it's wrong to honor a brave police officer who suffers serious wounds while protecting his city. how is that political? in addition an organization called blue hearts for heroes which helps the families of law enforcement, had this post flagged as spam. the cofounder spoke out this morning on fox and friends. >> i think there are facebook employees at look at certain post they see something with law enforcement and right away they block it or put into spam that means bad. 100 percent i believe that. we have reached out to facebook they have given us no indi

be able to communicate with their friends who are still on facebook. in other words, some interoperability requirement that by lowering the barriers to switching social networks that could really have a strong influence on breaking facebook monopoly. and that's something that they're still asking for. we're not jerry's information minister says he expects a band on twitter to be lifted by the end of the m lie. mohamad says the government is waiting for the social media platform to fulfill 3 final conditions. they include setting up a local office, paying tax locally, and working with the government to regulate content. the band was imposed in june after twitter removed a controversial post by the president. how many do bahati keepers government says introduce tighter controls and the use of social media banning what it calls? false news, anything it says could damage the country's prestige. roseborough has this these were the largest protest in queue wine decades. thousands took to the streets last month to demand food medicines and freedom. young peop

be able to communicate with their friends who are still on facebook. in other words, some interoperability requirement that by lowering the barriers to switching social networks that could really have a strong influence on breaking facebook monopoly. and that's something that they're still asking for in the wrong city of cabella, security of titans, thousands of worshippers commemorates the assure holiday. the annual gathering of the faithful is the 2nd biggest source of income for iraq. i'm old underwear haver bulls. the she muslims walked towards the shrine of a man who seen in the city of karbala 80 kilometer. so the dud is where he was killed in battle. 1300 years ago. his fight against injustice is enact, here by men and boys, flagellating themselves. recall the agonies suffered to bite the man. the visitors from several countries take part in the procession most from iran said it came with her husband from the city of mush had we came to pray for an end to planks in the world, especially in 19 financing, so that the faithful can salvage their fre

itself they have facebook payments.hey have ways to transact and increasingly not just going to be about linking out to buy things that you maybe found on facebook, but doing everything within that facebook platform and, of course, the ability to do that and remove any of that friction that makes it more valuable for advertisers and that, of course, is facebook's bread and butter. >> yeah, detour, but they get the data julia, thanks. >>> morgan stanley is bullish on zoom ahead of next week's earnings read why on cnbc.com/pro and we're back in just a moment. at pnc bank, we believe in the power of the watch out. the “make way, coming through”... great. the storm alert... dad. and the subtle but effective ding. that's why we created low cash mode. the financial watch out that gives you the options and time needed to help you avoid overdraft fees. it's one way we're making a difference. because we believe how you handle overdrafts should be in your control, not just your banks. low cash mode on virtual wallet from pnc bank

>> facebook's argument is total nonsense. this is a classic facebook move.y scrutiny of their own behavior. the nyu is a volunteer program, really good disclosure. people volunteer to put a browser extension on their computers that simply looks to see what kind of ads facebook shows them. the whole purpose of this is to see what's going on in political advertising. the program has been going on for several years. it's just that right now there's a new set of things going on that they're tracking and they announced that was happening and facebook shut them down. the problem here, ali, is that facebook is not transparent. if regulators understood how much illegal behavior was going on and how much covid disinformation advertising was going on and scam medical cures, illegal drugs being promoted there and not just on facebook, on instagram and on other platforms like google and youtube. they would be appalled. this is just a classic facebook move. >> barb, you know, we don't really, we've been talking about this for years about whether social media needs to be

because facebook was upset that the word was in there.doesn't the intention have some power here and have we lost our minds is what i'm asking? >> yes we have lost our minds. they spoke is based in europe gargantuan signs with billions of pieces of content roll through facebook every hour. their human content moderators that they hire who just filed a class-action lawsuit because the working conditions are so terrible so any addition to humanse content monitor they use programs called clean sweep. no human thought i'm going to -- where they saw the term and it was gone. the town renamed itself. there's a lack of intention on social mediake platforms to keep up with regulation and they overran move which is a real problem and they also talk about cancel culture and you talk about the n t word. that word like swastika and a number of other things are simply radioactive. is a swastika allowed in germany? and no. it won't happen. they go beyond what they signify and the law school there was a student quoting from a judge's opinion that includ

facebook understands that. to make sure that they are contributing to what this new eco system will look like. >> fascinating chris, always grateful thank you so much. >> the last installment of the other side of the street breaking down his bear crawl on tesla and what we learn from elon musk's ai presentation. we are back in just two minutes. i think you're going to like it here. umm, why is everyone... throwing things at me? look, as cfo it's my job to be ready for whatever's next. that's why i have my finance team, randomly hurl things at me. it's also why we use workday. it gives us insights, so we quickly pivot our strategy, people, planning, you name it. sorry, sir. i will aim straight at your next step. see that you do. would you like some coffee? workday. the finance, hr, and planning system for a changing world. ♪ what happens when we welcome change? we can transform our workforce overnightd. out of convenience, or necessity. we can explore uncharted waters, and not only make new discoveries, but get

on the good side, there are so many things that are great about facebook.particular, how facebook takes care of its employees in a very generous way, which is something we absolutely want to make sure instacart is known for , and has a great culture. as well as the ability to scale to other products for the needs of billions of people. emily: what are some things you want to combat before they get bigger? >> a lot of it has to do with just making sure our shoppers and customers are safe. if a shopper or customer has a bad interaction with each other, we make sure they are never matched to the same person again. obviously if someone is on the -- is abusive, we take actions to remove them from the service. emily: women dominate your executive team, and the majority of your customers and shoppers are women. though i should say husband puts in his fair share of instacart orders himself, i should give him credit. how do you think having so many women at the top will impact the product and the culture of the company and the culture of the product? >> i think it i

let's see how facebook approach works. what's the, how the twitter approach, which is very different works and let's try to understand here in the coming weeks and months, which one seems to end up with a better result. interesting that these, the say that the fact that there isn't a uniform policy is, is, is a good thing because i was actually my next question. i'll put that to you in. these are all you know, to put a facebook you to these all private platforms. each with their own policies as, as, as jim said, there, but does that complicate things going forward in the fact that there's not a uniform policy med, does there need to be there's not a uniform policy in the u. s. i don't see why there would be one abroad. well, you know, us is much more trend lively territory for all of them. it's something that we don't feel out of here. i will say that even though their policies can sometimes inconsistent, they change their minds. a lot, all the platforms you this, their motivations remain largely the same across all of the

and for further discussion, you can go to our facebook page, that's facebook dot com, forward slash a j inside story. you can also join the conversation on twitter handle. there is a j inside story for me, hasn't speaker, and the whole team here, but now the ah, ah ah, that light emitted from history kept alive only in the family tales of those just by had to believe people who didn't seem to these damaging story as a polish women and children who endured the siberian glass, refuge in africa, never to return again an epic or to see every 1000000000 memory is our homeland. and now, just for the latest news, as it breaks the storms, spare the worst, her long island, which fear to direct it. but it's still whipped up high winds and high waves with detailed coverage of government and up to still to rent keepers. and all the children not only put them from around the world, hundreds of children have been born to women abused by ice and fighters. in addition to social pressure, you can only carry their religion if both parents are the in countries like mine, people have been killed to be wh